User login
Image-Based Techniques for Percutaneous Iliosacral Screw Start-Site Localization
Iliosacral (SI) screws remain the standard of care for the vast majority of posterior pelvic ring disruptions.1,2 However, despite their routine use, the procedure remains technically demanding with repeated cases of aberrant screw placement and complications.3,4 Sacral morphology is extremely variable within a patient population and affects accurate placement and trajectory of percutaneous screws.5 Classically, it is taught that the external starting position/landmark is at an intersection point of the greater trochanter and the anterior superior iliac spine (ASIS). While this “one size fits all” approach will certainly help to coordinate a start position, it is our experience that multiple stab incisions are necessary to find the optimal start site. To our knowledge, the most common image-based technique used to guide start-point localization and placement of SI screws begins with drawing a virtual sacrum on the patient’s side, guided by the lateral image.5 This article provides a novel image-based technique to be used with, or as a replacement for, the traditional technique.
Techniques
The patient is brought to the operating room and placed supine on a radiolucent operating table. If the closed reduction of the pelvic ring is successful or can be achieved via anterior manipulation/traction, posterior percutaneous pinning is planned. Either a rolled towel or a bag of saline is used as a bolster and placed midline underneath the sacrum and lumbar spine to help “bump” the pelvis and improve the range of motion for the surgeon’s drill. The patient is brought to the edge of the table when possible (ie, a posterior ring injury requiring fixation from only 1 side) to further enhance drill motion. If bilateral screws are planned, surgeons must be careful not to position 1 side at the expense of screw placement on the contralateral side. Nitrous-based anesthetic agents are avoided, because they may collect in the bowel and obscure good radiographic visualization. Arms are placed perpendicular to the body to facilitate the inlet view. Pre-preparation anteroposterior pelvis, inlet, and outlet views are obtained to assure ability to accurately and safely assess landmarks on all projections, and to mark the C-arm position and angles. This process helps decrease “useless” radiographs obtained during the procedure. Acceptable inlet radiographs show the anterior cortex of the S1 body superimposed on the S2 body. Acceptable outlet radiographs show the superior pubic symphysis at the level of the S2 foramen and visualization of the S1/S2 sacral foramen.6 The patient is then prepared in the standard fashion. Reduction maneuvers are performed and, if acceptable alignment is achieved, posterior percutaneous screw placement begins.
Technique 1
To our knowledge, the most common image-based technique used to guide start-point localization and placement of SI screws begins with drawing a virtual sacrum on the patient’s side using the lateral image. The fluoroscopic machine is set up in a lateral position.5 A free guide wire is superimposed upon the iliac cortical density and anterior sacral slope, which is marked on the skin (Figure 1). The superior portion of S1, as well as the posterior sacral slope, can be marked as well. This process has outlined the sacrum and provides an external landmark for the “safe zone” for screw placement. The operation proceeds in the standard fashion using inlet, outlet, and lateral radiographs. However, the externally drawn sacrum can aid as a reference during guide-pin placement.
Technique 2
This technique takes into account bone anatomy and soft-tissue coverage. It is helpful to think of the abdomen/pelvis as a box. The anterior abdomen represents the top of the box and the lateral buttock represents the side of the box. The corner of the imaginary box is where the abdomen begins to slope down and transitions laterally to become the buttock. This will be referenced as the “down-sloping point” and typically corresponds to the level of the iliac crest (Figure 2).
To begin, a standard cannulated screw guide wire is placed flush on the skin of the abdomen. An inlet fluoroscopy image is taken with the guide pin on the abdomen. Imagine that the resulting image represents the planned screw trajectory (Figure 3A). When the position of the guide wire is deemed adequate, a line is marked on the abdomen, using a pen, directly adjacent to the guide wire. This line represents inlet line 1 (Figure 2). The line must continue laterally until the down-sloping point. The sagittal angle of the imaginary inlet fluoroscopic beam is noted, and a guide wire is placed in the same sagittal orientation flush with the skin on the lateral buttock (Figure 3B). The guide wire must be placed so that it intersects with the first line at the down-sloping point. The skin on the lateral aspect of buttock is marked with a second line, which represents inlet line 2 (Figure 2).
The same process is repeated using an outlet view to create outlet lines 1 and 2 (Figures 4A, 4B). At this point there are 4 lines drawn on the patient (Figure 2). A stab incision is made at the intersection of the 2 lines drawn on the lateral buttock; this represents the skin start point, labeled “start incision” (Figure 2). The procedure continues in standard fashion.
The 4 external reference lines serve multiple purposes. First, the lines mark the true lateral start point for the pin at the level of the skin. This contrasts with the standard technique in which bony landmarks are marked on the skin and the surgeon must estimate a point on the skin that will provide an appropriate trajectory to the bony start point on the ilium. Further, the lines can also be used to reorient the cartesian plane so that adjustments can be isolated to a single plane, ensuring movements only alter the position on a single radiographic view (Figure 5).
Discussion
Despite the widespread use of percutaneous screw placement for posterior pelvic ring injuries, this remains a technically demanding surgery. Recent data suggest patient pelvic anatomy is extremely varied, especially the sacrum.7 Further, screw trajectories vary depending on surgical goals, fracture pattern, and number of screws. Taken together, this implies that there is no perfect universal starting site along the external ilium. Therefore, while classic teaching states to begin screw insertion within the vicinity of the intersection of the greater trochanter and the ASIS, it is our experience that this location is often not ideal.
The inlet, outlet, and lateral radiographs are all vital to assess correct trajectory of the guide pin and drill prior to final screw insertion, but the start site remains a critical step to assure a successful surgical outcome. We present 2 techniques, used together or separately, that allow the surgeon to place the initial guide pin more accurately for percutanous iliosacral screws. Though not specifically examined in this study, we think technique 2 has the potential to save operative time and use less fluoroscopic imaging because a lateral image is not required until later in the case. Technique 2 identifies the start point at the level of the skin. This is in contrast to technique 1, which identifies the desired sacral target and requires a surgeon to select a skin start site that will provide an optimal trajectory towards the desired target. Judging trajectory can be difficult, particularly in obese patients, and technique 2 eliminates this extra variable.
It is also important to consider that criteria-based nonorthogonal imaging is required for percutaneous screw placement. In these cases, it is more difficult to judge trajectory corrections because the fluoroscopic beam cannot guide perpendicular corrections as it can in operations that use orthogonal imaging. Adjustments made perpendicular to the fluoroscopic beam will change trajectory in multiple planes.8 Moreover, because the standard cartesian frame of reference is rotated, understanding the location of the sacrum in space can be especially challenging. When using the first technique, sacral landmarks are delineated, and a virtual sacrum drawn on the patient’s exterior helps with orientation. In the second technique, the ideal pin placement is mapped, and the external reference lines guide uniplanar changes. For example, the line drawn co-planar with the inlet view is essentially marking the sacral slope. Therefore, by following this line, uniplanar changes in the cranial and caudal direction are achieved on the outlet view (Figure 5). Because this line is also in reference to the already known ideal pin placement, ideal pin placement can be maintained in 1 radiographic projection while changing the start site in the appropriate direction. In a similar fashion, the co-planar line identified on the inlet view can be used on the outlet image to affect uniplanar changes in the anteroposterior direction. This technique effectively minimizes disorientation when placing percutaneous SI screws. This can be particularly beneficial when placing screws in the prone position.
Conclusion
We have shown 2 techniques that are routinely used at our institution to help identify an accurate starting position for percutaneous screw placement in posterior pelvic ring injuries. Even experienced traumatologists can more quickly and accurately identify the correct stab incisions leading to more confidently placed screws. Further, we believe understanding the usage of fluoroscopy and the concepts involved in drawing the lines enhance trainees’ comprehension of the complex anatomy of the sacrum.
1. Matta JM, Saucedo T. Internal fixation of pelvic ring fractures. Clin Orthop Relat Res. 1989;242:83-97.
2. Routt ML Jr, Kregor PJ, Simonian PT, Mayo KA. Early results of percutaneous iliosacral screws placed with the patient in the supine position. J Orthop Trauma. 1995;9(3):207-214.
3. Sagi HC, Lindvall EM. Inadvertent intraforaminal iliosacral screw placement despite apparent appropriate positioning on intraoperative fluoroscopy.
J Orthop Trauma. 2005;19(2):130-133.
4. Routt ML Jr, Simonian PT, Mills WJ. Iliosacral screw fixation: early complications of the percutaneous technique. J Orthop Trauma. 1997;11(8):584-589.
5. Routt ML Jr, Simonian PT, Agnew SG, Mann FA. Radiographic recognition of the sacral alar slope for optimal placement of iliosacral screws: a cadaveric and clinical study. J Orthop Trauma. 1996;10(3):171-177.
6. Gardner MJ, Ferrell ED, Nork SE, Segina DN, Routt ML Jr. Percutaneous placement of iliosacral screws without electrodiagnostic monitoring. J Trauma. 2009;66(5):1411-1415.
7. Miller AN, Routt ML Jr. Variations in sacral morphology and implications for iliosacral screw fixation. J Am Acad Orthop Surg. 2012;20(1):8-16.
8. Graves ML, Routt ML. Iliosacral screw placement: are uniplanar changes realistic based on standard fluoroscopic imaging? J Orthop Trauma. 2011;71(1):204-208.
Iliosacral (SI) screws remain the standard of care for the vast majority of posterior pelvic ring disruptions.1,2 However, despite their routine use, the procedure remains technically demanding with repeated cases of aberrant screw placement and complications.3,4 Sacral morphology is extremely variable within a patient population and affects accurate placement and trajectory of percutaneous screws.5 Classically, it is taught that the external starting position/landmark is at an intersection point of the greater trochanter and the anterior superior iliac spine (ASIS). While this “one size fits all” approach will certainly help to coordinate a start position, it is our experience that multiple stab incisions are necessary to find the optimal start site. To our knowledge, the most common image-based technique used to guide start-point localization and placement of SI screws begins with drawing a virtual sacrum on the patient’s side, guided by the lateral image.5 This article provides a novel image-based technique to be used with, or as a replacement for, the traditional technique.
Techniques
The patient is brought to the operating room and placed supine on a radiolucent operating table. If the closed reduction of the pelvic ring is successful or can be achieved via anterior manipulation/traction, posterior percutaneous pinning is planned. Either a rolled towel or a bag of saline is used as a bolster and placed midline underneath the sacrum and lumbar spine to help “bump” the pelvis and improve the range of motion for the surgeon’s drill. The patient is brought to the edge of the table when possible (ie, a posterior ring injury requiring fixation from only 1 side) to further enhance drill motion. If bilateral screws are planned, surgeons must be careful not to position 1 side at the expense of screw placement on the contralateral side. Nitrous-based anesthetic agents are avoided, because they may collect in the bowel and obscure good radiographic visualization. Arms are placed perpendicular to the body to facilitate the inlet view. Pre-preparation anteroposterior pelvis, inlet, and outlet views are obtained to assure ability to accurately and safely assess landmarks on all projections, and to mark the C-arm position and angles. This process helps decrease “useless” radiographs obtained during the procedure. Acceptable inlet radiographs show the anterior cortex of the S1 body superimposed on the S2 body. Acceptable outlet radiographs show the superior pubic symphysis at the level of the S2 foramen and visualization of the S1/S2 sacral foramen.6 The patient is then prepared in the standard fashion. Reduction maneuvers are performed and, if acceptable alignment is achieved, posterior percutaneous screw placement begins.
Technique 1
To our knowledge, the most common image-based technique used to guide start-point localization and placement of SI screws begins with drawing a virtual sacrum on the patient’s side using the lateral image. The fluoroscopic machine is set up in a lateral position.5 A free guide wire is superimposed upon the iliac cortical density and anterior sacral slope, which is marked on the skin (Figure 1). The superior portion of S1, as well as the posterior sacral slope, can be marked as well. This process has outlined the sacrum and provides an external landmark for the “safe zone” for screw placement. The operation proceeds in the standard fashion using inlet, outlet, and lateral radiographs. However, the externally drawn sacrum can aid as a reference during guide-pin placement.
Technique 2
This technique takes into account bone anatomy and soft-tissue coverage. It is helpful to think of the abdomen/pelvis as a box. The anterior abdomen represents the top of the box and the lateral buttock represents the side of the box. The corner of the imaginary box is where the abdomen begins to slope down and transitions laterally to become the buttock. This will be referenced as the “down-sloping point” and typically corresponds to the level of the iliac crest (Figure 2).
To begin, a standard cannulated screw guide wire is placed flush on the skin of the abdomen. An inlet fluoroscopy image is taken with the guide pin on the abdomen. Imagine that the resulting image represents the planned screw trajectory (Figure 3A). When the position of the guide wire is deemed adequate, a line is marked on the abdomen, using a pen, directly adjacent to the guide wire. This line represents inlet line 1 (Figure 2). The line must continue laterally until the down-sloping point. The sagittal angle of the imaginary inlet fluoroscopic beam is noted, and a guide wire is placed in the same sagittal orientation flush with the skin on the lateral buttock (Figure 3B). The guide wire must be placed so that it intersects with the first line at the down-sloping point. The skin on the lateral aspect of buttock is marked with a second line, which represents inlet line 2 (Figure 2).
The same process is repeated using an outlet view to create outlet lines 1 and 2 (Figures 4A, 4B). At this point there are 4 lines drawn on the patient (Figure 2). A stab incision is made at the intersection of the 2 lines drawn on the lateral buttock; this represents the skin start point, labeled “start incision” (Figure 2). The procedure continues in standard fashion.
The 4 external reference lines serve multiple purposes. First, the lines mark the true lateral start point for the pin at the level of the skin. This contrasts with the standard technique in which bony landmarks are marked on the skin and the surgeon must estimate a point on the skin that will provide an appropriate trajectory to the bony start point on the ilium. Further, the lines can also be used to reorient the cartesian plane so that adjustments can be isolated to a single plane, ensuring movements only alter the position on a single radiographic view (Figure 5).
Discussion
Despite the widespread use of percutaneous screw placement for posterior pelvic ring injuries, this remains a technically demanding surgery. Recent data suggest patient pelvic anatomy is extremely varied, especially the sacrum.7 Further, screw trajectories vary depending on surgical goals, fracture pattern, and number of screws. Taken together, this implies that there is no perfect universal starting site along the external ilium. Therefore, while classic teaching states to begin screw insertion within the vicinity of the intersection of the greater trochanter and the ASIS, it is our experience that this location is often not ideal.
The inlet, outlet, and lateral radiographs are all vital to assess correct trajectory of the guide pin and drill prior to final screw insertion, but the start site remains a critical step to assure a successful surgical outcome. We present 2 techniques, used together or separately, that allow the surgeon to place the initial guide pin more accurately for percutanous iliosacral screws. Though not specifically examined in this study, we think technique 2 has the potential to save operative time and use less fluoroscopic imaging because a lateral image is not required until later in the case. Technique 2 identifies the start point at the level of the skin. This is in contrast to technique 1, which identifies the desired sacral target and requires a surgeon to select a skin start site that will provide an optimal trajectory towards the desired target. Judging trajectory can be difficult, particularly in obese patients, and technique 2 eliminates this extra variable.
It is also important to consider that criteria-based nonorthogonal imaging is required for percutaneous screw placement. In these cases, it is more difficult to judge trajectory corrections because the fluoroscopic beam cannot guide perpendicular corrections as it can in operations that use orthogonal imaging. Adjustments made perpendicular to the fluoroscopic beam will change trajectory in multiple planes.8 Moreover, because the standard cartesian frame of reference is rotated, understanding the location of the sacrum in space can be especially challenging. When using the first technique, sacral landmarks are delineated, and a virtual sacrum drawn on the patient’s exterior helps with orientation. In the second technique, the ideal pin placement is mapped, and the external reference lines guide uniplanar changes. For example, the line drawn co-planar with the inlet view is essentially marking the sacral slope. Therefore, by following this line, uniplanar changes in the cranial and caudal direction are achieved on the outlet view (Figure 5). Because this line is also in reference to the already known ideal pin placement, ideal pin placement can be maintained in 1 radiographic projection while changing the start site in the appropriate direction. In a similar fashion, the co-planar line identified on the inlet view can be used on the outlet image to affect uniplanar changes in the anteroposterior direction. This technique effectively minimizes disorientation when placing percutaneous SI screws. This can be particularly beneficial when placing screws in the prone position.
Conclusion
We have shown 2 techniques that are routinely used at our institution to help identify an accurate starting position for percutaneous screw placement in posterior pelvic ring injuries. Even experienced traumatologists can more quickly and accurately identify the correct stab incisions leading to more confidently placed screws. Further, we believe understanding the usage of fluoroscopy and the concepts involved in drawing the lines enhance trainees’ comprehension of the complex anatomy of the sacrum.
Iliosacral (SI) screws remain the standard of care for the vast majority of posterior pelvic ring disruptions.1,2 However, despite their routine use, the procedure remains technically demanding with repeated cases of aberrant screw placement and complications.3,4 Sacral morphology is extremely variable within a patient population and affects accurate placement and trajectory of percutaneous screws.5 Classically, it is taught that the external starting position/landmark is at an intersection point of the greater trochanter and the anterior superior iliac spine (ASIS). While this “one size fits all” approach will certainly help to coordinate a start position, it is our experience that multiple stab incisions are necessary to find the optimal start site. To our knowledge, the most common image-based technique used to guide start-point localization and placement of SI screws begins with drawing a virtual sacrum on the patient’s side, guided by the lateral image.5 This article provides a novel image-based technique to be used with, or as a replacement for, the traditional technique.
Techniques
The patient is brought to the operating room and placed supine on a radiolucent operating table. If the closed reduction of the pelvic ring is successful or can be achieved via anterior manipulation/traction, posterior percutaneous pinning is planned. Either a rolled towel or a bag of saline is used as a bolster and placed midline underneath the sacrum and lumbar spine to help “bump” the pelvis and improve the range of motion for the surgeon’s drill. The patient is brought to the edge of the table when possible (ie, a posterior ring injury requiring fixation from only 1 side) to further enhance drill motion. If bilateral screws are planned, surgeons must be careful not to position 1 side at the expense of screw placement on the contralateral side. Nitrous-based anesthetic agents are avoided, because they may collect in the bowel and obscure good radiographic visualization. Arms are placed perpendicular to the body to facilitate the inlet view. Pre-preparation anteroposterior pelvis, inlet, and outlet views are obtained to assure ability to accurately and safely assess landmarks on all projections, and to mark the C-arm position and angles. This process helps decrease “useless” radiographs obtained during the procedure. Acceptable inlet radiographs show the anterior cortex of the S1 body superimposed on the S2 body. Acceptable outlet radiographs show the superior pubic symphysis at the level of the S2 foramen and visualization of the S1/S2 sacral foramen.6 The patient is then prepared in the standard fashion. Reduction maneuvers are performed and, if acceptable alignment is achieved, posterior percutaneous screw placement begins.
Technique 1
To our knowledge, the most common image-based technique used to guide start-point localization and placement of SI screws begins with drawing a virtual sacrum on the patient’s side using the lateral image. The fluoroscopic machine is set up in a lateral position.5 A free guide wire is superimposed upon the iliac cortical density and anterior sacral slope, which is marked on the skin (Figure 1). The superior portion of S1, as well as the posterior sacral slope, can be marked as well. This process has outlined the sacrum and provides an external landmark for the “safe zone” for screw placement. The operation proceeds in the standard fashion using inlet, outlet, and lateral radiographs. However, the externally drawn sacrum can aid as a reference during guide-pin placement.
Technique 2
This technique takes into account bone anatomy and soft-tissue coverage. It is helpful to think of the abdomen/pelvis as a box. The anterior abdomen represents the top of the box and the lateral buttock represents the side of the box. The corner of the imaginary box is where the abdomen begins to slope down and transitions laterally to become the buttock. This will be referenced as the “down-sloping point” and typically corresponds to the level of the iliac crest (Figure 2).
To begin, a standard cannulated screw guide wire is placed flush on the skin of the abdomen. An inlet fluoroscopy image is taken with the guide pin on the abdomen. Imagine that the resulting image represents the planned screw trajectory (Figure 3A). When the position of the guide wire is deemed adequate, a line is marked on the abdomen, using a pen, directly adjacent to the guide wire. This line represents inlet line 1 (Figure 2). The line must continue laterally until the down-sloping point. The sagittal angle of the imaginary inlet fluoroscopic beam is noted, and a guide wire is placed in the same sagittal orientation flush with the skin on the lateral buttock (Figure 3B). The guide wire must be placed so that it intersects with the first line at the down-sloping point. The skin on the lateral aspect of buttock is marked with a second line, which represents inlet line 2 (Figure 2).
The same process is repeated using an outlet view to create outlet lines 1 and 2 (Figures 4A, 4B). At this point there are 4 lines drawn on the patient (Figure 2). A stab incision is made at the intersection of the 2 lines drawn on the lateral buttock; this represents the skin start point, labeled “start incision” (Figure 2). The procedure continues in standard fashion.
The 4 external reference lines serve multiple purposes. First, the lines mark the true lateral start point for the pin at the level of the skin. This contrasts with the standard technique in which bony landmarks are marked on the skin and the surgeon must estimate a point on the skin that will provide an appropriate trajectory to the bony start point on the ilium. Further, the lines can also be used to reorient the cartesian plane so that adjustments can be isolated to a single plane, ensuring movements only alter the position on a single radiographic view (Figure 5).
Discussion
Despite the widespread use of percutaneous screw placement for posterior pelvic ring injuries, this remains a technically demanding surgery. Recent data suggest patient pelvic anatomy is extremely varied, especially the sacrum.7 Further, screw trajectories vary depending on surgical goals, fracture pattern, and number of screws. Taken together, this implies that there is no perfect universal starting site along the external ilium. Therefore, while classic teaching states to begin screw insertion within the vicinity of the intersection of the greater trochanter and the ASIS, it is our experience that this location is often not ideal.
The inlet, outlet, and lateral radiographs are all vital to assess correct trajectory of the guide pin and drill prior to final screw insertion, but the start site remains a critical step to assure a successful surgical outcome. We present 2 techniques, used together or separately, that allow the surgeon to place the initial guide pin more accurately for percutanous iliosacral screws. Though not specifically examined in this study, we think technique 2 has the potential to save operative time and use less fluoroscopic imaging because a lateral image is not required until later in the case. Technique 2 identifies the start point at the level of the skin. This is in contrast to technique 1, which identifies the desired sacral target and requires a surgeon to select a skin start site that will provide an optimal trajectory towards the desired target. Judging trajectory can be difficult, particularly in obese patients, and technique 2 eliminates this extra variable.
It is also important to consider that criteria-based nonorthogonal imaging is required for percutaneous screw placement. In these cases, it is more difficult to judge trajectory corrections because the fluoroscopic beam cannot guide perpendicular corrections as it can in operations that use orthogonal imaging. Adjustments made perpendicular to the fluoroscopic beam will change trajectory in multiple planes.8 Moreover, because the standard cartesian frame of reference is rotated, understanding the location of the sacrum in space can be especially challenging. When using the first technique, sacral landmarks are delineated, and a virtual sacrum drawn on the patient’s exterior helps with orientation. In the second technique, the ideal pin placement is mapped, and the external reference lines guide uniplanar changes. For example, the line drawn co-planar with the inlet view is essentially marking the sacral slope. Therefore, by following this line, uniplanar changes in the cranial and caudal direction are achieved on the outlet view (Figure 5). Because this line is also in reference to the already known ideal pin placement, ideal pin placement can be maintained in 1 radiographic projection while changing the start site in the appropriate direction. In a similar fashion, the co-planar line identified on the inlet view can be used on the outlet image to affect uniplanar changes in the anteroposterior direction. This technique effectively minimizes disorientation when placing percutaneous SI screws. This can be particularly beneficial when placing screws in the prone position.
Conclusion
We have shown 2 techniques that are routinely used at our institution to help identify an accurate starting position for percutaneous screw placement in posterior pelvic ring injuries. Even experienced traumatologists can more quickly and accurately identify the correct stab incisions leading to more confidently placed screws. Further, we believe understanding the usage of fluoroscopy and the concepts involved in drawing the lines enhance trainees’ comprehension of the complex anatomy of the sacrum.
1. Matta JM, Saucedo T. Internal fixation of pelvic ring fractures. Clin Orthop Relat Res. 1989;242:83-97.
2. Routt ML Jr, Kregor PJ, Simonian PT, Mayo KA. Early results of percutaneous iliosacral screws placed with the patient in the supine position. J Orthop Trauma. 1995;9(3):207-214.
3. Sagi HC, Lindvall EM. Inadvertent intraforaminal iliosacral screw placement despite apparent appropriate positioning on intraoperative fluoroscopy.
J Orthop Trauma. 2005;19(2):130-133.
4. Routt ML Jr, Simonian PT, Mills WJ. Iliosacral screw fixation: early complications of the percutaneous technique. J Orthop Trauma. 1997;11(8):584-589.
5. Routt ML Jr, Simonian PT, Agnew SG, Mann FA. Radiographic recognition of the sacral alar slope for optimal placement of iliosacral screws: a cadaveric and clinical study. J Orthop Trauma. 1996;10(3):171-177.
6. Gardner MJ, Ferrell ED, Nork SE, Segina DN, Routt ML Jr. Percutaneous placement of iliosacral screws without electrodiagnostic monitoring. J Trauma. 2009;66(5):1411-1415.
7. Miller AN, Routt ML Jr. Variations in sacral morphology and implications for iliosacral screw fixation. J Am Acad Orthop Surg. 2012;20(1):8-16.
8. Graves ML, Routt ML. Iliosacral screw placement: are uniplanar changes realistic based on standard fluoroscopic imaging? J Orthop Trauma. 2011;71(1):204-208.
1. Matta JM, Saucedo T. Internal fixation of pelvic ring fractures. Clin Orthop Relat Res. 1989;242:83-97.
2. Routt ML Jr, Kregor PJ, Simonian PT, Mayo KA. Early results of percutaneous iliosacral screws placed with the patient in the supine position. J Orthop Trauma. 1995;9(3):207-214.
3. Sagi HC, Lindvall EM. Inadvertent intraforaminal iliosacral screw placement despite apparent appropriate positioning on intraoperative fluoroscopy.
J Orthop Trauma. 2005;19(2):130-133.
4. Routt ML Jr, Simonian PT, Mills WJ. Iliosacral screw fixation: early complications of the percutaneous technique. J Orthop Trauma. 1997;11(8):584-589.
5. Routt ML Jr, Simonian PT, Agnew SG, Mann FA. Radiographic recognition of the sacral alar slope for optimal placement of iliosacral screws: a cadaveric and clinical study. J Orthop Trauma. 1996;10(3):171-177.
6. Gardner MJ, Ferrell ED, Nork SE, Segina DN, Routt ML Jr. Percutaneous placement of iliosacral screws without electrodiagnostic monitoring. J Trauma. 2009;66(5):1411-1415.
7. Miller AN, Routt ML Jr. Variations in sacral morphology and implications for iliosacral screw fixation. J Am Acad Orthop Surg. 2012;20(1):8-16.
8. Graves ML, Routt ML. Iliosacral screw placement: are uniplanar changes realistic based on standard fluoroscopic imaging? J Orthop Trauma. 2011;71(1):204-208.
Emergency Imaging
Case
A 32-year-old woman presented to the ED with a 6-month history of worsening skin erosion along her right elbow and forearm. The patient described unremitting pain and progressive shortening of her forearm. Radiographs were obtained; representative images are shown above (Figures 1a and 1b).
What is the diagnosis?
***BREAKING***
Answer
Anteroposterior and lateral radiographs of the right elbow demonstrated a large soft tissue defect involving the proximal forearm (white arrows, Figures 2a and 2b) with extensive osseous destruction of the proximal radius (R) and ulna (U). Deformity of the forearm was apparent. There was marked periosteal reaction involving the distal humerus (black arrows, Figures 2a and 2b). A needle fragment projected over the antecubital space on both radiographs (red arrow, Figures 2a and 2b). These findings indicated the presence of osteomyelitis and septic arthritis. The needle fragment suggested drug abuse as the likely etiology.
This patient had a 2-year history of intravenous (IV) drug abuse. She initially noticed an open wound on her elbow about 6 months prior to presentation. As the wound worsened, she developed increasing pain, numbness, and weakness in her forearm and hand. Physical examination revealed a markedly contracted forearm. There was a large, deep ulcer at the lateral aspect of the elbow and proximal forearm, with exposed bone and surrounding necrotic tissue. Motor function was limited to minimal movement of the thumb and index finger, and there was complete loss of sensation in an ulnar distribution. A deep tissue culture grew methicillin-resistant Staphylococcus aureus, and a bone biopsy confirmed the diagnosis of osteomyelitis. The patient was treated with antibiotics but ultimately required transhumeral amputation.
Intravenous drug users are at risk for soft tissue and bone complications, including ulcer, abscess, septic bursitis, tenosynovitis, cellulitis, necrotizing fasciitis, septic arthritis, and osteomyelitis.1 Osteomyelitis can arise from direct inoculation, hematogenous spread, or, as was the case in this patient, secondary to seeding from a contiguous soft tissue infection.2 Unlike hematogenous osteomyelitis, contiguous focus osteomyelitis is often polymicrobial.
Radiographs are not sensitive for osteomyelitis, particularly early in the process, but may reveal loss of soft tissue planes prior to the development of focal osteopenia and osseous destruction.3 In this case, the diagnosis could be made through radiography given the marked osseous destruction, periosteal reaction, and soft tissue ulceration. However, in presentations in which there is a continued clinical suspicion for osteomyelitis despite normal or inconclusive radiographs, magnetic resonance imaging (MRI) with contrast is the preferred examination for further evaluation. While both contrast and noncontrast-enhanced MRI may show the bone marrow edema related to osteomyelitis, contrast is helpful in evaluating for soft tissue abscesses and in determining if there is an adequate blood supply for IV treatment to be effective. An alternative exam to MRI would be nuclear scintigraphy (a tagged, white blood cell scan and/or a three-phase bone scan).
Later in the disease course, periosteal bone reaction and sclerotic reactive bone formation can be seen. A sequestrum forms when there is complete resorption of the bone adjacent to a devitalized segment of infected bone, leaving the isolated devitalized segment to function as a nidus for continued infection.3
Dr Spivey is a resident in the department of radiology at New York Presbyterian Hospital/Weill Cornell Medical College in New York City. Dr Bartolotta is an assistant professor of radiology at Weill Cornell Medical College in New York City and assistant attending radiologist at New York-Presbyterian Hospital/Weill Cornell Medical Center. Dr Hentel is an associate professor of clinical radiology at Weill Cornell Medical College in New York City. He is also chief of emergency/musculoskeletal imaging and executive vice-chairman for the department of radiology at New York-Presbyterian Hospital/Weill Cornell Medical Center; and associate editor, imaging, of the EMERGENCY MEDICINE editorial board.
- Theodorou SJ, Theodorou DJ, Resnick D. Imaging findings of complications affecting the upper extremity in intravenous drug users: featured cases. Emerg Radiol. 2008;15(4):227-239.
- Sia IG, Berbari, EF. Infection and musculoskeletal conditions: Osteomyelitis. Best Pract Res Clin Rheumatol. 2006;20(6):1065-1081.
- Gold RH, Hawkins RA, Katz RD. Bacterial osteomyelitis: findings on plain radiography, CT, MR, and scintigraphy. AJR Am J Roentgenol. 1991;157(2):365-370.
Case
A 32-year-old woman presented to the ED with a 6-month history of worsening skin erosion along her right elbow and forearm. The patient described unremitting pain and progressive shortening of her forearm. Radiographs were obtained; representative images are shown above (Figures 1a and 1b).
What is the diagnosis?
***BREAKING***
Answer
Anteroposterior and lateral radiographs of the right elbow demonstrated a large soft tissue defect involving the proximal forearm (white arrows, Figures 2a and 2b) with extensive osseous destruction of the proximal radius (R) and ulna (U). Deformity of the forearm was apparent. There was marked periosteal reaction involving the distal humerus (black arrows, Figures 2a and 2b). A needle fragment projected over the antecubital space on both radiographs (red arrow, Figures 2a and 2b). These findings indicated the presence of osteomyelitis and septic arthritis. The needle fragment suggested drug abuse as the likely etiology.
This patient had a 2-year history of intravenous (IV) drug abuse. She initially noticed an open wound on her elbow about 6 months prior to presentation. As the wound worsened, she developed increasing pain, numbness, and weakness in her forearm and hand. Physical examination revealed a markedly contracted forearm. There was a large, deep ulcer at the lateral aspect of the elbow and proximal forearm, with exposed bone and surrounding necrotic tissue. Motor function was limited to minimal movement of the thumb and index finger, and there was complete loss of sensation in an ulnar distribution. A deep tissue culture grew methicillin-resistant Staphylococcus aureus, and a bone biopsy confirmed the diagnosis of osteomyelitis. The patient was treated with antibiotics but ultimately required transhumeral amputation.
Intravenous drug users are at risk for soft tissue and bone complications, including ulcer, abscess, septic bursitis, tenosynovitis, cellulitis, necrotizing fasciitis, septic arthritis, and osteomyelitis.1 Osteomyelitis can arise from direct inoculation, hematogenous spread, or, as was the case in this patient, secondary to seeding from a contiguous soft tissue infection.2 Unlike hematogenous osteomyelitis, contiguous focus osteomyelitis is often polymicrobial.
Radiographs are not sensitive for osteomyelitis, particularly early in the process, but may reveal loss of soft tissue planes prior to the development of focal osteopenia and osseous destruction.3 In this case, the diagnosis could be made through radiography given the marked osseous destruction, periosteal reaction, and soft tissue ulceration. However, in presentations in which there is a continued clinical suspicion for osteomyelitis despite normal or inconclusive radiographs, magnetic resonance imaging (MRI) with contrast is the preferred examination for further evaluation. While both contrast and noncontrast-enhanced MRI may show the bone marrow edema related to osteomyelitis, contrast is helpful in evaluating for soft tissue abscesses and in determining if there is an adequate blood supply for IV treatment to be effective. An alternative exam to MRI would be nuclear scintigraphy (a tagged, white blood cell scan and/or a three-phase bone scan).
Later in the disease course, periosteal bone reaction and sclerotic reactive bone formation can be seen. A sequestrum forms when there is complete resorption of the bone adjacent to a devitalized segment of infected bone, leaving the isolated devitalized segment to function as a nidus for continued infection.3
Dr Spivey is a resident in the department of radiology at New York Presbyterian Hospital/Weill Cornell Medical College in New York City. Dr Bartolotta is an assistant professor of radiology at Weill Cornell Medical College in New York City and assistant attending radiologist at New York-Presbyterian Hospital/Weill Cornell Medical Center. Dr Hentel is an associate professor of clinical radiology at Weill Cornell Medical College in New York City. He is also chief of emergency/musculoskeletal imaging and executive vice-chairman for the department of radiology at New York-Presbyterian Hospital/Weill Cornell Medical Center; and associate editor, imaging, of the EMERGENCY MEDICINE editorial board.
Case
A 32-year-old woman presented to the ED with a 6-month history of worsening skin erosion along her right elbow and forearm. The patient described unremitting pain and progressive shortening of her forearm. Radiographs were obtained; representative images are shown above (Figures 1a and 1b).
What is the diagnosis?
***BREAKING***
Answer
Anteroposterior and lateral radiographs of the right elbow demonstrated a large soft tissue defect involving the proximal forearm (white arrows, Figures 2a and 2b) with extensive osseous destruction of the proximal radius (R) and ulna (U). Deformity of the forearm was apparent. There was marked periosteal reaction involving the distal humerus (black arrows, Figures 2a and 2b). A needle fragment projected over the antecubital space on both radiographs (red arrow, Figures 2a and 2b). These findings indicated the presence of osteomyelitis and septic arthritis. The needle fragment suggested drug abuse as the likely etiology.
This patient had a 2-year history of intravenous (IV) drug abuse. She initially noticed an open wound on her elbow about 6 months prior to presentation. As the wound worsened, she developed increasing pain, numbness, and weakness in her forearm and hand. Physical examination revealed a markedly contracted forearm. There was a large, deep ulcer at the lateral aspect of the elbow and proximal forearm, with exposed bone and surrounding necrotic tissue. Motor function was limited to minimal movement of the thumb and index finger, and there was complete loss of sensation in an ulnar distribution. A deep tissue culture grew methicillin-resistant Staphylococcus aureus, and a bone biopsy confirmed the diagnosis of osteomyelitis. The patient was treated with antibiotics but ultimately required transhumeral amputation.
Intravenous drug users are at risk for soft tissue and bone complications, including ulcer, abscess, septic bursitis, tenosynovitis, cellulitis, necrotizing fasciitis, septic arthritis, and osteomyelitis.1 Osteomyelitis can arise from direct inoculation, hematogenous spread, or, as was the case in this patient, secondary to seeding from a contiguous soft tissue infection.2 Unlike hematogenous osteomyelitis, contiguous focus osteomyelitis is often polymicrobial.
Radiographs are not sensitive for osteomyelitis, particularly early in the process, but may reveal loss of soft tissue planes prior to the development of focal osteopenia and osseous destruction.3 In this case, the diagnosis could be made through radiography given the marked osseous destruction, periosteal reaction, and soft tissue ulceration. However, in presentations in which there is a continued clinical suspicion for osteomyelitis despite normal or inconclusive radiographs, magnetic resonance imaging (MRI) with contrast is the preferred examination for further evaluation. While both contrast and noncontrast-enhanced MRI may show the bone marrow edema related to osteomyelitis, contrast is helpful in evaluating for soft tissue abscesses and in determining if there is an adequate blood supply for IV treatment to be effective. An alternative exam to MRI would be nuclear scintigraphy (a tagged, white blood cell scan and/or a three-phase bone scan).
Later in the disease course, periosteal bone reaction and sclerotic reactive bone formation can be seen. A sequestrum forms when there is complete resorption of the bone adjacent to a devitalized segment of infected bone, leaving the isolated devitalized segment to function as a nidus for continued infection.3
Dr Spivey is a resident in the department of radiology at New York Presbyterian Hospital/Weill Cornell Medical College in New York City. Dr Bartolotta is an assistant professor of radiology at Weill Cornell Medical College in New York City and assistant attending radiologist at New York-Presbyterian Hospital/Weill Cornell Medical Center. Dr Hentel is an associate professor of clinical radiology at Weill Cornell Medical College in New York City. He is also chief of emergency/musculoskeletal imaging and executive vice-chairman for the department of radiology at New York-Presbyterian Hospital/Weill Cornell Medical Center; and associate editor, imaging, of the EMERGENCY MEDICINE editorial board.
- Theodorou SJ, Theodorou DJ, Resnick D. Imaging findings of complications affecting the upper extremity in intravenous drug users: featured cases. Emerg Radiol. 2008;15(4):227-239.
- Sia IG, Berbari, EF. Infection and musculoskeletal conditions: Osteomyelitis. Best Pract Res Clin Rheumatol. 2006;20(6):1065-1081.
- Gold RH, Hawkins RA, Katz RD. Bacterial osteomyelitis: findings on plain radiography, CT, MR, and scintigraphy. AJR Am J Roentgenol. 1991;157(2):365-370.
- Theodorou SJ, Theodorou DJ, Resnick D. Imaging findings of complications affecting the upper extremity in intravenous drug users: featured cases. Emerg Radiol. 2008;15(4):227-239.
- Sia IG, Berbari, EF. Infection and musculoskeletal conditions: Osteomyelitis. Best Pract Res Clin Rheumatol. 2006;20(6):1065-1081.
- Gold RH, Hawkins RA, Katz RD. Bacterial osteomyelitis: findings on plain radiography, CT, MR, and scintigraphy. AJR Am J Roentgenol. 1991;157(2):365-370.
An unusual cause of vitamin B12 and iron deficiency
A 76-year-old woman visiting from Ethiopia presented for further evaluation of concomitant iron and vitamin B12 deficiency anemia that had developed over the previous 6 months. During that time, she had complained of ongoing fatigue and increasing paresthesias in the hands and feet.
At presentation, her hemoglobin concentration was 7.8 g/dL (reference range 11.5–15), with a mean corpuscular volume of 81.8 fL (81.5–97.0). These values were down from her baseline hemoglobin of 12 g/dL and corpuscular volume of 85.8 recorded more than 1 year ago. Serum studies showed an iron concentration of 21 µg/dL (37–170), ferritin 3 ng/mL (10–107), and percent saturation of transferrin 5% (20%–55%). Also noted was a low vitamin B12 level of 108 pg/mL (180–1,241 pg/mL). She had no overt signs of gastrointestinal blood loss. She did not report altered bowel habits or use of nonsteroidal anti-inflammatory medications.
Given her country of origin, she was sent for initial stool testing for ova and parasites, which was unrevealing.
She underwent esophagogastroduodenoscopy and colonoscopy, which revealed no underlying cause of her iron deficiency or vitamin B12 insufficiency. But further evaluation with capsule endoscopy showed evidence of a tapeworm in the distal duodenum (Figure 1).
She was given praziquantel in a single oral dose of 10 mg/kg. Repeat stool culture 1 month later showed no evidence of tapeworm infection, and at follow-up 3 months later, her hemoglobin had recovered to 13.2 g/dL with a corpuscular volume of 87.6 fL and no residual vitamin B12 or iron deficiency. She reported complete resolution of fatigue and of paresthesias of the hands and feet.
DIPHYLLOBOTHRIUM LATUM
The appearance on capsule endoscopy indicated Diphyllobothrium latum as the likely parasite. This tapeworm is acquired by ingesting undercooked or raw fish. Infection is most common in Northern Europe but has been reported in Africa.1
As it grows, the tapeworm develops chains of segments and can reach a length of 1 to 15 meters.1 In humans, it typically resides in the small intestine. Most patients are asymptomatic or have moderate nonspecific symptoms such as abdominal pain and diarrhea. A key differentiating aspect of D latum infection is vitamin B12 deficiency caused by consumption of the vitamin by the parasite, as well as by parasite-mediated dissociation of the vitamin B12-intrinsic factor complex, thus making the vitamin unavailable to the host.
Up to 40% of people infected with D latum develop low levels of vitamin B12, and 2% develop symptomatic megaloblastic anemia.2 Iron deficiency anemia is uncommon but has been reported.3 In our patient, the concomitant iron deficiency was probably secondary to involvement of the duodenum, where a significant amount of dietary iron is absorbed.
The diagnosis is typically established by stool testing for ova and parasites. When stool samples do not reveal a cause of the symptoms, as in this patient, endoscopy can be used. Capsule endoscopy has not been widely used in the diagnosis of intestinal helminth infection, although reports exist describing the use of capsule endoscopy to detect intestinal parasites. Notably, as in this case, intestinal parasite infection is occasionally found during investigations of anemia and vitamin deficiencies of unknown cause.4
As in our patient, treatment of infection with this species of tapeworm typically involves a single oral dose of praziquantel; this off-label use has been shown to lead to resolution of symptoms in nearly all patients treated.5
- Schantz PM. Tapeworms (cestodiasis). Gastroenterol Clin North Am 1996; 25:637–653.
- Scholz T, Garcia HH, Kuchta R, Wicht B. Update on the human broad tapeworm (genus Diphyllobothrium), including clinical relevance. Clin Microbiol Rev 2009; 22:146–160,
- Stanciu C, Trifan A, Singeap AM, Sfarti C, Cojocariu C, Luca M. Diphyllobothrium latum identified by capsule endoscopy—an unusual cause of iron-deficiency anemia. J Gastrointestin Liver Dis 2009; 18:142.
- Soga K, Handa O, Yamada M, et al. In vivo imaging of intestinal helminths by capsule endoscopy. Parasitol Int 2014; 63:221–228.
- Drugs for Parasitic Infections. 3rd edition. Treatment guidelines from the Medical Letter 2010. The Medical Letter, Inc., New Rochelle, NY.
A 76-year-old woman visiting from Ethiopia presented for further evaluation of concomitant iron and vitamin B12 deficiency anemia that had developed over the previous 6 months. During that time, she had complained of ongoing fatigue and increasing paresthesias in the hands and feet.
At presentation, her hemoglobin concentration was 7.8 g/dL (reference range 11.5–15), with a mean corpuscular volume of 81.8 fL (81.5–97.0). These values were down from her baseline hemoglobin of 12 g/dL and corpuscular volume of 85.8 recorded more than 1 year ago. Serum studies showed an iron concentration of 21 µg/dL (37–170), ferritin 3 ng/mL (10–107), and percent saturation of transferrin 5% (20%–55%). Also noted was a low vitamin B12 level of 108 pg/mL (180–1,241 pg/mL). She had no overt signs of gastrointestinal blood loss. She did not report altered bowel habits or use of nonsteroidal anti-inflammatory medications.
Given her country of origin, she was sent for initial stool testing for ova and parasites, which was unrevealing.
She underwent esophagogastroduodenoscopy and colonoscopy, which revealed no underlying cause of her iron deficiency or vitamin B12 insufficiency. But further evaluation with capsule endoscopy showed evidence of a tapeworm in the distal duodenum (Figure 1).
She was given praziquantel in a single oral dose of 10 mg/kg. Repeat stool culture 1 month later showed no evidence of tapeworm infection, and at follow-up 3 months later, her hemoglobin had recovered to 13.2 g/dL with a corpuscular volume of 87.6 fL and no residual vitamin B12 or iron deficiency. She reported complete resolution of fatigue and of paresthesias of the hands and feet.
DIPHYLLOBOTHRIUM LATUM
The appearance on capsule endoscopy indicated Diphyllobothrium latum as the likely parasite. This tapeworm is acquired by ingesting undercooked or raw fish. Infection is most common in Northern Europe but has been reported in Africa.1
As it grows, the tapeworm develops chains of segments and can reach a length of 1 to 15 meters.1 In humans, it typically resides in the small intestine. Most patients are asymptomatic or have moderate nonspecific symptoms such as abdominal pain and diarrhea. A key differentiating aspect of D latum infection is vitamin B12 deficiency caused by consumption of the vitamin by the parasite, as well as by parasite-mediated dissociation of the vitamin B12-intrinsic factor complex, thus making the vitamin unavailable to the host.
Up to 40% of people infected with D latum develop low levels of vitamin B12, and 2% develop symptomatic megaloblastic anemia.2 Iron deficiency anemia is uncommon but has been reported.3 In our patient, the concomitant iron deficiency was probably secondary to involvement of the duodenum, where a significant amount of dietary iron is absorbed.
The diagnosis is typically established by stool testing for ova and parasites. When stool samples do not reveal a cause of the symptoms, as in this patient, endoscopy can be used. Capsule endoscopy has not been widely used in the diagnosis of intestinal helminth infection, although reports exist describing the use of capsule endoscopy to detect intestinal parasites. Notably, as in this case, intestinal parasite infection is occasionally found during investigations of anemia and vitamin deficiencies of unknown cause.4
As in our patient, treatment of infection with this species of tapeworm typically involves a single oral dose of praziquantel; this off-label use has been shown to lead to resolution of symptoms in nearly all patients treated.5
A 76-year-old woman visiting from Ethiopia presented for further evaluation of concomitant iron and vitamin B12 deficiency anemia that had developed over the previous 6 months. During that time, she had complained of ongoing fatigue and increasing paresthesias in the hands and feet.
At presentation, her hemoglobin concentration was 7.8 g/dL (reference range 11.5–15), with a mean corpuscular volume of 81.8 fL (81.5–97.0). These values were down from her baseline hemoglobin of 12 g/dL and corpuscular volume of 85.8 recorded more than 1 year ago. Serum studies showed an iron concentration of 21 µg/dL (37–170), ferritin 3 ng/mL (10–107), and percent saturation of transferrin 5% (20%–55%). Also noted was a low vitamin B12 level of 108 pg/mL (180–1,241 pg/mL). She had no overt signs of gastrointestinal blood loss. She did not report altered bowel habits or use of nonsteroidal anti-inflammatory medications.
Given her country of origin, she was sent for initial stool testing for ova and parasites, which was unrevealing.
She underwent esophagogastroduodenoscopy and colonoscopy, which revealed no underlying cause of her iron deficiency or vitamin B12 insufficiency. But further evaluation with capsule endoscopy showed evidence of a tapeworm in the distal duodenum (Figure 1).
She was given praziquantel in a single oral dose of 10 mg/kg. Repeat stool culture 1 month later showed no evidence of tapeworm infection, and at follow-up 3 months later, her hemoglobin had recovered to 13.2 g/dL with a corpuscular volume of 87.6 fL and no residual vitamin B12 or iron deficiency. She reported complete resolution of fatigue and of paresthesias of the hands and feet.
DIPHYLLOBOTHRIUM LATUM
The appearance on capsule endoscopy indicated Diphyllobothrium latum as the likely parasite. This tapeworm is acquired by ingesting undercooked or raw fish. Infection is most common in Northern Europe but has been reported in Africa.1
As it grows, the tapeworm develops chains of segments and can reach a length of 1 to 15 meters.1 In humans, it typically resides in the small intestine. Most patients are asymptomatic or have moderate nonspecific symptoms such as abdominal pain and diarrhea. A key differentiating aspect of D latum infection is vitamin B12 deficiency caused by consumption of the vitamin by the parasite, as well as by parasite-mediated dissociation of the vitamin B12-intrinsic factor complex, thus making the vitamin unavailable to the host.
Up to 40% of people infected with D latum develop low levels of vitamin B12, and 2% develop symptomatic megaloblastic anemia.2 Iron deficiency anemia is uncommon but has been reported.3 In our patient, the concomitant iron deficiency was probably secondary to involvement of the duodenum, where a significant amount of dietary iron is absorbed.
The diagnosis is typically established by stool testing for ova and parasites. When stool samples do not reveal a cause of the symptoms, as in this patient, endoscopy can be used. Capsule endoscopy has not been widely used in the diagnosis of intestinal helminth infection, although reports exist describing the use of capsule endoscopy to detect intestinal parasites. Notably, as in this case, intestinal parasite infection is occasionally found during investigations of anemia and vitamin deficiencies of unknown cause.4
As in our patient, treatment of infection with this species of tapeworm typically involves a single oral dose of praziquantel; this off-label use has been shown to lead to resolution of symptoms in nearly all patients treated.5
- Schantz PM. Tapeworms (cestodiasis). Gastroenterol Clin North Am 1996; 25:637–653.
- Scholz T, Garcia HH, Kuchta R, Wicht B. Update on the human broad tapeworm (genus Diphyllobothrium), including clinical relevance. Clin Microbiol Rev 2009; 22:146–160,
- Stanciu C, Trifan A, Singeap AM, Sfarti C, Cojocariu C, Luca M. Diphyllobothrium latum identified by capsule endoscopy—an unusual cause of iron-deficiency anemia. J Gastrointestin Liver Dis 2009; 18:142.
- Soga K, Handa O, Yamada M, et al. In vivo imaging of intestinal helminths by capsule endoscopy. Parasitol Int 2014; 63:221–228.
- Drugs for Parasitic Infections. 3rd edition. Treatment guidelines from the Medical Letter 2010. The Medical Letter, Inc., New Rochelle, NY.
- Schantz PM. Tapeworms (cestodiasis). Gastroenterol Clin North Am 1996; 25:637–653.
- Scholz T, Garcia HH, Kuchta R, Wicht B. Update on the human broad tapeworm (genus Diphyllobothrium), including clinical relevance. Clin Microbiol Rev 2009; 22:146–160,
- Stanciu C, Trifan A, Singeap AM, Sfarti C, Cojocariu C, Luca M. Diphyllobothrium latum identified by capsule endoscopy—an unusual cause of iron-deficiency anemia. J Gastrointestin Liver Dis 2009; 18:142.
- Soga K, Handa O, Yamada M, et al. In vivo imaging of intestinal helminths by capsule endoscopy. Parasitol Int 2014; 63:221–228.
- Drugs for Parasitic Infections. 3rd edition. Treatment guidelines from the Medical Letter 2010. The Medical Letter, Inc., New Rochelle, NY.
SAEM: Pelvic CT may not be needed to diagnose intra-abdominal injury in children
SAN DIEGO – Children who have suffered blunt trauma are routinely screened in emergency departments for intra-abdominal injury via computed tomography of the abdomen and pelvis.
But concerns about excess exposure to CT radiation, particularly to the gonads, led one group of researchers to question whether it’s necessary to scan the entire abdominopelvic region in all of these patients to identify intra-abdominal injury (IAI).
Dr. Stacy Reynolds and her colleagues at the Carolinas Medical Center in Charlotte, N.C., hypothesized that CT limited to the radiographic abdomen – the region between the dome of the diaphragm to the top of the iliac crest – can capture the vast majority of IAIs in this population.
At the Society for Academic Emergency Medicine annual meeting, Dr. Reynolds presented results from a retrospective cohort study enrolling 313 hemodynamically stable pediatric patients (median age 14 years, 64% male) presenting to 12 EDs after blunt trauma. Patients with known pelvic fractures or hip dislocation were excluded, as they would have had a clear indication for a full abdominopelvic CT.
All subjects underwent axial abdominopelvic CT imaging. Researchers created matched pairs of images comprising the original scans and those that had been altered with software that truncated the pelvic portion of the study to create CT abdomen-only studies. Study radiologists were blinded to the results of the original scans.
Twenty-six IAI’s were diagnosed in 24 patients: 8 hepatic injuries, 12 splenic injuries, 5 renal injuries, and 1 retroperitoneal hemorrhage. Abdominal CT alone was 85% sensitive (95% confidence interval, 65%-96%) and 99% specific (95% CI, 97%-100%) in identifying IAIs. The four missed injuries were solid organ injuries within the radiographic abdomen. False positives occurred in two of the complete scans, both involving free fluid prompting suspicion of small bowel injury later ruled out by clinical observation.
Dr. Reynolds said in an interview said that the findings, while promising, were limited by the study’s small numbers, and its use of axial images alone, when sagittal images also would be required for the most accurate diagnoses. Also, physician suspicion of IAI prior to imaging was not captured because of the study’s retrospective design, she said. “The real key to whether or not this hypothesis is valuable is if physicians are able to target the right population of patients for application.”
Dr. Reynolds cautioned that the findings would need to be validated in a larger trial before any changes could be made to clinical practice. “Some of the outcomes that we need to make sure whether we’re missing are still rare,” she said. “You couldn’t feel confident that this is the right way to go with a study this small, but it establishes that we can safely and ethically pursue a multicenter trial that would examine the issue with bigger numbers.”
Other groups of investigators, including members of the Pediatric Emergency Care Applied Research Network (PECARN), also have taken up the question of identifying children at low risk of IAI who may not need CT screening after blunt trauma. In 2013, PECARN published a prediction rule using only patient history and physical examination findings intended to obviate use of CT in the lowest-risk patients (Ann. Emerg. Med. 2013;62:107-16.e2).
Dr. Reynolds said that while overuse of CT was a worrisome trend that could have long-term implications for patients, and that it was important to identify ways it might be limited, there is a reason it remains the go-to technology in the ED for detecting IAI. “It’s got very high sensitivity and specificity. If you’re a busy trauma surgeon who’s admitting 20 injured patients in a night, there’s no faster or more efficient way to determine whether the patient in front of you is injured.”
The study was funded by the Carolinas Trauma Network Research Center of Excellence. None of the investigators disclosed conflicts of interest.
SAN DIEGO – Children who have suffered blunt trauma are routinely screened in emergency departments for intra-abdominal injury via computed tomography of the abdomen and pelvis.
But concerns about excess exposure to CT radiation, particularly to the gonads, led one group of researchers to question whether it’s necessary to scan the entire abdominopelvic region in all of these patients to identify intra-abdominal injury (IAI).
Dr. Stacy Reynolds and her colleagues at the Carolinas Medical Center in Charlotte, N.C., hypothesized that CT limited to the radiographic abdomen – the region between the dome of the diaphragm to the top of the iliac crest – can capture the vast majority of IAIs in this population.
At the Society for Academic Emergency Medicine annual meeting, Dr. Reynolds presented results from a retrospective cohort study enrolling 313 hemodynamically stable pediatric patients (median age 14 years, 64% male) presenting to 12 EDs after blunt trauma. Patients with known pelvic fractures or hip dislocation were excluded, as they would have had a clear indication for a full abdominopelvic CT.
All subjects underwent axial abdominopelvic CT imaging. Researchers created matched pairs of images comprising the original scans and those that had been altered with software that truncated the pelvic portion of the study to create CT abdomen-only studies. Study radiologists were blinded to the results of the original scans.
Twenty-six IAI’s were diagnosed in 24 patients: 8 hepatic injuries, 12 splenic injuries, 5 renal injuries, and 1 retroperitoneal hemorrhage. Abdominal CT alone was 85% sensitive (95% confidence interval, 65%-96%) and 99% specific (95% CI, 97%-100%) in identifying IAIs. The four missed injuries were solid organ injuries within the radiographic abdomen. False positives occurred in two of the complete scans, both involving free fluid prompting suspicion of small bowel injury later ruled out by clinical observation.
Dr. Reynolds said in an interview said that the findings, while promising, were limited by the study’s small numbers, and its use of axial images alone, when sagittal images also would be required for the most accurate diagnoses. Also, physician suspicion of IAI prior to imaging was not captured because of the study’s retrospective design, she said. “The real key to whether or not this hypothesis is valuable is if physicians are able to target the right population of patients for application.”
Dr. Reynolds cautioned that the findings would need to be validated in a larger trial before any changes could be made to clinical practice. “Some of the outcomes that we need to make sure whether we’re missing are still rare,” she said. “You couldn’t feel confident that this is the right way to go with a study this small, but it establishes that we can safely and ethically pursue a multicenter trial that would examine the issue with bigger numbers.”
Other groups of investigators, including members of the Pediatric Emergency Care Applied Research Network (PECARN), also have taken up the question of identifying children at low risk of IAI who may not need CT screening after blunt trauma. In 2013, PECARN published a prediction rule using only patient history and physical examination findings intended to obviate use of CT in the lowest-risk patients (Ann. Emerg. Med. 2013;62:107-16.e2).
Dr. Reynolds said that while overuse of CT was a worrisome trend that could have long-term implications for patients, and that it was important to identify ways it might be limited, there is a reason it remains the go-to technology in the ED for detecting IAI. “It’s got very high sensitivity and specificity. If you’re a busy trauma surgeon who’s admitting 20 injured patients in a night, there’s no faster or more efficient way to determine whether the patient in front of you is injured.”
The study was funded by the Carolinas Trauma Network Research Center of Excellence. None of the investigators disclosed conflicts of interest.
SAN DIEGO – Children who have suffered blunt trauma are routinely screened in emergency departments for intra-abdominal injury via computed tomography of the abdomen and pelvis.
But concerns about excess exposure to CT radiation, particularly to the gonads, led one group of researchers to question whether it’s necessary to scan the entire abdominopelvic region in all of these patients to identify intra-abdominal injury (IAI).
Dr. Stacy Reynolds and her colleagues at the Carolinas Medical Center in Charlotte, N.C., hypothesized that CT limited to the radiographic abdomen – the region between the dome of the diaphragm to the top of the iliac crest – can capture the vast majority of IAIs in this population.
At the Society for Academic Emergency Medicine annual meeting, Dr. Reynolds presented results from a retrospective cohort study enrolling 313 hemodynamically stable pediatric patients (median age 14 years, 64% male) presenting to 12 EDs after blunt trauma. Patients with known pelvic fractures or hip dislocation were excluded, as they would have had a clear indication for a full abdominopelvic CT.
All subjects underwent axial abdominopelvic CT imaging. Researchers created matched pairs of images comprising the original scans and those that had been altered with software that truncated the pelvic portion of the study to create CT abdomen-only studies. Study radiologists were blinded to the results of the original scans.
Twenty-six IAI’s were diagnosed in 24 patients: 8 hepatic injuries, 12 splenic injuries, 5 renal injuries, and 1 retroperitoneal hemorrhage. Abdominal CT alone was 85% sensitive (95% confidence interval, 65%-96%) and 99% specific (95% CI, 97%-100%) in identifying IAIs. The four missed injuries were solid organ injuries within the radiographic abdomen. False positives occurred in two of the complete scans, both involving free fluid prompting suspicion of small bowel injury later ruled out by clinical observation.
Dr. Reynolds said in an interview said that the findings, while promising, were limited by the study’s small numbers, and its use of axial images alone, when sagittal images also would be required for the most accurate diagnoses. Also, physician suspicion of IAI prior to imaging was not captured because of the study’s retrospective design, she said. “The real key to whether or not this hypothesis is valuable is if physicians are able to target the right population of patients for application.”
Dr. Reynolds cautioned that the findings would need to be validated in a larger trial before any changes could be made to clinical practice. “Some of the outcomes that we need to make sure whether we’re missing are still rare,” she said. “You couldn’t feel confident that this is the right way to go with a study this small, but it establishes that we can safely and ethically pursue a multicenter trial that would examine the issue with bigger numbers.”
Other groups of investigators, including members of the Pediatric Emergency Care Applied Research Network (PECARN), also have taken up the question of identifying children at low risk of IAI who may not need CT screening after blunt trauma. In 2013, PECARN published a prediction rule using only patient history and physical examination findings intended to obviate use of CT in the lowest-risk patients (Ann. Emerg. Med. 2013;62:107-16.e2).
Dr. Reynolds said that while overuse of CT was a worrisome trend that could have long-term implications for patients, and that it was important to identify ways it might be limited, there is a reason it remains the go-to technology in the ED for detecting IAI. “It’s got very high sensitivity and specificity. If you’re a busy trauma surgeon who’s admitting 20 injured patients in a night, there’s no faster or more efficient way to determine whether the patient in front of you is injured.”
The study was funded by the Carolinas Trauma Network Research Center of Excellence. None of the investigators disclosed conflicts of interest.
FROM SAEM 2015
Key clinical point: Abdominal CT scans without a pelvic portion may diagnose intra-abdominal injury in children as well as do full abdominopelvic scans, with less radiation exposure to patients.
Major finding: Abdominal CT alone was 85% sensitive (95% CI, 65%-96%) and 99% specific (95% CI, 97%-100%) in identifying IAIs. The four missed injuries were solid organ injuries within the radiographic abdomen.
Data source: A retrospective cohort study of 313 patients aged 3-17 years presenting to 12 emergency departments.
Disclosures: The study was funded by the Carolinas Trauma Network Research Center of Excellence. None of the investigators disclosed conflicts of interest.
Two different MRI-safe ICDs show safety, efficacy
BOSTON – An implantable cardioverter defibrillator device that can safely undergo magnetic resonance imaging may soon be a commercial reality as two different models from two different manufacturers showed safety and mostly uncompromised efficacy during and after MRI in two separate studies reported at the annual scientific sessions of the Heart Rhythm Society.
The impending availability of two different brands of implantable cardioverter defibrillators (ICDs) that allow patients to safely undergo MRI “will hopefully open a new era when most [ICDs] are designed” to be MRI safe, said Dr. Khaled A. Awad, an electrophysiologist at the University of Alabama at Birmingham, and lead investigator for one of the new studies.
“Within 10 years, all ICDs getting implanted will be MRI compatible,” predicted Dr. Michael R. Gold, chief of cardiology and medical director of the heart and vascular center at the Medical University of South Carolina in Charleston and lead investigator for the second study.
Until now, having an ICD in a patient created a contraindication for using MRI on the patient, a situation that would change once MRI-safe ICDs become routinely available, noted Dr. Gold. MRI-compatible implanted pacemakers have been on the U.S. market since 2011; ICDs able to safely undergo MRI exposure became the next frontier for creating implanted cardiovascular devices that allow MRIs. Both studies used MRI performed with a 1.5-T magnetic field, a strength commonly used in routine practice today.
The ProMRI study reported by Dr. Awad enrolled patients at 39 U.S. centers who at least 5 weeks previously had received an Iforia ICD made by Biotronik along with commercially available leads believed to be MRI safe. The researchers performed MRIs of the heart or thoracic spine on 154 patients, and then ran follow-up examinations on 150 patients 1 month after the MRI, and a second, 3-month follow-up on 92 of the enrolled patients. The study did not include any control patients who received the ICD and did not undergo MRI.
No patient had an adverse event related or possibly related to their ICD either at the time of the MRI or at follow-up, Dr. Awad reported. In addition, no patients had a significant change in their ICD’s ventricular capture threshold, and one patient had a significant change in the ICD’s ventricular sensing. During follow-up, the ICDs of enrolled patients detected a total of 403 ventricular arrhythmias in 39 patients, with all these episodes appropriately detected and treated.
The study reported by Dr. Gold enrolled patients at 42 centers in 13 countries including the United States. The investigators implanted ICDs into 263 patients using commercially available leads, and then 9-12 weeks after placement, they randomized patients at a 2:1 rate to either undergo MRI or receive no MRI and serve as controls. Of the 175 patients randomized to undergo MRI, 156 actually received the examination, a full-body examination, and 147 participated in follow-up to at least 1 month and were part of the safety analysis.
Patient follow-up showed no complications, no episodes of a significant change in ventricular-pacing sensing threshold, and one episode of a significant change in ventricular-sensing amplitude, Dr. Gold reported, showing safety and efficacy outcomes identical to those in the trial of the Biotronik device. During follow-up 34 episodes of ventricular tachycardia or fibrillation occurred in 24 patients in the MRI group, and the implanted ICDs detected and treated all episodes appropriately. Concurrent with Dr. Gold’s report, the results also appeared in an article published online (J. Am. Coll. Cardiol. 2015 [doi:10.1016/j.jacc.2015.04.047]).
[email protected]
On Twitter @mitchelzoler
MRI-safe implantable cardioverter defibrillators will become the standard of care. They are especially appropriate for patients who are younger when they receive their device and hence more likely to need an MRI at sometime in their future, as well as for older patients who are known to need an MRI in the foreseeable future.
![]() |
Dr. Fred M. Kusumoto |
MRI-safe implanted pacemakers have been routinely available in the United States for a few years, and since their U.S. introduction they have gradually increased their market share and have become the dominant device for younger patients and for patients with a scheduled, upcoming MRI.
Now that MRI-safe pacemakers and implantable cardioverter defibrillators exist, the next step will be to create an MRI-compatible cardiac resynchronization therapy device, but their more complicated design and lead placements will mean further design and engineering challenges.
Dr. Fred M. Kusumoto is a professor of medicine and an electrophysiologist at the Mayo Clinic in Jacksonville, Fla. He had no relevant financial disclosures. He made these comments in an interview.
MRI-safe implantable cardioverter defibrillators will become the standard of care. They are especially appropriate for patients who are younger when they receive their device and hence more likely to need an MRI at sometime in their future, as well as for older patients who are known to need an MRI in the foreseeable future.
![]() |
Dr. Fred M. Kusumoto |
MRI-safe implanted pacemakers have been routinely available in the United States for a few years, and since their U.S. introduction they have gradually increased their market share and have become the dominant device for younger patients and for patients with a scheduled, upcoming MRI.
Now that MRI-safe pacemakers and implantable cardioverter defibrillators exist, the next step will be to create an MRI-compatible cardiac resynchronization therapy device, but their more complicated design and lead placements will mean further design and engineering challenges.
Dr. Fred M. Kusumoto is a professor of medicine and an electrophysiologist at the Mayo Clinic in Jacksonville, Fla. He had no relevant financial disclosures. He made these comments in an interview.
MRI-safe implantable cardioverter defibrillators will become the standard of care. They are especially appropriate for patients who are younger when they receive their device and hence more likely to need an MRI at sometime in their future, as well as for older patients who are known to need an MRI in the foreseeable future.
![]() |
Dr. Fred M. Kusumoto |
MRI-safe implanted pacemakers have been routinely available in the United States for a few years, and since their U.S. introduction they have gradually increased their market share and have become the dominant device for younger patients and for patients with a scheduled, upcoming MRI.
Now that MRI-safe pacemakers and implantable cardioverter defibrillators exist, the next step will be to create an MRI-compatible cardiac resynchronization therapy device, but their more complicated design and lead placements will mean further design and engineering challenges.
Dr. Fred M. Kusumoto is a professor of medicine and an electrophysiologist at the Mayo Clinic in Jacksonville, Fla. He had no relevant financial disclosures. He made these comments in an interview.
BOSTON – An implantable cardioverter defibrillator device that can safely undergo magnetic resonance imaging may soon be a commercial reality as two different models from two different manufacturers showed safety and mostly uncompromised efficacy during and after MRI in two separate studies reported at the annual scientific sessions of the Heart Rhythm Society.
The impending availability of two different brands of implantable cardioverter defibrillators (ICDs) that allow patients to safely undergo MRI “will hopefully open a new era when most [ICDs] are designed” to be MRI safe, said Dr. Khaled A. Awad, an electrophysiologist at the University of Alabama at Birmingham, and lead investigator for one of the new studies.
“Within 10 years, all ICDs getting implanted will be MRI compatible,” predicted Dr. Michael R. Gold, chief of cardiology and medical director of the heart and vascular center at the Medical University of South Carolina in Charleston and lead investigator for the second study.
Until now, having an ICD in a patient created a contraindication for using MRI on the patient, a situation that would change once MRI-safe ICDs become routinely available, noted Dr. Gold. MRI-compatible implanted pacemakers have been on the U.S. market since 2011; ICDs able to safely undergo MRI exposure became the next frontier for creating implanted cardiovascular devices that allow MRIs. Both studies used MRI performed with a 1.5-T magnetic field, a strength commonly used in routine practice today.
The ProMRI study reported by Dr. Awad enrolled patients at 39 U.S. centers who at least 5 weeks previously had received an Iforia ICD made by Biotronik along with commercially available leads believed to be MRI safe. The researchers performed MRIs of the heart or thoracic spine on 154 patients, and then ran follow-up examinations on 150 patients 1 month after the MRI, and a second, 3-month follow-up on 92 of the enrolled patients. The study did not include any control patients who received the ICD and did not undergo MRI.
No patient had an adverse event related or possibly related to their ICD either at the time of the MRI or at follow-up, Dr. Awad reported. In addition, no patients had a significant change in their ICD’s ventricular capture threshold, and one patient had a significant change in the ICD’s ventricular sensing. During follow-up, the ICDs of enrolled patients detected a total of 403 ventricular arrhythmias in 39 patients, with all these episodes appropriately detected and treated.
The study reported by Dr. Gold enrolled patients at 42 centers in 13 countries including the United States. The investigators implanted ICDs into 263 patients using commercially available leads, and then 9-12 weeks after placement, they randomized patients at a 2:1 rate to either undergo MRI or receive no MRI and serve as controls. Of the 175 patients randomized to undergo MRI, 156 actually received the examination, a full-body examination, and 147 participated in follow-up to at least 1 month and were part of the safety analysis.
Patient follow-up showed no complications, no episodes of a significant change in ventricular-pacing sensing threshold, and one episode of a significant change in ventricular-sensing amplitude, Dr. Gold reported, showing safety and efficacy outcomes identical to those in the trial of the Biotronik device. During follow-up 34 episodes of ventricular tachycardia or fibrillation occurred in 24 patients in the MRI group, and the implanted ICDs detected and treated all episodes appropriately. Concurrent with Dr. Gold’s report, the results also appeared in an article published online (J. Am. Coll. Cardiol. 2015 [doi:10.1016/j.jacc.2015.04.047]).
[email protected]
On Twitter @mitchelzoler
BOSTON – An implantable cardioverter defibrillator device that can safely undergo magnetic resonance imaging may soon be a commercial reality as two different models from two different manufacturers showed safety and mostly uncompromised efficacy during and after MRI in two separate studies reported at the annual scientific sessions of the Heart Rhythm Society.
The impending availability of two different brands of implantable cardioverter defibrillators (ICDs) that allow patients to safely undergo MRI “will hopefully open a new era when most [ICDs] are designed” to be MRI safe, said Dr. Khaled A. Awad, an electrophysiologist at the University of Alabama at Birmingham, and lead investigator for one of the new studies.
“Within 10 years, all ICDs getting implanted will be MRI compatible,” predicted Dr. Michael R. Gold, chief of cardiology and medical director of the heart and vascular center at the Medical University of South Carolina in Charleston and lead investigator for the second study.
Until now, having an ICD in a patient created a contraindication for using MRI on the patient, a situation that would change once MRI-safe ICDs become routinely available, noted Dr. Gold. MRI-compatible implanted pacemakers have been on the U.S. market since 2011; ICDs able to safely undergo MRI exposure became the next frontier for creating implanted cardiovascular devices that allow MRIs. Both studies used MRI performed with a 1.5-T magnetic field, a strength commonly used in routine practice today.
The ProMRI study reported by Dr. Awad enrolled patients at 39 U.S. centers who at least 5 weeks previously had received an Iforia ICD made by Biotronik along with commercially available leads believed to be MRI safe. The researchers performed MRIs of the heart or thoracic spine on 154 patients, and then ran follow-up examinations on 150 patients 1 month after the MRI, and a second, 3-month follow-up on 92 of the enrolled patients. The study did not include any control patients who received the ICD and did not undergo MRI.
No patient had an adverse event related or possibly related to their ICD either at the time of the MRI or at follow-up, Dr. Awad reported. In addition, no patients had a significant change in their ICD’s ventricular capture threshold, and one patient had a significant change in the ICD’s ventricular sensing. During follow-up, the ICDs of enrolled patients detected a total of 403 ventricular arrhythmias in 39 patients, with all these episodes appropriately detected and treated.
The study reported by Dr. Gold enrolled patients at 42 centers in 13 countries including the United States. The investigators implanted ICDs into 263 patients using commercially available leads, and then 9-12 weeks after placement, they randomized patients at a 2:1 rate to either undergo MRI or receive no MRI and serve as controls. Of the 175 patients randomized to undergo MRI, 156 actually received the examination, a full-body examination, and 147 participated in follow-up to at least 1 month and were part of the safety analysis.
Patient follow-up showed no complications, no episodes of a significant change in ventricular-pacing sensing threshold, and one episode of a significant change in ventricular-sensing amplitude, Dr. Gold reported, showing safety and efficacy outcomes identical to those in the trial of the Biotronik device. During follow-up 34 episodes of ventricular tachycardia or fibrillation occurred in 24 patients in the MRI group, and the implanted ICDs detected and treated all episodes appropriately. Concurrent with Dr. Gold’s report, the results also appeared in an article published online (J. Am. Coll. Cardiol. 2015 [doi:10.1016/j.jacc.2015.04.047]).
[email protected]
On Twitter @mitchelzoler
AT HEART RHYTHM 2015
Key clinical point: Two different MRI-safe implantable cardioverter defibrillators showed safety and efficacy in pivotal trials.
Major finding: In each study, MRI produced no adverse events and resulted in one episode of impaired ventricular sensing.
Data source: A randomized, controlled trial with 253 patients and data from a prospective series of 154 patients.
Disclosures: Dr. Awad has received research support from Biosense Webster, and two of his coauthors are Biotronik employees. Dr. Gold has been a consultant to and received research grants from Boston Scientific, Medtronic, and St. Jude.
Tech Tools— Innovative Devices for the ED
Emergency physicians (EPs) are always interested in what are the “tried-and-true” as well as the “latest-and-greatest” devices that will provide the best results for their patients. This article, while not a comprehensive list of every such device introduced over the past few years, does provide an overview of the most notable ones applicable for use in the ED.
Tonometry
The standard iCare tonometer device (TA01i; iCare Finland Oy, Vantaa, Finland),1 began to gain acceptance in the United States in 2007 (Figure 1). Early studies2 have shown its measurement accuracy of intraocular pressure (IOP) to be equivalent to traditional tonometers such as the Tono-Pen XL Applanation Tonometer (Reichert Techonologies, Depew, New York).3
The iCare tonometer is easy to calibrate and use. Consisting of a pin inserted into a magnetic housing, the magnet quickly pushes the blunt end of the pin out to make contact with the cornea. Six quick measurements provide the clinician with an average IOP. The device can be used without anesthesia and is also applicable for at-home use.
Airway Devices
C-MAC Tip System
While direct laryngoscopy will always have a role in clinical practice, there has been a revolution in airway management over the past few years, with video laryngoscopy rapidly replacing direct laryngoscopy. The C-MAC Tip system (Karl Storz Endoscopy-America, Inc, El Segundo, California) is one of the devices currently available.4,5 While this device is not at the lower end of the cost spectrum in airway devices, it is, in this author’s opinion, among the highest quality video laryngoscopes on the market. The hub of C-MAC Tip system is a video screen that accepts input from multiple devices. The most common is the video MacIntosh blade, which is shaped like a traditional MacIntosh but with a slightly thicker handle—allowing both direct and indirect intubation.
The C-MAC Tip system is a great teaching tool, allowing learners to perform direct laryngoscopy while providing reassuring visualization to the instructor of the intubation on the screen. (No longer does the instructor need to repeatedly ask the learner what he or she is viewing!) Moreover, when required, the clinician performing the intubation can look at the screen to benefit from the superior visualization of indirect laryngoscopy.
The C-MAC can also accept input from the D-Blade, which facilitates indirect intubation of anterior airways; however, it does not allow direct intubation when secretions or blood obscure the camera, though there is a suction channel that assists in clearing secretions. The clinician can also add a nasal pharyngeal scope as well as an adult or pediatric bronchoscope. The modularity of the C-MAC system is therefore a flexible addition to any airway armamentarium.
Regarding its use in emergency medicine, in addition to cost considerations, a potential concern is the ability of the plastic adapters to hold up to frequent, repetitive use in a setting such as a busy ED.
Wireless Vital Signs Monitoring Systems
Patient vital signs monitoring systems can currently double as four-point restraints. One new device, the ViSi Mobile Monitor System (Sotera Wireless, Inc, San Diego, CA), however, may make this a thing of the past.6 This system allows for inpatient monitoring of respiratory rate (RR), pulse oximetry, continuous blood pressure (BP), and temperature, as well as a multilead electrocardiogram. The entire system attaches to a small wrist-mounted device, which connects to a hospital monitoring system through a WiFi network (Figures 2a and 2b).ViSi Mobile Monitor
Another example of a wireless monitoring device is the EarlySense Chair Sensor system (EarlySense, Ltd, Ramat Gan, Israel) (Figure 3).7 This device assesses heart rate (HR) and RR simply by seating the patient in a chair. In the near future, this device will likely have the ability to take full vital signs. While not quite ready for prime-time in the ED, systems such as the EarlySense Chair Sensor offer a glimpse of the future in vital sign monitoring technology.
Vascular Access
Traditional intravenous (IV) line placement continues to be the standard of care for vascular access, but is not always feasible. Intraosseous needles, which have been around for decades, are seeing a new renaissance of use thanks to devices such as the Arrow EZ-IO Intraosseous Vascular Access System (Teleflex, Shavano Park, Texas).8 With these standards in mind, some new considerations are on the market, including the AV400 vein visualization system (AccuVein, Inc, Huntington, New York).
Arrow EZ-IO Intraosseous Vascular Access System
Teleflex, the maker of the EZ-IO, has recently made a push for humeral placement in order to achieve faster flow rates. Teleflex recommends using the longer needles (normally reserved for obese patients) with specific placement suggestions to facilitate retention of the needle. The Teleflex Web site8 and mobile application provide succinct, easy-to-understand instructions on placement.
AV400 Vein Visualization System
In addition to the Intraosseous Vascular Access System, the placement of an IV line may also be facilitated by laser devices such as AccuVein’s AV400 vein visualization technology. While earlier versions of both of these systems were comparable to that of a skilled technician in obtaining line placement, the latest generations of these devices have improved depth and visualization of truly difficult vascular access.
Internet-Connected Smart Glasses
In addition to the above-mentioned evolutionary changes in facilitating venous access, revolutionary technological advancements have been in development and are forthcoming. One such technology is network-connected smart glasses.
Eyes-On Glasses
Among the first in network-connected eyewear is Eyes-On Glasses (Evena Medical Inc, Los Altos, California).9 This system functions in a similar manner as other laser systems, except that the screen is a display mounted on eyeglasses, making venous placement much more intuitive (This is especially helpful for those who have difficulty translating the three-dimensional world to a two-dimensional screen).
Another variation on head-mounted technology is General Electric’s (GE) beta software for Google Glass (Google Inc, Mountain View, California) (Figure 4). This prototype links a GE ultrasound machine to Google Glass via WiFi, again simultaneously facilitating visualization of the field and the screen.10 While Google Glass is not currently available for the general public, there is still a place for it in the clinical setting.
Both the Eyes-On Glasses and Google Glass devices share a common thread: to improve patient comfort and facilitate time-consuming procedures.
Wound Care
Aquacel Ag
The EP sees a fair share of burn victims, the standard of care for which has been silver sulfadiazine and daily dressing changes. Care for burn wounds is beginning to change with the introduction of antimicrobial impregnated dressings such as Aquacel Ag (ConvaTec Inc, Greensboro, North Carolina).11 Aquacel Ag comes packaged in various forms and sizes ranging from large sheets for torsos to custom formed gloves for hands. This product is safe to use on the face and can be applied to partial thickness burns where the dermal layer is gone. The fluid from the wound moistens the bandage and helps it adhere to the skin. The dressings are then left in place until they slough-off on their own (approximately 7 to 10 days after placement). Consequently, no dressing changes are required, with cosmesis matching that of classic treatment.
While EPs may find Aquacel Ag useful in treating burns that do not require inpatient hospital admission, they also will find its use highly beneficial in treating patients with “road rash,” the abrasions that occur when one wipes-out at high speeds on asphalt (eg, motorcycle accidents). As with burn wounds, only a single application of Aquacel Ag is required on a debrided abrasion.
With respect to price, a single application of Aquacel Ag costs roughly the same as multiple dressing changes with other wound-care products.12 One concern relating to the use of advanced silver-impregnated dressings is the cost of care since silver-impregnated dressings are relatively expensive compared to traditional dressings. The higher cost, however, is partially offset by the reduced use of secondary gauze, and retention dressings, as well as improved wound healing together with the reduced costs of other care. Cost-effectiveness calculations comparing Aquacel Ag to standard of care in patients with acute and chronic wounds showed favorable results using Aquacel Ag.12-18
When using these dressings, the EP should make sure the follow-up clinic is familiar with their application so that they are not inadvertently removed at the patient’s first visit.
Medication Event Monitoring Systems
There have been a couple of recent changes in medication monitoring that are beginning to make manual pill-counting a thing of the past. Earlier generations of smart pill bottles came with a timer and an alarm that chimed and lit up to alert the patient when it was time to take his or her medication. Once the bottle was opened, the system reset itself. Unfortunately, the basic nature of these systems was not able to account for the number of pills a patient ingested at each scheduled dosing.
An example of newer and more technologically advanced pill-monitoring systems is AdhereTech’s smart wireless pill bottle (AdhereTech, New York, New York). In this system, the pill bottle can be connected to a WiFi network, allowing medication information to be shared (Figure 5).19 For example, a user could have the bottle connected to his or her provider, home healthcare worker, and family member. If a patient misses a dose of medication, the appropriate person receives notification and can make contact with the patient or family member to intervene. As with earlier generation products, these systems cannot account for or prevent a patient from either overdosing or underdosing on a medication.
The patch and sensor-enabled pill system, the Ingestible Event Marker, (Proteus Digital Health, Redwood City, California), which became available this past year, provides more advanced medication monitoring.20 This system allows tracking of individual pills through small chips imbedded in the tablet (Figure 6). The chip is then monitored through a patch worn on the patient’s body. Once connected, the physician is able to not only track when a pill bottle is opened, but also when and how many tablets the patient is ingesting. Moreover, the system has the ability to perform physiologic tracking to monitor patient response to the medication.21
Each of the above systems is a huge benefit to elderly patients and their geographically-separated families. Through these devices, children and other family members can stay apprised of a parent or other loved one’s health through these at-home monitoring systems—in a similar manner as some parents track a new teenaged driver through his or her cell phone!
Other Smart Devices
Connected devices are moving past pill bottles and smart glasses. In the same manner that many people employ fitness trackers to monitor the number of steps taken and calories burned, multiple glucometers are available that sync with a patient’s smart phone, allowing upload of the data to his or her healthcare provider. This field is also growing into commercially available HR monitors that allow easy monitoring for arrhythmias in low-risk patients.
While these devices are a boon for primary care physicians and can greatly assist in determining medication noncompliance, some potential systems issues may result in a false emergency notification akin to patients presenting to the ED for evaluation after receiving an inaccurate high BP reading on a grocery-store or home monitoring device. For instance, HR monitors with a faulty lead may cause an alert from the monitoring system noting atrial fibrillation and recommending the patient seek immediate evaluation. Similarly, a smart phone-connected glucometer may note hyperglycemia in a patient after he or she has consumed a high-sugar meal.
While there has been a reemergence in the use of traditional tourniquets, they are not effective in controlling hemorrhage at junctional sites such as the groin or axilla as there is inadequate space to accommodate the tourniquet. Two recent solutions are the Combat Ready Clamp (CRoC) and SAM Junctional Tourniquet, which are specially designed to control bleeding in an improvised explosive device or blast-type injury. As with intraosseous access devices, the use of tourniquets is also making a comeback. Both owe their new-found popularity—at least in some part—to the involvement of the United States in the recent wars in Iraq and Afghanistan. High casualty rates from improvised explosive devices countered by significant improvements in body armor have resulted in preservation of the torso at the expense of extremities. Life-threatening hemorrhage from a distal extremity can easily be controlled by a tourniquet—something this author never used as an infantryman during Desert Storm, but which is now carried on the person of every soldier in the field.
The Combat Ready Clamp (Combat Medical Systems, Harrisburg, North Carolina)22 compresses the aorta and vena cava though intra-abdominal pressure (Figure 7). While some may find this device a bit cumbersome for field use, it is definitely feasible and applicable for hospital use. A similar option, the SAM Junctional Tourniquet (SAM Medical Products, Wilsonville, Oregon),23 (Figure 8) functions in a similar manner as the CROC but uses pneumatic instead of mechanical pressure. The SAM device is definitely more “rucksack friendly,” but both products are good alternatives for controlling hemorrhages in the ED.
Hemostatic agents such as QuickClot (Z-Medica, Wallingford, Connecticut)24 have been in popular use for about a decade now, and the next generation of this family of treatment options has become available. The XStat-30 (RevMedx, Wilsonville, Oregon)25 (Figure 9) is one such product. Its large syringe applicator (like a large Toomey syringe) is filled with tablets of chitin. The injector is designed to be inserted into a penetrating injury and its contents injected into the wound. Upon contact with blood, the chitin tablets expand in a similar manner as children’s “hatch-and-grow” toy eggs and capsules when immersed in water. The XStat-30 provides not only hemostasis, but also some level of tamponade.
Resuscitative Endovascular Balloon Occlusion of the Aorta
The final addition to the hemostasis comeback tour is the Resuscitative Endovascular Balloon Occlusion of the Aorta (REBOA) device (Pryor Medical, San Antonio, Texas).26 Like many of the products discussed in this article, REBOA has been around for some time, but its use had fallen out of practice. A recent reemergence has shown that REBOA benefits patients with lower abdominal, pelvic, and extremity injuries.
The principal of its use is simple: An occlusive balloon is inserted into the femoral artery and advanced to roughly the level of the midabdomen. Once inflated, the balloon stops blood flow distally. While more research needs to be done on indications and outcomes, REBOA has been successfully used in England in many hospitals and even in the field.27
Summary
Some of the most notable recent evolutionary and revolutionary technological advancements to have a significant and beneficial impact on patient care have been seen in new noninvasive tonographic devices to measure IOP; video laryngoscopic devices for airway management; wireless patient vital signs monitoring systems; alternatives to traditional vascular access such as intraosseous vascular systems, laser-assisted vein visualization technology, and Internet-connected smart glasses; advances in wound-care dressings; medication monitoring systems; clamps and tourniquets to control junctional hemorrhage; and wireless, smart-phone connected glucometer devices and HR monitors. Many of these devices and systems are applicable and appropriate for use in the ED, the implementation of which will further facilitate and improve the quality of patient care.
Dr Wagner is an assistant professor of emergency medicine; program director for the emergency medicine residency program; and director of augmented learning at Barnes-Jewish Hospital, Saint Louis, Missouri.
The author invites readers to contact him via Twitter @TheTechDoc with suggestions for future devices.
The views expressed in this article are those of the author and do not represent the views or opinions of the editorial staff, the editorial board or the publisher.
- iCare Tonometer. iCare Finland. http://www.icaretonometer.com/products/icare-ta01/. Accessed June 2, 2015.
- García-Resúa C, González-Meijome JM, Gilino J, Yebra-Pimentel E. Accuracy of the new ICare rebound tonometer vs. other portable tonometers in healthy eyes. Optom Vis Sci. 2006;83(2):102-107.
- Reichert Technologies. Tono-Pen & Ocu-Film +. http://www.reichert.com/products.cfm?pcId=474. Accessed June 2, 2015.
- Karl Storz-Endoskope. From Laryngoscopy to Video Laryngoscopy. The history of endotracheal intubation. https://www.karlstorz.com/cps/rde/xbcr/karlstorz_assets/ASSETS/2133990.pdf. Accessed May 5, 2015.
- Lipe DN, Lindstrom R, Tauferner D, Mitchell C, Moffett P. Evaluation of Karl Storz C-MAC Tip Device Versus Traditional Airway Suction in a Cadaver Model. West J Emerg Med. 2014;15(4):548-553.
- ViSi Mobile. Sotera Wireless. http://www.visimobile.com/. Accessed May 6, 2015.
- EarlySense Chair Sensor Receives FDA Clearance [press release]. Waltham, MA:Early Sense; July 2, 2014. http://www.earlysense.com/news-and-events/news/jul-2-2014/. Accessed May 6, 2015.
- Arrow EZ-10. Teleflex. http://www.arrowezio.com/. Accessed May 6, 2015.
- Evena Medical Eyes-On Glass 1.0. http://evenamed.com/~even5672/~even5672/products/glasses. Accessed May 6, 2015.
- Wu TS, Dameff CJ, Tully JL. Ultrasound-guided central venous access using google glass. J Emerg Med. 2014;47(6):668-675.
- Aquacel Ag Dressing. ConvaTec. http://www.convatec.com/wound-skin/aquacel-ag-dressing. Accessed May 6, 2015.
- A review of the applications of the hydrofiber dressing with silver (Aquacel Ag) in wound care. Ther Clin Risk Manag. 2010;6:21-27.
- Caruso DM, Foster KN, Blome-Eberwein SA, et al. Randomized clinical study of Hydrofiber dressing with silver or silver sulfadiazine in the management of partial-thickness burns. J Burn Care Res. 2006;27(3):298–309.
- Kaźmierski M, Mańkowski P, Jankowski A, Harasymczuk J. Comparison of the results of operative and conservative treatment of deep dermal partial-thickness scalds in children. Eur J Pediatr Surg. 2007;17(5):354–361.
- Lohana P, Potokar TS. Aquacel Ag in paediatric burns: a prospective audit. Ann Burns Fire Disasters. 2006;19(3):144-147.
- Paddock HN, Fabia R, Giles S, et al. A silver-impregnated antimicrobial dressing reduces hospital costs for pediatric burn patients. J Pediatr Surg. 2007;42(1):211–213.
- Saba SC, Tsai R, Glat P. Clinical evaluation comparing the efficacy of aquacel ag hydrofiber dressing versus petrolatum gauze with antibiotic ointment in partial-thickness burns in a pediatric burn center. J Burn Care Res. 2009;30(3):380–385.
- Scanlon E, Karlsmark T, Leaper DJ, et al. Cost-effective faster wound healing with a sustained silver-releasing foam dressing in delayed healing leg ulcers-a health-economic analysis. Int Wound J. 2005;2(2):150-160.
- Smart Wireless Pill Bottles. AdhereTech. http://adheretech.com/. Accessed May 6, 2015.
- Proteus Digital Health. http://www.proteus.com/. Accessed May 6, 2015.
- Kim E. ‘Digital pill’ with chip inside gets FDA green light. CNN Money. http://money.cnn.com/2012/08/03/technology/startups/ingestible-sensor-proteus/. Accessed May 6, 2015.
- CROC Combat Ready Clamp (CRoC). Combat Medical. http://combatmedicalsystems.com/products/prod_massivehem_croc/ Accessed May 6, 2015.
- SAM Junctional Tourniquet. SAM Medical Products. http://www.sammedical.com/products/the-sam-junctional-tourniquet/. Accessed May 6, 2015.
- QuikClot hemostatic devices help patients survive traumatic blood loss. QuikClot. http://www.quikclot.com/. Accessed May 6, 2015.
- Revmedx. Revolutionary Medical Technologies. http://www.revmedx.com/#!xstat-dressing/c2500. Accessed May 6, 2015.
- Stannard A, Eliason JL, Rasmussen TE. Resuscitative Endovascular Balloon Occlusion of the Aorta (REBOA) as an adjunct for hemorrhagic shock J Trauma. 2011;71(6):1869-1872.
- London’s Air Ambulance Performs World’s First Prehospital REBOA. EMSWORLD – Patient Care. http://www.emsworld.com/news/11545597/londons-air-ambulance-performs-worlds-first-prehospital-reboa. Published July 2, 2014. Accessed May 6, 2015.
Emergency physicians (EPs) are always interested in what are the “tried-and-true” as well as the “latest-and-greatest” devices that will provide the best results for their patients. This article, while not a comprehensive list of every such device introduced over the past few years, does provide an overview of the most notable ones applicable for use in the ED.
Tonometry
The standard iCare tonometer device (TA01i; iCare Finland Oy, Vantaa, Finland),1 began to gain acceptance in the United States in 2007 (Figure 1). Early studies2 have shown its measurement accuracy of intraocular pressure (IOP) to be equivalent to traditional tonometers such as the Tono-Pen XL Applanation Tonometer (Reichert Techonologies, Depew, New York).3
The iCare tonometer is easy to calibrate and use. Consisting of a pin inserted into a magnetic housing, the magnet quickly pushes the blunt end of the pin out to make contact with the cornea. Six quick measurements provide the clinician with an average IOP. The device can be used without anesthesia and is also applicable for at-home use.
Airway Devices
C-MAC Tip System
While direct laryngoscopy will always have a role in clinical practice, there has been a revolution in airway management over the past few years, with video laryngoscopy rapidly replacing direct laryngoscopy. The C-MAC Tip system (Karl Storz Endoscopy-America, Inc, El Segundo, California) is one of the devices currently available.4,5 While this device is not at the lower end of the cost spectrum in airway devices, it is, in this author’s opinion, among the highest quality video laryngoscopes on the market. The hub of C-MAC Tip system is a video screen that accepts input from multiple devices. The most common is the video MacIntosh blade, which is shaped like a traditional MacIntosh but with a slightly thicker handle—allowing both direct and indirect intubation.
The C-MAC Tip system is a great teaching tool, allowing learners to perform direct laryngoscopy while providing reassuring visualization to the instructor of the intubation on the screen. (No longer does the instructor need to repeatedly ask the learner what he or she is viewing!) Moreover, when required, the clinician performing the intubation can look at the screen to benefit from the superior visualization of indirect laryngoscopy.
The C-MAC can also accept input from the D-Blade, which facilitates indirect intubation of anterior airways; however, it does not allow direct intubation when secretions or blood obscure the camera, though there is a suction channel that assists in clearing secretions. The clinician can also add a nasal pharyngeal scope as well as an adult or pediatric bronchoscope. The modularity of the C-MAC system is therefore a flexible addition to any airway armamentarium.
Regarding its use in emergency medicine, in addition to cost considerations, a potential concern is the ability of the plastic adapters to hold up to frequent, repetitive use in a setting such as a busy ED.
Wireless Vital Signs Monitoring Systems
Patient vital signs monitoring systems can currently double as four-point restraints. One new device, the ViSi Mobile Monitor System (Sotera Wireless, Inc, San Diego, CA), however, may make this a thing of the past.6 This system allows for inpatient monitoring of respiratory rate (RR), pulse oximetry, continuous blood pressure (BP), and temperature, as well as a multilead electrocardiogram. The entire system attaches to a small wrist-mounted device, which connects to a hospital monitoring system through a WiFi network (Figures 2a and 2b).ViSi Mobile Monitor
Another example of a wireless monitoring device is the EarlySense Chair Sensor system (EarlySense, Ltd, Ramat Gan, Israel) (Figure 3).7 This device assesses heart rate (HR) and RR simply by seating the patient in a chair. In the near future, this device will likely have the ability to take full vital signs. While not quite ready for prime-time in the ED, systems such as the EarlySense Chair Sensor offer a glimpse of the future in vital sign monitoring technology.
Vascular Access
Traditional intravenous (IV) line placement continues to be the standard of care for vascular access, but is not always feasible. Intraosseous needles, which have been around for decades, are seeing a new renaissance of use thanks to devices such as the Arrow EZ-IO Intraosseous Vascular Access System (Teleflex, Shavano Park, Texas).8 With these standards in mind, some new considerations are on the market, including the AV400 vein visualization system (AccuVein, Inc, Huntington, New York).
Arrow EZ-IO Intraosseous Vascular Access System
Teleflex, the maker of the EZ-IO, has recently made a push for humeral placement in order to achieve faster flow rates. Teleflex recommends using the longer needles (normally reserved for obese patients) with specific placement suggestions to facilitate retention of the needle. The Teleflex Web site8 and mobile application provide succinct, easy-to-understand instructions on placement.
AV400 Vein Visualization System
In addition to the Intraosseous Vascular Access System, the placement of an IV line may also be facilitated by laser devices such as AccuVein’s AV400 vein visualization technology. While earlier versions of both of these systems were comparable to that of a skilled technician in obtaining line placement, the latest generations of these devices have improved depth and visualization of truly difficult vascular access.
Internet-Connected Smart Glasses
In addition to the above-mentioned evolutionary changes in facilitating venous access, revolutionary technological advancements have been in development and are forthcoming. One such technology is network-connected smart glasses.
Eyes-On Glasses
Among the first in network-connected eyewear is Eyes-On Glasses (Evena Medical Inc, Los Altos, California).9 This system functions in a similar manner as other laser systems, except that the screen is a display mounted on eyeglasses, making venous placement much more intuitive (This is especially helpful for those who have difficulty translating the three-dimensional world to a two-dimensional screen).
Another variation on head-mounted technology is General Electric’s (GE) beta software for Google Glass (Google Inc, Mountain View, California) (Figure 4). This prototype links a GE ultrasound machine to Google Glass via WiFi, again simultaneously facilitating visualization of the field and the screen.10 While Google Glass is not currently available for the general public, there is still a place for it in the clinical setting.
Both the Eyes-On Glasses and Google Glass devices share a common thread: to improve patient comfort and facilitate time-consuming procedures.
Wound Care
Aquacel Ag
The EP sees a fair share of burn victims, the standard of care for which has been silver sulfadiazine and daily dressing changes. Care for burn wounds is beginning to change with the introduction of antimicrobial impregnated dressings such as Aquacel Ag (ConvaTec Inc, Greensboro, North Carolina).11 Aquacel Ag comes packaged in various forms and sizes ranging from large sheets for torsos to custom formed gloves for hands. This product is safe to use on the face and can be applied to partial thickness burns where the dermal layer is gone. The fluid from the wound moistens the bandage and helps it adhere to the skin. The dressings are then left in place until they slough-off on their own (approximately 7 to 10 days after placement). Consequently, no dressing changes are required, with cosmesis matching that of classic treatment.
While EPs may find Aquacel Ag useful in treating burns that do not require inpatient hospital admission, they also will find its use highly beneficial in treating patients with “road rash,” the abrasions that occur when one wipes-out at high speeds on asphalt (eg, motorcycle accidents). As with burn wounds, only a single application of Aquacel Ag is required on a debrided abrasion.
With respect to price, a single application of Aquacel Ag costs roughly the same as multiple dressing changes with other wound-care products.12 One concern relating to the use of advanced silver-impregnated dressings is the cost of care since silver-impregnated dressings are relatively expensive compared to traditional dressings. The higher cost, however, is partially offset by the reduced use of secondary gauze, and retention dressings, as well as improved wound healing together with the reduced costs of other care. Cost-effectiveness calculations comparing Aquacel Ag to standard of care in patients with acute and chronic wounds showed favorable results using Aquacel Ag.12-18
When using these dressings, the EP should make sure the follow-up clinic is familiar with their application so that they are not inadvertently removed at the patient’s first visit.
Medication Event Monitoring Systems
There have been a couple of recent changes in medication monitoring that are beginning to make manual pill-counting a thing of the past. Earlier generations of smart pill bottles came with a timer and an alarm that chimed and lit up to alert the patient when it was time to take his or her medication. Once the bottle was opened, the system reset itself. Unfortunately, the basic nature of these systems was not able to account for the number of pills a patient ingested at each scheduled dosing.
An example of newer and more technologically advanced pill-monitoring systems is AdhereTech’s smart wireless pill bottle (AdhereTech, New York, New York). In this system, the pill bottle can be connected to a WiFi network, allowing medication information to be shared (Figure 5).19 For example, a user could have the bottle connected to his or her provider, home healthcare worker, and family member. If a patient misses a dose of medication, the appropriate person receives notification and can make contact with the patient or family member to intervene. As with earlier generation products, these systems cannot account for or prevent a patient from either overdosing or underdosing on a medication.
The patch and sensor-enabled pill system, the Ingestible Event Marker, (Proteus Digital Health, Redwood City, California), which became available this past year, provides more advanced medication monitoring.20 This system allows tracking of individual pills through small chips imbedded in the tablet (Figure 6). The chip is then monitored through a patch worn on the patient’s body. Once connected, the physician is able to not only track when a pill bottle is opened, but also when and how many tablets the patient is ingesting. Moreover, the system has the ability to perform physiologic tracking to monitor patient response to the medication.21
Each of the above systems is a huge benefit to elderly patients and their geographically-separated families. Through these devices, children and other family members can stay apprised of a parent or other loved one’s health through these at-home monitoring systems—in a similar manner as some parents track a new teenaged driver through his or her cell phone!
Other Smart Devices
Connected devices are moving past pill bottles and smart glasses. In the same manner that many people employ fitness trackers to monitor the number of steps taken and calories burned, multiple glucometers are available that sync with a patient’s smart phone, allowing upload of the data to his or her healthcare provider. This field is also growing into commercially available HR monitors that allow easy monitoring for arrhythmias in low-risk patients.
While these devices are a boon for primary care physicians and can greatly assist in determining medication noncompliance, some potential systems issues may result in a false emergency notification akin to patients presenting to the ED for evaluation after receiving an inaccurate high BP reading on a grocery-store or home monitoring device. For instance, HR monitors with a faulty lead may cause an alert from the monitoring system noting atrial fibrillation and recommending the patient seek immediate evaluation. Similarly, a smart phone-connected glucometer may note hyperglycemia in a patient after he or she has consumed a high-sugar meal.
While there has been a reemergence in the use of traditional tourniquets, they are not effective in controlling hemorrhage at junctional sites such as the groin or axilla as there is inadequate space to accommodate the tourniquet. Two recent solutions are the Combat Ready Clamp (CRoC) and SAM Junctional Tourniquet, which are specially designed to control bleeding in an improvised explosive device or blast-type injury. As with intraosseous access devices, the use of tourniquets is also making a comeback. Both owe their new-found popularity—at least in some part—to the involvement of the United States in the recent wars in Iraq and Afghanistan. High casualty rates from improvised explosive devices countered by significant improvements in body armor have resulted in preservation of the torso at the expense of extremities. Life-threatening hemorrhage from a distal extremity can easily be controlled by a tourniquet—something this author never used as an infantryman during Desert Storm, but which is now carried on the person of every soldier in the field.
The Combat Ready Clamp (Combat Medical Systems, Harrisburg, North Carolina)22 compresses the aorta and vena cava though intra-abdominal pressure (Figure 7). While some may find this device a bit cumbersome for field use, it is definitely feasible and applicable for hospital use. A similar option, the SAM Junctional Tourniquet (SAM Medical Products, Wilsonville, Oregon),23 (Figure 8) functions in a similar manner as the CROC but uses pneumatic instead of mechanical pressure. The SAM device is definitely more “rucksack friendly,” but both products are good alternatives for controlling hemorrhages in the ED.
Hemostatic agents such as QuickClot (Z-Medica, Wallingford, Connecticut)24 have been in popular use for about a decade now, and the next generation of this family of treatment options has become available. The XStat-30 (RevMedx, Wilsonville, Oregon)25 (Figure 9) is one such product. Its large syringe applicator (like a large Toomey syringe) is filled with tablets of chitin. The injector is designed to be inserted into a penetrating injury and its contents injected into the wound. Upon contact with blood, the chitin tablets expand in a similar manner as children’s “hatch-and-grow” toy eggs and capsules when immersed in water. The XStat-30 provides not only hemostasis, but also some level of tamponade.
Resuscitative Endovascular Balloon Occlusion of the Aorta
The final addition to the hemostasis comeback tour is the Resuscitative Endovascular Balloon Occlusion of the Aorta (REBOA) device (Pryor Medical, San Antonio, Texas).26 Like many of the products discussed in this article, REBOA has been around for some time, but its use had fallen out of practice. A recent reemergence has shown that REBOA benefits patients with lower abdominal, pelvic, and extremity injuries.
The principal of its use is simple: An occlusive balloon is inserted into the femoral artery and advanced to roughly the level of the midabdomen. Once inflated, the balloon stops blood flow distally. While more research needs to be done on indications and outcomes, REBOA has been successfully used in England in many hospitals and even in the field.27
Summary
Some of the most notable recent evolutionary and revolutionary technological advancements to have a significant and beneficial impact on patient care have been seen in new noninvasive tonographic devices to measure IOP; video laryngoscopic devices for airway management; wireless patient vital signs monitoring systems; alternatives to traditional vascular access such as intraosseous vascular systems, laser-assisted vein visualization technology, and Internet-connected smart glasses; advances in wound-care dressings; medication monitoring systems; clamps and tourniquets to control junctional hemorrhage; and wireless, smart-phone connected glucometer devices and HR monitors. Many of these devices and systems are applicable and appropriate for use in the ED, the implementation of which will further facilitate and improve the quality of patient care.
Dr Wagner is an assistant professor of emergency medicine; program director for the emergency medicine residency program; and director of augmented learning at Barnes-Jewish Hospital, Saint Louis, Missouri.
The author invites readers to contact him via Twitter @TheTechDoc with suggestions for future devices.
The views expressed in this article are those of the author and do not represent the views or opinions of the editorial staff, the editorial board or the publisher.
Emergency physicians (EPs) are always interested in what are the “tried-and-true” as well as the “latest-and-greatest” devices that will provide the best results for their patients. This article, while not a comprehensive list of every such device introduced over the past few years, does provide an overview of the most notable ones applicable for use in the ED.
Tonometry
The standard iCare tonometer device (TA01i; iCare Finland Oy, Vantaa, Finland),1 began to gain acceptance in the United States in 2007 (Figure 1). Early studies2 have shown its measurement accuracy of intraocular pressure (IOP) to be equivalent to traditional tonometers such as the Tono-Pen XL Applanation Tonometer (Reichert Techonologies, Depew, New York).3
The iCare tonometer is easy to calibrate and use. Consisting of a pin inserted into a magnetic housing, the magnet quickly pushes the blunt end of the pin out to make contact with the cornea. Six quick measurements provide the clinician with an average IOP. The device can be used without anesthesia and is also applicable for at-home use.
Airway Devices
C-MAC Tip System
While direct laryngoscopy will always have a role in clinical practice, there has been a revolution in airway management over the past few years, with video laryngoscopy rapidly replacing direct laryngoscopy. The C-MAC Tip system (Karl Storz Endoscopy-America, Inc, El Segundo, California) is one of the devices currently available.4,5 While this device is not at the lower end of the cost spectrum in airway devices, it is, in this author’s opinion, among the highest quality video laryngoscopes on the market. The hub of C-MAC Tip system is a video screen that accepts input from multiple devices. The most common is the video MacIntosh blade, which is shaped like a traditional MacIntosh but with a slightly thicker handle—allowing both direct and indirect intubation.
The C-MAC Tip system is a great teaching tool, allowing learners to perform direct laryngoscopy while providing reassuring visualization to the instructor of the intubation on the screen. (No longer does the instructor need to repeatedly ask the learner what he or she is viewing!) Moreover, when required, the clinician performing the intubation can look at the screen to benefit from the superior visualization of indirect laryngoscopy.
The C-MAC can also accept input from the D-Blade, which facilitates indirect intubation of anterior airways; however, it does not allow direct intubation when secretions or blood obscure the camera, though there is a suction channel that assists in clearing secretions. The clinician can also add a nasal pharyngeal scope as well as an adult or pediatric bronchoscope. The modularity of the C-MAC system is therefore a flexible addition to any airway armamentarium.
Regarding its use in emergency medicine, in addition to cost considerations, a potential concern is the ability of the plastic adapters to hold up to frequent, repetitive use in a setting such as a busy ED.
Wireless Vital Signs Monitoring Systems
Patient vital signs monitoring systems can currently double as four-point restraints. One new device, the ViSi Mobile Monitor System (Sotera Wireless, Inc, San Diego, CA), however, may make this a thing of the past.6 This system allows for inpatient monitoring of respiratory rate (RR), pulse oximetry, continuous blood pressure (BP), and temperature, as well as a multilead electrocardiogram. The entire system attaches to a small wrist-mounted device, which connects to a hospital monitoring system through a WiFi network (Figures 2a and 2b).ViSi Mobile Monitor
Another example of a wireless monitoring device is the EarlySense Chair Sensor system (EarlySense, Ltd, Ramat Gan, Israel) (Figure 3).7 This device assesses heart rate (HR) and RR simply by seating the patient in a chair. In the near future, this device will likely have the ability to take full vital signs. While not quite ready for prime-time in the ED, systems such as the EarlySense Chair Sensor offer a glimpse of the future in vital sign monitoring technology.
Vascular Access
Traditional intravenous (IV) line placement continues to be the standard of care for vascular access, but is not always feasible. Intraosseous needles, which have been around for decades, are seeing a new renaissance of use thanks to devices such as the Arrow EZ-IO Intraosseous Vascular Access System (Teleflex, Shavano Park, Texas).8 With these standards in mind, some new considerations are on the market, including the AV400 vein visualization system (AccuVein, Inc, Huntington, New York).
Arrow EZ-IO Intraosseous Vascular Access System
Teleflex, the maker of the EZ-IO, has recently made a push for humeral placement in order to achieve faster flow rates. Teleflex recommends using the longer needles (normally reserved for obese patients) with specific placement suggestions to facilitate retention of the needle. The Teleflex Web site8 and mobile application provide succinct, easy-to-understand instructions on placement.
AV400 Vein Visualization System
In addition to the Intraosseous Vascular Access System, the placement of an IV line may also be facilitated by laser devices such as AccuVein’s AV400 vein visualization technology. While earlier versions of both of these systems were comparable to that of a skilled technician in obtaining line placement, the latest generations of these devices have improved depth and visualization of truly difficult vascular access.
Internet-Connected Smart Glasses
In addition to the above-mentioned evolutionary changes in facilitating venous access, revolutionary technological advancements have been in development and are forthcoming. One such technology is network-connected smart glasses.
Eyes-On Glasses
Among the first in network-connected eyewear is Eyes-On Glasses (Evena Medical Inc, Los Altos, California).9 This system functions in a similar manner as other laser systems, except that the screen is a display mounted on eyeglasses, making venous placement much more intuitive (This is especially helpful for those who have difficulty translating the three-dimensional world to a two-dimensional screen).
Another variation on head-mounted technology is General Electric’s (GE) beta software for Google Glass (Google Inc, Mountain View, California) (Figure 4). This prototype links a GE ultrasound machine to Google Glass via WiFi, again simultaneously facilitating visualization of the field and the screen.10 While Google Glass is not currently available for the general public, there is still a place for it in the clinical setting.
Both the Eyes-On Glasses and Google Glass devices share a common thread: to improve patient comfort and facilitate time-consuming procedures.
Wound Care
Aquacel Ag
The EP sees a fair share of burn victims, the standard of care for which has been silver sulfadiazine and daily dressing changes. Care for burn wounds is beginning to change with the introduction of antimicrobial impregnated dressings such as Aquacel Ag (ConvaTec Inc, Greensboro, North Carolina).11 Aquacel Ag comes packaged in various forms and sizes ranging from large sheets for torsos to custom formed gloves for hands. This product is safe to use on the face and can be applied to partial thickness burns where the dermal layer is gone. The fluid from the wound moistens the bandage and helps it adhere to the skin. The dressings are then left in place until they slough-off on their own (approximately 7 to 10 days after placement). Consequently, no dressing changes are required, with cosmesis matching that of classic treatment.
While EPs may find Aquacel Ag useful in treating burns that do not require inpatient hospital admission, they also will find its use highly beneficial in treating patients with “road rash,” the abrasions that occur when one wipes-out at high speeds on asphalt (eg, motorcycle accidents). As with burn wounds, only a single application of Aquacel Ag is required on a debrided abrasion.
With respect to price, a single application of Aquacel Ag costs roughly the same as multiple dressing changes with other wound-care products.12 One concern relating to the use of advanced silver-impregnated dressings is the cost of care since silver-impregnated dressings are relatively expensive compared to traditional dressings. The higher cost, however, is partially offset by the reduced use of secondary gauze, and retention dressings, as well as improved wound healing together with the reduced costs of other care. Cost-effectiveness calculations comparing Aquacel Ag to standard of care in patients with acute and chronic wounds showed favorable results using Aquacel Ag.12-18
When using these dressings, the EP should make sure the follow-up clinic is familiar with their application so that they are not inadvertently removed at the patient’s first visit.
Medication Event Monitoring Systems
There have been a couple of recent changes in medication monitoring that are beginning to make manual pill-counting a thing of the past. Earlier generations of smart pill bottles came with a timer and an alarm that chimed and lit up to alert the patient when it was time to take his or her medication. Once the bottle was opened, the system reset itself. Unfortunately, the basic nature of these systems was not able to account for the number of pills a patient ingested at each scheduled dosing.
An example of newer and more technologically advanced pill-monitoring systems is AdhereTech’s smart wireless pill bottle (AdhereTech, New York, New York). In this system, the pill bottle can be connected to a WiFi network, allowing medication information to be shared (Figure 5).19 For example, a user could have the bottle connected to his or her provider, home healthcare worker, and family member. If a patient misses a dose of medication, the appropriate person receives notification and can make contact with the patient or family member to intervene. As with earlier generation products, these systems cannot account for or prevent a patient from either overdosing or underdosing on a medication.
The patch and sensor-enabled pill system, the Ingestible Event Marker, (Proteus Digital Health, Redwood City, California), which became available this past year, provides more advanced medication monitoring.20 This system allows tracking of individual pills through small chips imbedded in the tablet (Figure 6). The chip is then monitored through a patch worn on the patient’s body. Once connected, the physician is able to not only track when a pill bottle is opened, but also when and how many tablets the patient is ingesting. Moreover, the system has the ability to perform physiologic tracking to monitor patient response to the medication.21
Each of the above systems is a huge benefit to elderly patients and their geographically-separated families. Through these devices, children and other family members can stay apprised of a parent or other loved one’s health through these at-home monitoring systems—in a similar manner as some parents track a new teenaged driver through his or her cell phone!
Other Smart Devices
Connected devices are moving past pill bottles and smart glasses. In the same manner that many people employ fitness trackers to monitor the number of steps taken and calories burned, multiple glucometers are available that sync with a patient’s smart phone, allowing upload of the data to his or her healthcare provider. This field is also growing into commercially available HR monitors that allow easy monitoring for arrhythmias in low-risk patients.
While these devices are a boon for primary care physicians and can greatly assist in determining medication noncompliance, some potential systems issues may result in a false emergency notification akin to patients presenting to the ED for evaluation after receiving an inaccurate high BP reading on a grocery-store or home monitoring device. For instance, HR monitors with a faulty lead may cause an alert from the monitoring system noting atrial fibrillation and recommending the patient seek immediate evaluation. Similarly, a smart phone-connected glucometer may note hyperglycemia in a patient after he or she has consumed a high-sugar meal.
While there has been a reemergence in the use of traditional tourniquets, they are not effective in controlling hemorrhage at junctional sites such as the groin or axilla as there is inadequate space to accommodate the tourniquet. Two recent solutions are the Combat Ready Clamp (CRoC) and SAM Junctional Tourniquet, which are specially designed to control bleeding in an improvised explosive device or blast-type injury. As with intraosseous access devices, the use of tourniquets is also making a comeback. Both owe their new-found popularity—at least in some part—to the involvement of the United States in the recent wars in Iraq and Afghanistan. High casualty rates from improvised explosive devices countered by significant improvements in body armor have resulted in preservation of the torso at the expense of extremities. Life-threatening hemorrhage from a distal extremity can easily be controlled by a tourniquet—something this author never used as an infantryman during Desert Storm, but which is now carried on the person of every soldier in the field.
The Combat Ready Clamp (Combat Medical Systems, Harrisburg, North Carolina)22 compresses the aorta and vena cava though intra-abdominal pressure (Figure 7). While some may find this device a bit cumbersome for field use, it is definitely feasible and applicable for hospital use. A similar option, the SAM Junctional Tourniquet (SAM Medical Products, Wilsonville, Oregon),23 (Figure 8) functions in a similar manner as the CROC but uses pneumatic instead of mechanical pressure. The SAM device is definitely more “rucksack friendly,” but both products are good alternatives for controlling hemorrhages in the ED.
Hemostatic agents such as QuickClot (Z-Medica, Wallingford, Connecticut)24 have been in popular use for about a decade now, and the next generation of this family of treatment options has become available. The XStat-30 (RevMedx, Wilsonville, Oregon)25 (Figure 9) is one such product. Its large syringe applicator (like a large Toomey syringe) is filled with tablets of chitin. The injector is designed to be inserted into a penetrating injury and its contents injected into the wound. Upon contact with blood, the chitin tablets expand in a similar manner as children’s “hatch-and-grow” toy eggs and capsules when immersed in water. The XStat-30 provides not only hemostasis, but also some level of tamponade.
Resuscitative Endovascular Balloon Occlusion of the Aorta
The final addition to the hemostasis comeback tour is the Resuscitative Endovascular Balloon Occlusion of the Aorta (REBOA) device (Pryor Medical, San Antonio, Texas).26 Like many of the products discussed in this article, REBOA has been around for some time, but its use had fallen out of practice. A recent reemergence has shown that REBOA benefits patients with lower abdominal, pelvic, and extremity injuries.
The principal of its use is simple: An occlusive balloon is inserted into the femoral artery and advanced to roughly the level of the midabdomen. Once inflated, the balloon stops blood flow distally. While more research needs to be done on indications and outcomes, REBOA has been successfully used in England in many hospitals and even in the field.27
Summary
Some of the most notable recent evolutionary and revolutionary technological advancements to have a significant and beneficial impact on patient care have been seen in new noninvasive tonographic devices to measure IOP; video laryngoscopic devices for airway management; wireless patient vital signs monitoring systems; alternatives to traditional vascular access such as intraosseous vascular systems, laser-assisted vein visualization technology, and Internet-connected smart glasses; advances in wound-care dressings; medication monitoring systems; clamps and tourniquets to control junctional hemorrhage; and wireless, smart-phone connected glucometer devices and HR monitors. Many of these devices and systems are applicable and appropriate for use in the ED, the implementation of which will further facilitate and improve the quality of patient care.
Dr Wagner is an assistant professor of emergency medicine; program director for the emergency medicine residency program; and director of augmented learning at Barnes-Jewish Hospital, Saint Louis, Missouri.
The author invites readers to contact him via Twitter @TheTechDoc with suggestions for future devices.
The views expressed in this article are those of the author and do not represent the views or opinions of the editorial staff, the editorial board or the publisher.
- iCare Tonometer. iCare Finland. http://www.icaretonometer.com/products/icare-ta01/. Accessed June 2, 2015.
- García-Resúa C, González-Meijome JM, Gilino J, Yebra-Pimentel E. Accuracy of the new ICare rebound tonometer vs. other portable tonometers in healthy eyes. Optom Vis Sci. 2006;83(2):102-107.
- Reichert Technologies. Tono-Pen & Ocu-Film +. http://www.reichert.com/products.cfm?pcId=474. Accessed June 2, 2015.
- Karl Storz-Endoskope. From Laryngoscopy to Video Laryngoscopy. The history of endotracheal intubation. https://www.karlstorz.com/cps/rde/xbcr/karlstorz_assets/ASSETS/2133990.pdf. Accessed May 5, 2015.
- Lipe DN, Lindstrom R, Tauferner D, Mitchell C, Moffett P. Evaluation of Karl Storz C-MAC Tip Device Versus Traditional Airway Suction in a Cadaver Model. West J Emerg Med. 2014;15(4):548-553.
- ViSi Mobile. Sotera Wireless. http://www.visimobile.com/. Accessed May 6, 2015.
- EarlySense Chair Sensor Receives FDA Clearance [press release]. Waltham, MA:Early Sense; July 2, 2014. http://www.earlysense.com/news-and-events/news/jul-2-2014/. Accessed May 6, 2015.
- Arrow EZ-10. Teleflex. http://www.arrowezio.com/. Accessed May 6, 2015.
- Evena Medical Eyes-On Glass 1.0. http://evenamed.com/~even5672/~even5672/products/glasses. Accessed May 6, 2015.
- Wu TS, Dameff CJ, Tully JL. Ultrasound-guided central venous access using google glass. J Emerg Med. 2014;47(6):668-675.
- Aquacel Ag Dressing. ConvaTec. http://www.convatec.com/wound-skin/aquacel-ag-dressing. Accessed May 6, 2015.
- A review of the applications of the hydrofiber dressing with silver (Aquacel Ag) in wound care. Ther Clin Risk Manag. 2010;6:21-27.
- Caruso DM, Foster KN, Blome-Eberwein SA, et al. Randomized clinical study of Hydrofiber dressing with silver or silver sulfadiazine in the management of partial-thickness burns. J Burn Care Res. 2006;27(3):298–309.
- Kaźmierski M, Mańkowski P, Jankowski A, Harasymczuk J. Comparison of the results of operative and conservative treatment of deep dermal partial-thickness scalds in children. Eur J Pediatr Surg. 2007;17(5):354–361.
- Lohana P, Potokar TS. Aquacel Ag in paediatric burns: a prospective audit. Ann Burns Fire Disasters. 2006;19(3):144-147.
- Paddock HN, Fabia R, Giles S, et al. A silver-impregnated antimicrobial dressing reduces hospital costs for pediatric burn patients. J Pediatr Surg. 2007;42(1):211–213.
- Saba SC, Tsai R, Glat P. Clinical evaluation comparing the efficacy of aquacel ag hydrofiber dressing versus petrolatum gauze with antibiotic ointment in partial-thickness burns in a pediatric burn center. J Burn Care Res. 2009;30(3):380–385.
- Scanlon E, Karlsmark T, Leaper DJ, et al. Cost-effective faster wound healing with a sustained silver-releasing foam dressing in delayed healing leg ulcers-a health-economic analysis. Int Wound J. 2005;2(2):150-160.
- Smart Wireless Pill Bottles. AdhereTech. http://adheretech.com/. Accessed May 6, 2015.
- Proteus Digital Health. http://www.proteus.com/. Accessed May 6, 2015.
- Kim E. ‘Digital pill’ with chip inside gets FDA green light. CNN Money. http://money.cnn.com/2012/08/03/technology/startups/ingestible-sensor-proteus/. Accessed May 6, 2015.
- CROC Combat Ready Clamp (CRoC). Combat Medical. http://combatmedicalsystems.com/products/prod_massivehem_croc/ Accessed May 6, 2015.
- SAM Junctional Tourniquet. SAM Medical Products. http://www.sammedical.com/products/the-sam-junctional-tourniquet/. Accessed May 6, 2015.
- QuikClot hemostatic devices help patients survive traumatic blood loss. QuikClot. http://www.quikclot.com/. Accessed May 6, 2015.
- Revmedx. Revolutionary Medical Technologies. http://www.revmedx.com/#!xstat-dressing/c2500. Accessed May 6, 2015.
- Stannard A, Eliason JL, Rasmussen TE. Resuscitative Endovascular Balloon Occlusion of the Aorta (REBOA) as an adjunct for hemorrhagic shock J Trauma. 2011;71(6):1869-1872.
- London’s Air Ambulance Performs World’s First Prehospital REBOA. EMSWORLD – Patient Care. http://www.emsworld.com/news/11545597/londons-air-ambulance-performs-worlds-first-prehospital-reboa. Published July 2, 2014. Accessed May 6, 2015.
- iCare Tonometer. iCare Finland. http://www.icaretonometer.com/products/icare-ta01/. Accessed June 2, 2015.
- García-Resúa C, González-Meijome JM, Gilino J, Yebra-Pimentel E. Accuracy of the new ICare rebound tonometer vs. other portable tonometers in healthy eyes. Optom Vis Sci. 2006;83(2):102-107.
- Reichert Technologies. Tono-Pen & Ocu-Film +. http://www.reichert.com/products.cfm?pcId=474. Accessed June 2, 2015.
- Karl Storz-Endoskope. From Laryngoscopy to Video Laryngoscopy. The history of endotracheal intubation. https://www.karlstorz.com/cps/rde/xbcr/karlstorz_assets/ASSETS/2133990.pdf. Accessed May 5, 2015.
- Lipe DN, Lindstrom R, Tauferner D, Mitchell C, Moffett P. Evaluation of Karl Storz C-MAC Tip Device Versus Traditional Airway Suction in a Cadaver Model. West J Emerg Med. 2014;15(4):548-553.
- ViSi Mobile. Sotera Wireless. http://www.visimobile.com/. Accessed May 6, 2015.
- EarlySense Chair Sensor Receives FDA Clearance [press release]. Waltham, MA:Early Sense; July 2, 2014. http://www.earlysense.com/news-and-events/news/jul-2-2014/. Accessed May 6, 2015.
- Arrow EZ-10. Teleflex. http://www.arrowezio.com/. Accessed May 6, 2015.
- Evena Medical Eyes-On Glass 1.0. http://evenamed.com/~even5672/~even5672/products/glasses. Accessed May 6, 2015.
- Wu TS, Dameff CJ, Tully JL. Ultrasound-guided central venous access using google glass. J Emerg Med. 2014;47(6):668-675.
- Aquacel Ag Dressing. ConvaTec. http://www.convatec.com/wound-skin/aquacel-ag-dressing. Accessed May 6, 2015.
- A review of the applications of the hydrofiber dressing with silver (Aquacel Ag) in wound care. Ther Clin Risk Manag. 2010;6:21-27.
- Caruso DM, Foster KN, Blome-Eberwein SA, et al. Randomized clinical study of Hydrofiber dressing with silver or silver sulfadiazine in the management of partial-thickness burns. J Burn Care Res. 2006;27(3):298–309.
- Kaźmierski M, Mańkowski P, Jankowski A, Harasymczuk J. Comparison of the results of operative and conservative treatment of deep dermal partial-thickness scalds in children. Eur J Pediatr Surg. 2007;17(5):354–361.
- Lohana P, Potokar TS. Aquacel Ag in paediatric burns: a prospective audit. Ann Burns Fire Disasters. 2006;19(3):144-147.
- Paddock HN, Fabia R, Giles S, et al. A silver-impregnated antimicrobial dressing reduces hospital costs for pediatric burn patients. J Pediatr Surg. 2007;42(1):211–213.
- Saba SC, Tsai R, Glat P. Clinical evaluation comparing the efficacy of aquacel ag hydrofiber dressing versus petrolatum gauze with antibiotic ointment in partial-thickness burns in a pediatric burn center. J Burn Care Res. 2009;30(3):380–385.
- Scanlon E, Karlsmark T, Leaper DJ, et al. Cost-effective faster wound healing with a sustained silver-releasing foam dressing in delayed healing leg ulcers-a health-economic analysis. Int Wound J. 2005;2(2):150-160.
- Smart Wireless Pill Bottles. AdhereTech. http://adheretech.com/. Accessed May 6, 2015.
- Proteus Digital Health. http://www.proteus.com/. Accessed May 6, 2015.
- Kim E. ‘Digital pill’ with chip inside gets FDA green light. CNN Money. http://money.cnn.com/2012/08/03/technology/startups/ingestible-sensor-proteus/. Accessed May 6, 2015.
- CROC Combat Ready Clamp (CRoC). Combat Medical. http://combatmedicalsystems.com/products/prod_massivehem_croc/ Accessed May 6, 2015.
- SAM Junctional Tourniquet. SAM Medical Products. http://www.sammedical.com/products/the-sam-junctional-tourniquet/. Accessed May 6, 2015.
- QuikClot hemostatic devices help patients survive traumatic blood loss. QuikClot. http://www.quikclot.com/. Accessed May 6, 2015.
- Revmedx. Revolutionary Medical Technologies. http://www.revmedx.com/#!xstat-dressing/c2500. Accessed May 6, 2015.
- Stannard A, Eliason JL, Rasmussen TE. Resuscitative Endovascular Balloon Occlusion of the Aorta (REBOA) as an adjunct for hemorrhagic shock J Trauma. 2011;71(6):1869-1872.
- London’s Air Ambulance Performs World’s First Prehospital REBOA. EMSWORLD – Patient Care. http://www.emsworld.com/news/11545597/londons-air-ambulance-performs-worlds-first-prehospital-reboa. Published July 2, 2014. Accessed May 6, 2015.
Emergency Ultrasound: Pneumothorax Assessment
Background
In practiced hands, ultrasound is more sensitive than chest X-ray in evaluating patients with suspected pneumothorax. Due to its portability, this modality can rapidly identify pathology and facilitate prompt intervention in a decompensating patient. This article reviews the proper techniques for evaluating patients for pneumothorax as well as the classic signs indicative of this condition.
Performing the Scan
The probe also should be oriented as perpendicular to the chest wall as possible, which will make the pleura appear brighter. Once this view is achieved, the clinician can evaluate for evidence of lung sliding. Since air in pneumothorax rises to the least dependent portion of the chest, this is the area that should be evaluated. In the supine patient, the probe is placed on the anterior chest wall in the second intercostal space, midclavicular line. A high-frequency linear probe is best for evaluating pneumothorax and should be positioned with the indicator marker toward the head. The clinician will need to adjust the probe to visualize the pleura, which will appear as a bright hyperechoic line outlined on both sides by a rib with shadowing beneath (Figure 1).
Lung Siding and Comet-Tail Artifacts
The appearance of lung sliding or a comet-tail artifact on the ultrasound confirms the lung is inflated. Lung sliding has been described as a shimmering appearance of the pleura, or like tiny ants marching on a string. The pleura will seem to slide back and forth as the patient breathes. Comet tails, vertical artifacts originating from the pleura, may be visible on ultrasound, also proving the lung is inflated (Figure 2).
The Lung Point
By continuing to scan laterally down the chest, the clinician may encounter the “lung point”—the junction between the normally inflated lung and pneumothorax. This point moves with respiration, and if visualized, confirms pneumothorax.
Motion Mode
Since lung sliding is sometimes challenging to visualize, using the motion mode (M-mode) on ultrasound can help to confirm findings. The M-mode takes a single line of echoes from the two-dimensional image and plots it against time. (The manner in which the image is produced may be thought of as a graph, with the x-axis representing time and the y-axis the depth.) When using M-mode, the screen will vary in appearance depending on the type of ultrasound being used. While performing the ultrasound, it is important to always keep the probe as still as possible to identify independent motion at the pleura.
Sand-on-the-Beach Sign
In a normal lung, M-mode images are often described as having a “sand-on-the-beach” appearance (Figure 3). As a normal lung inflates, the motion of the lung changes the brightness of the echoes that return to the machine, creating a speckled appearance like grains of sand beneath the bright pleural line. The soft tissues above the pleural line do not vary with time and thus have a linear appearance.
Barcode or Stratosphere Sign
In pneumothorax, however, the granular sand appearance is absent. Instead, the M-mode shows a linear pattern below the pleural line. This pattern is described as the “barcode sign” or “stratosphere sign” (Figure 4).
Pitfalls
There are several pitfalls that can limit the ability to correctly diagnose a pneumothorax. The presence of scarring and adhesions may cause the patient to develop loculated air collections. If one evaluates only the anterior chest, air trapped in another location may be missed. The clinician should also be mindful of the presence of bullae as the appearance of sliding may be diminished in patients with bullous disease. Using the M-mode in these cases may help to identify inflated lung in patients with limited movement at the pleural line.
Furthermore, since it is easy to confuse a bright layer of fascia with the pleura, the clinician should always make sure to identify landmarks. In some cases of pneumothorax, subcutaneous air may obscure the pleura. The ribs should always be identified to ensure one is looking at the pleural line.
Although absence of lung sliding can suggest pneumothorax, other conditions, such as severe consolidation, acute respiratory distress syndrome, and mainstem intubation, can give a similar appearance. Remember, visualization of the lung point is pathnognomic for pneumothorax.
Conclusion
Pneumothorax is a medical emergency requiring immediate diagnosis and treatment. Patients presenting with suspected pneumothorax can be assessed quickly through bedside ultrasound. Once visualization of the pleura is established, the lung may be assessed for the presence or absence of normal lung sliding and comet-tail artifacts. The M-mode setting further enhances visualization and aids in the diagnosis of pneumothorax.
Dr Beck is an assistant professor, department of emergency medicine, Emory University School of Medicine, Atlanta, Georgia. Dr Meer is an assistant professor and director of emergency ultrasound, department of emergency medicine, Emory University School of Medicine, Atlanta, Georgia. Dr Taylor is an assistant professor and director of postgraduate medical education, department of emergency medicine, Emory University School of Medicine, Atlanta, Georgia.
An example of ultrasound demonstrating normal lung sliding, no sliding, and lung point in the presence of pneumothorax may be accessed at https://youtu.be/gRmPh_j_RE8.
Additional information and a video demonstrating lung sliding, may be accessed at http://www.em.emory.edu/ultrasound/ImageWeek/2012/lung_point.html.
Background
In practiced hands, ultrasound is more sensitive than chest X-ray in evaluating patients with suspected pneumothorax. Due to its portability, this modality can rapidly identify pathology and facilitate prompt intervention in a decompensating patient. This article reviews the proper techniques for evaluating patients for pneumothorax as well as the classic signs indicative of this condition.
Performing the Scan
The probe also should be oriented as perpendicular to the chest wall as possible, which will make the pleura appear brighter. Once this view is achieved, the clinician can evaluate for evidence of lung sliding. Since air in pneumothorax rises to the least dependent portion of the chest, this is the area that should be evaluated. In the supine patient, the probe is placed on the anterior chest wall in the second intercostal space, midclavicular line. A high-frequency linear probe is best for evaluating pneumothorax and should be positioned with the indicator marker toward the head. The clinician will need to adjust the probe to visualize the pleura, which will appear as a bright hyperechoic line outlined on both sides by a rib with shadowing beneath (Figure 1).
Lung Siding and Comet-Tail Artifacts
The appearance of lung sliding or a comet-tail artifact on the ultrasound confirms the lung is inflated. Lung sliding has been described as a shimmering appearance of the pleura, or like tiny ants marching on a string. The pleura will seem to slide back and forth as the patient breathes. Comet tails, vertical artifacts originating from the pleura, may be visible on ultrasound, also proving the lung is inflated (Figure 2).
The Lung Point
By continuing to scan laterally down the chest, the clinician may encounter the “lung point”—the junction between the normally inflated lung and pneumothorax. This point moves with respiration, and if visualized, confirms pneumothorax.
Motion Mode
Since lung sliding is sometimes challenging to visualize, using the motion mode (M-mode) on ultrasound can help to confirm findings. The M-mode takes a single line of echoes from the two-dimensional image and plots it against time. (The manner in which the image is produced may be thought of as a graph, with the x-axis representing time and the y-axis the depth.) When using M-mode, the screen will vary in appearance depending on the type of ultrasound being used. While performing the ultrasound, it is important to always keep the probe as still as possible to identify independent motion at the pleura.
Sand-on-the-Beach Sign
In a normal lung, M-mode images are often described as having a “sand-on-the-beach” appearance (Figure 3). As a normal lung inflates, the motion of the lung changes the brightness of the echoes that return to the machine, creating a speckled appearance like grains of sand beneath the bright pleural line. The soft tissues above the pleural line do not vary with time and thus have a linear appearance.
Barcode or Stratosphere Sign
In pneumothorax, however, the granular sand appearance is absent. Instead, the M-mode shows a linear pattern below the pleural line. This pattern is described as the “barcode sign” or “stratosphere sign” (Figure 4).
Pitfalls
There are several pitfalls that can limit the ability to correctly diagnose a pneumothorax. The presence of scarring and adhesions may cause the patient to develop loculated air collections. If one evaluates only the anterior chest, air trapped in another location may be missed. The clinician should also be mindful of the presence of bullae as the appearance of sliding may be diminished in patients with bullous disease. Using the M-mode in these cases may help to identify inflated lung in patients with limited movement at the pleural line.
Furthermore, since it is easy to confuse a bright layer of fascia with the pleura, the clinician should always make sure to identify landmarks. In some cases of pneumothorax, subcutaneous air may obscure the pleura. The ribs should always be identified to ensure one is looking at the pleural line.
Although absence of lung sliding can suggest pneumothorax, other conditions, such as severe consolidation, acute respiratory distress syndrome, and mainstem intubation, can give a similar appearance. Remember, visualization of the lung point is pathnognomic for pneumothorax.
Conclusion
Pneumothorax is a medical emergency requiring immediate diagnosis and treatment. Patients presenting with suspected pneumothorax can be assessed quickly through bedside ultrasound. Once visualization of the pleura is established, the lung may be assessed for the presence or absence of normal lung sliding and comet-tail artifacts. The M-mode setting further enhances visualization and aids in the diagnosis of pneumothorax.
Dr Beck is an assistant professor, department of emergency medicine, Emory University School of Medicine, Atlanta, Georgia. Dr Meer is an assistant professor and director of emergency ultrasound, department of emergency medicine, Emory University School of Medicine, Atlanta, Georgia. Dr Taylor is an assistant professor and director of postgraduate medical education, department of emergency medicine, Emory University School of Medicine, Atlanta, Georgia.
Background
In practiced hands, ultrasound is more sensitive than chest X-ray in evaluating patients with suspected pneumothorax. Due to its portability, this modality can rapidly identify pathology and facilitate prompt intervention in a decompensating patient. This article reviews the proper techniques for evaluating patients for pneumothorax as well as the classic signs indicative of this condition.
Performing the Scan
The probe also should be oriented as perpendicular to the chest wall as possible, which will make the pleura appear brighter. Once this view is achieved, the clinician can evaluate for evidence of lung sliding. Since air in pneumothorax rises to the least dependent portion of the chest, this is the area that should be evaluated. In the supine patient, the probe is placed on the anterior chest wall in the second intercostal space, midclavicular line. A high-frequency linear probe is best for evaluating pneumothorax and should be positioned with the indicator marker toward the head. The clinician will need to adjust the probe to visualize the pleura, which will appear as a bright hyperechoic line outlined on both sides by a rib with shadowing beneath (Figure 1).
Lung Siding and Comet-Tail Artifacts
The appearance of lung sliding or a comet-tail artifact on the ultrasound confirms the lung is inflated. Lung sliding has been described as a shimmering appearance of the pleura, or like tiny ants marching on a string. The pleura will seem to slide back and forth as the patient breathes. Comet tails, vertical artifacts originating from the pleura, may be visible on ultrasound, also proving the lung is inflated (Figure 2).
The Lung Point
By continuing to scan laterally down the chest, the clinician may encounter the “lung point”—the junction between the normally inflated lung and pneumothorax. This point moves with respiration, and if visualized, confirms pneumothorax.
Motion Mode
Since lung sliding is sometimes challenging to visualize, using the motion mode (M-mode) on ultrasound can help to confirm findings. The M-mode takes a single line of echoes from the two-dimensional image and plots it against time. (The manner in which the image is produced may be thought of as a graph, with the x-axis representing time and the y-axis the depth.) When using M-mode, the screen will vary in appearance depending on the type of ultrasound being used. While performing the ultrasound, it is important to always keep the probe as still as possible to identify independent motion at the pleura.
Sand-on-the-Beach Sign
In a normal lung, M-mode images are often described as having a “sand-on-the-beach” appearance (Figure 3). As a normal lung inflates, the motion of the lung changes the brightness of the echoes that return to the machine, creating a speckled appearance like grains of sand beneath the bright pleural line. The soft tissues above the pleural line do not vary with time and thus have a linear appearance.
Barcode or Stratosphere Sign
In pneumothorax, however, the granular sand appearance is absent. Instead, the M-mode shows a linear pattern below the pleural line. This pattern is described as the “barcode sign” or “stratosphere sign” (Figure 4).
Pitfalls
There are several pitfalls that can limit the ability to correctly diagnose a pneumothorax. The presence of scarring and adhesions may cause the patient to develop loculated air collections. If one evaluates only the anterior chest, air trapped in another location may be missed. The clinician should also be mindful of the presence of bullae as the appearance of sliding may be diminished in patients with bullous disease. Using the M-mode in these cases may help to identify inflated lung in patients with limited movement at the pleural line.
Furthermore, since it is easy to confuse a bright layer of fascia with the pleura, the clinician should always make sure to identify landmarks. In some cases of pneumothorax, subcutaneous air may obscure the pleura. The ribs should always be identified to ensure one is looking at the pleural line.
Although absence of lung sliding can suggest pneumothorax, other conditions, such as severe consolidation, acute respiratory distress syndrome, and mainstem intubation, can give a similar appearance. Remember, visualization of the lung point is pathnognomic for pneumothorax.
Conclusion
Pneumothorax is a medical emergency requiring immediate diagnosis and treatment. Patients presenting with suspected pneumothorax can be assessed quickly through bedside ultrasound. Once visualization of the pleura is established, the lung may be assessed for the presence or absence of normal lung sliding and comet-tail artifacts. The M-mode setting further enhances visualization and aids in the diagnosis of pneumothorax.
Dr Beck is an assistant professor, department of emergency medicine, Emory University School of Medicine, Atlanta, Georgia. Dr Meer is an assistant professor and director of emergency ultrasound, department of emergency medicine, Emory University School of Medicine, Atlanta, Georgia. Dr Taylor is an assistant professor and director of postgraduate medical education, department of emergency medicine, Emory University School of Medicine, Atlanta, Georgia.
An example of ultrasound demonstrating normal lung sliding, no sliding, and lung point in the presence of pneumothorax may be accessed at https://youtu.be/gRmPh_j_RE8.
Additional information and a video demonstrating lung sliding, may be accessed at http://www.em.emory.edu/ultrasound/ImageWeek/2012/lung_point.html.
An example of ultrasound demonstrating normal lung sliding, no sliding, and lung point in the presence of pneumothorax may be accessed at https://youtu.be/gRmPh_j_RE8.
Additional information and a video demonstrating lung sliding, may be accessed at http://www.em.emory.edu/ultrasound/ImageWeek/2012/lung_point.html.
Knee Extensor Mechanism Reconstruction With Complete Extensor Allograft After Failure of Patellar Tendon Repair
The extensor mechanism of the knee comprises the quadriceps tendon, the patella, and the patellar tendon. The extensor mechanism may be damaged by injury to these structures, with consequences such as the inability to actively extend the knee and hemarthrosis.1,2 Disruption of this mechanism is rare, and the most common injury pattern is an eccentric contraction of the quadriceps tendon on a flexed knee causing a tendon (quadriceps or patellar) rupture or a patella fracture.1,2
Patellar tendon ruptures are more common in persons younger than 40 years.1 Treatment is surgical, regardless of age and physical activity. In the acute setting, repair can be end-to-end suture or transosseous tunnel insertion. End-to-end suturing is difficult in chronic patellar tendon ruptures because of patella alta secondary to quadriceps contraction.3 Treatment options for chronic ruptures may involve transpatellar traction4 or tendon reinforcement with fascia lata, a semitendinosus band, or synthetic materials.3-5 Alternatively, tendon autograft and allografts have also been recommended, especially in extreme situations.1,6 Furthermore, animal experiments have shown that a compact platelet-rich fibrin scaffold (CPFS) has the potential to accelerate healing of patellar tendon defects and to act as a bioscaffold for graft augmentation.7
We describe the case of a 30-year-old man who underwent extensor mechanism reconstruction with cadaveric tendon–patellar tendon–bone allograft for failure of an infected primary end-to-end repair. The patient provided written informed consent for print and electronic publication of this case report.
Case Report
A 30-year-old healthy man landed on an empty glass fish tank, resulting in a traumatic right-knee arthrotomy. On initial evaluation, the patient had a negative straight-leg-raise test and impaired knee extension. The patient was taken urgently to the operating room for irrigation and débridement and concurrent repair of the patellar tendon laceration. Antibiotic prophylaxis with 2 g of intravenous (IV) cefazolin was given in the emergency room.
Intraoperatively, after visualizing the patellar tendon laceration and excluding any associated chondral lesions, we proceeded with extensive débridement and irrigation using 9 L of normal saline pulse lavage. After we achieved a clean site, we proceeded to repair the patellar tendon using No. 2 FiberWire sutures (Arthrex, Naples, Florida) with a classic Krackow repair8 consisting of 2 sutures run in a 4-row fashion through the patella and the patellar tendon. The suture was securely tightened and then tested for stability to at least 90° of knee flexion. The retinaculum was repaired using No. 0 Vicryl sutures (Ethicon, Somerville, New Jersey). After wound closure and dressing, the patient was placed in a hinged knee brace locked in extension at all times after surgery. Antibiotic treatment with IV cefazolin was administered for 48 hours.
Postoperative management consisted of weight-bearing as tolerated on the operative limb and appropriate deep venous thrombosis prophylaxis. The patient followed up in clinic 2 weeks and 4 weeks after surgery. At 4 weeks, the patient was noted to have a secondary wound infection with superficial dehiscence and serosanguineous drainage. No wound opening was noticed, and local wound care was performed with a 1-week course of oral cephalexin. The patient was scheduled to follow up a few weeks later but did not follow up for a year.
At 1-year follow-up, the patient reported that he had had a steady progression of his knee range of motion (ROM) with decreased pain. However, over time, the patient noted subjective instability of the knee, with frequent falls occurring close to his 1-year follow-up. Examination of his knee showed that his active ROM ranged from 20° in extension to 120° in flexion, with a weak extensor mechanism. Passively, his knee could be brought to full extension. His incision was well healed, but it had an area of bogginess in the middle. Radiographs showed patella alta on the affected knee, with a lengthening of the patellar tendon of 7.70 cm on the right compared with 5.18 cm on the left. Magnetic resonance imaging (MRI) showed moderate-to-severe patellar tendinosis with small fluid pockets around the surgical material and evidence of acute patellar enthesopathy. The laboratory values showed a white blood cell count of 7580/μL (normal, 4500-11,000/μL), an erythrocyte sedimentation rate of 2 mm/h (normal, 1-15 mm/h), and a C-reactive protein level of 1.93 mg/dL (normal, 0.00-0.29 mg/dL). Based on the clinical examination and imaging findings, there was a concern for a possible chronic deep-tissue infection, in addition to failure of the primary patellar tendon repair. Operative versus nonoperative management options were discussed with the patient, and he elected to undergo surgery.
During surgery, the patellar laxity was confirmed, and the patellar tendon was noticed to be chronically thickened and surrounded by unhealthy tissue. Initially, an extensive soft-tissue débridement was performed, and all patellar tendon loculations visualized on the preoperative MRI were drained; a solid purulent-like fluid was expressed. Unfortunately, the extensive and required débridement did not allow the preservation of the patellar tendon. Appropriate cultures were taken and sent for immediate Gram-stain analysis, which returned negative. Tissue samples from the patellar tendon were also sent to the pathology department for analysis. Intraoperatively, the infrapatellar defect was filled temporarily with a tobramycin cement spacer mixed with 2 g of vancomycin in a manner similar to that of the Masquelet technique used for infected long-bone nonunions with bone loss.9,10 This technique is a 2-stage procedure that promotes the formation of a biologic membrane that allows bone healing in the reconstruction of long-bone defects. The first stage consists of a radical débridement with soft-tissue repair by flaps when needed, with the insertion of a polymethylmethacrylate cement spacer into the bone defect. The second stage is usually performed 6 to 8 weeks later, with removal of the spacer and preservation of the induced membrane, which is filled with iliac crest bone autograft augmented (if necessary) with demineralized allograft.
The incision was closed primarily, and after surgery, the patient was allowed to bear weight as tolerated in a hinged knee brace locked in extension. Final laboratory analysis from cultures and tissue samples revealed acute and chronic inflammation with more than 20 neutrophils per high-powered field. No organisms grew from aerobic, anaerobic, fungal, or mycobacterial cultures. The infectious disease service was consulted and recommended oral cephalexin.
Because all cultures were negative, all laboratory examinations did not indicate any residual infections, and no bony involvement was noticed intraoperatively or in the preoperative knee MRI, we decided to proceed with the second stage of the Masquelet technique after 2 weeks. The patient returned to the operating room for final reconstruction of his patellar tendon using a custom-ordered cadaveric tendon–patellar tendon–bone allograft, the length of which was determined by measuring the contralateral patellar tendon, ie, 5.18 cm (Figure 1A). The previous anterior knee incision was reopened and extended distally past the tibial tuberosity and proximally toward the quadriceps tendon. The antibiotic spacer was removed. We proceeded with a repeat irrigation and débridement and the allograft transfer. The selected allograft was customized by reducing the tibial bone component to an approximately 1×2-cm bone block and by reducing the allograft patellar thickness with an oscillating saw, leaving an approximately 2-mm thick patellar bone graft attached to the patellar tendon. In a similar technique using an oscillating saw, we shaved off the anterior cortex of the patient’s patella to accommodate, in a sandwich fashion, the patellar allograft. Proximally, the quadriceps tendon insertion was split longitudinally and partially separated from the superior pole of the patellar tendon to allow seating and fixation of the modified quadriceps allograft tendon component.
We proceeded with the fixation of the allograft first distally on the patella. The anterior cortex of the tibial tuberosity was resected to allow the perfect seating of the bone block allograft. The graft was secured with a 4.0-mm fully threaded cancellous lag screw and reinforced with a 2.4-mm, 3-hole T-volar buttress plate (Synthes, Paoli, Pennsylvania). The plate was contoured to better fit the patient’s tibia. We sutured the patellar allograft tendon to the patella using two No. 2-0 FiberWire sutures in Krackow suture technique8 (Figures 1B, 1C). We obtained good fixation of the patellar tendon, and the distance between the patellar insertion and the inferior patellar pole was the same as before surgery: 5.57 cm and comparable to the contralateral side (Figures 2A-2C). The patellar allograft and autograft sandwich were secured with additional No. 2-0 FiberWire sutures, and the quadriceps allograft and autograft were secured with the cross-stitch technique with the same material. Fine suturing of the quadriceps tendon was done with No. 0 Vicryl sutures. After the fixation was completed, we tested the stability of the reconstruction and found good flexion up to 120°.
The postoperative protocol consisted of weight-bearing as tolerated in full extension and passive knee ROM, using a continuous passive ROM machine from 0° to 45° for the first 4 weeks, followed by active ROM, increased as tolerated, during the next 8 weeks.
The patient was seen in clinic 3 and 9 months after surgery. At the 3-month follow-up appointment, the patient’s examination showed knee ROM from 0° extension to 130° of flexion, no secondary infection signs, and radiographic evidence of a well-healing patellar allograft with symmetric patellar tendon length to the contralateral side. At 9-month follow-up, the patient’s active ROM was from 0° extension to 140° flexion (Figures 3A, 3B), and he had returned to his preinjury level of functioning.
Discussion
This case report describes the successful reconstruction of a patellar tendon defect with cadaveric tendon–patellar tendon–bone allograft. Extensor mechanism injuries are uncommon in general, and the incidence of patellar tendon injury is higher in men than in women.2 Patellar tendon tears occur frequently in active patients younger than 40 years, usually as a result of sudden quadriceps contraction with the knee slightly flexed.1 Treatment of patellar tendon injury is surgical, and functional outcomes for patients with this injury are equivalent to those of patients with quadriceps tendon injuries or patellar fractures.2 Acute patellar tendon tears can be repaired by end-to-end suturing or transosseous tunnel insertion in the tibia or patella.1 Reinforcement is often added between the patella and tibial tuberosity, using a semitendinosus band or wire.1 End-to-end suture is performed using a thick resorbable suture. It is important to avoid patella alta during suturing, comparing the position of the patella with the contralateral patella with the knee in 45° of flexion. In proximal avulsion, the tendon is anchored to the bone by 2 thick nonresorbable sutures through 2 parallel bone tunnels to the proximal pole of the patella. Distal avulsion is rare in adults, but it can be managed by using staples or suture anchors.1
End-to-end suturing of chronic patellar tendon defects is difficult more than 45 days after injury primarily because of difficulties in correcting patella alta secondary to the upward force exerted by the quadriceps tendon.1,3 Extreme situations similar to the case we present warrant Achilles or patellar tendon allograft for reconstruction of the extensor mechanism.1,3,6,9
Extensor mechanism allograft also provides an effective remedy for severe quadriceps deficiency caused by loss of the patella, patellar tendon, and quadriceps tendon in total knee arthroplasty.10 However, in such cases, late failure is common, and major quadriceps deficiency occurs after removal of the allograft material.10 To improve outcome, a novel technique using the medial gastrocnemius muscle transferred to the muscular portion of the vastus medialis and lateralis flaps provides a secure and strong closure of the anterior knee, thereby restoring the extensor mechanism of the knee.10
Patellar tendon reconstruction with allograft tissue has been successfully used, especially in cases related to chronic patellar tendon ruptures11 and total knee arthroplasty.6,12-14 Crossett and colleagues12 showed that, at 2-year follow-up, the average knee score for pain, ROM, and stability had improved from 26 points (range, 6-39 points) before surgery to 81 points (range, 40-92 points). The average knee score for function had also improved: 14 points (range, 0-35 points) before surgery to 53 points (range, 30-90 points).12 Primary repair may succeed in early intervention, but in an established rupture, allograft reconstruction is often necessary. Achilles tendon is the preferred allograft, with the calcaneus fragment embedded into the proximal tibia as a new tubercle and the tendon sutured into the remaining extensor mechanism.1,11 The repair is further protected using a cable loop from the superior pole of the patella to a drill hole in the upper tibia.9 Techniques have also been described involving passage of the proximal aspect of the allograft tendon through patellar bone tunnels and suture fixation to the native quadriceps tendon.11,15 However, in our technique, we shaved off the anterior cortex of the patient’s patella to allow a sandwich-type over-position of the allograft to secure fixation to the patella.
Another alternative to allograft reconstruction involves biocompatible scaffolds. Such scaffolds incorporate the use of platelets in a fibrin framework. A CPFS, produced from blood and calcium gluconate to improve healing of patellar tendon defects, has been described in animal studies.7 In the rabbit model, CPFS acts as a provisional bioscaffold that can accelerate healing of an injured patellar tendon repair, potentially secondary to several growth factors derived from platelets.7 Platelets are biocompatible sources of growth factors, and CPFS can act as a scaffold to restore the mechanical integrity of injured soft tissue.7,16 In addition, CPFS can act to lower donor-site morbidity associated with harvesting tissue autograft.7 However, to our knowledge, such scaffolds have not been used in human trials. The LARS biocompatible ligament (Corin Group PLC, Cirencester, United Kingdom), currently not approved by the US Food and Drug Administration, is used for reconstructions of isolated or multiple knee ligament injuries.17 This graft requires the presence of healthy tissue with good blood supply from which new tendon or ligament can grow in. Sometimes it is also used for extensor mechanism reconstruction after radical tumor resection around the knee; however, good results are achieved in only 59% of cases,18 and to our knowledge, only 1 case of primary repair of a patellar tendon rupture has been published.19
Techniques involving the use of tendon–patellar tendon–bone graft with fixation via the sandwich-type over-position of the allograft for chronic patellar tendon rupture have not been described in the literature. In our patient, given the extensive patellar tendon lesion and inflammation with chronic tissue degeneration, there was no option but to use allograft. To improve the patient’s outcome, we chose the strongest possible allograft, tendon–patellar tendon–bone graft.
Conclusion
Revision patellar tendon reconstruction is a challenging, but necessary, procedure to restore the extensor mechanism of the knee, especially in young, active individuals. Various options to reconstruct the tissue defects are available. Our patient was successfully treated with a tendon–patellar tendon–bone allograft reconstruction.
1. Saragaglia D, Pison A, Rubens-Duval B. Acute and old ruptures of the extensor apparatus of the knee in adults (excluding knee replacement). Orthop Traumatol Surg Res. 2013;99(1 suppl):S67-S76.
2. Tejwani NC, Lekic N, Bechtel C, Montero N, Egol KA. Outcomes after knee joint extensor mechanism disruptions: is it better to fracture the patella or rupture the tendon? J Orthop Trauma. 2012;26(11):648-651.
3. Ecker ML, Lotke PA, Glazer RM. Late reconstruction of the patellar tendon. J Bone Joint Surg Am. 1979;61(6):884-886.
4. Siwek CW, Rao JP. Ruptures of the extensor mechanism of the knee joint. J Bone Joint Surg Am. 1981;63(6):932-937.
5. Levy M, Goldstein J, Rosner M. A method of repair for quadriceps tendon or patellar ligament (tendon) ruptures without cast immobilization. Preliminary report. Clin Orthop Relat Res. 1987;218:297-301.
6. Burks RT, Edelson RH. Allograft reconstruction of the patellar ligament. A case report. J Bone Joint Surg Am. 1994;76(7):1077-1079.
7. Matsunaga D, Akizuki S, Takizawa T, Omae S, Kato H. Compact platelet-rich fibrin scaffold to improve healing of patellar tendon defects and for medial collateral ligament reconstruction. Knee. 2013;20(6):545-550.
8. Krackow KA, Thomas SC, Jones LC. Ligament-tendon fixation: analysis of a new stitch and comparison with standard techniques. Orthopedics. 1988;11(6):909-917.
9. Brooks P. Extensor mechanism ruptures. Orthopedics. 2009;32(9):683-684.
10. Whiteside LA. Surgical technique: muscle transfer restores extensor function after failed patella-patellar tendon allograft. Clin Orthop Relat Res. 2014;472(1):218-226.
11. Farmer K, Cosgarea AJ. Procedure 25. Acute and chronic patellar tendon ruptures. In: Miller MD, Cole BJ, Cosgarea AJ, Sekiya JK, eds. Operative Techniques: Sports Knee Surgery. Philadelphia, PA: Saunders (Elsevier); 2008:397-417.
12. Crossett LS, Sinha RK, Sechriest VF, Rubash HE. Reconstruction of a ruptured patellar tendon with achilles tendon allograft following total knee arthroplasty. J Bone Joint Surg Am. 2002;84(8):1354-1361.
13. Lahav A, Burks RT, Scholl MD. Allograft reconstruction of the patellar tendon: 12-year follow-up. Am J Orthop. 2004;33(12):623-624.
14. Yoo JH, Chang JD, Seo YJ, Baek SW. Reconstruction of a patellar tendon with Achilles tendon allograft for severe patellar infera--a case report. Knee. 2011;18(5):350-353.
15. Saldua NS, Mazurek MT. Procedure 37. Quadriceps and patellar tendon repair. In: Reider B, Terry MA, Provencher MT, eds. Operative Techniques: Sports Medicine Surgery. Philadelphia, PA: Saunders (Elsevier); 2010:623-640.
16. Anitua E, Andia I, Ardanza B, Nurden P, Nurden AT. Autologous platelets as a source of proteins for healing and tissue regeneration. Thromb Haemost. 2004;91(1):4-15.
17. Ibrahim SAR, Ahmad FHF, Salah M, Al Misfer ARK, Ghaffer SA, Khirat S. Surgical management of traumatic knee dislocation. Arthroscopy. 2008;24(2):178-187.
18. Dominkus M, Sabeti M, Toma C, Abdolvahab F, Trieb K, Kotz RI. Reconstructing the extensor apparatus with a new polyester ligament. Clin Orthop Relat Res. 2006;453:328-334.
19. Naim S, Gougoulias N, Griffiths D. Patellar tendon reconstruction using LARS ligament: surgical technique and case report. Strategies Trauma Limb Reconstr. 2011;6(1):39-41.
The extensor mechanism of the knee comprises the quadriceps tendon, the patella, and the patellar tendon. The extensor mechanism may be damaged by injury to these structures, with consequences such as the inability to actively extend the knee and hemarthrosis.1,2 Disruption of this mechanism is rare, and the most common injury pattern is an eccentric contraction of the quadriceps tendon on a flexed knee causing a tendon (quadriceps or patellar) rupture or a patella fracture.1,2
Patellar tendon ruptures are more common in persons younger than 40 years.1 Treatment is surgical, regardless of age and physical activity. In the acute setting, repair can be end-to-end suture or transosseous tunnel insertion. End-to-end suturing is difficult in chronic patellar tendon ruptures because of patella alta secondary to quadriceps contraction.3 Treatment options for chronic ruptures may involve transpatellar traction4 or tendon reinforcement with fascia lata, a semitendinosus band, or synthetic materials.3-5 Alternatively, tendon autograft and allografts have also been recommended, especially in extreme situations.1,6 Furthermore, animal experiments have shown that a compact platelet-rich fibrin scaffold (CPFS) has the potential to accelerate healing of patellar tendon defects and to act as a bioscaffold for graft augmentation.7
We describe the case of a 30-year-old man who underwent extensor mechanism reconstruction with cadaveric tendon–patellar tendon–bone allograft for failure of an infected primary end-to-end repair. The patient provided written informed consent for print and electronic publication of this case report.
Case Report
A 30-year-old healthy man landed on an empty glass fish tank, resulting in a traumatic right-knee arthrotomy. On initial evaluation, the patient had a negative straight-leg-raise test and impaired knee extension. The patient was taken urgently to the operating room for irrigation and débridement and concurrent repair of the patellar tendon laceration. Antibiotic prophylaxis with 2 g of intravenous (IV) cefazolin was given in the emergency room.
Intraoperatively, after visualizing the patellar tendon laceration and excluding any associated chondral lesions, we proceeded with extensive débridement and irrigation using 9 L of normal saline pulse lavage. After we achieved a clean site, we proceeded to repair the patellar tendon using No. 2 FiberWire sutures (Arthrex, Naples, Florida) with a classic Krackow repair8 consisting of 2 sutures run in a 4-row fashion through the patella and the patellar tendon. The suture was securely tightened and then tested for stability to at least 90° of knee flexion. The retinaculum was repaired using No. 0 Vicryl sutures (Ethicon, Somerville, New Jersey). After wound closure and dressing, the patient was placed in a hinged knee brace locked in extension at all times after surgery. Antibiotic treatment with IV cefazolin was administered for 48 hours.
Postoperative management consisted of weight-bearing as tolerated on the operative limb and appropriate deep venous thrombosis prophylaxis. The patient followed up in clinic 2 weeks and 4 weeks after surgery. At 4 weeks, the patient was noted to have a secondary wound infection with superficial dehiscence and serosanguineous drainage. No wound opening was noticed, and local wound care was performed with a 1-week course of oral cephalexin. The patient was scheduled to follow up a few weeks later but did not follow up for a year.
At 1-year follow-up, the patient reported that he had had a steady progression of his knee range of motion (ROM) with decreased pain. However, over time, the patient noted subjective instability of the knee, with frequent falls occurring close to his 1-year follow-up. Examination of his knee showed that his active ROM ranged from 20° in extension to 120° in flexion, with a weak extensor mechanism. Passively, his knee could be brought to full extension. His incision was well healed, but it had an area of bogginess in the middle. Radiographs showed patella alta on the affected knee, with a lengthening of the patellar tendon of 7.70 cm on the right compared with 5.18 cm on the left. Magnetic resonance imaging (MRI) showed moderate-to-severe patellar tendinosis with small fluid pockets around the surgical material and evidence of acute patellar enthesopathy. The laboratory values showed a white blood cell count of 7580/μL (normal, 4500-11,000/μL), an erythrocyte sedimentation rate of 2 mm/h (normal, 1-15 mm/h), and a C-reactive protein level of 1.93 mg/dL (normal, 0.00-0.29 mg/dL). Based on the clinical examination and imaging findings, there was a concern for a possible chronic deep-tissue infection, in addition to failure of the primary patellar tendon repair. Operative versus nonoperative management options were discussed with the patient, and he elected to undergo surgery.
During surgery, the patellar laxity was confirmed, and the patellar tendon was noticed to be chronically thickened and surrounded by unhealthy tissue. Initially, an extensive soft-tissue débridement was performed, and all patellar tendon loculations visualized on the preoperative MRI were drained; a solid purulent-like fluid was expressed. Unfortunately, the extensive and required débridement did not allow the preservation of the patellar tendon. Appropriate cultures were taken and sent for immediate Gram-stain analysis, which returned negative. Tissue samples from the patellar tendon were also sent to the pathology department for analysis. Intraoperatively, the infrapatellar defect was filled temporarily with a tobramycin cement spacer mixed with 2 g of vancomycin in a manner similar to that of the Masquelet technique used for infected long-bone nonunions with bone loss.9,10 This technique is a 2-stage procedure that promotes the formation of a biologic membrane that allows bone healing in the reconstruction of long-bone defects. The first stage consists of a radical débridement with soft-tissue repair by flaps when needed, with the insertion of a polymethylmethacrylate cement spacer into the bone defect. The second stage is usually performed 6 to 8 weeks later, with removal of the spacer and preservation of the induced membrane, which is filled with iliac crest bone autograft augmented (if necessary) with demineralized allograft.
The incision was closed primarily, and after surgery, the patient was allowed to bear weight as tolerated in a hinged knee brace locked in extension. Final laboratory analysis from cultures and tissue samples revealed acute and chronic inflammation with more than 20 neutrophils per high-powered field. No organisms grew from aerobic, anaerobic, fungal, or mycobacterial cultures. The infectious disease service was consulted and recommended oral cephalexin.
Because all cultures were negative, all laboratory examinations did not indicate any residual infections, and no bony involvement was noticed intraoperatively or in the preoperative knee MRI, we decided to proceed with the second stage of the Masquelet technique after 2 weeks. The patient returned to the operating room for final reconstruction of his patellar tendon using a custom-ordered cadaveric tendon–patellar tendon–bone allograft, the length of which was determined by measuring the contralateral patellar tendon, ie, 5.18 cm (Figure 1A). The previous anterior knee incision was reopened and extended distally past the tibial tuberosity and proximally toward the quadriceps tendon. The antibiotic spacer was removed. We proceeded with a repeat irrigation and débridement and the allograft transfer. The selected allograft was customized by reducing the tibial bone component to an approximately 1×2-cm bone block and by reducing the allograft patellar thickness with an oscillating saw, leaving an approximately 2-mm thick patellar bone graft attached to the patellar tendon. In a similar technique using an oscillating saw, we shaved off the anterior cortex of the patient’s patella to accommodate, in a sandwich fashion, the patellar allograft. Proximally, the quadriceps tendon insertion was split longitudinally and partially separated from the superior pole of the patellar tendon to allow seating and fixation of the modified quadriceps allograft tendon component.
We proceeded with the fixation of the allograft first distally on the patella. The anterior cortex of the tibial tuberosity was resected to allow the perfect seating of the bone block allograft. The graft was secured with a 4.0-mm fully threaded cancellous lag screw and reinforced with a 2.4-mm, 3-hole T-volar buttress plate (Synthes, Paoli, Pennsylvania). The plate was contoured to better fit the patient’s tibia. We sutured the patellar allograft tendon to the patella using two No. 2-0 FiberWire sutures in Krackow suture technique8 (Figures 1B, 1C). We obtained good fixation of the patellar tendon, and the distance between the patellar insertion and the inferior patellar pole was the same as before surgery: 5.57 cm and comparable to the contralateral side (Figures 2A-2C). The patellar allograft and autograft sandwich were secured with additional No. 2-0 FiberWire sutures, and the quadriceps allograft and autograft were secured with the cross-stitch technique with the same material. Fine suturing of the quadriceps tendon was done with No. 0 Vicryl sutures. After the fixation was completed, we tested the stability of the reconstruction and found good flexion up to 120°.
The postoperative protocol consisted of weight-bearing as tolerated in full extension and passive knee ROM, using a continuous passive ROM machine from 0° to 45° for the first 4 weeks, followed by active ROM, increased as tolerated, during the next 8 weeks.
The patient was seen in clinic 3 and 9 months after surgery. At the 3-month follow-up appointment, the patient’s examination showed knee ROM from 0° extension to 130° of flexion, no secondary infection signs, and radiographic evidence of a well-healing patellar allograft with symmetric patellar tendon length to the contralateral side. At 9-month follow-up, the patient’s active ROM was from 0° extension to 140° flexion (Figures 3A, 3B), and he had returned to his preinjury level of functioning.
Discussion
This case report describes the successful reconstruction of a patellar tendon defect with cadaveric tendon–patellar tendon–bone allograft. Extensor mechanism injuries are uncommon in general, and the incidence of patellar tendon injury is higher in men than in women.2 Patellar tendon tears occur frequently in active patients younger than 40 years, usually as a result of sudden quadriceps contraction with the knee slightly flexed.1 Treatment of patellar tendon injury is surgical, and functional outcomes for patients with this injury are equivalent to those of patients with quadriceps tendon injuries or patellar fractures.2 Acute patellar tendon tears can be repaired by end-to-end suturing or transosseous tunnel insertion in the tibia or patella.1 Reinforcement is often added between the patella and tibial tuberosity, using a semitendinosus band or wire.1 End-to-end suture is performed using a thick resorbable suture. It is important to avoid patella alta during suturing, comparing the position of the patella with the contralateral patella with the knee in 45° of flexion. In proximal avulsion, the tendon is anchored to the bone by 2 thick nonresorbable sutures through 2 parallel bone tunnels to the proximal pole of the patella. Distal avulsion is rare in adults, but it can be managed by using staples or suture anchors.1
End-to-end suturing of chronic patellar tendon defects is difficult more than 45 days after injury primarily because of difficulties in correcting patella alta secondary to the upward force exerted by the quadriceps tendon.1,3 Extreme situations similar to the case we present warrant Achilles or patellar tendon allograft for reconstruction of the extensor mechanism.1,3,6,9
Extensor mechanism allograft also provides an effective remedy for severe quadriceps deficiency caused by loss of the patella, patellar tendon, and quadriceps tendon in total knee arthroplasty.10 However, in such cases, late failure is common, and major quadriceps deficiency occurs after removal of the allograft material.10 To improve outcome, a novel technique using the medial gastrocnemius muscle transferred to the muscular portion of the vastus medialis and lateralis flaps provides a secure and strong closure of the anterior knee, thereby restoring the extensor mechanism of the knee.10
Patellar tendon reconstruction with allograft tissue has been successfully used, especially in cases related to chronic patellar tendon ruptures11 and total knee arthroplasty.6,12-14 Crossett and colleagues12 showed that, at 2-year follow-up, the average knee score for pain, ROM, and stability had improved from 26 points (range, 6-39 points) before surgery to 81 points (range, 40-92 points). The average knee score for function had also improved: 14 points (range, 0-35 points) before surgery to 53 points (range, 30-90 points).12 Primary repair may succeed in early intervention, but in an established rupture, allograft reconstruction is often necessary. Achilles tendon is the preferred allograft, with the calcaneus fragment embedded into the proximal tibia as a new tubercle and the tendon sutured into the remaining extensor mechanism.1,11 The repair is further protected using a cable loop from the superior pole of the patella to a drill hole in the upper tibia.9 Techniques have also been described involving passage of the proximal aspect of the allograft tendon through patellar bone tunnels and suture fixation to the native quadriceps tendon.11,15 However, in our technique, we shaved off the anterior cortex of the patient’s patella to allow a sandwich-type over-position of the allograft to secure fixation to the patella.
Another alternative to allograft reconstruction involves biocompatible scaffolds. Such scaffolds incorporate the use of platelets in a fibrin framework. A CPFS, produced from blood and calcium gluconate to improve healing of patellar tendon defects, has been described in animal studies.7 In the rabbit model, CPFS acts as a provisional bioscaffold that can accelerate healing of an injured patellar tendon repair, potentially secondary to several growth factors derived from platelets.7 Platelets are biocompatible sources of growth factors, and CPFS can act as a scaffold to restore the mechanical integrity of injured soft tissue.7,16 In addition, CPFS can act to lower donor-site morbidity associated with harvesting tissue autograft.7 However, to our knowledge, such scaffolds have not been used in human trials. The LARS biocompatible ligament (Corin Group PLC, Cirencester, United Kingdom), currently not approved by the US Food and Drug Administration, is used for reconstructions of isolated or multiple knee ligament injuries.17 This graft requires the presence of healthy tissue with good blood supply from which new tendon or ligament can grow in. Sometimes it is also used for extensor mechanism reconstruction after radical tumor resection around the knee; however, good results are achieved in only 59% of cases,18 and to our knowledge, only 1 case of primary repair of a patellar tendon rupture has been published.19
Techniques involving the use of tendon–patellar tendon–bone graft with fixation via the sandwich-type over-position of the allograft for chronic patellar tendon rupture have not been described in the literature. In our patient, given the extensive patellar tendon lesion and inflammation with chronic tissue degeneration, there was no option but to use allograft. To improve the patient’s outcome, we chose the strongest possible allograft, tendon–patellar tendon–bone graft.
Conclusion
Revision patellar tendon reconstruction is a challenging, but necessary, procedure to restore the extensor mechanism of the knee, especially in young, active individuals. Various options to reconstruct the tissue defects are available. Our patient was successfully treated with a tendon–patellar tendon–bone allograft reconstruction.
The extensor mechanism of the knee comprises the quadriceps tendon, the patella, and the patellar tendon. The extensor mechanism may be damaged by injury to these structures, with consequences such as the inability to actively extend the knee and hemarthrosis.1,2 Disruption of this mechanism is rare, and the most common injury pattern is an eccentric contraction of the quadriceps tendon on a flexed knee causing a tendon (quadriceps or patellar) rupture or a patella fracture.1,2
Patellar tendon ruptures are more common in persons younger than 40 years.1 Treatment is surgical, regardless of age and physical activity. In the acute setting, repair can be end-to-end suture or transosseous tunnel insertion. End-to-end suturing is difficult in chronic patellar tendon ruptures because of patella alta secondary to quadriceps contraction.3 Treatment options for chronic ruptures may involve transpatellar traction4 or tendon reinforcement with fascia lata, a semitendinosus band, or synthetic materials.3-5 Alternatively, tendon autograft and allografts have also been recommended, especially in extreme situations.1,6 Furthermore, animal experiments have shown that a compact platelet-rich fibrin scaffold (CPFS) has the potential to accelerate healing of patellar tendon defects and to act as a bioscaffold for graft augmentation.7
We describe the case of a 30-year-old man who underwent extensor mechanism reconstruction with cadaveric tendon–patellar tendon–bone allograft for failure of an infected primary end-to-end repair. The patient provided written informed consent for print and electronic publication of this case report.
Case Report
A 30-year-old healthy man landed on an empty glass fish tank, resulting in a traumatic right-knee arthrotomy. On initial evaluation, the patient had a negative straight-leg-raise test and impaired knee extension. The patient was taken urgently to the operating room for irrigation and débridement and concurrent repair of the patellar tendon laceration. Antibiotic prophylaxis with 2 g of intravenous (IV) cefazolin was given in the emergency room.
Intraoperatively, after visualizing the patellar tendon laceration and excluding any associated chondral lesions, we proceeded with extensive débridement and irrigation using 9 L of normal saline pulse lavage. After we achieved a clean site, we proceeded to repair the patellar tendon using No. 2 FiberWire sutures (Arthrex, Naples, Florida) with a classic Krackow repair8 consisting of 2 sutures run in a 4-row fashion through the patella and the patellar tendon. The suture was securely tightened and then tested for stability to at least 90° of knee flexion. The retinaculum was repaired using No. 0 Vicryl sutures (Ethicon, Somerville, New Jersey). After wound closure and dressing, the patient was placed in a hinged knee brace locked in extension at all times after surgery. Antibiotic treatment with IV cefazolin was administered for 48 hours.
Postoperative management consisted of weight-bearing as tolerated on the operative limb and appropriate deep venous thrombosis prophylaxis. The patient followed up in clinic 2 weeks and 4 weeks after surgery. At 4 weeks, the patient was noted to have a secondary wound infection with superficial dehiscence and serosanguineous drainage. No wound opening was noticed, and local wound care was performed with a 1-week course of oral cephalexin. The patient was scheduled to follow up a few weeks later but did not follow up for a year.
At 1-year follow-up, the patient reported that he had had a steady progression of his knee range of motion (ROM) with decreased pain. However, over time, the patient noted subjective instability of the knee, with frequent falls occurring close to his 1-year follow-up. Examination of his knee showed that his active ROM ranged from 20° in extension to 120° in flexion, with a weak extensor mechanism. Passively, his knee could be brought to full extension. His incision was well healed, but it had an area of bogginess in the middle. Radiographs showed patella alta on the affected knee, with a lengthening of the patellar tendon of 7.70 cm on the right compared with 5.18 cm on the left. Magnetic resonance imaging (MRI) showed moderate-to-severe patellar tendinosis with small fluid pockets around the surgical material and evidence of acute patellar enthesopathy. The laboratory values showed a white blood cell count of 7580/μL (normal, 4500-11,000/μL), an erythrocyte sedimentation rate of 2 mm/h (normal, 1-15 mm/h), and a C-reactive protein level of 1.93 mg/dL (normal, 0.00-0.29 mg/dL). Based on the clinical examination and imaging findings, there was a concern for a possible chronic deep-tissue infection, in addition to failure of the primary patellar tendon repair. Operative versus nonoperative management options were discussed with the patient, and he elected to undergo surgery.
During surgery, the patellar laxity was confirmed, and the patellar tendon was noticed to be chronically thickened and surrounded by unhealthy tissue. Initially, an extensive soft-tissue débridement was performed, and all patellar tendon loculations visualized on the preoperative MRI were drained; a solid purulent-like fluid was expressed. Unfortunately, the extensive and required débridement did not allow the preservation of the patellar tendon. Appropriate cultures were taken and sent for immediate Gram-stain analysis, which returned negative. Tissue samples from the patellar tendon were also sent to the pathology department for analysis. Intraoperatively, the infrapatellar defect was filled temporarily with a tobramycin cement spacer mixed with 2 g of vancomycin in a manner similar to that of the Masquelet technique used for infected long-bone nonunions with bone loss.9,10 This technique is a 2-stage procedure that promotes the formation of a biologic membrane that allows bone healing in the reconstruction of long-bone defects. The first stage consists of a radical débridement with soft-tissue repair by flaps when needed, with the insertion of a polymethylmethacrylate cement spacer into the bone defect. The second stage is usually performed 6 to 8 weeks later, with removal of the spacer and preservation of the induced membrane, which is filled with iliac crest bone autograft augmented (if necessary) with demineralized allograft.
The incision was closed primarily, and after surgery, the patient was allowed to bear weight as tolerated in a hinged knee brace locked in extension. Final laboratory analysis from cultures and tissue samples revealed acute and chronic inflammation with more than 20 neutrophils per high-powered field. No organisms grew from aerobic, anaerobic, fungal, or mycobacterial cultures. The infectious disease service was consulted and recommended oral cephalexin.
Because all cultures were negative, all laboratory examinations did not indicate any residual infections, and no bony involvement was noticed intraoperatively or in the preoperative knee MRI, we decided to proceed with the second stage of the Masquelet technique after 2 weeks. The patient returned to the operating room for final reconstruction of his patellar tendon using a custom-ordered cadaveric tendon–patellar tendon–bone allograft, the length of which was determined by measuring the contralateral patellar tendon, ie, 5.18 cm (Figure 1A). The previous anterior knee incision was reopened and extended distally past the tibial tuberosity and proximally toward the quadriceps tendon. The antibiotic spacer was removed. We proceeded with a repeat irrigation and débridement and the allograft transfer. The selected allograft was customized by reducing the tibial bone component to an approximately 1×2-cm bone block and by reducing the allograft patellar thickness with an oscillating saw, leaving an approximately 2-mm thick patellar bone graft attached to the patellar tendon. In a similar technique using an oscillating saw, we shaved off the anterior cortex of the patient’s patella to accommodate, in a sandwich fashion, the patellar allograft. Proximally, the quadriceps tendon insertion was split longitudinally and partially separated from the superior pole of the patellar tendon to allow seating and fixation of the modified quadriceps allograft tendon component.
We proceeded with the fixation of the allograft first distally on the patella. The anterior cortex of the tibial tuberosity was resected to allow the perfect seating of the bone block allograft. The graft was secured with a 4.0-mm fully threaded cancellous lag screw and reinforced with a 2.4-mm, 3-hole T-volar buttress plate (Synthes, Paoli, Pennsylvania). The plate was contoured to better fit the patient’s tibia. We sutured the patellar allograft tendon to the patella using two No. 2-0 FiberWire sutures in Krackow suture technique8 (Figures 1B, 1C). We obtained good fixation of the patellar tendon, and the distance between the patellar insertion and the inferior patellar pole was the same as before surgery: 5.57 cm and comparable to the contralateral side (Figures 2A-2C). The patellar allograft and autograft sandwich were secured with additional No. 2-0 FiberWire sutures, and the quadriceps allograft and autograft were secured with the cross-stitch technique with the same material. Fine suturing of the quadriceps tendon was done with No. 0 Vicryl sutures. After the fixation was completed, we tested the stability of the reconstruction and found good flexion up to 120°.
The postoperative protocol consisted of weight-bearing as tolerated in full extension and passive knee ROM, using a continuous passive ROM machine from 0° to 45° for the first 4 weeks, followed by active ROM, increased as tolerated, during the next 8 weeks.
The patient was seen in clinic 3 and 9 months after surgery. At the 3-month follow-up appointment, the patient’s examination showed knee ROM from 0° extension to 130° of flexion, no secondary infection signs, and radiographic evidence of a well-healing patellar allograft with symmetric patellar tendon length to the contralateral side. At 9-month follow-up, the patient’s active ROM was from 0° extension to 140° flexion (Figures 3A, 3B), and he had returned to his preinjury level of functioning.
Discussion
This case report describes the successful reconstruction of a patellar tendon defect with cadaveric tendon–patellar tendon–bone allograft. Extensor mechanism injuries are uncommon in general, and the incidence of patellar tendon injury is higher in men than in women.2 Patellar tendon tears occur frequently in active patients younger than 40 years, usually as a result of sudden quadriceps contraction with the knee slightly flexed.1 Treatment of patellar tendon injury is surgical, and functional outcomes for patients with this injury are equivalent to those of patients with quadriceps tendon injuries or patellar fractures.2 Acute patellar tendon tears can be repaired by end-to-end suturing or transosseous tunnel insertion in the tibia or patella.1 Reinforcement is often added between the patella and tibial tuberosity, using a semitendinosus band or wire.1 End-to-end suture is performed using a thick resorbable suture. It is important to avoid patella alta during suturing, comparing the position of the patella with the contralateral patella with the knee in 45° of flexion. In proximal avulsion, the tendon is anchored to the bone by 2 thick nonresorbable sutures through 2 parallel bone tunnels to the proximal pole of the patella. Distal avulsion is rare in adults, but it can be managed by using staples or suture anchors.1
End-to-end suturing of chronic patellar tendon defects is difficult more than 45 days after injury primarily because of difficulties in correcting patella alta secondary to the upward force exerted by the quadriceps tendon.1,3 Extreme situations similar to the case we present warrant Achilles or patellar tendon allograft for reconstruction of the extensor mechanism.1,3,6,9
Extensor mechanism allograft also provides an effective remedy for severe quadriceps deficiency caused by loss of the patella, patellar tendon, and quadriceps tendon in total knee arthroplasty.10 However, in such cases, late failure is common, and major quadriceps deficiency occurs after removal of the allograft material.10 To improve outcome, a novel technique using the medial gastrocnemius muscle transferred to the muscular portion of the vastus medialis and lateralis flaps provides a secure and strong closure of the anterior knee, thereby restoring the extensor mechanism of the knee.10
Patellar tendon reconstruction with allograft tissue has been successfully used, especially in cases related to chronic patellar tendon ruptures11 and total knee arthroplasty.6,12-14 Crossett and colleagues12 showed that, at 2-year follow-up, the average knee score for pain, ROM, and stability had improved from 26 points (range, 6-39 points) before surgery to 81 points (range, 40-92 points). The average knee score for function had also improved: 14 points (range, 0-35 points) before surgery to 53 points (range, 30-90 points).12 Primary repair may succeed in early intervention, but in an established rupture, allograft reconstruction is often necessary. Achilles tendon is the preferred allograft, with the calcaneus fragment embedded into the proximal tibia as a new tubercle and the tendon sutured into the remaining extensor mechanism.1,11 The repair is further protected using a cable loop from the superior pole of the patella to a drill hole in the upper tibia.9 Techniques have also been described involving passage of the proximal aspect of the allograft tendon through patellar bone tunnels and suture fixation to the native quadriceps tendon.11,15 However, in our technique, we shaved off the anterior cortex of the patient’s patella to allow a sandwich-type over-position of the allograft to secure fixation to the patella.
Another alternative to allograft reconstruction involves biocompatible scaffolds. Such scaffolds incorporate the use of platelets in a fibrin framework. A CPFS, produced from blood and calcium gluconate to improve healing of patellar tendon defects, has been described in animal studies.7 In the rabbit model, CPFS acts as a provisional bioscaffold that can accelerate healing of an injured patellar tendon repair, potentially secondary to several growth factors derived from platelets.7 Platelets are biocompatible sources of growth factors, and CPFS can act as a scaffold to restore the mechanical integrity of injured soft tissue.7,16 In addition, CPFS can act to lower donor-site morbidity associated with harvesting tissue autograft.7 However, to our knowledge, such scaffolds have not been used in human trials. The LARS biocompatible ligament (Corin Group PLC, Cirencester, United Kingdom), currently not approved by the US Food and Drug Administration, is used for reconstructions of isolated or multiple knee ligament injuries.17 This graft requires the presence of healthy tissue with good blood supply from which new tendon or ligament can grow in. Sometimes it is also used for extensor mechanism reconstruction after radical tumor resection around the knee; however, good results are achieved in only 59% of cases,18 and to our knowledge, only 1 case of primary repair of a patellar tendon rupture has been published.19
Techniques involving the use of tendon–patellar tendon–bone graft with fixation via the sandwich-type over-position of the allograft for chronic patellar tendon rupture have not been described in the literature. In our patient, given the extensive patellar tendon lesion and inflammation with chronic tissue degeneration, there was no option but to use allograft. To improve the patient’s outcome, we chose the strongest possible allograft, tendon–patellar tendon–bone graft.
Conclusion
Revision patellar tendon reconstruction is a challenging, but necessary, procedure to restore the extensor mechanism of the knee, especially in young, active individuals. Various options to reconstruct the tissue defects are available. Our patient was successfully treated with a tendon–patellar tendon–bone allograft reconstruction.
1. Saragaglia D, Pison A, Rubens-Duval B. Acute and old ruptures of the extensor apparatus of the knee in adults (excluding knee replacement). Orthop Traumatol Surg Res. 2013;99(1 suppl):S67-S76.
2. Tejwani NC, Lekic N, Bechtel C, Montero N, Egol KA. Outcomes after knee joint extensor mechanism disruptions: is it better to fracture the patella or rupture the tendon? J Orthop Trauma. 2012;26(11):648-651.
3. Ecker ML, Lotke PA, Glazer RM. Late reconstruction of the patellar tendon. J Bone Joint Surg Am. 1979;61(6):884-886.
4. Siwek CW, Rao JP. Ruptures of the extensor mechanism of the knee joint. J Bone Joint Surg Am. 1981;63(6):932-937.
5. Levy M, Goldstein J, Rosner M. A method of repair for quadriceps tendon or patellar ligament (tendon) ruptures without cast immobilization. Preliminary report. Clin Orthop Relat Res. 1987;218:297-301.
6. Burks RT, Edelson RH. Allograft reconstruction of the patellar ligament. A case report. J Bone Joint Surg Am. 1994;76(7):1077-1079.
7. Matsunaga D, Akizuki S, Takizawa T, Omae S, Kato H. Compact platelet-rich fibrin scaffold to improve healing of patellar tendon defects and for medial collateral ligament reconstruction. Knee. 2013;20(6):545-550.
8. Krackow KA, Thomas SC, Jones LC. Ligament-tendon fixation: analysis of a new stitch and comparison with standard techniques. Orthopedics. 1988;11(6):909-917.
9. Brooks P. Extensor mechanism ruptures. Orthopedics. 2009;32(9):683-684.
10. Whiteside LA. Surgical technique: muscle transfer restores extensor function after failed patella-patellar tendon allograft. Clin Orthop Relat Res. 2014;472(1):218-226.
11. Farmer K, Cosgarea AJ. Procedure 25. Acute and chronic patellar tendon ruptures. In: Miller MD, Cole BJ, Cosgarea AJ, Sekiya JK, eds. Operative Techniques: Sports Knee Surgery. Philadelphia, PA: Saunders (Elsevier); 2008:397-417.
12. Crossett LS, Sinha RK, Sechriest VF, Rubash HE. Reconstruction of a ruptured patellar tendon with achilles tendon allograft following total knee arthroplasty. J Bone Joint Surg Am. 2002;84(8):1354-1361.
13. Lahav A, Burks RT, Scholl MD. Allograft reconstruction of the patellar tendon: 12-year follow-up. Am J Orthop. 2004;33(12):623-624.
14. Yoo JH, Chang JD, Seo YJ, Baek SW. Reconstruction of a patellar tendon with Achilles tendon allograft for severe patellar infera--a case report. Knee. 2011;18(5):350-353.
15. Saldua NS, Mazurek MT. Procedure 37. Quadriceps and patellar tendon repair. In: Reider B, Terry MA, Provencher MT, eds. Operative Techniques: Sports Medicine Surgery. Philadelphia, PA: Saunders (Elsevier); 2010:623-640.
16. Anitua E, Andia I, Ardanza B, Nurden P, Nurden AT. Autologous platelets as a source of proteins for healing and tissue regeneration. Thromb Haemost. 2004;91(1):4-15.
17. Ibrahim SAR, Ahmad FHF, Salah M, Al Misfer ARK, Ghaffer SA, Khirat S. Surgical management of traumatic knee dislocation. Arthroscopy. 2008;24(2):178-187.
18. Dominkus M, Sabeti M, Toma C, Abdolvahab F, Trieb K, Kotz RI. Reconstructing the extensor apparatus with a new polyester ligament. Clin Orthop Relat Res. 2006;453:328-334.
19. Naim S, Gougoulias N, Griffiths D. Patellar tendon reconstruction using LARS ligament: surgical technique and case report. Strategies Trauma Limb Reconstr. 2011;6(1):39-41.
1. Saragaglia D, Pison A, Rubens-Duval B. Acute and old ruptures of the extensor apparatus of the knee in adults (excluding knee replacement). Orthop Traumatol Surg Res. 2013;99(1 suppl):S67-S76.
2. Tejwani NC, Lekic N, Bechtel C, Montero N, Egol KA. Outcomes after knee joint extensor mechanism disruptions: is it better to fracture the patella or rupture the tendon? J Orthop Trauma. 2012;26(11):648-651.
3. Ecker ML, Lotke PA, Glazer RM. Late reconstruction of the patellar tendon. J Bone Joint Surg Am. 1979;61(6):884-886.
4. Siwek CW, Rao JP. Ruptures of the extensor mechanism of the knee joint. J Bone Joint Surg Am. 1981;63(6):932-937.
5. Levy M, Goldstein J, Rosner M. A method of repair for quadriceps tendon or patellar ligament (tendon) ruptures without cast immobilization. Preliminary report. Clin Orthop Relat Res. 1987;218:297-301.
6. Burks RT, Edelson RH. Allograft reconstruction of the patellar ligament. A case report. J Bone Joint Surg Am. 1994;76(7):1077-1079.
7. Matsunaga D, Akizuki S, Takizawa T, Omae S, Kato H. Compact platelet-rich fibrin scaffold to improve healing of patellar tendon defects and for medial collateral ligament reconstruction. Knee. 2013;20(6):545-550.
8. Krackow KA, Thomas SC, Jones LC. Ligament-tendon fixation: analysis of a new stitch and comparison with standard techniques. Orthopedics. 1988;11(6):909-917.
9. Brooks P. Extensor mechanism ruptures. Orthopedics. 2009;32(9):683-684.
10. Whiteside LA. Surgical technique: muscle transfer restores extensor function after failed patella-patellar tendon allograft. Clin Orthop Relat Res. 2014;472(1):218-226.
11. Farmer K, Cosgarea AJ. Procedure 25. Acute and chronic patellar tendon ruptures. In: Miller MD, Cole BJ, Cosgarea AJ, Sekiya JK, eds. Operative Techniques: Sports Knee Surgery. Philadelphia, PA: Saunders (Elsevier); 2008:397-417.
12. Crossett LS, Sinha RK, Sechriest VF, Rubash HE. Reconstruction of a ruptured patellar tendon with achilles tendon allograft following total knee arthroplasty. J Bone Joint Surg Am. 2002;84(8):1354-1361.
13. Lahav A, Burks RT, Scholl MD. Allograft reconstruction of the patellar tendon: 12-year follow-up. Am J Orthop. 2004;33(12):623-624.
14. Yoo JH, Chang JD, Seo YJ, Baek SW. Reconstruction of a patellar tendon with Achilles tendon allograft for severe patellar infera--a case report. Knee. 2011;18(5):350-353.
15. Saldua NS, Mazurek MT. Procedure 37. Quadriceps and patellar tendon repair. In: Reider B, Terry MA, Provencher MT, eds. Operative Techniques: Sports Medicine Surgery. Philadelphia, PA: Saunders (Elsevier); 2010:623-640.
16. Anitua E, Andia I, Ardanza B, Nurden P, Nurden AT. Autologous platelets as a source of proteins for healing and tissue regeneration. Thromb Haemost. 2004;91(1):4-15.
17. Ibrahim SAR, Ahmad FHF, Salah M, Al Misfer ARK, Ghaffer SA, Khirat S. Surgical management of traumatic knee dislocation. Arthroscopy. 2008;24(2):178-187.
18. Dominkus M, Sabeti M, Toma C, Abdolvahab F, Trieb K, Kotz RI. Reconstructing the extensor apparatus with a new polyester ligament. Clin Orthop Relat Res. 2006;453:328-334.
19. Naim S, Gougoulias N, Griffiths D. Patellar tendon reconstruction using LARS ligament: surgical technique and case report. Strategies Trauma Limb Reconstr. 2011;6(1):39-41.
Spontaneous Osteonecrosis of Knee After Arthroscopy Is Not Necessarily Related to the Procedure
The term spontaneous osteonecrosis of the knee was first used by Ahlbäck1 in 1968. This term, and the acronym SONK (sometimes SPONK2), has subsequently been used by other authors to refer to an apparent osteonecrosis of the knee, most commonly occurring within the medial femoral condyle. SONK typically occurs in older women who usually do not have the typical osteonecrosis risk factors, such as steroid use, sickle-cell anemia, and excessive alcohol intake. Furthermore, the radiologic appearance of SONK differs from the typical avascular necrosis findings seen with radiography and magnetic resonance imaging (MRI). In particular, on MRI, the abnormality of SONK does not have the typical serpiginous margin of bone infarction, or the double-line sign indicating both sclerosis and granulation tissue.3 SONK is normally seen as a line of signal intensity on T1- and T2-weighted sequences; this line is adjacent to or parallels the subchondral bone with an adjacent area of extensive edema.
There is dispute over the cause of SONK. Yamamoto and Bullough4 proposed the lesion is in part a subchondral insufficiency fracture and staged it into 4 parts. Histologic findings suggest at least some SONK lesions are subchondral insufficiency fractures.5 Brahme and colleagues6 were the first to describe SONK occurring after arthroscopy, and others have documented this finding. The condition has also been referred to as osteonecrosis in the postoperative knee.7-13 An association of postoperative SONK with cartilage loss and meniscal tear has been proposed.7-13
We reviewed the clinical, radiologic, and MRI findings in 11 patients with evidence of postarthroscopy SONK to try to identify any risk factors that might predispose them to poor outcomes. Our study population consisted of 11 patients (12 knees) with SONK; 6 of the knees had the lesion before knee arthroscopy, and the other 6 developed the lesion after arthroscopy. We also considered MRI findings in a group of 11 age- and sex-matched patients who underwent knee arthroscopy and did not have or develop SONK. We reviewed the preoperative MRI findings of both groups for meniscal tear, meniscal extrusion, and cartilage loss. We had 2 hypotheses. First, patients with preoperative MRI findings of SONK would have articular cartilage changes, posterior root degeneration, and meniscal extrusion similar to those of patients who developed SONK after arthroscopy. Second, an age- and sex-matched group of patients who underwent arthroscopy and did not develop SONK would be similar in articular cartilage changes, posterior root degeneration or tear, and meniscal extrusion.
Materials and Methods
With institutional review board approval and waived informed consent, we reviewed all imaging studies, particularly the radiographs and MRI studies, of 11 patients (12 knees) who either had SONK before arthroscopy or developed it after arthroscopy. In all these cases, arthroscopy was performed to alleviate mechanical symptoms associated with meniscal tear.
On subsequent review by a musculoskeletal radiologist, 6 patients with SONK had an identifiable lesion before surgery. All patients’ symptoms had not improved with an earlier trial of conservative management. All preoperative and postoperative radiologic and MRI findings were reviewed. The patient group was assembled by writing to all the orthopedic surgeons who performed arthroscopy at our institution and asking for SONK cases seen in their practices. All but 2 cases were performed by a surgeon who treated a predominantly older, less active population. Clinical notes were reviewed for outcomes, and the musculoskeletal radiologist reviewed all radiologic studies. The 4 men and 7 women in the SONK group (1 woman had bilateral knee lesions) ranged in age from 43 to 74 years (mean, 63.8 years), and the 4 men and 7 women in the control group were age-matched to 43 to 75 years (mean, 63.6 years). The controls were chosen from a pool of patients who underwent knee arthroscopy at our institution.
MRI was performed using General Electric 1-T, 1.5-T, or 3-T magnets (GE Healthcare, Milwaukee, Wisconsin) or using Philips 1.5-T or open 0.7-T magnets (Philips Healthcare, Andover, Massachusetts). Imaging included sagittal and coronal proton density–weighted sequences and coronal and axial fat-suppressed T2-weighted sequences. SONK was diagnosed when a low signal line adjacent to the subchondral bone plate on the femoral or tibial condyles was present with an adjacent area of bone marrow edema in the respective condyle or when there was depression of the subchondral bone plate with adjacent edema. The MRI studies were reviewed for lesion location, and medial meniscus and lateral meniscus were reviewed for tear. Type of meniscal tear (horizontal cleavage, radial, complex degenerative) was documented, as was meniscal extrusion. The meniscus was regarded as extruded if the body extended more than 3 mm from the joint margin. Cartilage in the medial and lateral compartment was reviewed according to a modified Noyes scale listing 0 as normal, 1 as internal changes only, 2A as 1% to 49% cartilage loss, 2B as 50% to 90% loss of articular cartilage, 3A as 100% articular cartilage loss with subchondral bone plate intact, and 3B as 100% articular cartilage loss with ulcerated subchondral bone plate.14 Osteoarthritic severity was similarly classified using the Kellgren-Lawrence scale,15 where grade 0 is normal; grade 1 is unlikely to have narrowing of the joint space but potentially has osteophytic lipping; grade 2 has both definite narrowing of the joint space and osteophytes; grade 3 has narrowing of the joint space and multiple osteophytes, some sclerosis, and possible deformity of bone contour; and grade 4 has marked narrowing of the joint space, large osteophytes, severe sclerosis, and definite deformity of bone contour. Follow-up clinical notes and radiologic studies were reviewed in the assessment of patient outcomes.
All statistical analyses were performed with SAS 9.2 software (SAS Institute, Cary, North Carolina). Age data were evaluated with the Shapiro-Wilk test and graphical displays and were found to violate normality assumptions, so they are presented as medians and ranges; other variables are presented as count and column percentages. The Wilcoxon rank sum test was used to compare the 2 groups’ age distributions. Fisher exact tests were used to compare proportions between the 2 groups for the other variables. Statistical significance was set at P < .05.
Results
Table 1 lists the demographics and imaging characteristics of the 11 patients—6 had SONK before arthroscopy and 6 developed it after arthroscopy. Comparison of the 11 patients with SONK and the 11 controls is summarized with P values in Table 2. Representative cases that either presented before surgery or developed after surgery are shown in Figures 1 to 4. There were 6 prearthroscopy lesions and 6 postarthroscopy lesions—all 12 in the medial femoral condyle. Eleven of the 12 knees had a medial meniscal tear, and 1 knee had both medial and lateral meniscal tears. In 8 of the 12 knees, the lateral meniscus was normal; in 2 knees, it had mild degeneration; and, in 1 knee, it had a complex tear. Assessment of hyaline cartilage revealed medial cartilage loss ranging from 2A to 3B (median, 2B) in the patients with SONK, and lateral cartilage loss ranging from 0 to 2A (median, 0). At surgery, all knees had a partial medial meniscectomy, and 6 had a partial lateral meniscectomy. Ten of the 12 knees had chondroplasty, 9 patellar and 5 of the medial femoral condyle. Only 4 of the 11 patients with follow-up of more than 1 year went on to joint replacement. Six of the 12 had follow-up of more than 2 years. Of the 6 patients without an identifiable SONK lesion on MRI before arthroscopy, 4 had mild to moderate knee pain 0.5, 2.4, 3.5, and 4 years after surgery. For the other 2 patients, knee replacement was performed 1.5 and 1.8 years after surgery. Of the 6 patients with prearthroscopy SONK, 4 had mild to moderate knee pain 1.5, 3.7, 6.5, and 6.8 years after surgery; the other 2 had knee replacement 0.5 and 1.8 years after surgery. Articular cartilage degeneration and meniscal extrusion were similar (Table 1). In the control group, there was only 1 knee replacement, at 3 years, and the other 11 were functioning 2.6 to 5 years later. The longer follow-up resulted from selection of appropriate controls from the same year. Of the 6 SONK lesions found on preoperative MRI, 3 were read by the interpreting radiologist before surgery as possible SONK lesions, 2 were read as insufficiency fractures, and 1 was read as a possible insufficiency fracture.
Discussion
SONK is well described as a complication of arthroscopic knee surgery. However, this condition more commonly appears spontaneously in a population that has not had surgery. It has become clear that the term SONK may be misleading.16 In a recent series of postoperative subchondral fractures reported by MacDessi and colleagues,5 the average age of patients included in their study was 64 years. Pathologic analysis revealed subchondral fracture with callus formation in all cases. Only 2 knees had evidence of osteonecrosis, which appeared to be secondary to the fracture. Based on these findings, the authors concluded that “further investigation into the etiology of this condition is warranted.” A prominent association with medial meniscal tear has been noted, with the medial femoral condyle predominantly affected. As already mentioned, SONK differs from classical avascular necrosis on several points, including lack of the typical avascular osteonecrosis risk factors and absence of the serpiginous margin and double-line sign seen with typical bone infarction. In addition, the SONK lesions seen on radiographs and MRIs of the knee typically are in the medial femoral condyle and are very different from the typical area of infarction seen in patients with known risk factors for secondary osteonecrosis.
The cause of SONK is not known. Of more importance from a medicolegal standpoint is that these lesions are not necessarily related to arthroscopy.17 Interestingly, Pape and colleagues17 noted that some of the lesions they studied may have been present before surgery, which is what we found in 6 (50%) of the SONK knees in our study. Our data thus support the proposition that some SONK lesions are present before arthroscopy, and some cases of so-called postarthroscopy SONK may in fact have been progressing before surgery.
Our data also reinforce the importance of radiologist–orthopedic surgeon communication regarding the presence of SONK. We emphasize the importance of communicating the MRI findings clearly, whether the lesion is called SONK, SPONK, or insufficiency fracture. The orthopedic surgeons in our series may have been unaware of the presence of these lesions before arthroscopic meniscectomy, given the wide variety of terms being used in radiologic reports.
The natural history of spontaneous osteonecrosis of the medial tibial plateau has also been studied.18 There were 3 outcome patterns—acute extensive collapse of the medial tibial plateau, rapid progression to varying degrees of osteoarthritis, and complete resolution. It has been shown that resolution of SONK can occur in the early stages of the disease, within several months, but often the changes progress to bone destruction and articular cartilage collapse.19
In our series of patients, there was a female predominance, and mean age was 64 years. We investigated cartilage loss, meniscal tear, and meniscal extrusion to see if we could predict outcomes in patients who had the lesion before arthroscopy and if we could predict who might be at risk for developing the lesion after arthroscopy. Type of surgical procedure was also reviewed. For the sake of simplicity, we divided the follow-up patients into 2 groups: those managed with conservative treatment, which we deemed a reasonable outcome, and those who subsequently required knee joint replacement, which we deemed a poor outcome. As seen from our representative cases, both groups had patients with cartilage loss, meniscal tear, and meniscal extrusion to varying degrees. There were no risk factors pointing to a reasonable or poor outcome. In the group of patients with prearthroscopy lesions, we found the same problem. We were unable to identify a risk factor that might suggest a poor rather than a reasonable outcome. We must also emphasize that, in our review of patient charts, we could find no other causes for osteonecrosis. In particular, arthroscopic causes of acute chondral loss (eg, thermal wash, laser, bupivacaine pain pumps, epinephrine in irrigant) were not identified.
This study consisted of a series of cases managed at our institution over the past 8 years. Our data and this study had several limitations:
We may have been unable to identify other SONK cases that belonged in the group from our institution. In addition, we had only 11 patients for comparison with patients without SONK. Likewise, there were only 6 knees each in the prearthroscopy and postarthroscopy SONK groups. We also used images obtained from 1-T, 1.5-T, and 3-T closed MRI devices and one 0.7-T open device. These were, however, at the same institution.
Timing of our imaging was not uniform. In particular, in 3 of the patients who developed SONK after arthroscopy, preoperative MRI studies were performed quite some time before surgery. However, in these patients, more recent preoperative radiographs did not show any evidence of lesions. It can also be seen that postarthroscopy follow-up of patients varied. It is possible that, on longer follow-up, some of the cases we classified as having a reasonable outcome may have gone on to require total knee arthroplasty. One could argue that, in the patient who developed SONK within 1 year after surgery (Figure 4), the lesion was not related to the surgery. However, this patient’s radiographs 3 months after surgery did not show the SONK lesion but clearly showed prominent medial joint space narrowing—a new finding.
Only 1 musculoskeletal radiologist evaluated the radiographs, MRIs, and tomosynthesis (similar to computed tomography) studies for this investigation.
This lesion is not common, thus giving us a small group to analyze.
Despite our data limitations and the retrospective nature of this study, we compiled a reasonably representative sample of surgical SONK patients that matches other samples reported in the literature. Unfortunately, we could not identify any risk factors pointing to the likelihood of developing SONK or any risk factors pointing to either a reasonable or a poor prognosis in these patients. The etiology of the lesion remains an enigma. Our finding 6 cases of prearthroscopy lesions that did not necessarily result in a poor outcome, combined with our inability to identify any risk factors for SONK, points to the lack of a causal relationship with arthroscopy.
1. Ahlbäck S. Osteoarthritis of the knee. A radiographic investigation. Acta Radiol Diagn. 1968;(suppl 277):7-72.
2. Juréus J, Lindstrand A, Geijer M, Robertsson O, Tägil M. The natural course of spontaneous osteonecrosis of the knee (SPONK): a 1- to 27-year follow-up of 40 patients. Acta Orthop. 2013;84(4):410-414.
3. Zurlo JV. The double-line sign. Radiology. 1999;212(2):541-542.
4. Yamamoto T, Bullough PG. Spontaneous osteonecrosis of the knee: the result of subchondral insufficiency fracture. J Bone Joint Surg Am. 2000;82(6):858-866.
5. MacDessi SJ, Brophy RH, Bullough PG, Windsor RE, Sculco TP. Subchondral fracture following arthroscopic knee surgery. A series of eight cases. J Bone Joint Surg Am. 2008;90(5):1007-1012.
6. Brahme SK, Fox JM, Ferkel RD, Friedman MJ, Flannigan BD, Resnick DL. Osteonecrosis of the knee after arthroscopic surgery: diagnosis with MR imaging. Radiology. 1991;178(3):851-853.
7. Faletti C, Robba T, de Petro P. Postmeniscectomy osteonecrosis. Arthroscopy. 2002;18(1):91-94.
8. Johnson TC, Evans JA, Gilley JA, DeLee JC. Osteonecrosis of the knee after arthroscopic surgery for meniscal tears and chondral lesions. Arthroscopy. 2000;16(3):254-261.
9. al-Kaar M, Garcia J, Fritschy D, Bonvin JC. Aseptic osteonecrosis of the femoral condyle after meniscectomy by the arthroscopic approach. J Radiol. 1997;78(4):283-288.
10. DeFalco RA, Ricci AR, Balduini FC. Osteonecrosis of the knee after arthroscopic meniscectomy and chondroplasty: a case report and literature review. Am J Sports Med. 2003;31(6):1013-1016.
11. Kusayama T. Idiopathic osteonecrosis of the femoral condyle after meniscectomy. Tokai J Exp Clin Med. 2003;28(4):145-150.
12. Prues-Latour V, Bonvin JC, Fritschy D. Nine cases of osteonecrosis in elderly patients following arthroscopic meniscectomy. Knee Surg Sports Traumatol Arthrosc. 1998;6(3):142-147.
13. Santori N, Condello V, Adriani E, Mariani PP. Osteonecrosis after arthroscopic medial meniscectomy. Arthroscopy. 1995;11(2):220-224.
14. Noyes FR, Stabler CL. A system for grading articular cartilage lesions at arthroscopy. Am J Sports Med. 1989;17(4):505-513.
15. Kellgren JH, Lawrence JS. Radiological assessment of osteo-arthrosis. Ann Rheum Dis. 1957;16(4):494-502.
16. Kidwai AS, Hemphill SD, Griffiths HJ. Radiologic case study. Spontaneous osteonecrosis of the knee reclassified as insufficiency fracture. Orthopedics. 2005;28(3):236, 333-236.
17. Pape D, Lorbach O, Anagnostakos K, Kohn D. Osteonecrosis in the postarthroscopic knee. Orthopade. 2008;37(11):1099-1107.
18. Satku K, Kumar VP, Chacha PB. Stress fractures around the knee in elderly patients. A cause of acute pain in the knee. J Bone Joint Surg Am. 1990;72(6):918-922.
19. Soucacos PN, Xenakis TH, Beris AE, Soucacos PK, Georgoulis A. Idiopathic osteonecrosis of the medial femoral condyle. Classification and treatment. Clin Orthop. 1997;(341):82-89.
The term spontaneous osteonecrosis of the knee was first used by Ahlbäck1 in 1968. This term, and the acronym SONK (sometimes SPONK2), has subsequently been used by other authors to refer to an apparent osteonecrosis of the knee, most commonly occurring within the medial femoral condyle. SONK typically occurs in older women who usually do not have the typical osteonecrosis risk factors, such as steroid use, sickle-cell anemia, and excessive alcohol intake. Furthermore, the radiologic appearance of SONK differs from the typical avascular necrosis findings seen with radiography and magnetic resonance imaging (MRI). In particular, on MRI, the abnormality of SONK does not have the typical serpiginous margin of bone infarction, or the double-line sign indicating both sclerosis and granulation tissue.3 SONK is normally seen as a line of signal intensity on T1- and T2-weighted sequences; this line is adjacent to or parallels the subchondral bone with an adjacent area of extensive edema.
There is dispute over the cause of SONK. Yamamoto and Bullough4 proposed the lesion is in part a subchondral insufficiency fracture and staged it into 4 parts. Histologic findings suggest at least some SONK lesions are subchondral insufficiency fractures.5 Brahme and colleagues6 were the first to describe SONK occurring after arthroscopy, and others have documented this finding. The condition has also been referred to as osteonecrosis in the postoperative knee.7-13 An association of postoperative SONK with cartilage loss and meniscal tear has been proposed.7-13
We reviewed the clinical, radiologic, and MRI findings in 11 patients with evidence of postarthroscopy SONK to try to identify any risk factors that might predispose them to poor outcomes. Our study population consisted of 11 patients (12 knees) with SONK; 6 of the knees had the lesion before knee arthroscopy, and the other 6 developed the lesion after arthroscopy. We also considered MRI findings in a group of 11 age- and sex-matched patients who underwent knee arthroscopy and did not have or develop SONK. We reviewed the preoperative MRI findings of both groups for meniscal tear, meniscal extrusion, and cartilage loss. We had 2 hypotheses. First, patients with preoperative MRI findings of SONK would have articular cartilage changes, posterior root degeneration, and meniscal extrusion similar to those of patients who developed SONK after arthroscopy. Second, an age- and sex-matched group of patients who underwent arthroscopy and did not develop SONK would be similar in articular cartilage changes, posterior root degeneration or tear, and meniscal extrusion.
Materials and Methods
With institutional review board approval and waived informed consent, we reviewed all imaging studies, particularly the radiographs and MRI studies, of 11 patients (12 knees) who either had SONK before arthroscopy or developed it after arthroscopy. In all these cases, arthroscopy was performed to alleviate mechanical symptoms associated with meniscal tear.
On subsequent review by a musculoskeletal radiologist, 6 patients with SONK had an identifiable lesion before surgery. All patients’ symptoms had not improved with an earlier trial of conservative management. All preoperative and postoperative radiologic and MRI findings were reviewed. The patient group was assembled by writing to all the orthopedic surgeons who performed arthroscopy at our institution and asking for SONK cases seen in their practices. All but 2 cases were performed by a surgeon who treated a predominantly older, less active population. Clinical notes were reviewed for outcomes, and the musculoskeletal radiologist reviewed all radiologic studies. The 4 men and 7 women in the SONK group (1 woman had bilateral knee lesions) ranged in age from 43 to 74 years (mean, 63.8 years), and the 4 men and 7 women in the control group were age-matched to 43 to 75 years (mean, 63.6 years). The controls were chosen from a pool of patients who underwent knee arthroscopy at our institution.
MRI was performed using General Electric 1-T, 1.5-T, or 3-T magnets (GE Healthcare, Milwaukee, Wisconsin) or using Philips 1.5-T or open 0.7-T magnets (Philips Healthcare, Andover, Massachusetts). Imaging included sagittal and coronal proton density–weighted sequences and coronal and axial fat-suppressed T2-weighted sequences. SONK was diagnosed when a low signal line adjacent to the subchondral bone plate on the femoral or tibial condyles was present with an adjacent area of bone marrow edema in the respective condyle or when there was depression of the subchondral bone plate with adjacent edema. The MRI studies were reviewed for lesion location, and medial meniscus and lateral meniscus were reviewed for tear. Type of meniscal tear (horizontal cleavage, radial, complex degenerative) was documented, as was meniscal extrusion. The meniscus was regarded as extruded if the body extended more than 3 mm from the joint margin. Cartilage in the medial and lateral compartment was reviewed according to a modified Noyes scale listing 0 as normal, 1 as internal changes only, 2A as 1% to 49% cartilage loss, 2B as 50% to 90% loss of articular cartilage, 3A as 100% articular cartilage loss with subchondral bone plate intact, and 3B as 100% articular cartilage loss with ulcerated subchondral bone plate.14 Osteoarthritic severity was similarly classified using the Kellgren-Lawrence scale,15 where grade 0 is normal; grade 1 is unlikely to have narrowing of the joint space but potentially has osteophytic lipping; grade 2 has both definite narrowing of the joint space and osteophytes; grade 3 has narrowing of the joint space and multiple osteophytes, some sclerosis, and possible deformity of bone contour; and grade 4 has marked narrowing of the joint space, large osteophytes, severe sclerosis, and definite deformity of bone contour. Follow-up clinical notes and radiologic studies were reviewed in the assessment of patient outcomes.
All statistical analyses were performed with SAS 9.2 software (SAS Institute, Cary, North Carolina). Age data were evaluated with the Shapiro-Wilk test and graphical displays and were found to violate normality assumptions, so they are presented as medians and ranges; other variables are presented as count and column percentages. The Wilcoxon rank sum test was used to compare the 2 groups’ age distributions. Fisher exact tests were used to compare proportions between the 2 groups for the other variables. Statistical significance was set at P < .05.
Results
Table 1 lists the demographics and imaging characteristics of the 11 patients—6 had SONK before arthroscopy and 6 developed it after arthroscopy. Comparison of the 11 patients with SONK and the 11 controls is summarized with P values in Table 2. Representative cases that either presented before surgery or developed after surgery are shown in Figures 1 to 4. There were 6 prearthroscopy lesions and 6 postarthroscopy lesions—all 12 in the medial femoral condyle. Eleven of the 12 knees had a medial meniscal tear, and 1 knee had both medial and lateral meniscal tears. In 8 of the 12 knees, the lateral meniscus was normal; in 2 knees, it had mild degeneration; and, in 1 knee, it had a complex tear. Assessment of hyaline cartilage revealed medial cartilage loss ranging from 2A to 3B (median, 2B) in the patients with SONK, and lateral cartilage loss ranging from 0 to 2A (median, 0). At surgery, all knees had a partial medial meniscectomy, and 6 had a partial lateral meniscectomy. Ten of the 12 knees had chondroplasty, 9 patellar and 5 of the medial femoral condyle. Only 4 of the 11 patients with follow-up of more than 1 year went on to joint replacement. Six of the 12 had follow-up of more than 2 years. Of the 6 patients without an identifiable SONK lesion on MRI before arthroscopy, 4 had mild to moderate knee pain 0.5, 2.4, 3.5, and 4 years after surgery. For the other 2 patients, knee replacement was performed 1.5 and 1.8 years after surgery. Of the 6 patients with prearthroscopy SONK, 4 had mild to moderate knee pain 1.5, 3.7, 6.5, and 6.8 years after surgery; the other 2 had knee replacement 0.5 and 1.8 years after surgery. Articular cartilage degeneration and meniscal extrusion were similar (Table 1). In the control group, there was only 1 knee replacement, at 3 years, and the other 11 were functioning 2.6 to 5 years later. The longer follow-up resulted from selection of appropriate controls from the same year. Of the 6 SONK lesions found on preoperative MRI, 3 were read by the interpreting radiologist before surgery as possible SONK lesions, 2 were read as insufficiency fractures, and 1 was read as a possible insufficiency fracture.
Discussion
SONK is well described as a complication of arthroscopic knee surgery. However, this condition more commonly appears spontaneously in a population that has not had surgery. It has become clear that the term SONK may be misleading.16 In a recent series of postoperative subchondral fractures reported by MacDessi and colleagues,5 the average age of patients included in their study was 64 years. Pathologic analysis revealed subchondral fracture with callus formation in all cases. Only 2 knees had evidence of osteonecrosis, which appeared to be secondary to the fracture. Based on these findings, the authors concluded that “further investigation into the etiology of this condition is warranted.” A prominent association with medial meniscal tear has been noted, with the medial femoral condyle predominantly affected. As already mentioned, SONK differs from classical avascular necrosis on several points, including lack of the typical avascular osteonecrosis risk factors and absence of the serpiginous margin and double-line sign seen with typical bone infarction. In addition, the SONK lesions seen on radiographs and MRIs of the knee typically are in the medial femoral condyle and are very different from the typical area of infarction seen in patients with known risk factors for secondary osteonecrosis.
The cause of SONK is not known. Of more importance from a medicolegal standpoint is that these lesions are not necessarily related to arthroscopy.17 Interestingly, Pape and colleagues17 noted that some of the lesions they studied may have been present before surgery, which is what we found in 6 (50%) of the SONK knees in our study. Our data thus support the proposition that some SONK lesions are present before arthroscopy, and some cases of so-called postarthroscopy SONK may in fact have been progressing before surgery.
Our data also reinforce the importance of radiologist–orthopedic surgeon communication regarding the presence of SONK. We emphasize the importance of communicating the MRI findings clearly, whether the lesion is called SONK, SPONK, or insufficiency fracture. The orthopedic surgeons in our series may have been unaware of the presence of these lesions before arthroscopic meniscectomy, given the wide variety of terms being used in radiologic reports.
The natural history of spontaneous osteonecrosis of the medial tibial plateau has also been studied.18 There were 3 outcome patterns—acute extensive collapse of the medial tibial plateau, rapid progression to varying degrees of osteoarthritis, and complete resolution. It has been shown that resolution of SONK can occur in the early stages of the disease, within several months, but often the changes progress to bone destruction and articular cartilage collapse.19
In our series of patients, there was a female predominance, and mean age was 64 years. We investigated cartilage loss, meniscal tear, and meniscal extrusion to see if we could predict outcomes in patients who had the lesion before arthroscopy and if we could predict who might be at risk for developing the lesion after arthroscopy. Type of surgical procedure was also reviewed. For the sake of simplicity, we divided the follow-up patients into 2 groups: those managed with conservative treatment, which we deemed a reasonable outcome, and those who subsequently required knee joint replacement, which we deemed a poor outcome. As seen from our representative cases, both groups had patients with cartilage loss, meniscal tear, and meniscal extrusion to varying degrees. There were no risk factors pointing to a reasonable or poor outcome. In the group of patients with prearthroscopy lesions, we found the same problem. We were unable to identify a risk factor that might suggest a poor rather than a reasonable outcome. We must also emphasize that, in our review of patient charts, we could find no other causes for osteonecrosis. In particular, arthroscopic causes of acute chondral loss (eg, thermal wash, laser, bupivacaine pain pumps, epinephrine in irrigant) were not identified.
This study consisted of a series of cases managed at our institution over the past 8 years. Our data and this study had several limitations:
We may have been unable to identify other SONK cases that belonged in the group from our institution. In addition, we had only 11 patients for comparison with patients without SONK. Likewise, there were only 6 knees each in the prearthroscopy and postarthroscopy SONK groups. We also used images obtained from 1-T, 1.5-T, and 3-T closed MRI devices and one 0.7-T open device. These were, however, at the same institution.
Timing of our imaging was not uniform. In particular, in 3 of the patients who developed SONK after arthroscopy, preoperative MRI studies were performed quite some time before surgery. However, in these patients, more recent preoperative radiographs did not show any evidence of lesions. It can also be seen that postarthroscopy follow-up of patients varied. It is possible that, on longer follow-up, some of the cases we classified as having a reasonable outcome may have gone on to require total knee arthroplasty. One could argue that, in the patient who developed SONK within 1 year after surgery (Figure 4), the lesion was not related to the surgery. However, this patient’s radiographs 3 months after surgery did not show the SONK lesion but clearly showed prominent medial joint space narrowing—a new finding.
Only 1 musculoskeletal radiologist evaluated the radiographs, MRIs, and tomosynthesis (similar to computed tomography) studies for this investigation.
This lesion is not common, thus giving us a small group to analyze.
Despite our data limitations and the retrospective nature of this study, we compiled a reasonably representative sample of surgical SONK patients that matches other samples reported in the literature. Unfortunately, we could not identify any risk factors pointing to the likelihood of developing SONK or any risk factors pointing to either a reasonable or a poor prognosis in these patients. The etiology of the lesion remains an enigma. Our finding 6 cases of prearthroscopy lesions that did not necessarily result in a poor outcome, combined with our inability to identify any risk factors for SONK, points to the lack of a causal relationship with arthroscopy.
The term spontaneous osteonecrosis of the knee was first used by Ahlbäck1 in 1968. This term, and the acronym SONK (sometimes SPONK2), has subsequently been used by other authors to refer to an apparent osteonecrosis of the knee, most commonly occurring within the medial femoral condyle. SONK typically occurs in older women who usually do not have the typical osteonecrosis risk factors, such as steroid use, sickle-cell anemia, and excessive alcohol intake. Furthermore, the radiologic appearance of SONK differs from the typical avascular necrosis findings seen with radiography and magnetic resonance imaging (MRI). In particular, on MRI, the abnormality of SONK does not have the typical serpiginous margin of bone infarction, or the double-line sign indicating both sclerosis and granulation tissue.3 SONK is normally seen as a line of signal intensity on T1- and T2-weighted sequences; this line is adjacent to or parallels the subchondral bone with an adjacent area of extensive edema.
There is dispute over the cause of SONK. Yamamoto and Bullough4 proposed the lesion is in part a subchondral insufficiency fracture and staged it into 4 parts. Histologic findings suggest at least some SONK lesions are subchondral insufficiency fractures.5 Brahme and colleagues6 were the first to describe SONK occurring after arthroscopy, and others have documented this finding. The condition has also been referred to as osteonecrosis in the postoperative knee.7-13 An association of postoperative SONK with cartilage loss and meniscal tear has been proposed.7-13
We reviewed the clinical, radiologic, and MRI findings in 11 patients with evidence of postarthroscopy SONK to try to identify any risk factors that might predispose them to poor outcomes. Our study population consisted of 11 patients (12 knees) with SONK; 6 of the knees had the lesion before knee arthroscopy, and the other 6 developed the lesion after arthroscopy. We also considered MRI findings in a group of 11 age- and sex-matched patients who underwent knee arthroscopy and did not have or develop SONK. We reviewed the preoperative MRI findings of both groups for meniscal tear, meniscal extrusion, and cartilage loss. We had 2 hypotheses. First, patients with preoperative MRI findings of SONK would have articular cartilage changes, posterior root degeneration, and meniscal extrusion similar to those of patients who developed SONK after arthroscopy. Second, an age- and sex-matched group of patients who underwent arthroscopy and did not develop SONK would be similar in articular cartilage changes, posterior root degeneration or tear, and meniscal extrusion.
Materials and Methods
With institutional review board approval and waived informed consent, we reviewed all imaging studies, particularly the radiographs and MRI studies, of 11 patients (12 knees) who either had SONK before arthroscopy or developed it after arthroscopy. In all these cases, arthroscopy was performed to alleviate mechanical symptoms associated with meniscal tear.
On subsequent review by a musculoskeletal radiologist, 6 patients with SONK had an identifiable lesion before surgery. All patients’ symptoms had not improved with an earlier trial of conservative management. All preoperative and postoperative radiologic and MRI findings were reviewed. The patient group was assembled by writing to all the orthopedic surgeons who performed arthroscopy at our institution and asking for SONK cases seen in their practices. All but 2 cases were performed by a surgeon who treated a predominantly older, less active population. Clinical notes were reviewed for outcomes, and the musculoskeletal radiologist reviewed all radiologic studies. The 4 men and 7 women in the SONK group (1 woman had bilateral knee lesions) ranged in age from 43 to 74 years (mean, 63.8 years), and the 4 men and 7 women in the control group were age-matched to 43 to 75 years (mean, 63.6 years). The controls were chosen from a pool of patients who underwent knee arthroscopy at our institution.
MRI was performed using General Electric 1-T, 1.5-T, or 3-T magnets (GE Healthcare, Milwaukee, Wisconsin) or using Philips 1.5-T or open 0.7-T magnets (Philips Healthcare, Andover, Massachusetts). Imaging included sagittal and coronal proton density–weighted sequences and coronal and axial fat-suppressed T2-weighted sequences. SONK was diagnosed when a low signal line adjacent to the subchondral bone plate on the femoral or tibial condyles was present with an adjacent area of bone marrow edema in the respective condyle or when there was depression of the subchondral bone plate with adjacent edema. The MRI studies were reviewed for lesion location, and medial meniscus and lateral meniscus were reviewed for tear. Type of meniscal tear (horizontal cleavage, radial, complex degenerative) was documented, as was meniscal extrusion. The meniscus was regarded as extruded if the body extended more than 3 mm from the joint margin. Cartilage in the medial and lateral compartment was reviewed according to a modified Noyes scale listing 0 as normal, 1 as internal changes only, 2A as 1% to 49% cartilage loss, 2B as 50% to 90% loss of articular cartilage, 3A as 100% articular cartilage loss with subchondral bone plate intact, and 3B as 100% articular cartilage loss with ulcerated subchondral bone plate.14 Osteoarthritic severity was similarly classified using the Kellgren-Lawrence scale,15 where grade 0 is normal; grade 1 is unlikely to have narrowing of the joint space but potentially has osteophytic lipping; grade 2 has both definite narrowing of the joint space and osteophytes; grade 3 has narrowing of the joint space and multiple osteophytes, some sclerosis, and possible deformity of bone contour; and grade 4 has marked narrowing of the joint space, large osteophytes, severe sclerosis, and definite deformity of bone contour. Follow-up clinical notes and radiologic studies were reviewed in the assessment of patient outcomes.
All statistical analyses were performed with SAS 9.2 software (SAS Institute, Cary, North Carolina). Age data were evaluated with the Shapiro-Wilk test and graphical displays and were found to violate normality assumptions, so they are presented as medians and ranges; other variables are presented as count and column percentages. The Wilcoxon rank sum test was used to compare the 2 groups’ age distributions. Fisher exact tests were used to compare proportions between the 2 groups for the other variables. Statistical significance was set at P < .05.
Results
Table 1 lists the demographics and imaging characteristics of the 11 patients—6 had SONK before arthroscopy and 6 developed it after arthroscopy. Comparison of the 11 patients with SONK and the 11 controls is summarized with P values in Table 2. Representative cases that either presented before surgery or developed after surgery are shown in Figures 1 to 4. There were 6 prearthroscopy lesions and 6 postarthroscopy lesions—all 12 in the medial femoral condyle. Eleven of the 12 knees had a medial meniscal tear, and 1 knee had both medial and lateral meniscal tears. In 8 of the 12 knees, the lateral meniscus was normal; in 2 knees, it had mild degeneration; and, in 1 knee, it had a complex tear. Assessment of hyaline cartilage revealed medial cartilage loss ranging from 2A to 3B (median, 2B) in the patients with SONK, and lateral cartilage loss ranging from 0 to 2A (median, 0). At surgery, all knees had a partial medial meniscectomy, and 6 had a partial lateral meniscectomy. Ten of the 12 knees had chondroplasty, 9 patellar and 5 of the medial femoral condyle. Only 4 of the 11 patients with follow-up of more than 1 year went on to joint replacement. Six of the 12 had follow-up of more than 2 years. Of the 6 patients without an identifiable SONK lesion on MRI before arthroscopy, 4 had mild to moderate knee pain 0.5, 2.4, 3.5, and 4 years after surgery. For the other 2 patients, knee replacement was performed 1.5 and 1.8 years after surgery. Of the 6 patients with prearthroscopy SONK, 4 had mild to moderate knee pain 1.5, 3.7, 6.5, and 6.8 years after surgery; the other 2 had knee replacement 0.5 and 1.8 years after surgery. Articular cartilage degeneration and meniscal extrusion were similar (Table 1). In the control group, there was only 1 knee replacement, at 3 years, and the other 11 were functioning 2.6 to 5 years later. The longer follow-up resulted from selection of appropriate controls from the same year. Of the 6 SONK lesions found on preoperative MRI, 3 were read by the interpreting radiologist before surgery as possible SONK lesions, 2 were read as insufficiency fractures, and 1 was read as a possible insufficiency fracture.
Discussion
SONK is well described as a complication of arthroscopic knee surgery. However, this condition more commonly appears spontaneously in a population that has not had surgery. It has become clear that the term SONK may be misleading.16 In a recent series of postoperative subchondral fractures reported by MacDessi and colleagues,5 the average age of patients included in their study was 64 years. Pathologic analysis revealed subchondral fracture with callus formation in all cases. Only 2 knees had evidence of osteonecrosis, which appeared to be secondary to the fracture. Based on these findings, the authors concluded that “further investigation into the etiology of this condition is warranted.” A prominent association with medial meniscal tear has been noted, with the medial femoral condyle predominantly affected. As already mentioned, SONK differs from classical avascular necrosis on several points, including lack of the typical avascular osteonecrosis risk factors and absence of the serpiginous margin and double-line sign seen with typical bone infarction. In addition, the SONK lesions seen on radiographs and MRIs of the knee typically are in the medial femoral condyle and are very different from the typical area of infarction seen in patients with known risk factors for secondary osteonecrosis.
The cause of SONK is not known. Of more importance from a medicolegal standpoint is that these lesions are not necessarily related to arthroscopy.17 Interestingly, Pape and colleagues17 noted that some of the lesions they studied may have been present before surgery, which is what we found in 6 (50%) of the SONK knees in our study. Our data thus support the proposition that some SONK lesions are present before arthroscopy, and some cases of so-called postarthroscopy SONK may in fact have been progressing before surgery.
Our data also reinforce the importance of radiologist–orthopedic surgeon communication regarding the presence of SONK. We emphasize the importance of communicating the MRI findings clearly, whether the lesion is called SONK, SPONK, or insufficiency fracture. The orthopedic surgeons in our series may have been unaware of the presence of these lesions before arthroscopic meniscectomy, given the wide variety of terms being used in radiologic reports.
The natural history of spontaneous osteonecrosis of the medial tibial plateau has also been studied.18 There were 3 outcome patterns—acute extensive collapse of the medial tibial plateau, rapid progression to varying degrees of osteoarthritis, and complete resolution. It has been shown that resolution of SONK can occur in the early stages of the disease, within several months, but often the changes progress to bone destruction and articular cartilage collapse.19
In our series of patients, there was a female predominance, and mean age was 64 years. We investigated cartilage loss, meniscal tear, and meniscal extrusion to see if we could predict outcomes in patients who had the lesion before arthroscopy and if we could predict who might be at risk for developing the lesion after arthroscopy. Type of surgical procedure was also reviewed. For the sake of simplicity, we divided the follow-up patients into 2 groups: those managed with conservative treatment, which we deemed a reasonable outcome, and those who subsequently required knee joint replacement, which we deemed a poor outcome. As seen from our representative cases, both groups had patients with cartilage loss, meniscal tear, and meniscal extrusion to varying degrees. There were no risk factors pointing to a reasonable or poor outcome. In the group of patients with prearthroscopy lesions, we found the same problem. We were unable to identify a risk factor that might suggest a poor rather than a reasonable outcome. We must also emphasize that, in our review of patient charts, we could find no other causes for osteonecrosis. In particular, arthroscopic causes of acute chondral loss (eg, thermal wash, laser, bupivacaine pain pumps, epinephrine in irrigant) were not identified.
This study consisted of a series of cases managed at our institution over the past 8 years. Our data and this study had several limitations:
We may have been unable to identify other SONK cases that belonged in the group from our institution. In addition, we had only 11 patients for comparison with patients without SONK. Likewise, there were only 6 knees each in the prearthroscopy and postarthroscopy SONK groups. We also used images obtained from 1-T, 1.5-T, and 3-T closed MRI devices and one 0.7-T open device. These were, however, at the same institution.
Timing of our imaging was not uniform. In particular, in 3 of the patients who developed SONK after arthroscopy, preoperative MRI studies were performed quite some time before surgery. However, in these patients, more recent preoperative radiographs did not show any evidence of lesions. It can also be seen that postarthroscopy follow-up of patients varied. It is possible that, on longer follow-up, some of the cases we classified as having a reasonable outcome may have gone on to require total knee arthroplasty. One could argue that, in the patient who developed SONK within 1 year after surgery (Figure 4), the lesion was not related to the surgery. However, this patient’s radiographs 3 months after surgery did not show the SONK lesion but clearly showed prominent medial joint space narrowing—a new finding.
Only 1 musculoskeletal radiologist evaluated the radiographs, MRIs, and tomosynthesis (similar to computed tomography) studies for this investigation.
This lesion is not common, thus giving us a small group to analyze.
Despite our data limitations and the retrospective nature of this study, we compiled a reasonably representative sample of surgical SONK patients that matches other samples reported in the literature. Unfortunately, we could not identify any risk factors pointing to the likelihood of developing SONK or any risk factors pointing to either a reasonable or a poor prognosis in these patients. The etiology of the lesion remains an enigma. Our finding 6 cases of prearthroscopy lesions that did not necessarily result in a poor outcome, combined with our inability to identify any risk factors for SONK, points to the lack of a causal relationship with arthroscopy.
1. Ahlbäck S. Osteoarthritis of the knee. A radiographic investigation. Acta Radiol Diagn. 1968;(suppl 277):7-72.
2. Juréus J, Lindstrand A, Geijer M, Robertsson O, Tägil M. The natural course of spontaneous osteonecrosis of the knee (SPONK): a 1- to 27-year follow-up of 40 patients. Acta Orthop. 2013;84(4):410-414.
3. Zurlo JV. The double-line sign. Radiology. 1999;212(2):541-542.
4. Yamamoto T, Bullough PG. Spontaneous osteonecrosis of the knee: the result of subchondral insufficiency fracture. J Bone Joint Surg Am. 2000;82(6):858-866.
5. MacDessi SJ, Brophy RH, Bullough PG, Windsor RE, Sculco TP. Subchondral fracture following arthroscopic knee surgery. A series of eight cases. J Bone Joint Surg Am. 2008;90(5):1007-1012.
6. Brahme SK, Fox JM, Ferkel RD, Friedman MJ, Flannigan BD, Resnick DL. Osteonecrosis of the knee after arthroscopic surgery: diagnosis with MR imaging. Radiology. 1991;178(3):851-853.
7. Faletti C, Robba T, de Petro P. Postmeniscectomy osteonecrosis. Arthroscopy. 2002;18(1):91-94.
8. Johnson TC, Evans JA, Gilley JA, DeLee JC. Osteonecrosis of the knee after arthroscopic surgery for meniscal tears and chondral lesions. Arthroscopy. 2000;16(3):254-261.
9. al-Kaar M, Garcia J, Fritschy D, Bonvin JC. Aseptic osteonecrosis of the femoral condyle after meniscectomy by the arthroscopic approach. J Radiol. 1997;78(4):283-288.
10. DeFalco RA, Ricci AR, Balduini FC. Osteonecrosis of the knee after arthroscopic meniscectomy and chondroplasty: a case report and literature review. Am J Sports Med. 2003;31(6):1013-1016.
11. Kusayama T. Idiopathic osteonecrosis of the femoral condyle after meniscectomy. Tokai J Exp Clin Med. 2003;28(4):145-150.
12. Prues-Latour V, Bonvin JC, Fritschy D. Nine cases of osteonecrosis in elderly patients following arthroscopic meniscectomy. Knee Surg Sports Traumatol Arthrosc. 1998;6(3):142-147.
13. Santori N, Condello V, Adriani E, Mariani PP. Osteonecrosis after arthroscopic medial meniscectomy. Arthroscopy. 1995;11(2):220-224.
14. Noyes FR, Stabler CL. A system for grading articular cartilage lesions at arthroscopy. Am J Sports Med. 1989;17(4):505-513.
15. Kellgren JH, Lawrence JS. Radiological assessment of osteo-arthrosis. Ann Rheum Dis. 1957;16(4):494-502.
16. Kidwai AS, Hemphill SD, Griffiths HJ. Radiologic case study. Spontaneous osteonecrosis of the knee reclassified as insufficiency fracture. Orthopedics. 2005;28(3):236, 333-236.
17. Pape D, Lorbach O, Anagnostakos K, Kohn D. Osteonecrosis in the postarthroscopic knee. Orthopade. 2008;37(11):1099-1107.
18. Satku K, Kumar VP, Chacha PB. Stress fractures around the knee in elderly patients. A cause of acute pain in the knee. J Bone Joint Surg Am. 1990;72(6):918-922.
19. Soucacos PN, Xenakis TH, Beris AE, Soucacos PK, Georgoulis A. Idiopathic osteonecrosis of the medial femoral condyle. Classification and treatment. Clin Orthop. 1997;(341):82-89.
1. Ahlbäck S. Osteoarthritis of the knee. A radiographic investigation. Acta Radiol Diagn. 1968;(suppl 277):7-72.
2. Juréus J, Lindstrand A, Geijer M, Robertsson O, Tägil M. The natural course of spontaneous osteonecrosis of the knee (SPONK): a 1- to 27-year follow-up of 40 patients. Acta Orthop. 2013;84(4):410-414.
3. Zurlo JV. The double-line sign. Radiology. 1999;212(2):541-542.
4. Yamamoto T, Bullough PG. Spontaneous osteonecrosis of the knee: the result of subchondral insufficiency fracture. J Bone Joint Surg Am. 2000;82(6):858-866.
5. MacDessi SJ, Brophy RH, Bullough PG, Windsor RE, Sculco TP. Subchondral fracture following arthroscopic knee surgery. A series of eight cases. J Bone Joint Surg Am. 2008;90(5):1007-1012.
6. Brahme SK, Fox JM, Ferkel RD, Friedman MJ, Flannigan BD, Resnick DL. Osteonecrosis of the knee after arthroscopic surgery: diagnosis with MR imaging. Radiology. 1991;178(3):851-853.
7. Faletti C, Robba T, de Petro P. Postmeniscectomy osteonecrosis. Arthroscopy. 2002;18(1):91-94.
8. Johnson TC, Evans JA, Gilley JA, DeLee JC. Osteonecrosis of the knee after arthroscopic surgery for meniscal tears and chondral lesions. Arthroscopy. 2000;16(3):254-261.
9. al-Kaar M, Garcia J, Fritschy D, Bonvin JC. Aseptic osteonecrosis of the femoral condyle after meniscectomy by the arthroscopic approach. J Radiol. 1997;78(4):283-288.
10. DeFalco RA, Ricci AR, Balduini FC. Osteonecrosis of the knee after arthroscopic meniscectomy and chondroplasty: a case report and literature review. Am J Sports Med. 2003;31(6):1013-1016.
11. Kusayama T. Idiopathic osteonecrosis of the femoral condyle after meniscectomy. Tokai J Exp Clin Med. 2003;28(4):145-150.
12. Prues-Latour V, Bonvin JC, Fritschy D. Nine cases of osteonecrosis in elderly patients following arthroscopic meniscectomy. Knee Surg Sports Traumatol Arthrosc. 1998;6(3):142-147.
13. Santori N, Condello V, Adriani E, Mariani PP. Osteonecrosis after arthroscopic medial meniscectomy. Arthroscopy. 1995;11(2):220-224.
14. Noyes FR, Stabler CL. A system for grading articular cartilage lesions at arthroscopy. Am J Sports Med. 1989;17(4):505-513.
15. Kellgren JH, Lawrence JS. Radiological assessment of osteo-arthrosis. Ann Rheum Dis. 1957;16(4):494-502.
16. Kidwai AS, Hemphill SD, Griffiths HJ. Radiologic case study. Spontaneous osteonecrosis of the knee reclassified as insufficiency fracture. Orthopedics. 2005;28(3):236, 333-236.
17. Pape D, Lorbach O, Anagnostakos K, Kohn D. Osteonecrosis in the postarthroscopic knee. Orthopade. 2008;37(11):1099-1107.
18. Satku K, Kumar VP, Chacha PB. Stress fractures around the knee in elderly patients. A cause of acute pain in the knee. J Bone Joint Surg Am. 1990;72(6):918-922.
19. Soucacos PN, Xenakis TH, Beris AE, Soucacos PK, Georgoulis A. Idiopathic osteonecrosis of the medial femoral condyle. Classification and treatment. Clin Orthop. 1997;(341):82-89.
EuroPCR: CT-derived FFR promising in evaluating chest pain
PARIS – Noninvasive measurement of computed tomography–derived fractional flow reserve is a potential game changer in the management of patients with stable chest pain.
In a 200-patient proof-of-concept study known as FFR-CT RIPCORD, in which three experienced interventional cardiologists initially devised management plans based on coronary anatomy as defined by the results of CT angiography alone, subsequent knowledge of CT-derived fractional flow reserve (FFR-CT) caused them to change their management strategies in fully 36% of cases, Dr. Nick Curzen reported at the annual congress of the European Association of Percutaneous Cardiovascular Interventions.

“If this novel proof-of-concept result can be confirmed in large-scale trials, this suggests that noninvasive FFR-CT can be used as a clinically relevant tool that mimics the well-described ability of invasive FFR to refine management decisions for patients with chest pain that are made by invasive coronary angiography alone. This would indeed have important implications for routine clinical practice. FFR-CT may have potential as a noninvasive default method for simultaneous assessment of coronary anatomy and physiology in angina patients in order to define their management, which would completely change the way we look after them,” observed Dr. Curzen, professor of interventional cardiology at the University of Southampton (England).
EuroPCR codirector Dr. Williams Wijns was favorably impressed by the FFR-CT RIPCORD findings.
“This, I find just stunning. It’s really far reaching. This is a complete change in paradigm. Many patients that today undergo invasive angiography won’t even be sent to the cath lab. The invasive center becomes only for treatment,” commented Dr. Wijns, codirector of the cardiovascular center in Aalst, Belgium.
In FFR-CT RIPCORD, the cardiologists received information about a patient’s history and nonvasive CT angiography findings and were asked to reach consensus in selecting one of four management options: optimal medical therapy (OMT) alone, PCI plus OMT, CABG surgery and OMT, or ‘more information needed’ in the form of FFR findings, which identify those coronary lesions that are actually causing ischemia. Instead of receiving the results of conventional invasive FFR obtained using a pressure wire, however, the cardiologists were provided with the noninvasive FFR-CT findings in all 200 cases.
The resultant changes in management were substantial. Thirty percent of the patients initially slated for PCI were reallocated to OMT alone because no ischemic lesions were present. Twelve percent of patients assigned to OMT-only got reassigned to coronary revascularization. Moreover, in 18% of the PCI group, FFR-CT data led to a change in the vessel or vessels targeted for intervention.
“What particularly impressed me were two of those figures: that one-third of PCI patients are redirected to medical therapy, and – even more impressive to me – is the 18% of PCI patients who had a change in their target vessel. That’s a problem we often have in patients with multivessel disease and intermediate lesions: Sometimes we think, for example, the target is the LAD when in fact it’s another vessel,” commented Dr. Jean Fajadet, codirector of the interventional cardiovascular group at the Clinique Pasteur in Toulouse, France.
Dr. Curzen said the exciting thing about FFR-CT is that it could provide in one fell swoop a standardized way of obtaining both the anatomic and physiologic data necessary for informed clinical decision making, and without exposing patients needlessly to the risks of contrast and radiation exposure entailed in invasive coronary angiography.
“When we assess people with stable angina, if you have a room full of invasive cardiologists, we all do it differently at the moment. It’s crazy. A lot of us will do noninvasive tests like stress echo or MRI or some kind of exercise test, and then refer them for an invasive angiogram where we’ll also do an FFR. Some people will go straight for an angiogram. It’s a real mess. The thing I love about FFR-CT is it would be so slick for patients and their families: You see them in a chest pain clinic or your office and you put them in for this test. They don’t have to waste their time coming back several times for different tests. It’s a really beautiful concept,” Dr. Curzen continued.
Right now the turnaround time on FFR-CT is about 12 hours. The dataset has to be sent off to a supercomputer for a complex modeling analysis before the results come back.
“Of course, if this ever becomes clinically proven, I’m sure the turnaround time would become very quick,” according to the cardiologist.
A cost-effectiveness analysis of FFR-CT versus current standard care is ongoing and the results aren’t yet available. However, Dr. Curzen observed, “The cost to the patient is a very important issue: Who would want to have this done invasively if you have a test that proves you don’t need to have an invasive procedure?”
The FFR-CT RIPCORD study was sponsored by Heartflow. Dr. Curzen reported receiving research support from Heartflow, Boston Scientific, Haemonetics, and Medtronic.
PARIS – Noninvasive measurement of computed tomography–derived fractional flow reserve is a potential game changer in the management of patients with stable chest pain.
In a 200-patient proof-of-concept study known as FFR-CT RIPCORD, in which three experienced interventional cardiologists initially devised management plans based on coronary anatomy as defined by the results of CT angiography alone, subsequent knowledge of CT-derived fractional flow reserve (FFR-CT) caused them to change their management strategies in fully 36% of cases, Dr. Nick Curzen reported at the annual congress of the European Association of Percutaneous Cardiovascular Interventions.

“If this novel proof-of-concept result can be confirmed in large-scale trials, this suggests that noninvasive FFR-CT can be used as a clinically relevant tool that mimics the well-described ability of invasive FFR to refine management decisions for patients with chest pain that are made by invasive coronary angiography alone. This would indeed have important implications for routine clinical practice. FFR-CT may have potential as a noninvasive default method for simultaneous assessment of coronary anatomy and physiology in angina patients in order to define their management, which would completely change the way we look after them,” observed Dr. Curzen, professor of interventional cardiology at the University of Southampton (England).
EuroPCR codirector Dr. Williams Wijns was favorably impressed by the FFR-CT RIPCORD findings.
“This, I find just stunning. It’s really far reaching. This is a complete change in paradigm. Many patients that today undergo invasive angiography won’t even be sent to the cath lab. The invasive center becomes only for treatment,” commented Dr. Wijns, codirector of the cardiovascular center in Aalst, Belgium.
In FFR-CT RIPCORD, the cardiologists received information about a patient’s history and nonvasive CT angiography findings and were asked to reach consensus in selecting one of four management options: optimal medical therapy (OMT) alone, PCI plus OMT, CABG surgery and OMT, or ‘more information needed’ in the form of FFR findings, which identify those coronary lesions that are actually causing ischemia. Instead of receiving the results of conventional invasive FFR obtained using a pressure wire, however, the cardiologists were provided with the noninvasive FFR-CT findings in all 200 cases.
The resultant changes in management were substantial. Thirty percent of the patients initially slated for PCI were reallocated to OMT alone because no ischemic lesions were present. Twelve percent of patients assigned to OMT-only got reassigned to coronary revascularization. Moreover, in 18% of the PCI group, FFR-CT data led to a change in the vessel or vessels targeted for intervention.
“What particularly impressed me were two of those figures: that one-third of PCI patients are redirected to medical therapy, and – even more impressive to me – is the 18% of PCI patients who had a change in their target vessel. That’s a problem we often have in patients with multivessel disease and intermediate lesions: Sometimes we think, for example, the target is the LAD when in fact it’s another vessel,” commented Dr. Jean Fajadet, codirector of the interventional cardiovascular group at the Clinique Pasteur in Toulouse, France.
Dr. Curzen said the exciting thing about FFR-CT is that it could provide in one fell swoop a standardized way of obtaining both the anatomic and physiologic data necessary for informed clinical decision making, and without exposing patients needlessly to the risks of contrast and radiation exposure entailed in invasive coronary angiography.
“When we assess people with stable angina, if you have a room full of invasive cardiologists, we all do it differently at the moment. It’s crazy. A lot of us will do noninvasive tests like stress echo or MRI or some kind of exercise test, and then refer them for an invasive angiogram where we’ll also do an FFR. Some people will go straight for an angiogram. It’s a real mess. The thing I love about FFR-CT is it would be so slick for patients and their families: You see them in a chest pain clinic or your office and you put them in for this test. They don’t have to waste their time coming back several times for different tests. It’s a really beautiful concept,” Dr. Curzen continued.
Right now the turnaround time on FFR-CT is about 12 hours. The dataset has to be sent off to a supercomputer for a complex modeling analysis before the results come back.
“Of course, if this ever becomes clinically proven, I’m sure the turnaround time would become very quick,” according to the cardiologist.
A cost-effectiveness analysis of FFR-CT versus current standard care is ongoing and the results aren’t yet available. However, Dr. Curzen observed, “The cost to the patient is a very important issue: Who would want to have this done invasively if you have a test that proves you don’t need to have an invasive procedure?”
The FFR-CT RIPCORD study was sponsored by Heartflow. Dr. Curzen reported receiving research support from Heartflow, Boston Scientific, Haemonetics, and Medtronic.
PARIS – Noninvasive measurement of computed tomography–derived fractional flow reserve is a potential game changer in the management of patients with stable chest pain.
In a 200-patient proof-of-concept study known as FFR-CT RIPCORD, in which three experienced interventional cardiologists initially devised management plans based on coronary anatomy as defined by the results of CT angiography alone, subsequent knowledge of CT-derived fractional flow reserve (FFR-CT) caused them to change their management strategies in fully 36% of cases, Dr. Nick Curzen reported at the annual congress of the European Association of Percutaneous Cardiovascular Interventions.

“If this novel proof-of-concept result can be confirmed in large-scale trials, this suggests that noninvasive FFR-CT can be used as a clinically relevant tool that mimics the well-described ability of invasive FFR to refine management decisions for patients with chest pain that are made by invasive coronary angiography alone. This would indeed have important implications for routine clinical practice. FFR-CT may have potential as a noninvasive default method for simultaneous assessment of coronary anatomy and physiology in angina patients in order to define their management, which would completely change the way we look after them,” observed Dr. Curzen, professor of interventional cardiology at the University of Southampton (England).
EuroPCR codirector Dr. Williams Wijns was favorably impressed by the FFR-CT RIPCORD findings.
“This, I find just stunning. It’s really far reaching. This is a complete change in paradigm. Many patients that today undergo invasive angiography won’t even be sent to the cath lab. The invasive center becomes only for treatment,” commented Dr. Wijns, codirector of the cardiovascular center in Aalst, Belgium.
In FFR-CT RIPCORD, the cardiologists received information about a patient’s history and nonvasive CT angiography findings and were asked to reach consensus in selecting one of four management options: optimal medical therapy (OMT) alone, PCI plus OMT, CABG surgery and OMT, or ‘more information needed’ in the form of FFR findings, which identify those coronary lesions that are actually causing ischemia. Instead of receiving the results of conventional invasive FFR obtained using a pressure wire, however, the cardiologists were provided with the noninvasive FFR-CT findings in all 200 cases.
The resultant changes in management were substantial. Thirty percent of the patients initially slated for PCI were reallocated to OMT alone because no ischemic lesions were present. Twelve percent of patients assigned to OMT-only got reassigned to coronary revascularization. Moreover, in 18% of the PCI group, FFR-CT data led to a change in the vessel or vessels targeted for intervention.
“What particularly impressed me were two of those figures: that one-third of PCI patients are redirected to medical therapy, and – even more impressive to me – is the 18% of PCI patients who had a change in their target vessel. That’s a problem we often have in patients with multivessel disease and intermediate lesions: Sometimes we think, for example, the target is the LAD when in fact it’s another vessel,” commented Dr. Jean Fajadet, codirector of the interventional cardiovascular group at the Clinique Pasteur in Toulouse, France.
Dr. Curzen said the exciting thing about FFR-CT is that it could provide in one fell swoop a standardized way of obtaining both the anatomic and physiologic data necessary for informed clinical decision making, and without exposing patients needlessly to the risks of contrast and radiation exposure entailed in invasive coronary angiography.
“When we assess people with stable angina, if you have a room full of invasive cardiologists, we all do it differently at the moment. It’s crazy. A lot of us will do noninvasive tests like stress echo or MRI or some kind of exercise test, and then refer them for an invasive angiogram where we’ll also do an FFR. Some people will go straight for an angiogram. It’s a real mess. The thing I love about FFR-CT is it would be so slick for patients and their families: You see them in a chest pain clinic or your office and you put them in for this test. They don’t have to waste their time coming back several times for different tests. It’s a really beautiful concept,” Dr. Curzen continued.
Right now the turnaround time on FFR-CT is about 12 hours. The dataset has to be sent off to a supercomputer for a complex modeling analysis before the results come back.
“Of course, if this ever becomes clinically proven, I’m sure the turnaround time would become very quick,” according to the cardiologist.
A cost-effectiveness analysis of FFR-CT versus current standard care is ongoing and the results aren’t yet available. However, Dr. Curzen observed, “The cost to the patient is a very important issue: Who would want to have this done invasively if you have a test that proves you don’t need to have an invasive procedure?”
The FFR-CT RIPCORD study was sponsored by Heartflow. Dr. Curzen reported receiving research support from Heartflow, Boston Scientific, Haemonetics, and Medtronic.
AT EUROPCR
Key clinical point: Clinically decisive anatomic and physiologic data regarding the coronary arteries of patients with stable angina can be obtained noninvasively with a single test: CT-derived fractional flow reserve.
Major finding: Noninvasive FFR-CT findings resulted in a change in management strategy for 36% of patients with stable angina whose initial treatment plan was based on CT angiography alone.
Data source: A proof-of-concept study involving 200 patients with stable angina and a panel of three experienced interventional cardiologists making consensus decisions regarding their appropriate management.
Disclosures: The FFR-CT RIPCORD study was sponsored by Heartflow. The presenter reported having received research support from the company.