Pediatrics

CINCINNATI – Dystonia is a frequent complication seen in cerebral palsy, but it often goes undiagnosed. Using a unique video analysis, researchers have identified some movement features that have the potential to simplify diagnosis.

“[We have] previously demonstrated that by the age of 5 years, only 30% of children seen in a clinical setting have had their predominant motor phenotype identified, including dystonia. This helps demonstrate a broad diagnostic gap and the need for novel solutions,” said Laura Gilbert, DO, during her presentation of the results at the 2022 annual meeting of the Child Neurology Society.

Diagnosis of dystonia is challenging because of its clinical variability, and diagnostic tools often require a trained physician, which limits access to diagnoses. Expert clinician consensus therefore remains the gold standard for diagnosis of dystonia.

Another clinical need is that specific features of dystonia have not been well described in the upper extremities, and the research suggests there could be differences in brain injuries contributing to dystonia in the two domains.

The researchers set out to discover expert-identified features of patient videos that could be used to allow nonexperts to make a diagnosis of dystonia.

The researchers analyzed 26 videos with upper extremity exam maneuvers performed on children with periventricular leukomalacia at St. Louis Children’s Hospital Cerebral Palsy Center from 2005 to 2018. Among the study cohort, 65% of patients were male, 77% were White, and 11% were Black; 24% of patients were Gross Motor Function Classification Scale I, 24% were GMFCS II, 24% were GMFCS III, 16% were GMFCS IV, and 12% were GMFCS V. A total of 12% of patients were older than 20, 11% were aged 15-20, 38% were aged 10-15, 31% were aged 5-10, and 8% were age 5 or younger.
 

Video clues aid diagnosis

Three pediatric movement disorder specialists independently reviewed each video and assessed severity of dystonia. They then met over Zoom to reach a diagnostic consensus for each case.

The research team performed a content analysis of the experts’ discussions and identified specific statement fragments. The frequency of these fragments was then linked to severity of dystonia.

A total of 45% of the statement fragments referenced movement codes, which in turn comprised five content areas: 33% referenced a body part, 24% focused on laterality, 22% described movement features, 18% an action, and 3% described exam maneuvers. Examples included shoulder as a body part, flexion as an action descriptor, brisk as a movement feature, unilateral, and finger-nose-finger for exam maneuver.

With increasing dystonia severity, the shoulder was more often cited and hand was cited less often. Mirror movements, defined as involuntary, contralateral movements that are similar to the voluntary action, occurred more often in patients with no dystonia or only mild dystonia. Variability of movement over time, which is a distinguishing feature found in lower extremities, was not significantly associated with dystonia severity.

Within the category of exam maneuver, hand opening and closing was the most commonly cited, and it was cited more frequently among individuals with mild dystonia (70% vs. about 10% for both no dystonia and moderate to severe dystonia; P < .005).

“So how can we adopt this clinically? First, we can add in a very brief exam maneuver of hand opening and closing that can help assess for mild dystonia. Shoulder involvement may suggest more severe dystonia, and we must recognize the dystonia features seem to differ by body region and the triggering task. Overall, to help improve dystonia diagnosis, we must continue to work towards understanding these salient features to fully grasp the breadth of dystonia manifestations in people with [cerebral palsy],” said Dr. Gilbert, who is a pediatric movements disorder fellow at Washington University in St. Louis.
 

Key features help determine dystonia severity

The study is particularly interesting for its different findings in upper extremities versus lower extremities, according to Keith Coffman, MD, who comoderated the session where the study was presented. “That same group showed that there are very clear differences in lower-extremity function, but when they looked at upper extremity, there really weren’t robust differences. What it may show is that the features of cerebral palsy regarding dystonia may be very dependent on what type of injury you have to your brain. Because when you think about where the motor fibers that provide leg function, they live along the medial walls of the brain right along the midline, whereas the representation of the hand and arm are more out on the lateral side of the brain. So it may be that those regional anatomy differences and where the injury occurred could be at the baseline of why they had such differences in motor function,” said Dr. Coffman, who is a professor of pediatrics at University of Missouri–Kansas City and director of the movement disorders program at Children’s Mercy Hospital, also in Kansas City, Mo.

He suggested that the researchers might also do kinematic analysis of the videos to make predictions using quantitative differences in movement.

The research has the potential to improve dystonia diagnosis, according to comoderator Marc Patterson, MD, professor of neurology, pediatrics, and medical genetics at Mayo Clinic in Rochester, Minn. “I think they really pointed to some key features that can help clinicians distinguish [dystonia severity]. Something like the speed of opening and closing the hands [is a] fairly simple thing. That was to me the chief value of that study,” Dr. Patterson said.

Dr. Gilbert reported no relevant disclosures.

CINCINNATI – Dystonia is a frequent complication seen in cerebral palsy, but it often goes undiagnosed. Using a unique video analysis, researchers have identified some movement features that have the potential to simplify diagnosis.

“[We have] previously demonstrated that by the age of 5 years, only 30% of children seen in a clinical setting have had their predominant motor phenotype identified, including dystonia. This helps demonstrate a broad diagnostic gap and the need for novel solutions,” said Laura Gilbert, DO, during her presentation of the results at the 2022 annual meeting of the Child Neurology Society.

Diagnosis of dystonia is challenging because of its clinical variability, and diagnostic tools often require a trained physician, which limits access to diagnoses. Expert clinician consensus therefore remains the gold standard for diagnosis of dystonia.

Another clinical need is that specific features of dystonia have not been well described in the upper extremities, and the research suggests there could be differences in brain injuries contributing to dystonia in the two domains.

The researchers set out to discover expert-identified features of patient videos that could be used to allow nonexperts to make a diagnosis of dystonia.

The researchers analyzed 26 videos with upper extremity exam maneuvers performed on children with periventricular leukomalacia at St. Louis Children’s Hospital Cerebral Palsy Center from 2005 to 2018. Among the study cohort, 65% of patients were male, 77% were White, and 11% were Black; 24% of patients were Gross Motor Function Classification Scale I, 24% were GMFCS II, 24% were GMFCS III, 16% were GMFCS IV, and 12% were GMFCS V. A total of 12% of patients were older than 20, 11% were aged 15-20, 38% were aged 10-15, 31% were aged 5-10, and 8% were age 5 or younger.
 

Video clues aid diagnosis

Three pediatric movement disorder specialists independently reviewed each video and assessed severity of dystonia. They then met over Zoom to reach a diagnostic consensus for each case.

The research team performed a content analysis of the experts’ discussions and identified specific statement fragments. The frequency of these fragments was then linked to severity of dystonia.

A total of 45% of the statement fragments referenced movement codes, which in turn comprised five content areas: 33% referenced a body part, 24% focused on laterality, 22% described movement features, 18% an action, and 3% described exam maneuvers. Examples included shoulder as a body part, flexion as an action descriptor, brisk as a movement feature, unilateral, and finger-nose-finger for exam maneuver.

With increasing dystonia severity, the shoulder was more often cited and hand was cited less often. Mirror movements, defined as involuntary, contralateral movements that are similar to the voluntary action, occurred more often in patients with no dystonia or only mild dystonia. Variability of movement over time, which is a distinguishing feature found in lower extremities, was not significantly associated with dystonia severity.

Within the category of exam maneuver, hand opening and closing was the most commonly cited, and it was cited more frequently among individuals with mild dystonia (70% vs. about 10% for both no dystonia and moderate to severe dystonia; P < .005).

“So how can we adopt this clinically? First, we can add in a very brief exam maneuver of hand opening and closing that can help assess for mild dystonia. Shoulder involvement may suggest more severe dystonia, and we must recognize the dystonia features seem to differ by body region and the triggering task. Overall, to help improve dystonia diagnosis, we must continue to work towards understanding these salient features to fully grasp the breadth of dystonia manifestations in people with [cerebral palsy],” said Dr. Gilbert, who is a pediatric movements disorder fellow at Washington University in St. Louis.
 

Key features help determine dystonia severity

The study is particularly interesting for its different findings in upper extremities versus lower extremities, according to Keith Coffman, MD, who comoderated the session where the study was presented. “That same group showed that there are very clear differences in lower-extremity function, but when they looked at upper extremity, there really weren’t robust differences. What it may show is that the features of cerebral palsy regarding dystonia may be very dependent on what type of injury you have to your brain. Because when you think about where the motor fibers that provide leg function, they live along the medial walls of the brain right along the midline, whereas the representation of the hand and arm are more out on the lateral side of the brain. So it may be that those regional anatomy differences and where the injury occurred could be at the baseline of why they had such differences in motor function,” said Dr. Coffman, who is a professor of pediatrics at University of Missouri–Kansas City and director of the movement disorders program at Children’s Mercy Hospital, also in Kansas City, Mo.

He suggested that the researchers might also do kinematic analysis of the videos to make predictions using quantitative differences in movement.

The research has the potential to improve dystonia diagnosis, according to comoderator Marc Patterson, MD, professor of neurology, pediatrics, and medical genetics at Mayo Clinic in Rochester, Minn. “I think they really pointed to some key features that can help clinicians distinguish [dystonia severity]. Something like the speed of opening and closing the hands [is a] fairly simple thing. That was to me the chief value of that study,” Dr. Patterson said.

Dr. Gilbert reported no relevant disclosures.

CINCINNATI – Dystonia is a frequent complication seen in cerebral palsy, but it often goes undiagnosed. Using a unique video analysis, researchers have identified some movement features that have the potential to simplify diagnosis.

“[We have] previously demonstrated that by the age of 5 years, only 30% of children seen in a clinical setting have had their predominant motor phenotype identified, including dystonia. This helps demonstrate a broad diagnostic gap and the need for novel solutions,” said Laura Gilbert, DO, during her presentation of the results at the 2022 annual meeting of the Child Neurology Society.

Diagnosis of dystonia is challenging because of its clinical variability, and diagnostic tools often require a trained physician, which limits access to diagnoses. Expert clinician consensus therefore remains the gold standard for diagnosis of dystonia.

Another clinical need is that specific features of dystonia have not been well described in the upper extremities, and the research suggests there could be differences in brain injuries contributing to dystonia in the two domains.

The researchers set out to discover expert-identified features of patient videos that could be used to allow nonexperts to make a diagnosis of dystonia.

The researchers analyzed 26 videos with upper extremity exam maneuvers performed on children with periventricular leukomalacia at St. Louis Children’s Hospital Cerebral Palsy Center from 2005 to 2018. Among the study cohort, 65% of patients were male, 77% were White, and 11% were Black; 24% of patients were Gross Motor Function Classification Scale I, 24% were GMFCS II, 24% were GMFCS III, 16% were GMFCS IV, and 12% were GMFCS V. A total of 12% of patients were older than 20, 11% were aged 15-20, 38% were aged 10-15, 31% were aged 5-10, and 8% were age 5 or younger.
 

Video clues aid diagnosis

Three pediatric movement disorder specialists independently reviewed each video and assessed severity of dystonia. They then met over Zoom to reach a diagnostic consensus for each case.

The research team performed a content analysis of the experts’ discussions and identified specific statement fragments. The frequency of these fragments was then linked to severity of dystonia.

A total of 45% of the statement fragments referenced movement codes, which in turn comprised five content areas: 33% referenced a body part, 24% focused on laterality, 22% described movement features, 18% an action, and 3% described exam maneuvers. Examples included shoulder as a body part, flexion as an action descriptor, brisk as a movement feature, unilateral, and finger-nose-finger for exam maneuver.

With increasing dystonia severity, the shoulder was more often cited and hand was cited less often. Mirror movements, defined as involuntary, contralateral movements that are similar to the voluntary action, occurred more often in patients with no dystonia or only mild dystonia. Variability of movement over time, which is a distinguishing feature found in lower extremities, was not significantly associated with dystonia severity.

Within the category of exam maneuver, hand opening and closing was the most commonly cited, and it was cited more frequently among individuals with mild dystonia (70% vs. about 10% for both no dystonia and moderate to severe dystonia; P < .005).

“So how can we adopt this clinically? First, we can add in a very brief exam maneuver of hand opening and closing that can help assess for mild dystonia. Shoulder involvement may suggest more severe dystonia, and we must recognize the dystonia features seem to differ by body region and the triggering task. Overall, to help improve dystonia diagnosis, we must continue to work towards understanding these salient features to fully grasp the breadth of dystonia manifestations in people with [cerebral palsy],” said Dr. Gilbert, who is a pediatric movements disorder fellow at Washington University in St. Louis.
 

Key features help determine dystonia severity

The study is particularly interesting for its different findings in upper extremities versus lower extremities, according to Keith Coffman, MD, who comoderated the session where the study was presented. “That same group showed that there are very clear differences in lower-extremity function, but when they looked at upper extremity, there really weren’t robust differences. What it may show is that the features of cerebral palsy regarding dystonia may be very dependent on what type of injury you have to your brain. Because when you think about where the motor fibers that provide leg function, they live along the medial walls of the brain right along the midline, whereas the representation of the hand and arm are more out on the lateral side of the brain. So it may be that those regional anatomy differences and where the injury occurred could be at the baseline of why they had such differences in motor function,” said Dr. Coffman, who is a professor of pediatrics at University of Missouri–Kansas City and director of the movement disorders program at Children’s Mercy Hospital, also in Kansas City, Mo.

He suggested that the researchers might also do kinematic analysis of the videos to make predictions using quantitative differences in movement.

The research has the potential to improve dystonia diagnosis, according to comoderator Marc Patterson, MD, professor of neurology, pediatrics, and medical genetics at Mayo Clinic in Rochester, Minn. “I think they really pointed to some key features that can help clinicians distinguish [dystonia severity]. Something like the speed of opening and closing the hands [is a] fairly simple thing. That was to me the chief value of that study,” Dr. Patterson said.

Dr. Gilbert reported no relevant disclosures.

Courtesy of Daniel Stulberg, MD

These lesions, called Bohn nodules, manifest on the buccal or lingual portion of the maxillary alveolar ridge and, less frequently, on the mandibular alveolar ridge. Because Bohn nodules are white and have a firm consistency, they are often confused with teeth. They can be differentiated by location, as teeth usually erupt from the distal aspect of the alveolar ridge.

Bohn nodules are epithelial cysts that are filled with keratin, which gives them their white color. They are caused by portions of epithelium that get trapped under surrounding epithelial cells. Bohn nodules usually resolve when the overlying epithelium ruptures and releases the keratinaceous material (usually by the time the child is 3 months of age).¹

These nodules can be confused with neonatal or supernumerary teeth. Neonatal teeth can be abnormally small and pointed; they are true deciduous teeth that have erupted early. If they are removed, the child will not replace them until the time of their adult tooth eruption. Additionally, there are supernumerary teeth, which are extra teeth that are often abnormally shaped and loosely adherent. These abnormal teeth warrant extraction to avoid trauma to the tongue or aspiration.²

In this case, the family was advised regarding the benign nature of the nodules and the expectation that they would spontaneously resolve.

‌

Images and text courtesy of Daniel Stulberg, MD, FAAFP, Professor and Chair, Department of Family and Community Medicine, Western Michigan University Homer Stryker, MD School of Medicine Kalamazoo.

Courtesy of Daniel Stulberg, MD

These lesions, called Bohn nodules, manifest on the buccal or lingual portion of the maxillary alveolar ridge and, less frequently, on the mandibular alveolar ridge. Because Bohn nodules are white and have a firm consistency, they are often confused with teeth. They can be differentiated by location, as teeth usually erupt from the distal aspect of the alveolar ridge.

Bohn nodules are epithelial cysts that are filled with keratin, which gives them their white color. They are caused by portions of epithelium that get trapped under surrounding epithelial cells. Bohn nodules usually resolve when the overlying epithelium ruptures and releases the keratinaceous material (usually by the time the child is 3 months of age).¹

These nodules can be confused with neonatal or supernumerary teeth. Neonatal teeth can be abnormally small and pointed; they are true deciduous teeth that have erupted early. If they are removed, the child will not replace them until the time of their adult tooth eruption. Additionally, there are supernumerary teeth, which are extra teeth that are often abnormally shaped and loosely adherent. These abnormal teeth warrant extraction to avoid trauma to the tongue or aspiration.²

In this case, the family was advised regarding the benign nature of the nodules and the expectation that they would spontaneously resolve.

‌

Images and text courtesy of Daniel Stulberg, MD, FAAFP, Professor and Chair, Department of Family and Community Medicine, Western Michigan University Homer Stryker, MD School of Medicine Kalamazoo.

Courtesy of Daniel Stulberg, MD

These lesions, called Bohn nodules, manifest on the buccal or lingual portion of the maxillary alveolar ridge and, less frequently, on the mandibular alveolar ridge. Because Bohn nodules are white and have a firm consistency, they are often confused with teeth. They can be differentiated by location, as teeth usually erupt from the distal aspect of the alveolar ridge.

Bohn nodules are epithelial cysts that are filled with keratin, which gives them their white color. They are caused by portions of epithelium that get trapped under surrounding epithelial cells. Bohn nodules usually resolve when the overlying epithelium ruptures and releases the keratinaceous material (usually by the time the child is 3 months of age).¹

These nodules can be confused with neonatal or supernumerary teeth. Neonatal teeth can be abnormally small and pointed; they are true deciduous teeth that have erupted early. If they are removed, the child will not replace them until the time of their adult tooth eruption. Additionally, there are supernumerary teeth, which are extra teeth that are often abnormally shaped and loosely adherent. These abnormal teeth warrant extraction to avoid trauma to the tongue or aspiration.²

In this case, the family was advised regarding the benign nature of the nodules and the expectation that they would spontaneously resolve.

‌

Images and text courtesy of Daniel Stulberg, MD, FAAFP, Professor and Chair, Department of Family and Community Medicine, Western Michigan University Homer Stryker, MD School of Medicine Kalamazoo.

MADRID – Because of the hormone changes that occur throughout their lives, women experience sleep problems that differ significantly from those experienced by men. Indeed, 75%-84% of pregnant women don’t sleep well during the third trimester, and up to 80% of women in menopause have symptoms that prevent them from getting a good night’s rest. For those seeking a precision medicine approach, the challenge is to identify the relationship between the different sex-related phenotypes and the sleep conditions.

Irene Cano, MD, PhD, is the coordinator of the sleep department at the Spanish Society of Pulmonology and Thoracic Surgery. She spoke with this news organization about the significant impact of hormones on sleep disorders in women.

“Reproductive hormones like estrogen and progesterone play a meaningful role in brain functions – not only those linked to the regulation of reproduction but also other physiological processes related to the regulation of circadian rhythms, cognitive performance, mood, and sleep. In addition, other hormones – for example, prolactin, growth hormone, cortisol, and melatonin – have sex-dependent effects on sleep,” Dr. Cano said.

Girls start puberty at a younger age than boys. As girls enter adolescence, they go to bed later and waking up earlier. So, girls are getting less than the 10 hours of sleep that they should be getting at this stage of life. The result is sleep debt, which gives rise to various problems: poor academic performance, ADHD, obesity, and metabolic problems, to name a few. As Ariadna Farré, RN, a sleep unit nurse, noted at SEPAR’s Joint Winter Meeting, “schools would have to start morning classes later to get adolescents to perform well academically. As the situation is now, half of the kids are falling asleep at their desks.”
 

Influencing sleep quality

Dr. Cano explained the issue as follows: “In adolescence, along with changes in young women’s hormone levels, we begin to see differences between the sexes. The changes in levels of estrogens and progesterone are what’s responsible for the changes that, to some extent, cause those disturbances in the quality of our sleep and in the stages of our sleep.”

Thus, sleep can be affected by the changes in hormone level that occur during a menstrual cycle. Estrogens, which increase during the follicular phase, are associated with REM sleep, while progesterone, which increases during the luteal phase, increases non-REM sleep. “In the 3-6 days prior to menstruation, it’s quite common for a woman to report difficulties falling asleep and staying asleep, in connection with a decline in the percentage of time she spends in REM sleep, in the context of premenstrual syndrome. In addition,” Dr. Cano pointed out, “menstrual bleeding, that loss of blood, is associated with a drop in iron levels, making it more likely that the woman will experience restless legs syndrome.”
 

Cardiovascular system

This news organization also spoke with Milagros Merino, MD, PhD, president of the Spanish Sleep Society. “The consequences that lack of sleep have on the cardiovascular system – we’re essentially talking about certain arrhythmias, high blood pressure, thrombosis in some cases, stroke, and heart attack. Lack of sleep also gives rise to endocrine and metabolic issues, like overweight and being at a greater risk of developing diabetes. And as for mental health, we see, among other things, attention and memory problems, emotional lability, and irascibility. Numerous studies have confirmed all of this.”

Sleep apnea also deserves mention, Dr. Merino added. “Although this disorder is more common in men, we’re seeing it more and more now in women, along with the cardiovascular issues that it brings about.”

Another cardiovascular risk factor is insomnia, said Dr. Merino. “This sleep disorder is more prevalent in women. As hormones constantly change, the ways women sleep constantly change, from one stage of life to the next. They sleep one way in childhood, another way in adolescence, and yet another way in menopause.”
 

Sleep in pregnancy

During pregnancy, hormone changes are much more pronounced. During the first trimester, progesterone levels increase, making the woman drowsy. On top of that, her sleep is interrupted by more frequent visits to the bathroom as well as greater general discomfort.

In the second trimester, sleep interruptions persist but are not as bad as they were during the first 3 months. In the third trimester, 75%-84% of pregnant women find it difficult to sleep because of aches and pains, the need to urinate during the night, cramps, and heartburn.

“Major physical changes are happening. When the bladder gets compressed, the woman has to get up and go to the bathroom. There’s an interruption in her sleep,” Ms. Farré explained. In addition, as the pregnancy progresses, the woman gains weight and her body mass index (BMI) increases, which can bring on obstructive sleep apnea, high blood pressure, preeclampsia, and diabetes, if not closely monitored.

Other factors include concomitant treatments, such as contraceptives, and the stages of life, such as pregnancy and lactation. “When a woman of childbearing age has restless legs syndrome, more often than not, this means that she has an iron deficiency that needs to be treated with oral iron supplements,” said Dr. Merino. “However, there are few medications that can be given to a pregnant woman – and RLS is relatively common during pregnancy. So, we have to turn to oral or intravenous iron supplements. Yet another matter is narcolepsy. In these cases, all medications have to be stopped during pregnancy and lactation, as they can be harmful to the baby.”
 

Sleep apnea

While one in five menopausal women are asymptomatic, the others experience mild to severe symptoms of apnea that frequently interrupt their sleep. In this stage of life, which begins around age 50 years, the hormones that had provided protection against sleep disruptions start to decrease. As a result, there is a rise in sleep problems, especially insomnia, breathing-related sleep disorders (for example, apnea), and restless legs syndrome.

The prevalence of breathing-related sleep disorders during menopause is attributable to weight gain, the drop in levels of estrogens, and the redistribution of adipose tissue in the body. Other factors also increase a woman’s risk of experiencing apnea. They range from stress, depression, and other psychological and psychiatric conditions to health status, medication use, and simply the fact of getting older. “Sleep apnea is more common in men than in premenopausal women. The numbers even out, though, when we compare men against menopausal women,” Dr. Cano noted.

In women, symptoms of sleep apnea are frequently attributed to menopause. There is some overlap: insomnia, headache, irritability, low mood, decreased libido, fatigue during the day, and feeling sleepy. Only much later is the woman’s condition correctly diagnosed as sleep apnea. So, even though presenting with the same complaints, a man will be diagnosed with sleep apnea sooner than a woman will – in some cases, around 10 years sooner.

“On the other hand, we’d always thought that, in menopause, insomnia was characterized by awakenings occurring throughout the second half of the night. But perhaps what happens more often is that women are regularly waking up repeatedly over the course of the entire night, as opposed to experiencing a wakefulness that starts early and lasts throughout the night or having a problem falling asleep to begin with,” said Dr. Merino. “The good news is that hormone replacement therapy can get things back to the way they were. And getting better sleep will help to overcome insomnia.”
 

Socioeconomic status

Insomnia is the most common sleep disorder. It affects 10%-20% of people, mostly women. “The fact that sleep problems are more prevalent in women can be explained by the fact that among women, there is a higher incidence of conditions that disrupt sleep, such as depression,” said Dr. Cano.

“Insomnia is much more common in adult women than adult men. And at menopause, women find that the insomnia only gets worse,” Dr. Merino added. “But around that same age, 50 years old, what we start to see more frequently in men is REM sleep behavior disorder, a type of parasomnia that’s a risk marker of degenerative nerve diseases.”

Dr. Cano emphasized one finding that, though basic, is not well known. “After adjusting for socioeconomic characteristics, the difference between the sexes in reporting sleep problems is cut in half. This suggests that an important factor that explains why there are differences in sleep problems between the sexes is that women’s socioeconomic status is generally lower than men’s.

“As for sleep apnea in particular,” Dr. Cano continued, “the kinds of symptoms that women have can be different from the classic ones seen in men – snoring, pauses in breathing, and daytime sleepiness; women are being underdiagnosed, and when they are diagnosed, that’s happening at a later age and at a higher BMI.”

So, it’s alarming that, as reported by SEPAR, 90% of women with obstructive sleep apnea are not being diagnosed.
 

Precision medicine approach

“The majority of research studies on sleep apnea have focused on men – given the prevalence of cases – and the results have been extrapolated to women. This is why there’s still a lot of work to be done in terms of better defining the characteristics specific to each sleep disorder and how they relate to each sex,” said Dr. Cano. “Being able to identify the relationship between the different sex-related phenotypes and each condition will allow us to take a precision medicine approach tailored to a patient’s particular characteristics.”

As Dr. Merino put it: “The approach to sleep disorders is always personalized. The patient’s sex, in and of itself, doesn’t have that great of an impact on this approach. What does have a great impact are women’s life stages. There are some subtle differences here and there, such as types of continuous positive airway pressure machines. The ones that are designed for women have masks that are better suited to their facial features, which differ from men’s.”

A precision medicine approach can be taken to treat any sleep disorder. For insomnia, the approach allows healthcare professionals to employ an appropriate cognitive-behavioral therapy plan or to determine which drugs would be more effective – all on the basis of symptoms and the characteristics of the particular case. Regarding sleep apnea, Dr. Cano explained, “taking into account the different anatomical characteristics or the higher prevalence of positional apnea will also allow us to offer different therapeutic alternatives to continuous positive airway pressure, such as mandibular advancement devices or positional therapy devices.”

Women should be encouraged to develop good sleep habits. These include taking circadian rhythms into account and aligning lifestyles accordingly. It also means going to bed earlier than the men in the household. For menopausal women, recommended sleep habits range from keeping their bedroom at an ideal temperature, following a diet rich in vegetables to avoid becoming overweight, and exercising daily. While this advice may be more applicable to teenagers, adults can benefit from it as well: Electronic devices should be turned off well before bedtime. Whether from a phone screen, a tablet screen, or a TV screen, the light emitted can keep one awake, which can be harmful to one’s health.

Dr. Cano and Dr. Merino disclosed no relevant financial relationships.

A version of this article appeared on Medscape.com. This article was translated from the Medscape Spanish edition.

MADRID – Because of the hormone changes that occur throughout their lives, women experience sleep problems that differ significantly from those experienced by men. Indeed, 75%-84% of pregnant women don’t sleep well during the third trimester, and up to 80% of women in menopause have symptoms that prevent them from getting a good night’s rest. For those seeking a precision medicine approach, the challenge is to identify the relationship between the different sex-related phenotypes and the sleep conditions.

Irene Cano, MD, PhD, is the coordinator of the sleep department at the Spanish Society of Pulmonology and Thoracic Surgery. She spoke with this news organization about the significant impact of hormones on sleep disorders in women.

“Reproductive hormones like estrogen and progesterone play a meaningful role in brain functions – not only those linked to the regulation of reproduction but also other physiological processes related to the regulation of circadian rhythms, cognitive performance, mood, and sleep. In addition, other hormones – for example, prolactin, growth hormone, cortisol, and melatonin – have sex-dependent effects on sleep,” Dr. Cano said.

Girls start puberty at a younger age than boys. As girls enter adolescence, they go to bed later and waking up earlier. So, girls are getting less than the 10 hours of sleep that they should be getting at this stage of life. The result is sleep debt, which gives rise to various problems: poor academic performance, ADHD, obesity, and metabolic problems, to name a few. As Ariadna Farré, RN, a sleep unit nurse, noted at SEPAR’s Joint Winter Meeting, “schools would have to start morning classes later to get adolescents to perform well academically. As the situation is now, half of the kids are falling asleep at their desks.”
 

Influencing sleep quality

Dr. Cano explained the issue as follows: “In adolescence, along with changes in young women’s hormone levels, we begin to see differences between the sexes. The changes in levels of estrogens and progesterone are what’s responsible for the changes that, to some extent, cause those disturbances in the quality of our sleep and in the stages of our sleep.”

Thus, sleep can be affected by the changes in hormone level that occur during a menstrual cycle. Estrogens, which increase during the follicular phase, are associated with REM sleep, while progesterone, which increases during the luteal phase, increases non-REM sleep. “In the 3-6 days prior to menstruation, it’s quite common for a woman to report difficulties falling asleep and staying asleep, in connection with a decline in the percentage of time she spends in REM sleep, in the context of premenstrual syndrome. In addition,” Dr. Cano pointed out, “menstrual bleeding, that loss of blood, is associated with a drop in iron levels, making it more likely that the woman will experience restless legs syndrome.”
 

Cardiovascular system

This news organization also spoke with Milagros Merino, MD, PhD, president of the Spanish Sleep Society. “The consequences that lack of sleep have on the cardiovascular system – we’re essentially talking about certain arrhythmias, high blood pressure, thrombosis in some cases, stroke, and heart attack. Lack of sleep also gives rise to endocrine and metabolic issues, like overweight and being at a greater risk of developing diabetes. And as for mental health, we see, among other things, attention and memory problems, emotional lability, and irascibility. Numerous studies have confirmed all of this.”

Sleep apnea also deserves mention, Dr. Merino added. “Although this disorder is more common in men, we’re seeing it more and more now in women, along with the cardiovascular issues that it brings about.”

Another cardiovascular risk factor is insomnia, said Dr. Merino. “This sleep disorder is more prevalent in women. As hormones constantly change, the ways women sleep constantly change, from one stage of life to the next. They sleep one way in childhood, another way in adolescence, and yet another way in menopause.”
 

Sleep in pregnancy

During pregnancy, hormone changes are much more pronounced. During the first trimester, progesterone levels increase, making the woman drowsy. On top of that, her sleep is interrupted by more frequent visits to the bathroom as well as greater general discomfort.

In the second trimester, sleep interruptions persist but are not as bad as they were during the first 3 months. In the third trimester, 75%-84% of pregnant women find it difficult to sleep because of aches and pains, the need to urinate during the night, cramps, and heartburn.

“Major physical changes are happening. When the bladder gets compressed, the woman has to get up and go to the bathroom. There’s an interruption in her sleep,” Ms. Farré explained. In addition, as the pregnancy progresses, the woman gains weight and her body mass index (BMI) increases, which can bring on obstructive sleep apnea, high blood pressure, preeclampsia, and diabetes, if not closely monitored.

Other factors include concomitant treatments, such as contraceptives, and the stages of life, such as pregnancy and lactation. “When a woman of childbearing age has restless legs syndrome, more often than not, this means that she has an iron deficiency that needs to be treated with oral iron supplements,” said Dr. Merino. “However, there are few medications that can be given to a pregnant woman – and RLS is relatively common during pregnancy. So, we have to turn to oral or intravenous iron supplements. Yet another matter is narcolepsy. In these cases, all medications have to be stopped during pregnancy and lactation, as they can be harmful to the baby.”
 

Sleep apnea

While one in five menopausal women are asymptomatic, the others experience mild to severe symptoms of apnea that frequently interrupt their sleep. In this stage of life, which begins around age 50 years, the hormones that had provided protection against sleep disruptions start to decrease. As a result, there is a rise in sleep problems, especially insomnia, breathing-related sleep disorders (for example, apnea), and restless legs syndrome.

The prevalence of breathing-related sleep disorders during menopause is attributable to weight gain, the drop in levels of estrogens, and the redistribution of adipose tissue in the body. Other factors also increase a woman’s risk of experiencing apnea. They range from stress, depression, and other psychological and psychiatric conditions to health status, medication use, and simply the fact of getting older. “Sleep apnea is more common in men than in premenopausal women. The numbers even out, though, when we compare men against menopausal women,” Dr. Cano noted.

In women, symptoms of sleep apnea are frequently attributed to menopause. There is some overlap: insomnia, headache, irritability, low mood, decreased libido, fatigue during the day, and feeling sleepy. Only much later is the woman’s condition correctly diagnosed as sleep apnea. So, even though presenting with the same complaints, a man will be diagnosed with sleep apnea sooner than a woman will – in some cases, around 10 years sooner.

“On the other hand, we’d always thought that, in menopause, insomnia was characterized by awakenings occurring throughout the second half of the night. But perhaps what happens more often is that women are regularly waking up repeatedly over the course of the entire night, as opposed to experiencing a wakefulness that starts early and lasts throughout the night or having a problem falling asleep to begin with,” said Dr. Merino. “The good news is that hormone replacement therapy can get things back to the way they were. And getting better sleep will help to overcome insomnia.”
 

Socioeconomic status

Insomnia is the most common sleep disorder. It affects 10%-20% of people, mostly women. “The fact that sleep problems are more prevalent in women can be explained by the fact that among women, there is a higher incidence of conditions that disrupt sleep, such as depression,” said Dr. Cano.

“Insomnia is much more common in adult women than adult men. And at menopause, women find that the insomnia only gets worse,” Dr. Merino added. “But around that same age, 50 years old, what we start to see more frequently in men is REM sleep behavior disorder, a type of parasomnia that’s a risk marker of degenerative nerve diseases.”

Dr. Cano emphasized one finding that, though basic, is not well known. “After adjusting for socioeconomic characteristics, the difference between the sexes in reporting sleep problems is cut in half. This suggests that an important factor that explains why there are differences in sleep problems between the sexes is that women’s socioeconomic status is generally lower than men’s.

“As for sleep apnea in particular,” Dr. Cano continued, “the kinds of symptoms that women have can be different from the classic ones seen in men – snoring, pauses in breathing, and daytime sleepiness; women are being underdiagnosed, and when they are diagnosed, that’s happening at a later age and at a higher BMI.”

So, it’s alarming that, as reported by SEPAR, 90% of women with obstructive sleep apnea are not being diagnosed.
 

Precision medicine approach

“The majority of research studies on sleep apnea have focused on men – given the prevalence of cases – and the results have been extrapolated to women. This is why there’s still a lot of work to be done in terms of better defining the characteristics specific to each sleep disorder and how they relate to each sex,” said Dr. Cano. “Being able to identify the relationship between the different sex-related phenotypes and each condition will allow us to take a precision medicine approach tailored to a patient’s particular characteristics.”

As Dr. Merino put it: “The approach to sleep disorders is always personalized. The patient’s sex, in and of itself, doesn’t have that great of an impact on this approach. What does have a great impact are women’s life stages. There are some subtle differences here and there, such as types of continuous positive airway pressure machines. The ones that are designed for women have masks that are better suited to their facial features, which differ from men’s.”

A precision medicine approach can be taken to treat any sleep disorder. For insomnia, the approach allows healthcare professionals to employ an appropriate cognitive-behavioral therapy plan or to determine which drugs would be more effective – all on the basis of symptoms and the characteristics of the particular case. Regarding sleep apnea, Dr. Cano explained, “taking into account the different anatomical characteristics or the higher prevalence of positional apnea will also allow us to offer different therapeutic alternatives to continuous positive airway pressure, such as mandibular advancement devices or positional therapy devices.”

Women should be encouraged to develop good sleep habits. These include taking circadian rhythms into account and aligning lifestyles accordingly. It also means going to bed earlier than the men in the household. For menopausal women, recommended sleep habits range from keeping their bedroom at an ideal temperature, following a diet rich in vegetables to avoid becoming overweight, and exercising daily. While this advice may be more applicable to teenagers, adults can benefit from it as well: Electronic devices should be turned off well before bedtime. Whether from a phone screen, a tablet screen, or a TV screen, the light emitted can keep one awake, which can be harmful to one’s health.

Dr. Cano and Dr. Merino disclosed no relevant financial relationships.

A version of this article appeared on Medscape.com. This article was translated from the Medscape Spanish edition.

MADRID – Because of the hormone changes that occur throughout their lives, women experience sleep problems that differ significantly from those experienced by men. Indeed, 75%-84% of pregnant women don’t sleep well during the third trimester, and up to 80% of women in menopause have symptoms that prevent them from getting a good night’s rest. For those seeking a precision medicine approach, the challenge is to identify the relationship between the different sex-related phenotypes and the sleep conditions.

Irene Cano, MD, PhD, is the coordinator of the sleep department at the Spanish Society of Pulmonology and Thoracic Surgery. She spoke with this news organization about the significant impact of hormones on sleep disorders in women.

“Reproductive hormones like estrogen and progesterone play a meaningful role in brain functions – not only those linked to the regulation of reproduction but also other physiological processes related to the regulation of circadian rhythms, cognitive performance, mood, and sleep. In addition, other hormones – for example, prolactin, growth hormone, cortisol, and melatonin – have sex-dependent effects on sleep,” Dr. Cano said.

Girls start puberty at a younger age than boys. As girls enter adolescence, they go to bed later and waking up earlier. So, girls are getting less than the 10 hours of sleep that they should be getting at this stage of life. The result is sleep debt, which gives rise to various problems: poor academic performance, ADHD, obesity, and metabolic problems, to name a few. As Ariadna Farré, RN, a sleep unit nurse, noted at SEPAR’s Joint Winter Meeting, “schools would have to start morning classes later to get adolescents to perform well academically. As the situation is now, half of the kids are falling asleep at their desks.”
 

Influencing sleep quality

Dr. Cano explained the issue as follows: “In adolescence, along with changes in young women’s hormone levels, we begin to see differences between the sexes. The changes in levels of estrogens and progesterone are what’s responsible for the changes that, to some extent, cause those disturbances in the quality of our sleep and in the stages of our sleep.”

Thus, sleep can be affected by the changes in hormone level that occur during a menstrual cycle. Estrogens, which increase during the follicular phase, are associated with REM sleep, while progesterone, which increases during the luteal phase, increases non-REM sleep. “In the 3-6 days prior to menstruation, it’s quite common for a woman to report difficulties falling asleep and staying asleep, in connection with a decline in the percentage of time she spends in REM sleep, in the context of premenstrual syndrome. In addition,” Dr. Cano pointed out, “menstrual bleeding, that loss of blood, is associated with a drop in iron levels, making it more likely that the woman will experience restless legs syndrome.”
 

Cardiovascular system

This news organization also spoke with Milagros Merino, MD, PhD, president of the Spanish Sleep Society. “The consequences that lack of sleep have on the cardiovascular system – we’re essentially talking about certain arrhythmias, high blood pressure, thrombosis in some cases, stroke, and heart attack. Lack of sleep also gives rise to endocrine and metabolic issues, like overweight and being at a greater risk of developing diabetes. And as for mental health, we see, among other things, attention and memory problems, emotional lability, and irascibility. Numerous studies have confirmed all of this.”

Sleep apnea also deserves mention, Dr. Merino added. “Although this disorder is more common in men, we’re seeing it more and more now in women, along with the cardiovascular issues that it brings about.”

Another cardiovascular risk factor is insomnia, said Dr. Merino. “This sleep disorder is more prevalent in women. As hormones constantly change, the ways women sleep constantly change, from one stage of life to the next. They sleep one way in childhood, another way in adolescence, and yet another way in menopause.”
 

Sleep in pregnancy

During pregnancy, hormone changes are much more pronounced. During the first trimester, progesterone levels increase, making the woman drowsy. On top of that, her sleep is interrupted by more frequent visits to the bathroom as well as greater general discomfort.

In the second trimester, sleep interruptions persist but are not as bad as they were during the first 3 months. In the third trimester, 75%-84% of pregnant women find it difficult to sleep because of aches and pains, the need to urinate during the night, cramps, and heartburn.

“Major physical changes are happening. When the bladder gets compressed, the woman has to get up and go to the bathroom. There’s an interruption in her sleep,” Ms. Farré explained. In addition, as the pregnancy progresses, the woman gains weight and her body mass index (BMI) increases, which can bring on obstructive sleep apnea, high blood pressure, preeclampsia, and diabetes, if not closely monitored.

Other factors include concomitant treatments, such as contraceptives, and the stages of life, such as pregnancy and lactation. “When a woman of childbearing age has restless legs syndrome, more often than not, this means that she has an iron deficiency that needs to be treated with oral iron supplements,” said Dr. Merino. “However, there are few medications that can be given to a pregnant woman – and RLS is relatively common during pregnancy. So, we have to turn to oral or intravenous iron supplements. Yet another matter is narcolepsy. In these cases, all medications have to be stopped during pregnancy and lactation, as they can be harmful to the baby.”
 

Sleep apnea

While one in five menopausal women are asymptomatic, the others experience mild to severe symptoms of apnea that frequently interrupt their sleep. In this stage of life, which begins around age 50 years, the hormones that had provided protection against sleep disruptions start to decrease. As a result, there is a rise in sleep problems, especially insomnia, breathing-related sleep disorders (for example, apnea), and restless legs syndrome.

The prevalence of breathing-related sleep disorders during menopause is attributable to weight gain, the drop in levels of estrogens, and the redistribution of adipose tissue in the body. Other factors also increase a woman’s risk of experiencing apnea. They range from stress, depression, and other psychological and psychiatric conditions to health status, medication use, and simply the fact of getting older. “Sleep apnea is more common in men than in premenopausal women. The numbers even out, though, when we compare men against menopausal women,” Dr. Cano noted.

In women, symptoms of sleep apnea are frequently attributed to menopause. There is some overlap: insomnia, headache, irritability, low mood, decreased libido, fatigue during the day, and feeling sleepy. Only much later is the woman’s condition correctly diagnosed as sleep apnea. So, even though presenting with the same complaints, a man will be diagnosed with sleep apnea sooner than a woman will – in some cases, around 10 years sooner.

“On the other hand, we’d always thought that, in menopause, insomnia was characterized by awakenings occurring throughout the second half of the night. But perhaps what happens more often is that women are regularly waking up repeatedly over the course of the entire night, as opposed to experiencing a wakefulness that starts early and lasts throughout the night or having a problem falling asleep to begin with,” said Dr. Merino. “The good news is that hormone replacement therapy can get things back to the way they were. And getting better sleep will help to overcome insomnia.”
 

Socioeconomic status

Insomnia is the most common sleep disorder. It affects 10%-20% of people, mostly women. “The fact that sleep problems are more prevalent in women can be explained by the fact that among women, there is a higher incidence of conditions that disrupt sleep, such as depression,” said Dr. Cano.

“Insomnia is much more common in adult women than adult men. And at menopause, women find that the insomnia only gets worse,” Dr. Merino added. “But around that same age, 50 years old, what we start to see more frequently in men is REM sleep behavior disorder, a type of parasomnia that’s a risk marker of degenerative nerve diseases.”

Dr. Cano emphasized one finding that, though basic, is not well known. “After adjusting for socioeconomic characteristics, the difference between the sexes in reporting sleep problems is cut in half. This suggests that an important factor that explains why there are differences in sleep problems between the sexes is that women’s socioeconomic status is generally lower than men’s.

“As for sleep apnea in particular,” Dr. Cano continued, “the kinds of symptoms that women have can be different from the classic ones seen in men – snoring, pauses in breathing, and daytime sleepiness; women are being underdiagnosed, and when they are diagnosed, that’s happening at a later age and at a higher BMI.”

So, it’s alarming that, as reported by SEPAR, 90% of women with obstructive sleep apnea are not being diagnosed.
 

Precision medicine approach

“The majority of research studies on sleep apnea have focused on men – given the prevalence of cases – and the results have been extrapolated to women. This is why there’s still a lot of work to be done in terms of better defining the characteristics specific to each sleep disorder and how they relate to each sex,” said Dr. Cano. “Being able to identify the relationship between the different sex-related phenotypes and each condition will allow us to take a precision medicine approach tailored to a patient’s particular characteristics.”

As Dr. Merino put it: “The approach to sleep disorders is always personalized. The patient’s sex, in and of itself, doesn’t have that great of an impact on this approach. What does have a great impact are women’s life stages. There are some subtle differences here and there, such as types of continuous positive airway pressure machines. The ones that are designed for women have masks that are better suited to their facial features, which differ from men’s.”

A precision medicine approach can be taken to treat any sleep disorder. For insomnia, the approach allows healthcare professionals to employ an appropriate cognitive-behavioral therapy plan or to determine which drugs would be more effective – all on the basis of symptoms and the characteristics of the particular case. Regarding sleep apnea, Dr. Cano explained, “taking into account the different anatomical characteristics or the higher prevalence of positional apnea will also allow us to offer different therapeutic alternatives to continuous positive airway pressure, such as mandibular advancement devices or positional therapy devices.”

Women should be encouraged to develop good sleep habits. These include taking circadian rhythms into account and aligning lifestyles accordingly. It also means going to bed earlier than the men in the household. For menopausal women, recommended sleep habits range from keeping their bedroom at an ideal temperature, following a diet rich in vegetables to avoid becoming overweight, and exercising daily. While this advice may be more applicable to teenagers, adults can benefit from it as well: Electronic devices should be turned off well before bedtime. Whether from a phone screen, a tablet screen, or a TV screen, the light emitted can keep one awake, which can be harmful to one’s health.

Dr. Cano and Dr. Merino disclosed no relevant financial relationships.

A version of this article appeared on Medscape.com. This article was translated from the Medscape Spanish edition.

Teens diagnosed with attention-deficit/hyperactivity disorder in childhood reported similar overall quality of life compared with teens with ADHD behaviors but no childhood diagnosis, a new study finds.

The results align with findings from other studies suggesting lower quality of life (QOL) in teens with ADHD, but the current study is the first known to focus on the association between ADHD diagnosis itself vs. ADHD symptoms, and QOL, the researchers wrote. The findings show that at least some of the reduced QOL is associated with the diagnosis itself, they explained.

The researchers directly compared 393 teens with a childhood ADHD diagnosis to 393 matched teens with no ADHD diagnosis but who had hyperactive/inattentive behaviors.

The researchers reviewed self-reports from individuals who were enrolled in a population-based prospective study in Australia. The primary outcome was quality of life at age 14-15, which was measured with Child Health Utility 9D (CHU9D), a validated quality of life measure.
 

Study results

Overall, teens with and without an ADHD diagnosis reported similar levels of overall quality of life; the mean difference in the primary outcome CHU9D score was –0.03 (P = .10). Teens with and without an ADHD diagnosis also showed similar scores on measures of general health, happiness, and peer trust, the researchers noted.

The researchers also reviewed eight other prespecified, self-reported measures: academic self-concept, global health, negative social behaviors, overall happiness, peer trust, psychological sense of school membership, self-efficacy, and self-harm.

Teens diagnosed with ADHD in childhood were more than twice as likely to report self-harm (odds ratio 2.53, P less than .001) and displayed significantly more negative social behaviors (mean difference 1.56, P = .002), compared with teens without an ADHD diagnosis.

Teens diagnosed with ADHD in childhood also scored significantly worse on measures of sense of school membership (mean difference −2.58, P less than .001), academic self-concept (mean difference, −0.14; P = .02), and self-efficacy (mean difference −0.20; P = .007), compared to teens without an ADHD diagnosis.

The average age at ADHD diagnosis was 10 years, and 72% of the ADHD-diagnosed group were boys. No significant differences were noted for levels of hyperactive/inattentive behaviors and between girls and boys, but girls overall and children with the highest levels of hyperactive and inattentive behaviors reported generally worse outcomes, regardless of ADHD diagnosis, the researchers noted.
 

Don’t rush to diagnosis

Although rates of ADHD diagnosis in children continue to rise, the prevalence of hyperactivity and inattentive behaviors appears stable, which suggests a problem with diagnosis, senior author Alexandra Barratt, MBBS, MPH, PhD, professor of public health at the University of Sydney, Australia, said in an interview.

“Our hypothesis was that children who had been diagnosed, and we assume treated for, ADHD would have better outcomes, compared to children matched for hyperactivity/inattention behaviors who were left undiagnosed and untreated, but we were surprised to find that, at best, outcomes were unchanged, and for some outcomes, worse,” Dr. Barratt said.

“Our study provides evidence that diagnosing ADHD may lead, inadvertently, to long-term harms, particularly for children with mild or borderline hyperactivity and inattention behaviors,” she emphasized.

“We can’t say from this study what to do instead, but previously one of our team has looked at stepped diagnosis as an alternative option for children with mild or borderline hyperactivity and inattention behaviors,” she said.

The stepped diagnosis includes such actions as gathering behavior data from multiple sources, and conducting a period of watchful waiting without presumption of a diagnosis or active treatment.

Given the findings of the new study, “I would ask that health professionals considering a child who may have ADHD be aware that there is an evidence gap around the long-term impact of an ADHD diagnosis on children, and to proceed cautiously,” Dr. Barratt said. As for additional research, independent, high-quality, randomized controlled trials of ADHD diagnosis in children with mild or borderline hyperactivity/inattention behaviors are urgently needed, with long-term, patient-centered outcomes including quality of life she noted.

ADHD screening needs improvement

The incidence and prevalence of ADHD is on the rise, but much of the perceived increase in ADHD may be due to overdiagnosis, “and a lack of robust thorough psychological testing as standard of care for diagnosis,” Peter Loper, MD, a pediatrician and psychiatrist at the University of South Carolina, Columbia, said in an interview.

The current study “reinforces the necessity of consistent screening for comorbid mental health problems, and specifically for thoughts of self-harm, in those children who are diagnosed with ADHD,” he said.

Expressing his lack of astonishment about the study findings, Dr. Loper said: “Previous data indicates that while following initial diagnosis of a medical or mental health problem, patients may experience a sense of relief; however, this is followed shortly thereafter by feelings of insufficiency or anxiety related to their specific diagnosis.”

“As it stands now, ADHD is often diagnosed in children and adolescents using basic screening questionnaires,” said Dr. Loper. “The findings of this study may bolster calls for more robust and thorough psychological testing for supporting the diagnosis of ADHD,” he said.

Individuals diagnosed with ADHD can sometimes have difficulty with social skills and relating to others, said Dr. Loper. “They may be more prone to internalize their poor school performance as due to being ‘stupid’ or ‘dumb,’ ” he said. Children and teens with ADHD should, whenever possible, be involved in extracurricular activities that support the development of social skills, he said. Parents’ praise of the process/effort, rather than focusing only on outcomes such as grades, is very important for the esteem of children and teens with ADHD, he added.

The study limitations included the use of observational data vs. data from randomized trials, and the potential for confounding factors in propensity scoring, the researchers wrote. Additional limitations include the size of the sample, which may have been too small to detect additional differences between diagnosed teens and matched controls, they noted.

“As the study authors appropriately cite, a large, randomized trial would be very helpful in supporting additional understanding of this issue,” Dr. Loper added.

The study was supported by the National Health and Medical Research Council The researchers and Dr. Loper had no financial conflicts to disclose.

Teens diagnosed with attention-deficit/hyperactivity disorder in childhood reported similar overall quality of life compared with teens with ADHD behaviors but no childhood diagnosis, a new study finds.

The results align with findings from other studies suggesting lower quality of life (QOL) in teens with ADHD, but the current study is the first known to focus on the association between ADHD diagnosis itself vs. ADHD symptoms, and QOL, the researchers wrote. The findings show that at least some of the reduced QOL is associated with the diagnosis itself, they explained.

The researchers directly compared 393 teens with a childhood ADHD diagnosis to 393 matched teens with no ADHD diagnosis but who had hyperactive/inattentive behaviors.

The researchers reviewed self-reports from individuals who were enrolled in a population-based prospective study in Australia. The primary outcome was quality of life at age 14-15, which was measured with Child Health Utility 9D (CHU9D), a validated quality of life measure.
 

Study results

Overall, teens with and without an ADHD diagnosis reported similar levels of overall quality of life; the mean difference in the primary outcome CHU9D score was –0.03 (P = .10). Teens with and without an ADHD diagnosis also showed similar scores on measures of general health, happiness, and peer trust, the researchers noted.

The researchers also reviewed eight other prespecified, self-reported measures: academic self-concept, global health, negative social behaviors, overall happiness, peer trust, psychological sense of school membership, self-efficacy, and self-harm.

Teens diagnosed with ADHD in childhood were more than twice as likely to report self-harm (odds ratio 2.53, P less than .001) and displayed significantly more negative social behaviors (mean difference 1.56, P = .002), compared with teens without an ADHD diagnosis.

Teens diagnosed with ADHD in childhood also scored significantly worse on measures of sense of school membership (mean difference −2.58, P less than .001), academic self-concept (mean difference, −0.14; P = .02), and self-efficacy (mean difference −0.20; P = .007), compared to teens without an ADHD diagnosis.

The average age at ADHD diagnosis was 10 years, and 72% of the ADHD-diagnosed group were boys. No significant differences were noted for levels of hyperactive/inattentive behaviors and between girls and boys, but girls overall and children with the highest levels of hyperactive and inattentive behaviors reported generally worse outcomes, regardless of ADHD diagnosis, the researchers noted.
 

Don’t rush to diagnosis

Although rates of ADHD diagnosis in children continue to rise, the prevalence of hyperactivity and inattentive behaviors appears stable, which suggests a problem with diagnosis, senior author Alexandra Barratt, MBBS, MPH, PhD, professor of public health at the University of Sydney, Australia, said in an interview.

“Our hypothesis was that children who had been diagnosed, and we assume treated for, ADHD would have better outcomes, compared to children matched for hyperactivity/inattention behaviors who were left undiagnosed and untreated, but we were surprised to find that, at best, outcomes were unchanged, and for some outcomes, worse,” Dr. Barratt said.

“Our study provides evidence that diagnosing ADHD may lead, inadvertently, to long-term harms, particularly for children with mild or borderline hyperactivity and inattention behaviors,” she emphasized.

“We can’t say from this study what to do instead, but previously one of our team has looked at stepped diagnosis as an alternative option for children with mild or borderline hyperactivity and inattention behaviors,” she said.

The stepped diagnosis includes such actions as gathering behavior data from multiple sources, and conducting a period of watchful waiting without presumption of a diagnosis or active treatment.

Given the findings of the new study, “I would ask that health professionals considering a child who may have ADHD be aware that there is an evidence gap around the long-term impact of an ADHD diagnosis on children, and to proceed cautiously,” Dr. Barratt said. As for additional research, independent, high-quality, randomized controlled trials of ADHD diagnosis in children with mild or borderline hyperactivity/inattention behaviors are urgently needed, with long-term, patient-centered outcomes including quality of life she noted.

ADHD screening needs improvement

The incidence and prevalence of ADHD is on the rise, but much of the perceived increase in ADHD may be due to overdiagnosis, “and a lack of robust thorough psychological testing as standard of care for diagnosis,” Peter Loper, MD, a pediatrician and psychiatrist at the University of South Carolina, Columbia, said in an interview.

The current study “reinforces the necessity of consistent screening for comorbid mental health problems, and specifically for thoughts of self-harm, in those children who are diagnosed with ADHD,” he said.

Expressing his lack of astonishment about the study findings, Dr. Loper said: “Previous data indicates that while following initial diagnosis of a medical or mental health problem, patients may experience a sense of relief; however, this is followed shortly thereafter by feelings of insufficiency or anxiety related to their specific diagnosis.”

“As it stands now, ADHD is often diagnosed in children and adolescents using basic screening questionnaires,” said Dr. Loper. “The findings of this study may bolster calls for more robust and thorough psychological testing for supporting the diagnosis of ADHD,” he said.

Individuals diagnosed with ADHD can sometimes have difficulty with social skills and relating to others, said Dr. Loper. “They may be more prone to internalize their poor school performance as due to being ‘stupid’ or ‘dumb,’ ” he said. Children and teens with ADHD should, whenever possible, be involved in extracurricular activities that support the development of social skills, he said. Parents’ praise of the process/effort, rather than focusing only on outcomes such as grades, is very important for the esteem of children and teens with ADHD, he added.

The study limitations included the use of observational data vs. data from randomized trials, and the potential for confounding factors in propensity scoring, the researchers wrote. Additional limitations include the size of the sample, which may have been too small to detect additional differences between diagnosed teens and matched controls, they noted.

“As the study authors appropriately cite, a large, randomized trial would be very helpful in supporting additional understanding of this issue,” Dr. Loper added.

The study was supported by the National Health and Medical Research Council The researchers and Dr. Loper had no financial conflicts to disclose.

Teens diagnosed with attention-deficit/hyperactivity disorder in childhood reported similar overall quality of life compared with teens with ADHD behaviors but no childhood diagnosis, a new study finds.

The results align with findings from other studies suggesting lower quality of life (QOL) in teens with ADHD, but the current study is the first known to focus on the association between ADHD diagnosis itself vs. ADHD symptoms, and QOL, the researchers wrote. The findings show that at least some of the reduced QOL is associated with the diagnosis itself, they explained.

The researchers directly compared 393 teens with a childhood ADHD diagnosis to 393 matched teens with no ADHD diagnosis but who had hyperactive/inattentive behaviors.

The researchers reviewed self-reports from individuals who were enrolled in a population-based prospective study in Australia. The primary outcome was quality of life at age 14-15, which was measured with Child Health Utility 9D (CHU9D), a validated quality of life measure.
 

Study results

Overall, teens with and without an ADHD diagnosis reported similar levels of overall quality of life; the mean difference in the primary outcome CHU9D score was –0.03 (P = .10). Teens with and without an ADHD diagnosis also showed similar scores on measures of general health, happiness, and peer trust, the researchers noted.

The researchers also reviewed eight other prespecified, self-reported measures: academic self-concept, global health, negative social behaviors, overall happiness, peer trust, psychological sense of school membership, self-efficacy, and self-harm.

Teens diagnosed with ADHD in childhood were more than twice as likely to report self-harm (odds ratio 2.53, P less than .001) and displayed significantly more negative social behaviors (mean difference 1.56, P = .002), compared with teens without an ADHD diagnosis.

Teens diagnosed with ADHD in childhood also scored significantly worse on measures of sense of school membership (mean difference −2.58, P less than .001), academic self-concept (mean difference, −0.14; P = .02), and self-efficacy (mean difference −0.20; P = .007), compared to teens without an ADHD diagnosis.

The average age at ADHD diagnosis was 10 years, and 72% of the ADHD-diagnosed group were boys. No significant differences were noted for levels of hyperactive/inattentive behaviors and between girls and boys, but girls overall and children with the highest levels of hyperactive and inattentive behaviors reported generally worse outcomes, regardless of ADHD diagnosis, the researchers noted.
 

Don’t rush to diagnosis

Although rates of ADHD diagnosis in children continue to rise, the prevalence of hyperactivity and inattentive behaviors appears stable, which suggests a problem with diagnosis, senior author Alexandra Barratt, MBBS, MPH, PhD, professor of public health at the University of Sydney, Australia, said in an interview.

“Our hypothesis was that children who had been diagnosed, and we assume treated for, ADHD would have better outcomes, compared to children matched for hyperactivity/inattention behaviors who were left undiagnosed and untreated, but we were surprised to find that, at best, outcomes were unchanged, and for some outcomes, worse,” Dr. Barratt said.

“Our study provides evidence that diagnosing ADHD may lead, inadvertently, to long-term harms, particularly for children with mild or borderline hyperactivity and inattention behaviors,” she emphasized.

“We can’t say from this study what to do instead, but previously one of our team has looked at stepped diagnosis as an alternative option for children with mild or borderline hyperactivity and inattention behaviors,” she said.

The stepped diagnosis includes such actions as gathering behavior data from multiple sources, and conducting a period of watchful waiting without presumption of a diagnosis or active treatment.

Given the findings of the new study, “I would ask that health professionals considering a child who may have ADHD be aware that there is an evidence gap around the long-term impact of an ADHD diagnosis on children, and to proceed cautiously,” Dr. Barratt said. As for additional research, independent, high-quality, randomized controlled trials of ADHD diagnosis in children with mild or borderline hyperactivity/inattention behaviors are urgently needed, with long-term, patient-centered outcomes including quality of life she noted.

ADHD screening needs improvement

The incidence and prevalence of ADHD is on the rise, but much of the perceived increase in ADHD may be due to overdiagnosis, “and a lack of robust thorough psychological testing as standard of care for diagnosis,” Peter Loper, MD, a pediatrician and psychiatrist at the University of South Carolina, Columbia, said in an interview.

The current study “reinforces the necessity of consistent screening for comorbid mental health problems, and specifically for thoughts of self-harm, in those children who are diagnosed with ADHD,” he said.

Expressing his lack of astonishment about the study findings, Dr. Loper said: “Previous data indicates that while following initial diagnosis of a medical or mental health problem, patients may experience a sense of relief; however, this is followed shortly thereafter by feelings of insufficiency or anxiety related to their specific diagnosis.”

“As it stands now, ADHD is often diagnosed in children and adolescents using basic screening questionnaires,” said Dr. Loper. “The findings of this study may bolster calls for more robust and thorough psychological testing for supporting the diagnosis of ADHD,” he said.

Individuals diagnosed with ADHD can sometimes have difficulty with social skills and relating to others, said Dr. Loper. “They may be more prone to internalize their poor school performance as due to being ‘stupid’ or ‘dumb,’ ” he said. Children and teens with ADHD should, whenever possible, be involved in extracurricular activities that support the development of social skills, he said. Parents’ praise of the process/effort, rather than focusing only on outcomes such as grades, is very important for the esteem of children and teens with ADHD, he added.

The study limitations included the use of observational data vs. data from randomized trials, and the potential for confounding factors in propensity scoring, the researchers wrote. Additional limitations include the size of the sample, which may have been too small to detect additional differences between diagnosed teens and matched controls, they noted.

“As the study authors appropriately cite, a large, randomized trial would be very helpful in supporting additional understanding of this issue,” Dr. Loper added.

The study was supported by the National Health and Medical Research Council The researchers and Dr. Loper had no financial conflicts to disclose.

ANAHEIM – A wide range of factors can cause myocarditis; most often viral infections cause myocarditis in children and teens, according to Ryan Butts, MD, medical director of the pediatric advanced cardiac care program at the University of Texas Southwestern Medical Center and Children’s Health of Texas.

Dr. Butts provided an overview of what pediatricians and other clinicians caring for children and teens should know about myocarditis at the annual meeting of the American Academy of Pediatrics.

The important new things that attendees may want to take away from this for their practice are improved recognition and diagnostic workup for acute viral myocarditis, making sure cardiology follow-up occurs after an admission for the condition, enhanced evaluation of the child before they return to competitive sports, and the availability of written or verbal education for patients relating to COVID vaccine–associated myocarditis, Dr. Butts said.

He also provided a set of key takeaways:

• Myocarditis is rare.
• The most common viruses causing myocarditis are always changing.
• Myocarditis is most common in infants and teenagers but it has different clinical patterns in each population.
• MRI is becoming the diagnostic tool of choice.
• IVIG frequently is used but good evidence for the therapy is lacking.
• Patients may go home on cardiac medications but have good long-term outcomes.
• Patients must have a 6-month restriction on competitive sports after diagnosis.

Frank Han, MD, a pediatric cardiologist at OSF Medical Center and Children’s Hospital of Illinois in Peoria, said he found the most helpful parts of Dr. Butts’ presentation to be the diagnosis and triage of myocarditis in the major age groups.

“Myocarditis can have variable presentations, and its cause may influence how the myocarditis behaves,” Dr. Han said. Pediatric cardiologists, he said, are uniquely positioned to triage and diagnose myocarditis.
 

Epidemiology and presentation

Just 0.05% of admissions from 28.6 million U.S. pediatric ED visits every year are for myocarditis, Dr. Butts said. While viruses are the most common cause of myocarditis, bacterial infections and noninfectious causes, including hypersensitivity reactions, systemic disorders, and toxic substances, can also cause the condition. The dominant viruses causing myocarditis have shifted over the years as well. Coxsackie B was the most common cause in the 1980s, but adenovirus became more common in the 1990s and parvovirus B19 in the 2000s. Why some kids develop myocarditis while others don’t is unclear, but the host-immune response to the virus likely plays an important role.

Research has shown two substantial spikes in the incidence of myocarditis children: infants under 2 years old and teens aged 14-19. Although myocarditis refers to any inflammation of myocardium not caused by ischemia, the signs, symptoms, and lab results vary according to patient’s age group. The only constant is that diaphoresis is rare across all ages.

Infants are more likely to show respiratory distress (68%) and an enlarged liver (40%) but can also present with gastrointestinal symptoms (24%). Vomiting without fever or diarrhea should arouse clinical suspicion of myocarditis in infants, although fever and diarrhea can occur.

In young children, who have the lowest incidence, fatigue presents in about one-third, with 20% presenting with chest pain and 20% with hepatomegaly. The most common symptom in teens by far (80%) is chest pain. About one-third also have respiratory distress but gastrointestinal symptoms are less common (20%).

When should a clinician suspect myocarditis in a teen presenting with chest pain? “If the chest pain is reproducible and if you can localize it, they don’t need further evaluation,” Dr. Butts said. “After that, it’s a lot about the history.”

In terms of lab results, ventricular function measured by brain natriuretic peptide is significantly depressed in infants and young children but often near normal in teens. Inflammatory markers (C-reactive protein) tend to be low in infants but elevated in young children and teens. And troponin levels, denoting myocardial injury, are minimal in infants and young children but elevated in teens. Median ejection fraction on echocardiograms, about 55% in normal hearts, will often be low in infants and young children, around 30%-33%, but is near normal (54%) in teens.
 

Diagnosis and management

Cardiac MRI increasingly has been replacing endomyocardial biopsy for diagnosis, with MRI exceeding biopsy use between 2009 and 2010, Dr. Butts said. The advantage of endomyocardial biopsy is that it’s specific, if not very sensitive. The test is invasive, however, requiring sedation and carrying the risk of tricuspid injury. The most common finding on cardiac MRI is late gadolinium enhancement (80%) while early gadolinium enhancement is less common (55%).

Although Dr. Butts mentioned the Dallas diagnostic criteria from 1987, he advocated for the more recent Lake Louise Criteria, which require clinical suspicion of myocarditis and at least two of three findings on MRI: T2-weighted myocardial abnormalities, T1 early or late gadolinium enhancement, or regional wall motion abnormalities or evidence of pericarditis

Point-of-care ultrasound can be useful for detecting myocarditis, but its success depends on whether the user can pick up on the subtle changes in ventricular function. “Just because someone has a point-of-care ultrasound that’s normal or thought to be normal, it shouldn’t rule out the diagnosis,” he said.

Learning the etiology of viral myocarditis often is difficult, and etiology doesn’t affect management of the condition, Dr. Butts said. Even in cases of myocarditis confirmed by biopsy, the virus may be identified in only about 60%-70% of cases with myocardial polymerase chain reaction. In clinical cases, the virus can be determined only about 25%-30% of the time with serum PCR.

Prognosis is usually good, with 80%-90% of children and teens going home transplant free despite most arriving critically ill and 50%-80% initially being admitted to ICU. Two-thirds of those discharged go home with heart failure medications, but only one in six are readmitted within a year.

The strongest risk factors for poor prognosis are younger age and being critically ill at presentation but other risk factors include female sex, poor ventricular function, poor perfusion on exam, increased dilation on echocardiogram, and a need for ECMO or inotropes or mechanical ventilation.

That said, Dr. Butts cautioned attendees not to ignore normal function. In one study of 171 patients, among 75 who presented with normal function, 15% went home with inotropes, 12% required mechanical ventilation, 9% had arrhythmia, and 5% needed extracorporeal membrane oxygenation.

A big question in treatment is whether to give IVIG or not and the evidence is murky, Dr. Butts said. He reviewed a couple studies on IVIG, including one that suggested better ventricular functional recovery with the treatment but those who received IVIG were also more likely to be on an ACE inhibitor.

“Was it the ACE inhibitor or was it IVIG? We don’t know,” he said. Different cardiologists may give different opinions on IVIG. “It has nothing to do with the actual evidence behind it.”

IVIG has drawbacks: It’s very expensive and it involves risks that include serum sickness and interstitial nephritis.

“Pediatricians typically aren’t going to directly decide on giving or not giving IVIG,” Dr. Han said. “Typically, the ultimate choice comes from a group discussion between the hospital cardiologist – perhaps the hospitalist pediatrician if they are involved – and the family. We acknowledge the ambiguity of the evidence and decide based upon the severity of the initial disease process.”
 

Return to competitive sports; Follow-up critical

Experts are much more confident, however, about when teens admitted with viral myocarditis can return to competitive sports. But Dr. Butts said he suspects the guidelines for these children aren’t followed as closely as they should be. The American Heart Association recommends waiting 6 months after discharge and ensuring the athlete has a normal echocardiogram, Holter monitoring, and stress test.

“It’s incredibly important to have them come back and see the cardiologist 6 months after admission,” Dr. Butts said. “The only patient I’ve ever had who died 6-7 months post myocarditis is somebody who, during their stress test, had increasing ventricular ectopy. I told him not to do sports. He didn’t listen to me and unfortunately passed away – I’m assuming from arrhythmia.”
 

COVID and vaccine-associated myocarditis

Vaccine-associated myocarditis is substantially milder than viral myocarditis, Dr. Butts said. A small study from a single center in Atlanta found that ejection fraction at admission was normal, around 56%, in those with vaccine-associated myocarditis, compared with 45% with non-COVID viral myocarditis and 50% with multisystem inflammatory syndrome in children or myocarditis from COVID-19. All patients with vaccine-associated myocarditis had normal function at discharge, compared with 73% of those with viral myocarditis and 93% with COVID-associated myocarditis.

While 22% of those with vaccine-associated myocarditis were admitted to the ICU, twice as many (40%) with viral myocarditis were, and three times as many (68%) with COVID-associated myocarditis ended up in intensive care.

Dr. Butts also noted a Morbidity and Mortality Weekly Report from the Centers of Disease Control and Prevention that found teen boys had two to six times greater risk of heart complications after COVID-19 infection than after COVID vaccination.

In terms of direct comparisons, vaccine-related myocarditis occurred about 12-18 times per 100,000 doses for boys ages 5-11 years, compared with cardiac involvement in 93-133 cases out of 100,000 COVID-19 infections. Boys aged 12-17 years experienced 12-21 cases of myocarditis per 100,000 doses of the vaccine, compared with cardiac involvement in 50-64 out of 100,000 infections.

The bottom line, Dr. Butts said, is that cardiac involvement in MIS-C is common, but typically improves by discharge. “Vaccine-associated myocarditis is a mild clinical syndrome that has a very short duration, and, in my opinion, should never lead us to ever advise anybody not to get the vaccine. I’ve had many patients, even patients in their first year post transplant, who have gotten the COVID-19 vaccine and were just fine.”

Dr. Butts acknowledged that talking with families about the risk of myocarditis with the vaccine is challenging. He often starts these conversations by sharing the statistics, but he said relatable stories are the key. He will also relate the statistics to something the parents and teen will understand, whether it’s sports or another comparison. He does recommend that teens who develop vaccine-associated myocarditis complete the series and get the booster. Their chances of developing myocarditis again are extremely low, whereas “the likelihood of them being really ill from COVID-19 is much, much higher.”

Dr. Butts and Dr. Han had no disclosures. The presentation involved no external funding.

ANAHEIM – A wide range of factors can cause myocarditis; most often viral infections cause myocarditis in children and teens, according to Ryan Butts, MD, medical director of the pediatric advanced cardiac care program at the University of Texas Southwestern Medical Center and Children’s Health of Texas.

Dr. Butts provided an overview of what pediatricians and other clinicians caring for children and teens should know about myocarditis at the annual meeting of the American Academy of Pediatrics.

The important new things that attendees may want to take away from this for their practice are improved recognition and diagnostic workup for acute viral myocarditis, making sure cardiology follow-up occurs after an admission for the condition, enhanced evaluation of the child before they return to competitive sports, and the availability of written or verbal education for patients relating to COVID vaccine–associated myocarditis, Dr. Butts said.

He also provided a set of key takeaways:

• Myocarditis is rare.
• The most common viruses causing myocarditis are always changing.
• Myocarditis is most common in infants and teenagers but it has different clinical patterns in each population.
• MRI is becoming the diagnostic tool of choice.
• IVIG frequently is used but good evidence for the therapy is lacking.
• Patients may go home on cardiac medications but have good long-term outcomes.
• Patients must have a 6-month restriction on competitive sports after diagnosis.

Frank Han, MD, a pediatric cardiologist at OSF Medical Center and Children’s Hospital of Illinois in Peoria, said he found the most helpful parts of Dr. Butts’ presentation to be the diagnosis and triage of myocarditis in the major age groups.

“Myocarditis can have variable presentations, and its cause may influence how the myocarditis behaves,” Dr. Han said. Pediatric cardiologists, he said, are uniquely positioned to triage and diagnose myocarditis.
 

Epidemiology and presentation

Just 0.05% of admissions from 28.6 million U.S. pediatric ED visits every year are for myocarditis, Dr. Butts said. While viruses are the most common cause of myocarditis, bacterial infections and noninfectious causes, including hypersensitivity reactions, systemic disorders, and toxic substances, can also cause the condition. The dominant viruses causing myocarditis have shifted over the years as well. Coxsackie B was the most common cause in the 1980s, but adenovirus became more common in the 1990s and parvovirus B19 in the 2000s. Why some kids develop myocarditis while others don’t is unclear, but the host-immune response to the virus likely plays an important role.

Research has shown two substantial spikes in the incidence of myocarditis children: infants under 2 years old and teens aged 14-19. Although myocarditis refers to any inflammation of myocardium not caused by ischemia, the signs, symptoms, and lab results vary according to patient’s age group. The only constant is that diaphoresis is rare across all ages.

Infants are more likely to show respiratory distress (68%) and an enlarged liver (40%) but can also present with gastrointestinal symptoms (24%). Vomiting without fever or diarrhea should arouse clinical suspicion of myocarditis in infants, although fever and diarrhea can occur.

In young children, who have the lowest incidence, fatigue presents in about one-third, with 20% presenting with chest pain and 20% with hepatomegaly. The most common symptom in teens by far (80%) is chest pain. About one-third also have respiratory distress but gastrointestinal symptoms are less common (20%).

When should a clinician suspect myocarditis in a teen presenting with chest pain? “If the chest pain is reproducible and if you can localize it, they don’t need further evaluation,” Dr. Butts said. “After that, it’s a lot about the history.”

In terms of lab results, ventricular function measured by brain natriuretic peptide is significantly depressed in infants and young children but often near normal in teens. Inflammatory markers (C-reactive protein) tend to be low in infants but elevated in young children and teens. And troponin levels, denoting myocardial injury, are minimal in infants and young children but elevated in teens. Median ejection fraction on echocardiograms, about 55% in normal hearts, will often be low in infants and young children, around 30%-33%, but is near normal (54%) in teens.
 

Diagnosis and management

Cardiac MRI increasingly has been replacing endomyocardial biopsy for diagnosis, with MRI exceeding biopsy use between 2009 and 2010, Dr. Butts said. The advantage of endomyocardial biopsy is that it’s specific, if not very sensitive. The test is invasive, however, requiring sedation and carrying the risk of tricuspid injury. The most common finding on cardiac MRI is late gadolinium enhancement (80%) while early gadolinium enhancement is less common (55%).

Although Dr. Butts mentioned the Dallas diagnostic criteria from 1987, he advocated for the more recent Lake Louise Criteria, which require clinical suspicion of myocarditis and at least two of three findings on MRI: T2-weighted myocardial abnormalities, T1 early or late gadolinium enhancement, or regional wall motion abnormalities or evidence of pericarditis

Point-of-care ultrasound can be useful for detecting myocarditis, but its success depends on whether the user can pick up on the subtle changes in ventricular function. “Just because someone has a point-of-care ultrasound that’s normal or thought to be normal, it shouldn’t rule out the diagnosis,” he said.

Learning the etiology of viral myocarditis often is difficult, and etiology doesn’t affect management of the condition, Dr. Butts said. Even in cases of myocarditis confirmed by biopsy, the virus may be identified in only about 60%-70% of cases with myocardial polymerase chain reaction. In clinical cases, the virus can be determined only about 25%-30% of the time with serum PCR.

Prognosis is usually good, with 80%-90% of children and teens going home transplant free despite most arriving critically ill and 50%-80% initially being admitted to ICU. Two-thirds of those discharged go home with heart failure medications, but only one in six are readmitted within a year.

The strongest risk factors for poor prognosis are younger age and being critically ill at presentation but other risk factors include female sex, poor ventricular function, poor perfusion on exam, increased dilation on echocardiogram, and a need for ECMO or inotropes or mechanical ventilation.

That said, Dr. Butts cautioned attendees not to ignore normal function. In one study of 171 patients, among 75 who presented with normal function, 15% went home with inotropes, 12% required mechanical ventilation, 9% had arrhythmia, and 5% needed extracorporeal membrane oxygenation.

A big question in treatment is whether to give IVIG or not and the evidence is murky, Dr. Butts said. He reviewed a couple studies on IVIG, including one that suggested better ventricular functional recovery with the treatment but those who received IVIG were also more likely to be on an ACE inhibitor.

“Was it the ACE inhibitor or was it IVIG? We don’t know,” he said. Different cardiologists may give different opinions on IVIG. “It has nothing to do with the actual evidence behind it.”

IVIG has drawbacks: It’s very expensive and it involves risks that include serum sickness and interstitial nephritis.

“Pediatricians typically aren’t going to directly decide on giving or not giving IVIG,” Dr. Han said. “Typically, the ultimate choice comes from a group discussion between the hospital cardiologist – perhaps the hospitalist pediatrician if they are involved – and the family. We acknowledge the ambiguity of the evidence and decide based upon the severity of the initial disease process.”
 

Return to competitive sports; Follow-up critical

Experts are much more confident, however, about when teens admitted with viral myocarditis can return to competitive sports. But Dr. Butts said he suspects the guidelines for these children aren’t followed as closely as they should be. The American Heart Association recommends waiting 6 months after discharge and ensuring the athlete has a normal echocardiogram, Holter monitoring, and stress test.

“It’s incredibly important to have them come back and see the cardiologist 6 months after admission,” Dr. Butts said. “The only patient I’ve ever had who died 6-7 months post myocarditis is somebody who, during their stress test, had increasing ventricular ectopy. I told him not to do sports. He didn’t listen to me and unfortunately passed away – I’m assuming from arrhythmia.”
 

COVID and vaccine-associated myocarditis

Vaccine-associated myocarditis is substantially milder than viral myocarditis, Dr. Butts said. A small study from a single center in Atlanta found that ejection fraction at admission was normal, around 56%, in those with vaccine-associated myocarditis, compared with 45% with non-COVID viral myocarditis and 50% with multisystem inflammatory syndrome in children or myocarditis from COVID-19. All patients with vaccine-associated myocarditis had normal function at discharge, compared with 73% of those with viral myocarditis and 93% with COVID-associated myocarditis.

While 22% of those with vaccine-associated myocarditis were admitted to the ICU, twice as many (40%) with viral myocarditis were, and three times as many (68%) with COVID-associated myocarditis ended up in intensive care.

Dr. Butts also noted a Morbidity and Mortality Weekly Report from the Centers of Disease Control and Prevention that found teen boys had two to six times greater risk of heart complications after COVID-19 infection than after COVID vaccination.

In terms of direct comparisons, vaccine-related myocarditis occurred about 12-18 times per 100,000 doses for boys ages 5-11 years, compared with cardiac involvement in 93-133 cases out of 100,000 COVID-19 infections. Boys aged 12-17 years experienced 12-21 cases of myocarditis per 100,000 doses of the vaccine, compared with cardiac involvement in 50-64 out of 100,000 infections.

The bottom line, Dr. Butts said, is that cardiac involvement in MIS-C is common, but typically improves by discharge. “Vaccine-associated myocarditis is a mild clinical syndrome that has a very short duration, and, in my opinion, should never lead us to ever advise anybody not to get the vaccine. I’ve had many patients, even patients in their first year post transplant, who have gotten the COVID-19 vaccine and were just fine.”

Dr. Butts acknowledged that talking with families about the risk of myocarditis with the vaccine is challenging. He often starts these conversations by sharing the statistics, but he said relatable stories are the key. He will also relate the statistics to something the parents and teen will understand, whether it’s sports or another comparison. He does recommend that teens who develop vaccine-associated myocarditis complete the series and get the booster. Their chances of developing myocarditis again are extremely low, whereas “the likelihood of them being really ill from COVID-19 is much, much higher.”

Dr. Butts and Dr. Han had no disclosures. The presentation involved no external funding.

ANAHEIM – A wide range of factors can cause myocarditis; most often viral infections cause myocarditis in children and teens, according to Ryan Butts, MD, medical director of the pediatric advanced cardiac care program at the University of Texas Southwestern Medical Center and Children’s Health of Texas.

Dr. Butts provided an overview of what pediatricians and other clinicians caring for children and teens should know about myocarditis at the annual meeting of the American Academy of Pediatrics.

The important new things that attendees may want to take away from this for their practice are improved recognition and diagnostic workup for acute viral myocarditis, making sure cardiology follow-up occurs after an admission for the condition, enhanced evaluation of the child before they return to competitive sports, and the availability of written or verbal education for patients relating to COVID vaccine–associated myocarditis, Dr. Butts said.

He also provided a set of key takeaways:

• Myocarditis is rare.
• The most common viruses causing myocarditis are always changing.
• Myocarditis is most common in infants and teenagers but it has different clinical patterns in each population.
• MRI is becoming the diagnostic tool of choice.
• IVIG frequently is used but good evidence for the therapy is lacking.
• Patients may go home on cardiac medications but have good long-term outcomes.
• Patients must have a 6-month restriction on competitive sports after diagnosis.

Frank Han, MD, a pediatric cardiologist at OSF Medical Center and Children’s Hospital of Illinois in Peoria, said he found the most helpful parts of Dr. Butts’ presentation to be the diagnosis and triage of myocarditis in the major age groups.

“Myocarditis can have variable presentations, and its cause may influence how the myocarditis behaves,” Dr. Han said. Pediatric cardiologists, he said, are uniquely positioned to triage and diagnose myocarditis.
 

Epidemiology and presentation

Just 0.05% of admissions from 28.6 million U.S. pediatric ED visits every year are for myocarditis, Dr. Butts said. While viruses are the most common cause of myocarditis, bacterial infections and noninfectious causes, including hypersensitivity reactions, systemic disorders, and toxic substances, can also cause the condition. The dominant viruses causing myocarditis have shifted over the years as well. Coxsackie B was the most common cause in the 1980s, but adenovirus became more common in the 1990s and parvovirus B19 in the 2000s. Why some kids develop myocarditis while others don’t is unclear, but the host-immune response to the virus likely plays an important role.

Research has shown two substantial spikes in the incidence of myocarditis children: infants under 2 years old and teens aged 14-19. Although myocarditis refers to any inflammation of myocardium not caused by ischemia, the signs, symptoms, and lab results vary according to patient’s age group. The only constant is that diaphoresis is rare across all ages.

Infants are more likely to show respiratory distress (68%) and an enlarged liver (40%) but can also present with gastrointestinal symptoms (24%). Vomiting without fever or diarrhea should arouse clinical suspicion of myocarditis in infants, although fever and diarrhea can occur.

In young children, who have the lowest incidence, fatigue presents in about one-third, with 20% presenting with chest pain and 20% with hepatomegaly. The most common symptom in teens by far (80%) is chest pain. About one-third also have respiratory distress but gastrointestinal symptoms are less common (20%).

When should a clinician suspect myocarditis in a teen presenting with chest pain? “If the chest pain is reproducible and if you can localize it, they don’t need further evaluation,” Dr. Butts said. “After that, it’s a lot about the history.”

In terms of lab results, ventricular function measured by brain natriuretic peptide is significantly depressed in infants and young children but often near normal in teens. Inflammatory markers (C-reactive protein) tend to be low in infants but elevated in young children and teens. And troponin levels, denoting myocardial injury, are minimal in infants and young children but elevated in teens. Median ejection fraction on echocardiograms, about 55% in normal hearts, will often be low in infants and young children, around 30%-33%, but is near normal (54%) in teens.
 

Diagnosis and management

Cardiac MRI increasingly has been replacing endomyocardial biopsy for diagnosis, with MRI exceeding biopsy use between 2009 and 2010, Dr. Butts said. The advantage of endomyocardial biopsy is that it’s specific, if not very sensitive. The test is invasive, however, requiring sedation and carrying the risk of tricuspid injury. The most common finding on cardiac MRI is late gadolinium enhancement (80%) while early gadolinium enhancement is less common (55%).

Although Dr. Butts mentioned the Dallas diagnostic criteria from 1987, he advocated for the more recent Lake Louise Criteria, which require clinical suspicion of myocarditis and at least two of three findings on MRI: T2-weighted myocardial abnormalities, T1 early or late gadolinium enhancement, or regional wall motion abnormalities or evidence of pericarditis

Point-of-care ultrasound can be useful for detecting myocarditis, but its success depends on whether the user can pick up on the subtle changes in ventricular function. “Just because someone has a point-of-care ultrasound that’s normal or thought to be normal, it shouldn’t rule out the diagnosis,” he said.

Learning the etiology of viral myocarditis often is difficult, and etiology doesn’t affect management of the condition, Dr. Butts said. Even in cases of myocarditis confirmed by biopsy, the virus may be identified in only about 60%-70% of cases with myocardial polymerase chain reaction. In clinical cases, the virus can be determined only about 25%-30% of the time with serum PCR.

Prognosis is usually good, with 80%-90% of children and teens going home transplant free despite most arriving critically ill and 50%-80% initially being admitted to ICU. Two-thirds of those discharged go home with heart failure medications, but only one in six are readmitted within a year.

The strongest risk factors for poor prognosis are younger age and being critically ill at presentation but other risk factors include female sex, poor ventricular function, poor perfusion on exam, increased dilation on echocardiogram, and a need for ECMO or inotropes or mechanical ventilation.

That said, Dr. Butts cautioned attendees not to ignore normal function. In one study of 171 patients, among 75 who presented with normal function, 15% went home with inotropes, 12% required mechanical ventilation, 9% had arrhythmia, and 5% needed extracorporeal membrane oxygenation.

A big question in treatment is whether to give IVIG or not and the evidence is murky, Dr. Butts said. He reviewed a couple studies on IVIG, including one that suggested better ventricular functional recovery with the treatment but those who received IVIG were also more likely to be on an ACE inhibitor.

“Was it the ACE inhibitor or was it IVIG? We don’t know,” he said. Different cardiologists may give different opinions on IVIG. “It has nothing to do with the actual evidence behind it.”

IVIG has drawbacks: It’s very expensive and it involves risks that include serum sickness and interstitial nephritis.

“Pediatricians typically aren’t going to directly decide on giving or not giving IVIG,” Dr. Han said. “Typically, the ultimate choice comes from a group discussion between the hospital cardiologist – perhaps the hospitalist pediatrician if they are involved – and the family. We acknowledge the ambiguity of the evidence and decide based upon the severity of the initial disease process.”
 

Return to competitive sports; Follow-up critical

Experts are much more confident, however, about when teens admitted with viral myocarditis can return to competitive sports. But Dr. Butts said he suspects the guidelines for these children aren’t followed as closely as they should be. The American Heart Association recommends waiting 6 months after discharge and ensuring the athlete has a normal echocardiogram, Holter monitoring, and stress test.

“It’s incredibly important to have them come back and see the cardiologist 6 months after admission,” Dr. Butts said. “The only patient I’ve ever had who died 6-7 months post myocarditis is somebody who, during their stress test, had increasing ventricular ectopy. I told him not to do sports. He didn’t listen to me and unfortunately passed away – I’m assuming from arrhythmia.”
 

COVID and vaccine-associated myocarditis

Vaccine-associated myocarditis is substantially milder than viral myocarditis, Dr. Butts said. A small study from a single center in Atlanta found that ejection fraction at admission was normal, around 56%, in those with vaccine-associated myocarditis, compared with 45% with non-COVID viral myocarditis and 50% with multisystem inflammatory syndrome in children or myocarditis from COVID-19. All patients with vaccine-associated myocarditis had normal function at discharge, compared with 73% of those with viral myocarditis and 93% with COVID-associated myocarditis.

While 22% of those with vaccine-associated myocarditis were admitted to the ICU, twice as many (40%) with viral myocarditis were, and three times as many (68%) with COVID-associated myocarditis ended up in intensive care.

Dr. Butts also noted a Morbidity and Mortality Weekly Report from the Centers of Disease Control and Prevention that found teen boys had two to six times greater risk of heart complications after COVID-19 infection than after COVID vaccination.

In terms of direct comparisons, vaccine-related myocarditis occurred about 12-18 times per 100,000 doses for boys ages 5-11 years, compared with cardiac involvement in 93-133 cases out of 100,000 COVID-19 infections. Boys aged 12-17 years experienced 12-21 cases of myocarditis per 100,000 doses of the vaccine, compared with cardiac involvement in 50-64 out of 100,000 infections.

The bottom line, Dr. Butts said, is that cardiac involvement in MIS-C is common, but typically improves by discharge. “Vaccine-associated myocarditis is a mild clinical syndrome that has a very short duration, and, in my opinion, should never lead us to ever advise anybody not to get the vaccine. I’ve had many patients, even patients in their first year post transplant, who have gotten the COVID-19 vaccine and were just fine.”

Dr. Butts acknowledged that talking with families about the risk of myocarditis with the vaccine is challenging. He often starts these conversations by sharing the statistics, but he said relatable stories are the key. He will also relate the statistics to something the parents and teen will understand, whether it’s sports or another comparison. He does recommend that teens who develop vaccine-associated myocarditis complete the series and get the booster. Their chances of developing myocarditis again are extremely low, whereas “the likelihood of them being really ill from COVID-19 is much, much higher.”

Dr. Butts and Dr. Han had no disclosures. The presentation involved no external funding.

U.K. scientists show it is possible to spot signs of brain impairment in patients as early as 9 years before they receive a diagnosis of dementia, offering hope for interventions to reduce the risk of the disease developing.

To date it has been unclear whether it might be possible to detect changes in brain function before the onset of symptoms, so researchers at the University of Cambridge and Cambridge University Hospitals NHS Foundation Trust set out to determine whether people who developed a range of neurodegenerative diagnoses demonstrated reduced cognitive function at their baseline assessment.

The authors explained: “The pathophysiological processes of neurodegenerative diseases begin years before diagnosis. However, prediagnostic changes in cognition and physical function are poorly understood, especially in sporadic neurodegenerative disease.”
 

Prediagnostic cognitive and functional impairment identified

The researchers analyzed data from the UK Biobank and compared cognitive and functional measures, including problem solving, memory, reaction times and grip strength, as well as data on weight loss and gain and on the number of falls, in individuals who subsequently developed a number of dementia-related diseases (Alzheimer’s disease, Parkinson’s disease, frontotemporal dementia, progressive supranuclear palsy, dementia with Lewy bodies, and multiple system atrophy), with those who did not have a neurodegenerative diagnosis. After adjustment for the effects of age, the same measures were regressed against time to diagnosis. The study was published in Alzheimer’s & Dementia: The Journal of the Alzheimer’s Association.

The researchers found evidence of prediagnostic cognitive impairment and decline with time, particularly in Alzheimer’s disease where those who went on to develop the disease scored more poorly compared with healthy individuals when it came to problem solving tasks, reaction times, remembering lists of numbers, prospective memory, and pair matching. This was also the case for people who developed frontotemporal dementia, the authors said.

Nol Swaddiwudhipong, MB, of the University of Cambridge, and first author, said: “When we looked back at patients’ histories, it became clear that they were showing some cognitive impairment several years before their symptoms became obvious enough to prompt a diagnosis. The impairments were often subtle, but across a number of aspects of cognition.”

Prediagnostic functional impairment and decline was also observed in multiple diseases, the authors said. People who went on to develop Alzheimer’s disease were more likely than were healthy adults to have had a fall in the previous 12 months, with those patients who went on to develop progressive supranuclear palsy (PSP) being more than twice as likely as healthy individuals to have had a fall.

The time between baseline assessment and diagnosis varied between 4.7 years for dementia with Lewy bodies and 8.3 years for Alzheimer’s disease.

“For every condition studied – including Parkinson’s disease and dementia with Lewy bodies – patients reported poorer overall health at baseline,” said the authors.
 

Potential for new treatments

The study findings that cognitive and functional decline occurs “years before symptoms become obvious” in multiple neurodegenerative diseases, raises the possibility that in the future at-risk patients could be screened to help select those who would benefit from interventions to reduce their risk of developing one of the conditions, or to help identify patients suitable for recruitment to clinical trials for new treatments.

Dr Swaddiwudhipong emphasized: “This is a step towards us being able to screen people who are at greatest risk – for example, people over 50 or those who have high blood pressure or do not do enough exercise – and intervene at an earlier stage to help them reduce their risk.”

There are currently very few effective treatments for dementia or other forms of neurodegeneration, the authors pointed out, in part because these conditions are often only diagnosed once symptoms appear, whereas the underlying neurodegeneration may have “begun years, even decades, earlier.” This means that by the time patients take part in clinical trials, it may already be too late in the disease process to alter its course, they explained.

Timothy Rittman, BMBS, PhD, department of clinical neurosciences, University of Cambridge, and senior author, explained that the findings could also help identify people who can participate in clinical trials for potential new treatments. “The problem with clinical trials is that by necessity they often recruit patients with a diagnosis, but we know that by this point they are already some way down the road and their condition cannot be stopped. If we can find these individuals early enough, we’ll have a better chance of seeing if the drugs are effective,” he emphasized.

Commenting on the new research, Richard Oakley, PhD, associate director of research at Alzheimer’s Society, said: “Studies like this show the importance in continued investment in dementia research to revolutionize diagnosis and drive new treatments, so one day we will beat dementia.”

The research was funded by the Medical Research Council with support from the NIHR Cambridge Biomedical Research Centre. The authors reported no conflicts of interest.

A version of this article first appeared on Medscape UK.

U.K. scientists show it is possible to spot signs of brain impairment in patients as early as 9 years before they receive a diagnosis of dementia, offering hope for interventions to reduce the risk of the disease developing.

To date it has been unclear whether it might be possible to detect changes in brain function before the onset of symptoms, so researchers at the University of Cambridge and Cambridge University Hospitals NHS Foundation Trust set out to determine whether people who developed a range of neurodegenerative diagnoses demonstrated reduced cognitive function at their baseline assessment.

The authors explained: “The pathophysiological processes of neurodegenerative diseases begin years before diagnosis. However, prediagnostic changes in cognition and physical function are poorly understood, especially in sporadic neurodegenerative disease.”
 

Prediagnostic cognitive and functional impairment identified

The researchers analyzed data from the UK Biobank and compared cognitive and functional measures, including problem solving, memory, reaction times and grip strength, as well as data on weight loss and gain and on the number of falls, in individuals who subsequently developed a number of dementia-related diseases (Alzheimer’s disease, Parkinson’s disease, frontotemporal dementia, progressive supranuclear palsy, dementia with Lewy bodies, and multiple system atrophy), with those who did not have a neurodegenerative diagnosis. After adjustment for the effects of age, the same measures were regressed against time to diagnosis. The study was published in Alzheimer’s & Dementia: The Journal of the Alzheimer’s Association.

The researchers found evidence of prediagnostic cognitive impairment and decline with time, particularly in Alzheimer’s disease where those who went on to develop the disease scored more poorly compared with healthy individuals when it came to problem solving tasks, reaction times, remembering lists of numbers, prospective memory, and pair matching. This was also the case for people who developed frontotemporal dementia, the authors said.

Nol Swaddiwudhipong, MB, of the University of Cambridge, and first author, said: “When we looked back at patients’ histories, it became clear that they were showing some cognitive impairment several years before their symptoms became obvious enough to prompt a diagnosis. The impairments were often subtle, but across a number of aspects of cognition.”

Prediagnostic functional impairment and decline was also observed in multiple diseases, the authors said. People who went on to develop Alzheimer’s disease were more likely than were healthy adults to have had a fall in the previous 12 months, with those patients who went on to develop progressive supranuclear palsy (PSP) being more than twice as likely as healthy individuals to have had a fall.

The time between baseline assessment and diagnosis varied between 4.7 years for dementia with Lewy bodies and 8.3 years for Alzheimer’s disease.

“For every condition studied – including Parkinson’s disease and dementia with Lewy bodies – patients reported poorer overall health at baseline,” said the authors.
 

Potential for new treatments

The study findings that cognitive and functional decline occurs “years before symptoms become obvious” in multiple neurodegenerative diseases, raises the possibility that in the future at-risk patients could be screened to help select those who would benefit from interventions to reduce their risk of developing one of the conditions, or to help identify patients suitable for recruitment to clinical trials for new treatments.

Dr Swaddiwudhipong emphasized: “This is a step towards us being able to screen people who are at greatest risk – for example, people over 50 or those who have high blood pressure or do not do enough exercise – and intervene at an earlier stage to help them reduce their risk.”

There are currently very few effective treatments for dementia or other forms of neurodegeneration, the authors pointed out, in part because these conditions are often only diagnosed once symptoms appear, whereas the underlying neurodegeneration may have “begun years, even decades, earlier.” This means that by the time patients take part in clinical trials, it may already be too late in the disease process to alter its course, they explained.

Timothy Rittman, BMBS, PhD, department of clinical neurosciences, University of Cambridge, and senior author, explained that the findings could also help identify people who can participate in clinical trials for potential new treatments. “The problem with clinical trials is that by necessity they often recruit patients with a diagnosis, but we know that by this point they are already some way down the road and their condition cannot be stopped. If we can find these individuals early enough, we’ll have a better chance of seeing if the drugs are effective,” he emphasized.

Commenting on the new research, Richard Oakley, PhD, associate director of research at Alzheimer’s Society, said: “Studies like this show the importance in continued investment in dementia research to revolutionize diagnosis and drive new treatments, so one day we will beat dementia.”

The research was funded by the Medical Research Council with support from the NIHR Cambridge Biomedical Research Centre. The authors reported no conflicts of interest.

A version of this article first appeared on Medscape UK.

U.K. scientists show it is possible to spot signs of brain impairment in patients as early as 9 years before they receive a diagnosis of dementia, offering hope for interventions to reduce the risk of the disease developing.

To date it has been unclear whether it might be possible to detect changes in brain function before the onset of symptoms, so researchers at the University of Cambridge and Cambridge University Hospitals NHS Foundation Trust set out to determine whether people who developed a range of neurodegenerative diagnoses demonstrated reduced cognitive function at their baseline assessment.

The authors explained: “The pathophysiological processes of neurodegenerative diseases begin years before diagnosis. However, prediagnostic changes in cognition and physical function are poorly understood, especially in sporadic neurodegenerative disease.”
 

Prediagnostic cognitive and functional impairment identified

The researchers analyzed data from the UK Biobank and compared cognitive and functional measures, including problem solving, memory, reaction times and grip strength, as well as data on weight loss and gain and on the number of falls, in individuals who subsequently developed a number of dementia-related diseases (Alzheimer’s disease, Parkinson’s disease, frontotemporal dementia, progressive supranuclear palsy, dementia with Lewy bodies, and multiple system atrophy), with those who did not have a neurodegenerative diagnosis. After adjustment for the effects of age, the same measures were regressed against time to diagnosis. The study was published in Alzheimer’s & Dementia: The Journal of the Alzheimer’s Association.

The researchers found evidence of prediagnostic cognitive impairment and decline with time, particularly in Alzheimer’s disease where those who went on to develop the disease scored more poorly compared with healthy individuals when it came to problem solving tasks, reaction times, remembering lists of numbers, prospective memory, and pair matching. This was also the case for people who developed frontotemporal dementia, the authors said.

Nol Swaddiwudhipong, MB, of the University of Cambridge, and first author, said: “When we looked back at patients’ histories, it became clear that they were showing some cognitive impairment several years before their symptoms became obvious enough to prompt a diagnosis. The impairments were often subtle, but across a number of aspects of cognition.”

Prediagnostic functional impairment and decline was also observed in multiple diseases, the authors said. People who went on to develop Alzheimer’s disease were more likely than were healthy adults to have had a fall in the previous 12 months, with those patients who went on to develop progressive supranuclear palsy (PSP) being more than twice as likely as healthy individuals to have had a fall.

The time between baseline assessment and diagnosis varied between 4.7 years for dementia with Lewy bodies and 8.3 years for Alzheimer’s disease.

“For every condition studied – including Parkinson’s disease and dementia with Lewy bodies – patients reported poorer overall health at baseline,” said the authors.
 

Potential for new treatments

The study findings that cognitive and functional decline occurs “years before symptoms become obvious” in multiple neurodegenerative diseases, raises the possibility that in the future at-risk patients could be screened to help select those who would benefit from interventions to reduce their risk of developing one of the conditions, or to help identify patients suitable for recruitment to clinical trials for new treatments.

Dr Swaddiwudhipong emphasized: “This is a step towards us being able to screen people who are at greatest risk – for example, people over 50 or those who have high blood pressure or do not do enough exercise – and intervene at an earlier stage to help them reduce their risk.”

There are currently very few effective treatments for dementia or other forms of neurodegeneration, the authors pointed out, in part because these conditions are often only diagnosed once symptoms appear, whereas the underlying neurodegeneration may have “begun years, even decades, earlier.” This means that by the time patients take part in clinical trials, it may already be too late in the disease process to alter its course, they explained.

Timothy Rittman, BMBS, PhD, department of clinical neurosciences, University of Cambridge, and senior author, explained that the findings could also help identify people who can participate in clinical trials for potential new treatments. “The problem with clinical trials is that by necessity they often recruit patients with a diagnosis, but we know that by this point they are already some way down the road and their condition cannot be stopped. If we can find these individuals early enough, we’ll have a better chance of seeing if the drugs are effective,” he emphasized.

Commenting on the new research, Richard Oakley, PhD, associate director of research at Alzheimer’s Society, said: “Studies like this show the importance in continued investment in dementia research to revolutionize diagnosis and drive new treatments, so one day we will beat dementia.”

The research was funded by the Medical Research Council with support from the NIHR Cambridge Biomedical Research Centre. The authors reported no conflicts of interest.

A version of this article first appeared on Medscape UK.

Geographic location within the United States appears to have an impact on the specific symptoms of polycystic ovary syndrome (PCOS) that any one particular woman will develop, according to a new prospective cohort study.

Women in California were more likely to exhibit high levels of testosterone (hyperandrogenism), while women in Alabama with PCOS had more metabolic dysfunction and hirsutism.

And although the women in Alabama were younger and had a higher body mass index (BMI), even after adjusting for these factors, the clinical differences were still present between the geographic locations, the authors said.

“This study suggests there are regional differences in hormonal and metabolic parameters in women with PCOS in California and Alabama, highlighting the impact of differing genetic and environmental modulators on PCOS development,” Katherine VanHise, MD, of Cedars-Sinai Medical Center, Los Angeles, and colleagues wrote in their article, published online in the Journal of Clinical Endocrinology and Metabolism.
 

Genetic and environmental factors play a role

Prior research has looked at variations in symptoms of PCOS across countries and identified differences in hirsutism and its prevalence, which is greater in Middle Eastern, Mediterranean, and Indian women, noted senior author Margareta D. Pisarska, MD.

And women of some other backgrounds “are at increased risk of developing metabolic syndrome and insulin resistance, including South Asian, African, and Hispanic women, so they are at a greater risk trajectory of developing manifestations later on in life that can ultimately lead to adverse outcomes in overall health,” Dr. Pisarska, director of the division of reproductive endocrinology and infertility in obstetrics and gynecology at Cedars-Sinai, told this news organization.

“We do see regional differences in the diagnosis of PCOS [in the United States] as well as the manifestations of PCOS including high andrenoemia, hirsutism, and metabolic parameters ... and we need to better understand it because, at least in the entire population, weight was not the entire factor contributing to these differences,” she explained.

“So there are definitely environmental factors and possibly genetic factors that we need to take into consideration as we try to study these women and try to help them decrease their risk of metabolic syndrome later in life,” she noted.
 

Differences not attributable to race either

PCOS is a common endocrine disorder affecting women and female adolescents worldwide. Diagnosis usually requires at least two of the following to be present: ovulatory dysfunction, hyperandrogenism, and/or polycystic ovarian morphology.

Because of the prior work that had identified differences in symptoms among women with PCOS in different countries, the investigators set out to determine if women of the same race would have distinct hormonal and metabolic traits of PCOS in two geographical locations in the United States, suggesting geo-epidemiologic contributors of the disease

They evaluated 889 women at the University of Alabama at Birmingham and 721 at Cedars-Sinai Medical Center. Participants in Birmingham were a mean age of 28 years, had a mean BMI of 33.1 kg/m2, a mean waist-to-hip ratio of 0.8, and a mean hirsute rate of 84.6%. Participants in California were a mean age of 29.5 years, had an average BMI of 30.1 kg/m2, a mean waist-to-hip ratio of 0.9, and a mean hirsute rate of 72.8%.

The study team gathered data on menstrual cycle history, metabolic and hormonal parameters, and demographic data for each participant. They assessed hirsutism based on modified Ferriman-Gallwey scores of four or more. Patients were classified as having hyperandrogenemia if they had elevated androgen values greater than the 95th percentile of all values or androgen values that exceeded laboratory reference ranges.

The findings showed that Alabama women with PCOS had elevated homeostatic model assessment for insulin resistance scores (adjusted beta coefficient, 3.6; P < .001) and were more likely to be hirsute (adjusted odds ratio, 1.8; P < .001) after adjustment for BMI and age than those in California.

In contrast, women with PCOS in California were more likely to have elevated free testosterone and total testosterone values than women in Alabama (both P < .001). These findings persisted after adjusting for age and BMI.

When stratified by White race, these findings were similar. Notably, BMI and waist-to-hip ratio did not vary between regions in Black women with PCOS, although variations in metabolic dysfunction and androgen profiles persisted.

“This study supports regional differences in hormonal and metabolic parameters in women with PCOS in the United States, highlighting the impact of the environment on PCOS phenotype. Individuals of the same race in different geographical locations of the United States may have differing genetic predispositions for developing diseases such as PCOS,” the researchers said.

“Ongoing research is needed to identify modifiable environmental risk factors for PCOS that may be race and ethnic specific to bring precision medicine to the management of PCOS,” they conclude.

This work was supported in part by grants from the National Institutes of Health and an endowment of the Helping Hand of Los Angeles. Dr. VanHise reported no relevant financial relationships.

A version of this article first appeared on Medscape.com.

Geographic location within the United States appears to have an impact on the specific symptoms of polycystic ovary syndrome (PCOS) that any one particular woman will develop, according to a new prospective cohort study.

Women in California were more likely to exhibit high levels of testosterone (hyperandrogenism), while women in Alabama with PCOS had more metabolic dysfunction and hirsutism.

And although the women in Alabama were younger and had a higher body mass index (BMI), even after adjusting for these factors, the clinical differences were still present between the geographic locations, the authors said.

“This study suggests there are regional differences in hormonal and metabolic parameters in women with PCOS in California and Alabama, highlighting the impact of differing genetic and environmental modulators on PCOS development,” Katherine VanHise, MD, of Cedars-Sinai Medical Center, Los Angeles, and colleagues wrote in their article, published online in the Journal of Clinical Endocrinology and Metabolism.
 

Genetic and environmental factors play a role

Prior research has looked at variations in symptoms of PCOS across countries and identified differences in hirsutism and its prevalence, which is greater in Middle Eastern, Mediterranean, and Indian women, noted senior author Margareta D. Pisarska, MD.

And women of some other backgrounds “are at increased risk of developing metabolic syndrome and insulin resistance, including South Asian, African, and Hispanic women, so they are at a greater risk trajectory of developing manifestations later on in life that can ultimately lead to adverse outcomes in overall health,” Dr. Pisarska, director of the division of reproductive endocrinology and infertility in obstetrics and gynecology at Cedars-Sinai, told this news organization.

“We do see regional differences in the diagnosis of PCOS [in the United States] as well as the manifestations of PCOS including high andrenoemia, hirsutism, and metabolic parameters ... and we need to better understand it because, at least in the entire population, weight was not the entire factor contributing to these differences,” she explained.

“So there are definitely environmental factors and possibly genetic factors that we need to take into consideration as we try to study these women and try to help them decrease their risk of metabolic syndrome later in life,” she noted.
 

Differences not attributable to race either

PCOS is a common endocrine disorder affecting women and female adolescents worldwide. Diagnosis usually requires at least two of the following to be present: ovulatory dysfunction, hyperandrogenism, and/or polycystic ovarian morphology.

Because of the prior work that had identified differences in symptoms among women with PCOS in different countries, the investigators set out to determine if women of the same race would have distinct hormonal and metabolic traits of PCOS in two geographical locations in the United States, suggesting geo-epidemiologic contributors of the disease

They evaluated 889 women at the University of Alabama at Birmingham and 721 at Cedars-Sinai Medical Center. Participants in Birmingham were a mean age of 28 years, had a mean BMI of 33.1 kg/m2, a mean waist-to-hip ratio of 0.8, and a mean hirsute rate of 84.6%. Participants in California were a mean age of 29.5 years, had an average BMI of 30.1 kg/m2, a mean waist-to-hip ratio of 0.9, and a mean hirsute rate of 72.8%.

The study team gathered data on menstrual cycle history, metabolic and hormonal parameters, and demographic data for each participant. They assessed hirsutism based on modified Ferriman-Gallwey scores of four or more. Patients were classified as having hyperandrogenemia if they had elevated androgen values greater than the 95th percentile of all values or androgen values that exceeded laboratory reference ranges.

The findings showed that Alabama women with PCOS had elevated homeostatic model assessment for insulin resistance scores (adjusted beta coefficient, 3.6; P < .001) and were more likely to be hirsute (adjusted odds ratio, 1.8; P < .001) after adjustment for BMI and age than those in California.

In contrast, women with PCOS in California were more likely to have elevated free testosterone and total testosterone values than women in Alabama (both P < .001). These findings persisted after adjusting for age and BMI.

When stratified by White race, these findings were similar. Notably, BMI and waist-to-hip ratio did not vary between regions in Black women with PCOS, although variations in metabolic dysfunction and androgen profiles persisted.

“This study supports regional differences in hormonal and metabolic parameters in women with PCOS in the United States, highlighting the impact of the environment on PCOS phenotype. Individuals of the same race in different geographical locations of the United States may have differing genetic predispositions for developing diseases such as PCOS,” the researchers said.

“Ongoing research is needed to identify modifiable environmental risk factors for PCOS that may be race and ethnic specific to bring precision medicine to the management of PCOS,” they conclude.

This work was supported in part by grants from the National Institutes of Health and an endowment of the Helping Hand of Los Angeles. Dr. VanHise reported no relevant financial relationships.

A version of this article first appeared on Medscape.com.

Geographic location within the United States appears to have an impact on the specific symptoms of polycystic ovary syndrome (PCOS) that any one particular woman will develop, according to a new prospective cohort study.

Women in California were more likely to exhibit high levels of testosterone (hyperandrogenism), while women in Alabama with PCOS had more metabolic dysfunction and hirsutism.

And although the women in Alabama were younger and had a higher body mass index (BMI), even after adjusting for these factors, the clinical differences were still present between the geographic locations, the authors said.

“This study suggests there are regional differences in hormonal and metabolic parameters in women with PCOS in California and Alabama, highlighting the impact of differing genetic and environmental modulators on PCOS development,” Katherine VanHise, MD, of Cedars-Sinai Medical Center, Los Angeles, and colleagues wrote in their article, published online in the Journal of Clinical Endocrinology and Metabolism.
 

Genetic and environmental factors play a role

Prior research has looked at variations in symptoms of PCOS across countries and identified differences in hirsutism and its prevalence, which is greater in Middle Eastern, Mediterranean, and Indian women, noted senior author Margareta D. Pisarska, MD.

And women of some other backgrounds “are at increased risk of developing metabolic syndrome and insulin resistance, including South Asian, African, and Hispanic women, so they are at a greater risk trajectory of developing manifestations later on in life that can ultimately lead to adverse outcomes in overall health,” Dr. Pisarska, director of the division of reproductive endocrinology and infertility in obstetrics and gynecology at Cedars-Sinai, told this news organization.

“We do see regional differences in the diagnosis of PCOS [in the United States] as well as the manifestations of PCOS including high andrenoemia, hirsutism, and metabolic parameters ... and we need to better understand it because, at least in the entire population, weight was not the entire factor contributing to these differences,” she explained.

“So there are definitely environmental factors and possibly genetic factors that we need to take into consideration as we try to study these women and try to help them decrease their risk of metabolic syndrome later in life,” she noted.
 

Differences not attributable to race either

PCOS is a common endocrine disorder affecting women and female adolescents worldwide. Diagnosis usually requires at least two of the following to be present: ovulatory dysfunction, hyperandrogenism, and/or polycystic ovarian morphology.

Because of the prior work that had identified differences in symptoms among women with PCOS in different countries, the investigators set out to determine if women of the same race would have distinct hormonal and metabolic traits of PCOS in two geographical locations in the United States, suggesting geo-epidemiologic contributors of the disease

They evaluated 889 women at the University of Alabama at Birmingham and 721 at Cedars-Sinai Medical Center. Participants in Birmingham were a mean age of 28 years, had a mean BMI of 33.1 kg/m2, a mean waist-to-hip ratio of 0.8, and a mean hirsute rate of 84.6%. Participants in California were a mean age of 29.5 years, had an average BMI of 30.1 kg/m2, a mean waist-to-hip ratio of 0.9, and a mean hirsute rate of 72.8%.

The study team gathered data on menstrual cycle history, metabolic and hormonal parameters, and demographic data for each participant. They assessed hirsutism based on modified Ferriman-Gallwey scores of four or more. Patients were classified as having hyperandrogenemia if they had elevated androgen values greater than the 95th percentile of all values or androgen values that exceeded laboratory reference ranges.

The findings showed that Alabama women with PCOS had elevated homeostatic model assessment for insulin resistance scores (adjusted beta coefficient, 3.6; P < .001) and were more likely to be hirsute (adjusted odds ratio, 1.8; P < .001) after adjustment for BMI and age than those in California.

In contrast, women with PCOS in California were more likely to have elevated free testosterone and total testosterone values than women in Alabama (both P < .001). These findings persisted after adjusting for age and BMI.

When stratified by White race, these findings were similar. Notably, BMI and waist-to-hip ratio did not vary between regions in Black women with PCOS, although variations in metabolic dysfunction and androgen profiles persisted.

“This study supports regional differences in hormonal and metabolic parameters in women with PCOS in the United States, highlighting the impact of the environment on PCOS phenotype. Individuals of the same race in different geographical locations of the United States may have differing genetic predispositions for developing diseases such as PCOS,” the researchers said.

“Ongoing research is needed to identify modifiable environmental risk factors for PCOS that may be race and ethnic specific to bring precision medicine to the management of PCOS,” they conclude.

This work was supported in part by grants from the National Institutes of Health and an endowment of the Helping Hand of Los Angeles. Dr. VanHise reported no relevant financial relationships.

A version of this article first appeared on Medscape.com.

The prosecution concluded its case on Oct. 13 against a nurse from Chester who is on trial for the murder of seven babies and the attempted murder of another 10 babies under her care. Lucy Letby, 32, who worked at the Countess of Chester Hospital, is accused of multiple baby murders in the hospital’s neonatal unit from June 2015 to June 2016. She denies all charges.

Manchester Crown Court heard how Ms. Letby allegedly attempted to kill the children by injecting them with air, milk, or insulin, including two brothers from a set of triplets and one premature baby girl, who was only 98 minutes old.

Prosecutor Nicholas Johnson KC said the circumstances of the girl’s death were “an extreme example even by the standards of this case.”

“There were four separate occasions on which we allege Lucy Letby tried to kill her,” he said. “But ultimately at the fourth attempt, Lucy Letby succeeded in killing her.”
 

Attempts to murder the child ‘cold-blooded’ and ‘calculated’, says prosecutor

In the first alleged attempt, Ms. Letby injected the girl, identified for legal reasons as Child I, with air, but she was “resilient,” said Mr. Johnson. After the second attempt, Ms. Letby had stood in the doorway of Child I’s darkened room and commented that she looked pale. The designated nurse then approached and turned on the light, noticing that the child wasn’t breathing. After a third attempt the child was found to have excess air in her stomach, which had affected her breathing. Child I was then transferred to Arrowe Park Hospital, where she was stabilized before she was returned to Chester.

After the fourth attempt, Child I’s medical alarm rang, leading a nurse to spot Ms. Letby by the child’s incubator. Child I died that morning, said Mr. Johnson, who described the nurse’s attacks as premeditated. “It was persistent, it was calculated, and it was cold-blooded.”

The judge, Mr. Justice Goss, and jury heard how shortly after the parents were told of their child’s death, Ms. Letby approached the mother, who testified that the nurse was “smiling and kept going on about how she was present at the baby’s first bath and how much the baby had loved it.” She also sent a sympathy card to the parents, and the prosecutor says she kept an image of the card on her phone.
 

Doctor interrupted another alleged attempt

Dr. Ravi Jayaram, a paediatric consultant, had become suspicious of Ms. Letby in a number of unexplained child deaths. He later interrupted her as she allegedly tried to kill another baby, identified as Child K. He noticed that the nurse was alone with the baby and walked into the room, seeing Ms. Letby standing over the child’s incubator. He was “uncomfortable” as he had “started to notice a coincidence between unexplained deaths, serious collapses, and the presence of Lucy Letby,” said the prosecutor.

“Dr. Jayaram could see from the monitor on the wall that Child K’s oxygen saturation level was falling dangerously low, to somewhere in the 80s,” said Mr. Johnson. “He said an alarm should have been sounding as Child K’s oxygen levels were falling.” Despite this, the nurse had not called for assistance.

“We allege she was trying to kill Child K when Dr. Jayaram walked in,” Mr. Johnson said, adding that the child’s breathing tube was found dislodged. The prosecutor said it was possible for this to happen in an active baby, but Child K was very premature and had been sedated.

Despite his concerns, Dr. Jayaram did not make a note of his suspicions. Later that morning, Ms. Letby was again at Child K’s incubator calling for help. The nurse was assisting the baby with her breathing and the breathing tube was found to have slipped too far into her throat. The child was transferred to another hospital but later died. Ms. Letby is not accused of Child K’s murder.

However, after the death of Child K, Ms. Letby was moved to day shifts “because the consultants were concerned about the correlation between her presence and unexpected deaths and life-threatening episodes on the night shifts,” said Mr. Johnson. She was removed from the neonatal ward in June 2016 and moved to clerical duties where she would not come into contact with children.
 

Post-it note: Admission or anguish?

At the end of the prosecution’s presentation, Mr. Johnson mentioned a Post-it on which Ms. Letby had written, “I AM EVIL I DID THIS.” In the defense’s opening statements, Ben Myers KC, said the note was an “anguished outpouring of a young woman in fear and despair when she realises the enormity of what’s being said about her, in a moment to herself.”

He added that the nurse was dealing with employment issues at the time it was written, including a grievance procedure with the NHS Trust where she worked. Another note was shown on screens to the jury, which read: “Not good enough. I’m an awful person. I will never have children or marry. Despair.” and “I haven’t done anything wrong.”

Mr. Myers said that Ms. Letby was the type of person who often scribbles things down and the note was “nothing more extraordinary than that.”

In presenting the defense case, Mr. Myers argued that there was no evidence of Letby hurting the children, and that the prosecution’s case was “driven by the assumption that someone was doing deliberate harm” and that this was combined with “coincidence on certain occasions of Miss Letby’s presence.”

“What it isn’t driven by is evidence of Miss Letby actually doing what is alleged against her,” he added.

“There is a real danger that people will simply accept the prosecution theory of guilt, and that’s all we have so far,” Mr. Myers said. “A theory of guilt based firmly on coincidence – if anything can be based firmly on coincidence.”

A version of this article first appeared on Medscape UK.

The prosecution concluded its case on Oct. 13 against a nurse from Chester who is on trial for the murder of seven babies and the attempted murder of another 10 babies under her care. Lucy Letby, 32, who worked at the Countess of Chester Hospital, is accused of multiple baby murders in the hospital’s neonatal unit from June 2015 to June 2016. She denies all charges.

Manchester Crown Court heard how Ms. Letby allegedly attempted to kill the children by injecting them with air, milk, or insulin, including two brothers from a set of triplets and one premature baby girl, who was only 98 minutes old.

Prosecutor Nicholas Johnson KC said the circumstances of the girl’s death were “an extreme example even by the standards of this case.”

“There were four separate occasions on which we allege Lucy Letby tried to kill her,” he said. “But ultimately at the fourth attempt, Lucy Letby succeeded in killing her.”
 

Attempts to murder the child ‘cold-blooded’ and ‘calculated’, says prosecutor

In the first alleged attempt, Ms. Letby injected the girl, identified for legal reasons as Child I, with air, but she was “resilient,” said Mr. Johnson. After the second attempt, Ms. Letby had stood in the doorway of Child I’s darkened room and commented that she looked pale. The designated nurse then approached and turned on the light, noticing that the child wasn’t breathing. After a third attempt the child was found to have excess air in her stomach, which had affected her breathing. Child I was then transferred to Arrowe Park Hospital, where she was stabilized before she was returned to Chester.

After the fourth attempt, Child I’s medical alarm rang, leading a nurse to spot Ms. Letby by the child’s incubator. Child I died that morning, said Mr. Johnson, who described the nurse’s attacks as premeditated. “It was persistent, it was calculated, and it was cold-blooded.”

The judge, Mr. Justice Goss, and jury heard how shortly after the parents were told of their child’s death, Ms. Letby approached the mother, who testified that the nurse was “smiling and kept going on about how she was present at the baby’s first bath and how much the baby had loved it.” She also sent a sympathy card to the parents, and the prosecutor says she kept an image of the card on her phone.
 

Doctor interrupted another alleged attempt

Dr. Ravi Jayaram, a paediatric consultant, had become suspicious of Ms. Letby in a number of unexplained child deaths. He later interrupted her as she allegedly tried to kill another baby, identified as Child K. He noticed that the nurse was alone with the baby and walked into the room, seeing Ms. Letby standing over the child’s incubator. He was “uncomfortable” as he had “started to notice a coincidence between unexplained deaths, serious collapses, and the presence of Lucy Letby,” said the prosecutor.

“Dr. Jayaram could see from the monitor on the wall that Child K’s oxygen saturation level was falling dangerously low, to somewhere in the 80s,” said Mr. Johnson. “He said an alarm should have been sounding as Child K’s oxygen levels were falling.” Despite this, the nurse had not called for assistance.

“We allege she was trying to kill Child K when Dr. Jayaram walked in,” Mr. Johnson said, adding that the child’s breathing tube was found dislodged. The prosecutor said it was possible for this to happen in an active baby, but Child K was very premature and had been sedated.

Despite his concerns, Dr. Jayaram did not make a note of his suspicions. Later that morning, Ms. Letby was again at Child K’s incubator calling for help. The nurse was assisting the baby with her breathing and the breathing tube was found to have slipped too far into her throat. The child was transferred to another hospital but later died. Ms. Letby is not accused of Child K’s murder.

However, after the death of Child K, Ms. Letby was moved to day shifts “because the consultants were concerned about the correlation between her presence and unexpected deaths and life-threatening episodes on the night shifts,” said Mr. Johnson. She was removed from the neonatal ward in June 2016 and moved to clerical duties where she would not come into contact with children.
 

Post-it note: Admission or anguish?

At the end of the prosecution’s presentation, Mr. Johnson mentioned a Post-it on which Ms. Letby had written, “I AM EVIL I DID THIS.” In the defense’s opening statements, Ben Myers KC, said the note was an “anguished outpouring of a young woman in fear and despair when she realises the enormity of what’s being said about her, in a moment to herself.”

He added that the nurse was dealing with employment issues at the time it was written, including a grievance procedure with the NHS Trust where she worked. Another note was shown on screens to the jury, which read: “Not good enough. I’m an awful person. I will never have children or marry. Despair.” and “I haven’t done anything wrong.”

Mr. Myers said that Ms. Letby was the type of person who often scribbles things down and the note was “nothing more extraordinary than that.”

In presenting the defense case, Mr. Myers argued that there was no evidence of Letby hurting the children, and that the prosecution’s case was “driven by the assumption that someone was doing deliberate harm” and that this was combined with “coincidence on certain occasions of Miss Letby’s presence.”

“What it isn’t driven by is evidence of Miss Letby actually doing what is alleged against her,” he added.

“There is a real danger that people will simply accept the prosecution theory of guilt, and that’s all we have so far,” Mr. Myers said. “A theory of guilt based firmly on coincidence – if anything can be based firmly on coincidence.”

A version of this article first appeared on Medscape UK.

The prosecution concluded its case on Oct. 13 against a nurse from Chester who is on trial for the murder of seven babies and the attempted murder of another 10 babies under her care. Lucy Letby, 32, who worked at the Countess of Chester Hospital, is accused of multiple baby murders in the hospital’s neonatal unit from June 2015 to June 2016. She denies all charges.

Manchester Crown Court heard how Ms. Letby allegedly attempted to kill the children by injecting them with air, milk, or insulin, including two brothers from a set of triplets and one premature baby girl, who was only 98 minutes old.

Prosecutor Nicholas Johnson KC said the circumstances of the girl’s death were “an extreme example even by the standards of this case.”

“There were four separate occasions on which we allege Lucy Letby tried to kill her,” he said. “But ultimately at the fourth attempt, Lucy Letby succeeded in killing her.”
 

Attempts to murder the child ‘cold-blooded’ and ‘calculated’, says prosecutor

In the first alleged attempt, Ms. Letby injected the girl, identified for legal reasons as Child I, with air, but she was “resilient,” said Mr. Johnson. After the second attempt, Ms. Letby had stood in the doorway of Child I’s darkened room and commented that she looked pale. The designated nurse then approached and turned on the light, noticing that the child wasn’t breathing. After a third attempt the child was found to have excess air in her stomach, which had affected her breathing. Child I was then transferred to Arrowe Park Hospital, where she was stabilized before she was returned to Chester.

After the fourth attempt, Child I’s medical alarm rang, leading a nurse to spot Ms. Letby by the child’s incubator. Child I died that morning, said Mr. Johnson, who described the nurse’s attacks as premeditated. “It was persistent, it was calculated, and it was cold-blooded.”

The judge, Mr. Justice Goss, and jury heard how shortly after the parents were told of their child’s death, Ms. Letby approached the mother, who testified that the nurse was “smiling and kept going on about how she was present at the baby’s first bath and how much the baby had loved it.” She also sent a sympathy card to the parents, and the prosecutor says she kept an image of the card on her phone.
 

Doctor interrupted another alleged attempt

Dr. Ravi Jayaram, a paediatric consultant, had become suspicious of Ms. Letby in a number of unexplained child deaths. He later interrupted her as she allegedly tried to kill another baby, identified as Child K. He noticed that the nurse was alone with the baby and walked into the room, seeing Ms. Letby standing over the child’s incubator. He was “uncomfortable” as he had “started to notice a coincidence between unexplained deaths, serious collapses, and the presence of Lucy Letby,” said the prosecutor.

“Dr. Jayaram could see from the monitor on the wall that Child K’s oxygen saturation level was falling dangerously low, to somewhere in the 80s,” said Mr. Johnson. “He said an alarm should have been sounding as Child K’s oxygen levels were falling.” Despite this, the nurse had not called for assistance.

“We allege she was trying to kill Child K when Dr. Jayaram walked in,” Mr. Johnson said, adding that the child’s breathing tube was found dislodged. The prosecutor said it was possible for this to happen in an active baby, but Child K was very premature and had been sedated.

Despite his concerns, Dr. Jayaram did not make a note of his suspicions. Later that morning, Ms. Letby was again at Child K’s incubator calling for help. The nurse was assisting the baby with her breathing and the breathing tube was found to have slipped too far into her throat. The child was transferred to another hospital but later died. Ms. Letby is not accused of Child K’s murder.

However, after the death of Child K, Ms. Letby was moved to day shifts “because the consultants were concerned about the correlation between her presence and unexpected deaths and life-threatening episodes on the night shifts,” said Mr. Johnson. She was removed from the neonatal ward in June 2016 and moved to clerical duties where she would not come into contact with children.
 

Post-it note: Admission or anguish?

At the end of the prosecution’s presentation, Mr. Johnson mentioned a Post-it on which Ms. Letby had written, “I AM EVIL I DID THIS.” In the defense’s opening statements, Ben Myers KC, said the note was an “anguished outpouring of a young woman in fear and despair when she realises the enormity of what’s being said about her, in a moment to herself.”

He added that the nurse was dealing with employment issues at the time it was written, including a grievance procedure with the NHS Trust where she worked. Another note was shown on screens to the jury, which read: “Not good enough. I’m an awful person. I will never have children or marry. Despair.” and “I haven’t done anything wrong.”

Mr. Myers said that Ms. Letby was the type of person who often scribbles things down and the note was “nothing more extraordinary than that.”

In presenting the defense case, Mr. Myers argued that there was no evidence of Letby hurting the children, and that the prosecution’s case was “driven by the assumption that someone was doing deliberate harm” and that this was combined with “coincidence on certain occasions of Miss Letby’s presence.”

“What it isn’t driven by is evidence of Miss Letby actually doing what is alleged against her,” he added.

“There is a real danger that people will simply accept the prosecution theory of guilt, and that’s all we have so far,” Mr. Myers said. “A theory of guilt based firmly on coincidence – if anything can be based firmly on coincidence.”

A version of this article first appeared on Medscape UK.

Tourette syndrome, attention-deficit/hyperactivity disorder (ADHD), obsessive-compulsive disorder (OCD), and autism spectrum disorder (ASD) share significant overlap in symptomatology, and it can be challenging at times to distinguish between these conditions. Being able to do so, however, can help guide more targeted interventions and accommodations to optimize a patient’s level of functioning.

Oregon Health &amp; Science University (OHSU)

Case example

A healthy, bright 6-year-old boy is referred by his family doctor to an academic medical center for a full team evaluation because of suspicion of ASD, after having already been diagnosed with ADHD at the age of 5. His difficulties with inattention, impulsivity, and hyperactivity, as well as his behavioral rigidities and sensory avoidant and sensory seeking behaviors have caused functional impairments for him in his kindergarten classroom. He has been penalized with removal of recess on more than one occasion. A low dose of a stimulant had been tried but resulted in a perceived increase in disruptive behaviors.

The boy, while hyperkinetic and often paying poor attention, is quite capable of high-quality and well-modulated eye contact paired with typical social referencing and reciprocity when actively engaging with the examiner and his parents. He does have a reported history of serial fixated interests and some repetitive behaviors but is also noted to be flexible in his interpersonal style, maintains other varied and typical interests, easily directs affect, utilizes a wide array of fluid gestures paired naturally with verbal communication, and shares enjoyment with smoothly coordinated gaze. He has mild articulation errors but uses pronouns appropriately and has no scripted speech or echolalia, though does engage in some whispered palilalia intermittently.

He is generally quite cooperative and redirectable when focused and has a completely normal physical and neurologic examination. During the visit, the doctor notices the boy making an intermittent honking sound, which parents report as an attention-seeking strategy during times of stress. Further physician-guided information gathering around other repetitive noises and movements elicits a history of engagement in repetitive hand-to-groin movements, some exaggerated blinking, and a number of other waxing and waning subtle motor and phonic tics with onset in preschool. These noises and movements have generally been identified as “fidgeting” and “misbehaving” by well-meaning caregivers in the home and school environments.

Both Tourette syndrome and ASD are more common in males, with stereotyped patterns of movements and behaviors; anxious, obsessive, and compulsive behaviors resulting in behavioral rigidities; sensory sensitivities; and increased rates of hyperkinesis with decreased impulse control which result in increased sensory-seeking behaviors. Diagnostic criteria for Tourette syndrome are met when a child has had multiple motor tics and at least one phonic tic present for at least 1 year, with tic-free intervals lasting no longer than 3 months, and with onset before the age of 18. Typically, tics emerge in late preschool and early grade school, and some children even develop repetitive movements as early as toddlerhood. Tics tend to worsen around the peripubertal era, then often generally improve in the teen years. Tic types, frequency, and severity general fluctuate over time.

Forty percent of children with Tourette syndrome also meet criteria for OCD, with many more having OCD traits, and about 65% of children with Tourette syndrome also meet criteria for ADHD, with many more having ADHD traits. OCD can lead to more rigid and directive social interactions in children as well as obsessive interests, just as ADHD can lead to less socially attuned and less cooperative behaviors, even in children who do not meet criteria for ASD.

For example, a child with OCD in the absence of ASD may still “police” other kids in class and be overly focused on the rules of a game, which may become a social liability. Likewise, a child with ADHD in the absence of ASD may be so distractible that focusing on what other kids are saying and their paired facial expressions is compromised, leading to poor-quality social reciprocity during interactions with peers. Given the remarkable overlap in shared symptoms, it is essential for pediatric providers to consider Tourette syndrome in the differential for any child with repetitive movements and behaviors in addition to ASD and a wide array of other neurodevelopment differences, including global developmental delays and intellectual disabilities. This is of particular importance as the diagnosis of Tourette syndrome can be used to gain access to developmental disability services if the condition has resulted in true adaptive impairments.

It is determined that the boy does in fact meet criteria for ADHD, but also for OCD and Tourette syndrome. Both his Autism Diagnostic Observation Schedule and DSM-5–influenced autism interview are found to be in the nonclinical ranges, given his quality of communication, social engagement, imaginative play, and varied interests. A diagnosis of ASD is not felt to be an appropriate conceptualization of his neurodevelopmental differences. He is started on a low dose of guanfacine, which induces a decline in tics, impulsivity, and hyperkinesis. He is given a 504 plan in school that includes scheduled “tic breaks,” sensory fidgets for use in the classroom, extra movement opportunities as needed, and utilization of a gentle cueing system between him and his teacher for low-key redirection of disruptive behaviors. He is no longer penalized for inattention or tics, and his 504 plan protects him from the use of recess removal as a behavioral modification strategy.

His parents enroll him in the community swim program for extra exercise, focus on decreasing screen time, and give him an earlier bedtime to help decrease his tics and rigidities, while improving his ability to self-regulate. Eventually, a low dose of a newer-generation stimulant is added to his guanfacine, with excellent results and only a mild increase in tolerable tics.

The child in the vignette did well with a 504 plan based on his medical diagnoses, though if related learning difficulties had persisted, eligibility under Other Health Impaired could be used to provide eligibility for an Individualized Education Plan. Alpha-agonists can be helpful for symptom control in those with Tourette syndrome by simultaneously treating tics, hyperkinesis, and impulsivity, while decreasing the risk of tic exacerbation with use of stimulants. Overall, understanding the neurodiversity related to Tourette syndrome can help providers advocate for home and community-based supports to optimize general functioning and quality of life.

Dr. Roth is a developmental and behavioral pediatrician in Eugene, Ore. She has no conflicts of interest.

References

Darrow S et al. J Am Acad Child Adolescent Psych. 2017;56(7):610-7.

AAP Section on Developmental and Behavioral Pediatrics. Developmental and Behavioral Pediatrics. Voigt RG et al, eds. 2018: American Academy of Pediatrics.

Tourette syndrome, attention-deficit/hyperactivity disorder (ADHD), obsessive-compulsive disorder (OCD), and autism spectrum disorder (ASD) share significant overlap in symptomatology, and it can be challenging at times to distinguish between these conditions. Being able to do so, however, can help guide more targeted interventions and accommodations to optimize a patient’s level of functioning.

Oregon Health &amp; Science University (OHSU)

Case example

A healthy, bright 6-year-old boy is referred by his family doctor to an academic medical center for a full team evaluation because of suspicion of ASD, after having already been diagnosed with ADHD at the age of 5. His difficulties with inattention, impulsivity, and hyperactivity, as well as his behavioral rigidities and sensory avoidant and sensory seeking behaviors have caused functional impairments for him in his kindergarten classroom. He has been penalized with removal of recess on more than one occasion. A low dose of a stimulant had been tried but resulted in a perceived increase in disruptive behaviors.

The boy, while hyperkinetic and often paying poor attention, is quite capable of high-quality and well-modulated eye contact paired with typical social referencing and reciprocity when actively engaging with the examiner and his parents. He does have a reported history of serial fixated interests and some repetitive behaviors but is also noted to be flexible in his interpersonal style, maintains other varied and typical interests, easily directs affect, utilizes a wide array of fluid gestures paired naturally with verbal communication, and shares enjoyment with smoothly coordinated gaze. He has mild articulation errors but uses pronouns appropriately and has no scripted speech or echolalia, though does engage in some whispered palilalia intermittently.

He is generally quite cooperative and redirectable when focused and has a completely normal physical and neurologic examination. During the visit, the doctor notices the boy making an intermittent honking sound, which parents report as an attention-seeking strategy during times of stress. Further physician-guided information gathering around other repetitive noises and movements elicits a history of engagement in repetitive hand-to-groin movements, some exaggerated blinking, and a number of other waxing and waning subtle motor and phonic tics with onset in preschool. These noises and movements have generally been identified as “fidgeting” and “misbehaving” by well-meaning caregivers in the home and school environments.

Both Tourette syndrome and ASD are more common in males, with stereotyped patterns of movements and behaviors; anxious, obsessive, and compulsive behaviors resulting in behavioral rigidities; sensory sensitivities; and increased rates of hyperkinesis with decreased impulse control which result in increased sensory-seeking behaviors. Diagnostic criteria for Tourette syndrome are met when a child has had multiple motor tics and at least one phonic tic present for at least 1 year, with tic-free intervals lasting no longer than 3 months, and with onset before the age of 18. Typically, tics emerge in late preschool and early grade school, and some children even develop repetitive movements as early as toddlerhood. Tics tend to worsen around the peripubertal era, then often generally improve in the teen years. Tic types, frequency, and severity general fluctuate over time.

Forty percent of children with Tourette syndrome also meet criteria for OCD, with many more having OCD traits, and about 65% of children with Tourette syndrome also meet criteria for ADHD, with many more having ADHD traits. OCD can lead to more rigid and directive social interactions in children as well as obsessive interests, just as ADHD can lead to less socially attuned and less cooperative behaviors, even in children who do not meet criteria for ASD.

For example, a child with OCD in the absence of ASD may still “police” other kids in class and be overly focused on the rules of a game, which may become a social liability. Likewise, a child with ADHD in the absence of ASD may be so distractible that focusing on what other kids are saying and their paired facial expressions is compromised, leading to poor-quality social reciprocity during interactions with peers. Given the remarkable overlap in shared symptoms, it is essential for pediatric providers to consider Tourette syndrome in the differential for any child with repetitive movements and behaviors in addition to ASD and a wide array of other neurodevelopment differences, including global developmental delays and intellectual disabilities. This is of particular importance as the diagnosis of Tourette syndrome can be used to gain access to developmental disability services if the condition has resulted in true adaptive impairments.

It is determined that the boy does in fact meet criteria for ADHD, but also for OCD and Tourette syndrome. Both his Autism Diagnostic Observation Schedule and DSM-5–influenced autism interview are found to be in the nonclinical ranges, given his quality of communication, social engagement, imaginative play, and varied interests. A diagnosis of ASD is not felt to be an appropriate conceptualization of his neurodevelopmental differences. He is started on a low dose of guanfacine, which induces a decline in tics, impulsivity, and hyperkinesis. He is given a 504 plan in school that includes scheduled “tic breaks,” sensory fidgets for use in the classroom, extra movement opportunities as needed, and utilization of a gentle cueing system between him and his teacher for low-key redirection of disruptive behaviors. He is no longer penalized for inattention or tics, and his 504 plan protects him from the use of recess removal as a behavioral modification strategy.

His parents enroll him in the community swim program for extra exercise, focus on decreasing screen time, and give him an earlier bedtime to help decrease his tics and rigidities, while improving his ability to self-regulate. Eventually, a low dose of a newer-generation stimulant is added to his guanfacine, with excellent results and only a mild increase in tolerable tics.

The child in the vignette did well with a 504 plan based on his medical diagnoses, though if related learning difficulties had persisted, eligibility under Other Health Impaired could be used to provide eligibility for an Individualized Education Plan. Alpha-agonists can be helpful for symptom control in those with Tourette syndrome by simultaneously treating tics, hyperkinesis, and impulsivity, while decreasing the risk of tic exacerbation with use of stimulants. Overall, understanding the neurodiversity related to Tourette syndrome can help providers advocate for home and community-based supports to optimize general functioning and quality of life.

Dr. Roth is a developmental and behavioral pediatrician in Eugene, Ore. She has no conflicts of interest.

References

Darrow S et al. J Am Acad Child Adolescent Psych. 2017;56(7):610-7.

AAP Section on Developmental and Behavioral Pediatrics. Developmental and Behavioral Pediatrics. Voigt RG et al, eds. 2018: American Academy of Pediatrics.

Tourette syndrome, attention-deficit/hyperactivity disorder (ADHD), obsessive-compulsive disorder (OCD), and autism spectrum disorder (ASD) share significant overlap in symptomatology, and it can be challenging at times to distinguish between these conditions. Being able to do so, however, can help guide more targeted interventions and accommodations to optimize a patient’s level of functioning.

Oregon Health &amp; Science University (OHSU)

Case example

A healthy, bright 6-year-old boy is referred by his family doctor to an academic medical center for a full team evaluation because of suspicion of ASD, after having already been diagnosed with ADHD at the age of 5. His difficulties with inattention, impulsivity, and hyperactivity, as well as his behavioral rigidities and sensory avoidant and sensory seeking behaviors have caused functional impairments for him in his kindergarten classroom. He has been penalized with removal of recess on more than one occasion. A low dose of a stimulant had been tried but resulted in a perceived increase in disruptive behaviors.

The boy, while hyperkinetic and often paying poor attention, is quite capable of high-quality and well-modulated eye contact paired with typical social referencing and reciprocity when actively engaging with the examiner and his parents. He does have a reported history of serial fixated interests and some repetitive behaviors but is also noted to be flexible in his interpersonal style, maintains other varied and typical interests, easily directs affect, utilizes a wide array of fluid gestures paired naturally with verbal communication, and shares enjoyment with smoothly coordinated gaze. He has mild articulation errors but uses pronouns appropriately and has no scripted speech or echolalia, though does engage in some whispered palilalia intermittently.

He is generally quite cooperative and redirectable when focused and has a completely normal physical and neurologic examination. During the visit, the doctor notices the boy making an intermittent honking sound, which parents report as an attention-seeking strategy during times of stress. Further physician-guided information gathering around other repetitive noises and movements elicits a history of engagement in repetitive hand-to-groin movements, some exaggerated blinking, and a number of other waxing and waning subtle motor and phonic tics with onset in preschool. These noises and movements have generally been identified as “fidgeting” and “misbehaving” by well-meaning caregivers in the home and school environments.

Both Tourette syndrome and ASD are more common in males, with stereotyped patterns of movements and behaviors; anxious, obsessive, and compulsive behaviors resulting in behavioral rigidities; sensory sensitivities; and increased rates of hyperkinesis with decreased impulse control which result in increased sensory-seeking behaviors. Diagnostic criteria for Tourette syndrome are met when a child has had multiple motor tics and at least one phonic tic present for at least 1 year, with tic-free intervals lasting no longer than 3 months, and with onset before the age of 18. Typically, tics emerge in late preschool and early grade school, and some children even develop repetitive movements as early as toddlerhood. Tics tend to worsen around the peripubertal era, then often generally improve in the teen years. Tic types, frequency, and severity general fluctuate over time.

Forty percent of children with Tourette syndrome also meet criteria for OCD, with many more having OCD traits, and about 65% of children with Tourette syndrome also meet criteria for ADHD, with many more having ADHD traits. OCD can lead to more rigid and directive social interactions in children as well as obsessive interests, just as ADHD can lead to less socially attuned and less cooperative behaviors, even in children who do not meet criteria for ASD.

For example, a child with OCD in the absence of ASD may still “police” other kids in class and be overly focused on the rules of a game, which may become a social liability. Likewise, a child with ADHD in the absence of ASD may be so distractible that focusing on what other kids are saying and their paired facial expressions is compromised, leading to poor-quality social reciprocity during interactions with peers. Given the remarkable overlap in shared symptoms, it is essential for pediatric providers to consider Tourette syndrome in the differential for any child with repetitive movements and behaviors in addition to ASD and a wide array of other neurodevelopment differences, including global developmental delays and intellectual disabilities. This is of particular importance as the diagnosis of Tourette syndrome can be used to gain access to developmental disability services if the condition has resulted in true adaptive impairments.

It is determined that the boy does in fact meet criteria for ADHD, but also for OCD and Tourette syndrome. Both his Autism Diagnostic Observation Schedule and DSM-5–influenced autism interview are found to be in the nonclinical ranges, given his quality of communication, social engagement, imaginative play, and varied interests. A diagnosis of ASD is not felt to be an appropriate conceptualization of his neurodevelopmental differences. He is started on a low dose of guanfacine, which induces a decline in tics, impulsivity, and hyperkinesis. He is given a 504 plan in school that includes scheduled “tic breaks,” sensory fidgets for use in the classroom, extra movement opportunities as needed, and utilization of a gentle cueing system between him and his teacher for low-key redirection of disruptive behaviors. He is no longer penalized for inattention or tics, and his 504 plan protects him from the use of recess removal as a behavioral modification strategy.

His parents enroll him in the community swim program for extra exercise, focus on decreasing screen time, and give him an earlier bedtime to help decrease his tics and rigidities, while improving his ability to self-regulate. Eventually, a low dose of a newer-generation stimulant is added to his guanfacine, with excellent results and only a mild increase in tolerable tics.

The child in the vignette did well with a 504 plan based on his medical diagnoses, though if related learning difficulties had persisted, eligibility under Other Health Impaired could be used to provide eligibility for an Individualized Education Plan. Alpha-agonists can be helpful for symptom control in those with Tourette syndrome by simultaneously treating tics, hyperkinesis, and impulsivity, while decreasing the risk of tic exacerbation with use of stimulants. Overall, understanding the neurodiversity related to Tourette syndrome can help providers advocate for home and community-based supports to optimize general functioning and quality of life.

Dr. Roth is a developmental and behavioral pediatrician in Eugene, Ore. She has no conflicts of interest.

References

Darrow S et al. J Am Acad Child Adolescent Psych. 2017;56(7):610-7.

AAP Section on Developmental and Behavioral Pediatrics. Developmental and Behavioral Pediatrics. Voigt RG et al, eds. 2018: American Academy of Pediatrics.

The World Professional Association for Transgender Health (WPATH) is an interdisciplinary professional and educational organization devoted to transgender health. One of their activities is to produce the Standards of Care (SOC) for treatment of individuals with gender dysphoria. According to WPATH, the SOC “articulate a professional consensus about the psychiatric, psychological, medical, and surgical management of gender dysphoria and help professionals understand the parameters within which they may offer assistance to those with these conditions.” Many clinicians around the world use these guidelines to help them care for patients with gender dysphoria and diverse gender expressions.

The most recent SOC, version 8, were released on Sept. 15, 2022, after a 2-year postponement because of the pandemic. These new standards represent the first update to the SOC since version 7, which was released in 2012. Given how recent this update is, this column will attempt to summarize the changes in the new guidelines that affect children and adolescents.

One of the major differences between SOC versions 7 and 8 is that version 8 now includes a chapter specifically dedicated to the care of adolescents. Version 7 lumped children and adolescents together into one chapter. This is an important distinction for SOC 8, as it highlights that care for prepubertal youth is simply social in nature and distinct from that of pubertal adolescents. Social transition includes things such as using an affirmed name/pronouns and changing hair style and clothes. It does not include medications of any kind. Allowing these youth the time and space to explore the natural gender diversity of childhood leads to improved psychological outcomes over time and reduces adversity. Psychological support, where indicated, should be offered to gender-diverse children and their families to explore the persistence, consistence, and insistence of that child’s gender identity.

Once a child reaches puberty, medications may come into play as part of an adolescent’s transition. SOC 7 had established a minimum age of 16 before any partially reversible medications (testosterone, estrogen) were started as part of a patient’s medical transition. Starting with SOC 8, a minimum age has been removed for the initiation of gender-affirming hormone therapy. However, a patient must still have begun their natal puberty before any medication is started. A specific age was removed to acknowledge that maturity in adolescents occurs on a continuum and at different ages. SOC 8 guidelines continue to recommend that the individual’s emotional, cognitive, and psychosocial development be taken into account when determining their ability to provide consent for treatment. These individuals should still undergo a comprehensive assessment, as described below.

Similar to SOC 7, SOC 8 continues to stress the importance of a comprehensive, multidisciplinary evaluation of those adolescents who seek medical therapy as part of their transition. This allows for the exploration of additional coexisting causes of gender dysphoria, such as anxiety, depression, or other mental health conditions. If these exist, then they must be appropriately treated before any gender-affirming medical treatment is initiated. Assessments should be performed by clinicians who have training and expertise with the developmental trajectory of adolescents, as well as with common mental health conditions. These assessments are also critical, as SOC 8 acknowledges a rise in the number of adolescents who may not have had gender-diverse expression in childhood.

SOC 8 and the Endocrine Society Guidelines (see references) provide physicians and other health care professionals with a road map for addressing the needs of transgender and gender-diverse persons. By referencing these guidelines when taking care of these patients, physicians and other health care professionals will know that they are providing the most up-to-date, evidence-based care.

Dr. M. Brett Cooper is an assistant professor of pediatrics at University of Texas Southwestern, Dallas, and an adolescent medicine specialist at Children’s Medical Center Dallas.

References

SOC 8: https://www.tandfonline.com/doi/pdf/10.1080/26895269.2022.2100644

SOC 7: https://www.wpath.org/media/cms/Documents/SOC%20v7/SOC%20V7_English2012.pdf?_t=1613669341

Endocrine Society Gender Affirming Care Guidelines: https://academic.oup.com/jcem/article/102/11/3869/4157558?login=false

The World Professional Association for Transgender Health (WPATH) is an interdisciplinary professional and educational organization devoted to transgender health. One of their activities is to produce the Standards of Care (SOC) for treatment of individuals with gender dysphoria. According to WPATH, the SOC “articulate a professional consensus about the psychiatric, psychological, medical, and surgical management of gender dysphoria and help professionals understand the parameters within which they may offer assistance to those with these conditions.” Many clinicians around the world use these guidelines to help them care for patients with gender dysphoria and diverse gender expressions.

The most recent SOC, version 8, were released on Sept. 15, 2022, after a 2-year postponement because of the pandemic. These new standards represent the first update to the SOC since version 7, which was released in 2012. Given how recent this update is, this column will attempt to summarize the changes in the new guidelines that affect children and adolescents.

One of the major differences between SOC versions 7 and 8 is that version 8 now includes a chapter specifically dedicated to the care of adolescents. Version 7 lumped children and adolescents together into one chapter. This is an important distinction for SOC 8, as it highlights that care for prepubertal youth is simply social in nature and distinct from that of pubertal adolescents. Social transition includes things such as using an affirmed name/pronouns and changing hair style and clothes. It does not include medications of any kind. Allowing these youth the time and space to explore the natural gender diversity of childhood leads to improved psychological outcomes over time and reduces adversity. Psychological support, where indicated, should be offered to gender-diverse children and their families to explore the persistence, consistence, and insistence of that child’s gender identity.

Once a child reaches puberty, medications may come into play as part of an adolescent’s transition. SOC 7 had established a minimum age of 16 before any partially reversible medications (testosterone, estrogen) were started as part of a patient’s medical transition. Starting with SOC 8, a minimum age has been removed for the initiation of gender-affirming hormone therapy. However, a patient must still have begun their natal puberty before any medication is started. A specific age was removed to acknowledge that maturity in adolescents occurs on a continuum and at different ages. SOC 8 guidelines continue to recommend that the individual’s emotional, cognitive, and psychosocial development be taken into account when determining their ability to provide consent for treatment. These individuals should still undergo a comprehensive assessment, as described below.

Similar to SOC 7, SOC 8 continues to stress the importance of a comprehensive, multidisciplinary evaluation of those adolescents who seek medical therapy as part of their transition. This allows for the exploration of additional coexisting causes of gender dysphoria, such as anxiety, depression, or other mental health conditions. If these exist, then they must be appropriately treated before any gender-affirming medical treatment is initiated. Assessments should be performed by clinicians who have training and expertise with the developmental trajectory of adolescents, as well as with common mental health conditions. These assessments are also critical, as SOC 8 acknowledges a rise in the number of adolescents who may not have had gender-diverse expression in childhood.

SOC 8 and the Endocrine Society Guidelines (see references) provide physicians and other health care professionals with a road map for addressing the needs of transgender and gender-diverse persons. By referencing these guidelines when taking care of these patients, physicians and other health care professionals will know that they are providing the most up-to-date, evidence-based care.

Dr. M. Brett Cooper is an assistant professor of pediatrics at University of Texas Southwestern, Dallas, and an adolescent medicine specialist at Children’s Medical Center Dallas.

References

SOC 8: https://www.tandfonline.com/doi/pdf/10.1080/26895269.2022.2100644

SOC 7: https://www.wpath.org/media/cms/Documents/SOC%20v7/SOC%20V7_English2012.pdf?_t=1613669341

Endocrine Society Gender Affirming Care Guidelines: https://academic.oup.com/jcem/article/102/11/3869/4157558?login=false

The World Professional Association for Transgender Health (WPATH) is an interdisciplinary professional and educational organization devoted to transgender health. One of their activities is to produce the Standards of Care (SOC) for treatment of individuals with gender dysphoria. According to WPATH, the SOC “articulate a professional consensus about the psychiatric, psychological, medical, and surgical management of gender dysphoria and help professionals understand the parameters within which they may offer assistance to those with these conditions.” Many clinicians around the world use these guidelines to help them care for patients with gender dysphoria and diverse gender expressions.

The most recent SOC, version 8, were released on Sept. 15, 2022, after a 2-year postponement because of the pandemic. These new standards represent the first update to the SOC since version 7, which was released in 2012. Given how recent this update is, this column will attempt to summarize the changes in the new guidelines that affect children and adolescents.

One of the major differences between SOC versions 7 and 8 is that version 8 now includes a chapter specifically dedicated to the care of adolescents. Version 7 lumped children and adolescents together into one chapter. This is an important distinction for SOC 8, as it highlights that care for prepubertal youth is simply social in nature and distinct from that of pubertal adolescents. Social transition includes things such as using an affirmed name/pronouns and changing hair style and clothes. It does not include medications of any kind. Allowing these youth the time and space to explore the natural gender diversity of childhood leads to improved psychological outcomes over time and reduces adversity. Psychological support, where indicated, should be offered to gender-diverse children and their families to explore the persistence, consistence, and insistence of that child’s gender identity.

Once a child reaches puberty, medications may come into play as part of an adolescent’s transition. SOC 7 had established a minimum age of 16 before any partially reversible medications (testosterone, estrogen) were started as part of a patient’s medical transition. Starting with SOC 8, a minimum age has been removed for the initiation of gender-affirming hormone therapy. However, a patient must still have begun their natal puberty before any medication is started. A specific age was removed to acknowledge that maturity in adolescents occurs on a continuum and at different ages. SOC 8 guidelines continue to recommend that the individual’s emotional, cognitive, and psychosocial development be taken into account when determining their ability to provide consent for treatment. These individuals should still undergo a comprehensive assessment, as described below.

Similar to SOC 7, SOC 8 continues to stress the importance of a comprehensive, multidisciplinary evaluation of those adolescents who seek medical therapy as part of their transition. This allows for the exploration of additional coexisting causes of gender dysphoria, such as anxiety, depression, or other mental health conditions. If these exist, then they must be appropriately treated before any gender-affirming medical treatment is initiated. Assessments should be performed by clinicians who have training and expertise with the developmental trajectory of adolescents, as well as with common mental health conditions. These assessments are also critical, as SOC 8 acknowledges a rise in the number of adolescents who may not have had gender-diverse expression in childhood.

SOC 8 and the Endocrine Society Guidelines (see references) provide physicians and other health care professionals with a road map for addressing the needs of transgender and gender-diverse persons. By referencing these guidelines when taking care of these patients, physicians and other health care professionals will know that they are providing the most up-to-date, evidence-based care.

Dr. M. Brett Cooper is an assistant professor of pediatrics at University of Texas Southwestern, Dallas, and an adolescent medicine specialist at Children’s Medical Center Dallas.

References

SOC 8: https://www.tandfonline.com/doi/pdf/10.1080/26895269.2022.2100644

SOC 7: https://www.wpath.org/media/cms/Documents/SOC%20v7/SOC%20V7_English2012.pdf?_t=1613669341

Endocrine Society Gender Affirming Care Guidelines: https://academic.oup.com/jcem/article/102/11/3869/4157558?login=false