Jim Kling

In 2022, the Journal of Neurosurgery took the unusual step of publishing a case report of a nonhuman subject, in this case an 8-year-old male sea lion named Cronutt, who had severe epilepsy that in many ways mirrored the common form seen in humans.

A 2020 xenotransplantation of interneuron progenitor cells in the sea lion’s hippocampus may have cured him. “He’s doing fantastic,” said Scott Baraban, PhD, a professor of neurological surgery at the University of California San Francisco Weill Institute for Neurosciences. The procedure offered a confirmation of success stories in mice and could serve as a bridge to human studies, although the science remains murky. 

Cronutt’s story began the first time he was found stranded along the California coast in San Luis Obispo County, in November 2017, lethargic and disoriented. Nevertheless, he improved quickly under the care of the Marine Mammal Rescue Center in Sausalito, California, and they released him back into the wild 2 weeks later. Unfortunately, his troubles weren’t over. In the next 2 months, he came to the attention of the rehabilitation center two more times, and the resulting habituation to humans meant that he could not be re-released to the wild.

Things only got worse from there. He experienced a convulsive seizure and loss of consciousness in early 2018 and another seizure a year later. Despite anti-seizure medication, the episodes continued, and eventually, he stopped eating for long periods and lost a quarter of his body weight. It looked like euthanasia was the only alternative.

 

Neurosurgeons Take Notice

Baraban has devoted his career to animal models of epilepsy, focusing mainly on mice. He developed a method to transplant GABAergic interneurons from pigs, which can pick up the inhibitory role of endogenous neurons. In epileptic mice, mouse-derived progenitor cells mature into inhibitory synapses and dampen seizures, and even reverse behavioral problems. 

Baraban was intrigued by the potential of the procedure to help sea lions and potentially bridge the gap between murine and human studies, and he was eager to try the approach after he learned of Cronutt’s case through his colleague Paul Buckmaster at Stanford University, California, who had collaborated with the Marine Mammal Rescue Center to demonstrate that sea lions suffer hippocampal damage that is very similar to human temporal lobe epilepsy.

It turns out that surgery on a sea lion is more complicated than on a mouse. The surgeon needs to conduct an MRI scan to locate the lesion and guide the placement of transplanted cells, and the big animals need to be sedated and intubated. Their caretakers are not enthusiastic about invasive procedures, but Cronutt had already been imaged as part of an earlier study of the effects of exposure to domoic acid on the sea lion brain, giving neurosurgeons at UCSF the information they needed.

In 2020, they transplanted GABAergic interneurons into Cronutt’s hippocampus in a last-ditch effort to save his life. He improved rapidly, and his caregivers eventually tapered off his anti-seizure medications. Today, Cronutt is living seizure-free at the Six Flags Discovery Kingdom in Vallejo, California. He even began participating in shows at Six Flags. “He is able to learn things and do things cognitively that he couldn’t do before,” said Baraban.

The researchers have not followed up with more imaging. “We just haven’t had any reason to bother him. It’s very invasive to get him to an MRI center,” said Baraban.

There haven’t been any more procedures on sea lions, in part because sea lions at rescue centers must be returned to the wild within 6-8 months, and animals with pig-based progenitor cells can’t be released. Any sea lion that would undergo such a procedure would have to live permanently in captivity, potentially for 20-30 years. “It’s a huge undertaking and expense,” said Baraban. There are also logistical challenges with the need to have MRI and other facilities close at hand to where the sea lion is kept.

 

Human Connections

As a veterinarian interested in human epilepsy, Buckmaster sought to find additional animal models for human temporal lobe epilepsy. He later met a veterinarian who worked with the Marine Mammal Center, who told him about temporal lobe epilepsy in sea lions. 

Cronutt was just one of hundreds of California sea lions and other mammals rendered helpless by epileptic seizures induced by exposure to domoic acid, a chemical released by toxic algal blooms. Sea otters, whales, and even birds can likewise be affected. Humans, too, though it is rare: A domoic acid poisoning event in mussels from Prince Edward Island led to convulsions and an eventual diagnosis of temporal lobe epilepsy in an 84-year-old Canadian man, and three others died.

Most of Buckmaster’s work had been done in rats, but seizures are different than what are seen in humans. The damage isn’t unilateral, as in human epilepsy. The damage is unilateral in sea lions, and they suffer damage to similar neurons to those injured in humans. “In rats, you don’t see much loss of granule cells, which are the main neuron in the dentate gyrus, a region that’s really affected in temporal lobe epilepsy. In people, there’s a lot of variation, but [on average] you lose about half your granule cells, and that’s similar to sea lions. In rats, they just don’t lose them,” said Buckmaster.

That makes sea lions a useful model, but they hardly crack the case of human epilepsy. “To be humble about it, we don’t really know what’s causing the seizures. We have an idea of what region of the brain the seizures are coming from, but in terms of the cellular mechanisms, it’s still not clear,” said Buckmaster.

He also noted that, unlike sea lions, the vast majority of patients with human epilepsy have no exposure to domoic acid. That said, the case of sea lions and other marine animals makes researchers wonder. “This is speculative, but a lot of people with temporal epilepsy will have a history of some kind of precipitating event. Typically, it’s earlier in life, and a common one is prolonged febrile seizures. That could be a link to the domoic acid exposure in sea lions because the domoic acid exposure in sea lions frequently causes prolonged seizures. If the seizures are severe enough and long enough, they cause permanent brain damage, and that can cause temporal lobe epilepsy. That’s what we strongly believe is causing the temporal lobe epilepsy in sea lions. Prolonged, severe seizures can be caused by many things other than domoic acid, and that could be what causes it in many cases of human temporal lobe epilepsy,” said Buckmaster.

The approach taken with Cronutt makes sense to Buckmaster, who was not directly involved in the procedure. “The ideal treatment would be something that you would administer once, and it would cause cessation of seizures without any side effects. The transplantation of inhibitory cells is a treatment that would last and hopefully wouldn’t have any side effects and hopefully would provide complete control of seizures. It’s unlikely to reach all those goals, but it’s a step in the right direction, hopefully,” said Buckmaster.

He noted that Cronutt is only a single case and not proof that the procedure will work more generally. It’s possible the sea lion would have improved on his own without treatment, and the procedure itself could have influenced the brain. “That’s been the case with other neurological conditions that have attempted to be treated with cell transplantation,” said Buckmaster.

A phase 1/2 clinical trial, sponsored by Neurona Therapeutics, is currently recruiting patients to test transplant of human interneurons created from pluripotent stem cells into both temporal lobes of patients with drug-resistant bilateral mesial temporal lobe epilepsy.

 

Cronutt’s Course

Although he has improved dramatically, it’s possible that Cronutt continues to experience nonconvulsive seizures, which would not be easy to detect in an animal. “You don’t know if Cronutt’s seizures are controlled or not unless you can look at the electrical activity in Cronutt’s brain, and to my knowledge that has not been done,” said Buckmaster.

Previous studies in rats did repeatedly demonstrate the potential of the treatment approach. Despite the feel-good story of Cronutt, “that’s probably the most compelling evidence in support of that arm of treatment,” said Buckmaster.

Buckmaster and Barbaran had no relevant financial disclosures.

A version of this article appeared on Medscape.com.

In 2022, the Journal of Neurosurgery took the unusual step of publishing a case report of a nonhuman subject, in this case an 8-year-old male sea lion named Cronutt, who had severe epilepsy that in many ways mirrored the common form seen in humans.

A 2020 xenotransplantation of interneuron progenitor cells in the sea lion’s hippocampus may have cured him. “He’s doing fantastic,” said Scott Baraban, PhD, a professor of neurological surgery at the University of California San Francisco Weill Institute for Neurosciences. The procedure offered a confirmation of success stories in mice and could serve as a bridge to human studies, although the science remains murky. 

Cronutt’s story began the first time he was found stranded along the California coast in San Luis Obispo County, in November 2017, lethargic and disoriented. Nevertheless, he improved quickly under the care of the Marine Mammal Rescue Center in Sausalito, California, and they released him back into the wild 2 weeks later. Unfortunately, his troubles weren’t over. In the next 2 months, he came to the attention of the rehabilitation center two more times, and the resulting habituation to humans meant that he could not be re-released to the wild.

Things only got worse from there. He experienced a convulsive seizure and loss of consciousness in early 2018 and another seizure a year later. Despite anti-seizure medication, the episodes continued, and eventually, he stopped eating for long periods and lost a quarter of his body weight. It looked like euthanasia was the only alternative.

 

Neurosurgeons Take Notice

Baraban has devoted his career to animal models of epilepsy, focusing mainly on mice. He developed a method to transplant GABAergic interneurons from pigs, which can pick up the inhibitory role of endogenous neurons. In epileptic mice, mouse-derived progenitor cells mature into inhibitory synapses and dampen seizures, and even reverse behavioral problems. 

Baraban was intrigued by the potential of the procedure to help sea lions and potentially bridge the gap between murine and human studies, and he was eager to try the approach after he learned of Cronutt’s case through his colleague Paul Buckmaster at Stanford University, California, who had collaborated with the Marine Mammal Rescue Center to demonstrate that sea lions suffer hippocampal damage that is very similar to human temporal lobe epilepsy.

It turns out that surgery on a sea lion is more complicated than on a mouse. The surgeon needs to conduct an MRI scan to locate the lesion and guide the placement of transplanted cells, and the big animals need to be sedated and intubated. Their caretakers are not enthusiastic about invasive procedures, but Cronutt had already been imaged as part of an earlier study of the effects of exposure to domoic acid on the sea lion brain, giving neurosurgeons at UCSF the information they needed.

In 2020, they transplanted GABAergic interneurons into Cronutt’s hippocampus in a last-ditch effort to save his life. He improved rapidly, and his caregivers eventually tapered off his anti-seizure medications. Today, Cronutt is living seizure-free at the Six Flags Discovery Kingdom in Vallejo, California. He even began participating in shows at Six Flags. “He is able to learn things and do things cognitively that he couldn’t do before,” said Baraban.

The researchers have not followed up with more imaging. “We just haven’t had any reason to bother him. It’s very invasive to get him to an MRI center,” said Baraban.

There haven’t been any more procedures on sea lions, in part because sea lions at rescue centers must be returned to the wild within 6-8 months, and animals with pig-based progenitor cells can’t be released. Any sea lion that would undergo such a procedure would have to live permanently in captivity, potentially for 20-30 years. “It’s a huge undertaking and expense,” said Baraban. There are also logistical challenges with the need to have MRI and other facilities close at hand to where the sea lion is kept.

 

Human Connections

As a veterinarian interested in human epilepsy, Buckmaster sought to find additional animal models for human temporal lobe epilepsy. He later met a veterinarian who worked with the Marine Mammal Center, who told him about temporal lobe epilepsy in sea lions. 

Cronutt was just one of hundreds of California sea lions and other mammals rendered helpless by epileptic seizures induced by exposure to domoic acid, a chemical released by toxic algal blooms. Sea otters, whales, and even birds can likewise be affected. Humans, too, though it is rare: A domoic acid poisoning event in mussels from Prince Edward Island led to convulsions and an eventual diagnosis of temporal lobe epilepsy in an 84-year-old Canadian man, and three others died.

Most of Buckmaster’s work had been done in rats, but seizures are different than what are seen in humans. The damage isn’t unilateral, as in human epilepsy. The damage is unilateral in sea lions, and they suffer damage to similar neurons to those injured in humans. “In rats, you don’t see much loss of granule cells, which are the main neuron in the dentate gyrus, a region that’s really affected in temporal lobe epilepsy. In people, there’s a lot of variation, but [on average] you lose about half your granule cells, and that’s similar to sea lions. In rats, they just don’t lose them,” said Buckmaster.

That makes sea lions a useful model, but they hardly crack the case of human epilepsy. “To be humble about it, we don’t really know what’s causing the seizures. We have an idea of what region of the brain the seizures are coming from, but in terms of the cellular mechanisms, it’s still not clear,” said Buckmaster.

He also noted that, unlike sea lions, the vast majority of patients with human epilepsy have no exposure to domoic acid. That said, the case of sea lions and other marine animals makes researchers wonder. “This is speculative, but a lot of people with temporal epilepsy will have a history of some kind of precipitating event. Typically, it’s earlier in life, and a common one is prolonged febrile seizures. That could be a link to the domoic acid exposure in sea lions because the domoic acid exposure in sea lions frequently causes prolonged seizures. If the seizures are severe enough and long enough, they cause permanent brain damage, and that can cause temporal lobe epilepsy. That’s what we strongly believe is causing the temporal lobe epilepsy in sea lions. Prolonged, severe seizures can be caused by many things other than domoic acid, and that could be what causes it in many cases of human temporal lobe epilepsy,” said Buckmaster.

The approach taken with Cronutt makes sense to Buckmaster, who was not directly involved in the procedure. “The ideal treatment would be something that you would administer once, and it would cause cessation of seizures without any side effects. The transplantation of inhibitory cells is a treatment that would last and hopefully wouldn’t have any side effects and hopefully would provide complete control of seizures. It’s unlikely to reach all those goals, but it’s a step in the right direction, hopefully,” said Buckmaster.

He noted that Cronutt is only a single case and not proof that the procedure will work more generally. It’s possible the sea lion would have improved on his own without treatment, and the procedure itself could have influenced the brain. “That’s been the case with other neurological conditions that have attempted to be treated with cell transplantation,” said Buckmaster.

A phase 1/2 clinical trial, sponsored by Neurona Therapeutics, is currently recruiting patients to test transplant of human interneurons created from pluripotent stem cells into both temporal lobes of patients with drug-resistant bilateral mesial temporal lobe epilepsy.

 

Cronutt’s Course

Although he has improved dramatically, it’s possible that Cronutt continues to experience nonconvulsive seizures, which would not be easy to detect in an animal. “You don’t know if Cronutt’s seizures are controlled or not unless you can look at the electrical activity in Cronutt’s brain, and to my knowledge that has not been done,” said Buckmaster.

Previous studies in rats did repeatedly demonstrate the potential of the treatment approach. Despite the feel-good story of Cronutt, “that’s probably the most compelling evidence in support of that arm of treatment,” said Buckmaster.

Buckmaster and Barbaran had no relevant financial disclosures.

A version of this article appeared on Medscape.com.

In 2022, the Journal of Neurosurgery took the unusual step of publishing a case report of a nonhuman subject, in this case an 8-year-old male sea lion named Cronutt, who had severe epilepsy that in many ways mirrored the common form seen in humans.

A 2020 xenotransplantation of interneuron progenitor cells in the sea lion’s hippocampus may have cured him. “He’s doing fantastic,” said Scott Baraban, PhD, a professor of neurological surgery at the University of California San Francisco Weill Institute for Neurosciences. The procedure offered a confirmation of success stories in mice and could serve as a bridge to human studies, although the science remains murky. 

Cronutt’s story began the first time he was found stranded along the California coast in San Luis Obispo County, in November 2017, lethargic and disoriented. Nevertheless, he improved quickly under the care of the Marine Mammal Rescue Center in Sausalito, California, and they released him back into the wild 2 weeks later. Unfortunately, his troubles weren’t over. In the next 2 months, he came to the attention of the rehabilitation center two more times, and the resulting habituation to humans meant that he could not be re-released to the wild.

Things only got worse from there. He experienced a convulsive seizure and loss of consciousness in early 2018 and another seizure a year later. Despite anti-seizure medication, the episodes continued, and eventually, he stopped eating for long periods and lost a quarter of his body weight. It looked like euthanasia was the only alternative.

 

Neurosurgeons Take Notice

Baraban has devoted his career to animal models of epilepsy, focusing mainly on mice. He developed a method to transplant GABAergic interneurons from pigs, which can pick up the inhibitory role of endogenous neurons. In epileptic mice, mouse-derived progenitor cells mature into inhibitory synapses and dampen seizures, and even reverse behavioral problems. 

Baraban was intrigued by the potential of the procedure to help sea lions and potentially bridge the gap between murine and human studies, and he was eager to try the approach after he learned of Cronutt’s case through his colleague Paul Buckmaster at Stanford University, California, who had collaborated with the Marine Mammal Rescue Center to demonstrate that sea lions suffer hippocampal damage that is very similar to human temporal lobe epilepsy.

It turns out that surgery on a sea lion is more complicated than on a mouse. The surgeon needs to conduct an MRI scan to locate the lesion and guide the placement of transplanted cells, and the big animals need to be sedated and intubated. Their caretakers are not enthusiastic about invasive procedures, but Cronutt had already been imaged as part of an earlier study of the effects of exposure to domoic acid on the sea lion brain, giving neurosurgeons at UCSF the information they needed.

In 2020, they transplanted GABAergic interneurons into Cronutt’s hippocampus in a last-ditch effort to save his life. He improved rapidly, and his caregivers eventually tapered off his anti-seizure medications. Today, Cronutt is living seizure-free at the Six Flags Discovery Kingdom in Vallejo, California. He even began participating in shows at Six Flags. “He is able to learn things and do things cognitively that he couldn’t do before,” said Baraban.

The researchers have not followed up with more imaging. “We just haven’t had any reason to bother him. It’s very invasive to get him to an MRI center,” said Baraban.

There haven’t been any more procedures on sea lions, in part because sea lions at rescue centers must be returned to the wild within 6-8 months, and animals with pig-based progenitor cells can’t be released. Any sea lion that would undergo such a procedure would have to live permanently in captivity, potentially for 20-30 years. “It’s a huge undertaking and expense,” said Baraban. There are also logistical challenges with the need to have MRI and other facilities close at hand to where the sea lion is kept.

 

Human Connections

As a veterinarian interested in human epilepsy, Buckmaster sought to find additional animal models for human temporal lobe epilepsy. He later met a veterinarian who worked with the Marine Mammal Center, who told him about temporal lobe epilepsy in sea lions. 

Cronutt was just one of hundreds of California sea lions and other mammals rendered helpless by epileptic seizures induced by exposure to domoic acid, a chemical released by toxic algal blooms. Sea otters, whales, and even birds can likewise be affected. Humans, too, though it is rare: A domoic acid poisoning event in mussels from Prince Edward Island led to convulsions and an eventual diagnosis of temporal lobe epilepsy in an 84-year-old Canadian man, and three others died.

Most of Buckmaster’s work had been done in rats, but seizures are different than what are seen in humans. The damage isn’t unilateral, as in human epilepsy. The damage is unilateral in sea lions, and they suffer damage to similar neurons to those injured in humans. “In rats, you don’t see much loss of granule cells, which are the main neuron in the dentate gyrus, a region that’s really affected in temporal lobe epilepsy. In people, there’s a lot of variation, but [on average] you lose about half your granule cells, and that’s similar to sea lions. In rats, they just don’t lose them,” said Buckmaster.

That makes sea lions a useful model, but they hardly crack the case of human epilepsy. “To be humble about it, we don’t really know what’s causing the seizures. We have an idea of what region of the brain the seizures are coming from, but in terms of the cellular mechanisms, it’s still not clear,” said Buckmaster.

He also noted that, unlike sea lions, the vast majority of patients with human epilepsy have no exposure to domoic acid. That said, the case of sea lions and other marine animals makes researchers wonder. “This is speculative, but a lot of people with temporal epilepsy will have a history of some kind of precipitating event. Typically, it’s earlier in life, and a common one is prolonged febrile seizures. That could be a link to the domoic acid exposure in sea lions because the domoic acid exposure in sea lions frequently causes prolonged seizures. If the seizures are severe enough and long enough, they cause permanent brain damage, and that can cause temporal lobe epilepsy. That’s what we strongly believe is causing the temporal lobe epilepsy in sea lions. Prolonged, severe seizures can be caused by many things other than domoic acid, and that could be what causes it in many cases of human temporal lobe epilepsy,” said Buckmaster.

The approach taken with Cronutt makes sense to Buckmaster, who was not directly involved in the procedure. “The ideal treatment would be something that you would administer once, and it would cause cessation of seizures without any side effects. The transplantation of inhibitory cells is a treatment that would last and hopefully wouldn’t have any side effects and hopefully would provide complete control of seizures. It’s unlikely to reach all those goals, but it’s a step in the right direction, hopefully,” said Buckmaster.

He noted that Cronutt is only a single case and not proof that the procedure will work more generally. It’s possible the sea lion would have improved on his own without treatment, and the procedure itself could have influenced the brain. “That’s been the case with other neurological conditions that have attempted to be treated with cell transplantation,” said Buckmaster.

A phase 1/2 clinical trial, sponsored by Neurona Therapeutics, is currently recruiting patients to test transplant of human interneurons created from pluripotent stem cells into both temporal lobes of patients with drug-resistant bilateral mesial temporal lobe epilepsy.

 

Cronutt’s Course

Although he has improved dramatically, it’s possible that Cronutt continues to experience nonconvulsive seizures, which would not be easy to detect in an animal. “You don’t know if Cronutt’s seizures are controlled or not unless you can look at the electrical activity in Cronutt’s brain, and to my knowledge that has not been done,” said Buckmaster.

Previous studies in rats did repeatedly demonstrate the potential of the treatment approach. Despite the feel-good story of Cronutt, “that’s probably the most compelling evidence in support of that arm of treatment,” said Buckmaster.

Buckmaster and Barbaran had no relevant financial disclosures.

A version of this article appeared on Medscape.com.

LOS ANGELES — Artificial intelligence (AI) analysis of caregiver-recorded videos has the potential to diagnose infantile epileptic spasm syndrome, according to a new study.

Infants with the condition can have poor outcomes with even small delays in diagnosis and ensuing treatment, potentially leading to intellectual disability, autism, and worse epilepsy. “It’s super important to start the treatment early, but oftentimes, these symptoms are just misrecognized by primary care or ER physicians. It takes a long time to diagnose,” said Gadi Miron, MD, who presented the study at the American Epilepsy Society (AES) 78th Annual Meeting 2024.

 

What Is This? What Should I Do?

Parents who observe unusual behavior often seek advice from friends and family members and receive false reassurance that such behavior isn’t unusual. Even physicians may contribute if they are unaware of infantile spasms, which is a rare disorder. “And then again, they get false reassurance, and because of that false reassurance, you get a diagnostic delay,” said Shaun Hussain, MD, who was asked to comment on the study.

The timing and frequency of infantile spasms create challenges for diagnosis. They only last about 1 second, and they tend to cluster in the morning. By the time a caregiver brings an infant to a healthcare provider, they may have trouble describing the behavior. “Parents are struggling to describe what they saw, and it often just does not resonate, or doesn’t make the healthcare provider think about infantile spasms,” said Hussain.

The idea to employ AI came from looking at videos of infants on YouTube and the realization that many patients upload them in an effort to seek advice. “So many parents upload these videos and ask in the comments, ‘What is this? What should I do? Can somebody help me?’ said Miron, who is a neurologist and researcher at Charité — Universitätsmedizin Berlin in Germany.

 

AI and Video Can Aid Diagnosis

The researchers built a model that they trained to recognize epileptic spasms using openly available YouTube videos, including 141 infants, 991 recorded seizures, and 597 non-seizure video segments, along with a non-seizure cohort of 127 infants with an accompanying 1385 video segments.

Each video segment was reviewed by two specialists, and they had to agree for it to be counted as an epileptic spasm.

The model detected epileptic seizures with an area under the curve (AUC) of 0.96. It had a sensitivity of 82%, specificity of 90%, and accuracy of 85% when applied to the training set.

The researchers then tested it against three validation sets. In the first, a smartphone-based set retrieved from TikTok of 26 infants with 70 epileptic spasms and 31 non-seizure 5-second video segments, the model had an AUC of 0.98, a sensitivity of 89%, a specificity of 100%, and an accuracy of 92%.

A second smartphone-based set of 67 infants, drawn from YouTube, showed a false detection rate of 0.75% (five detections out of 666 video segments). A third dataset collected from in-hospital EEG monitoring of 21 infants without seizures revealed a false-positive rate of 3.4% (365 of 10,860 video segments).

The group is now developing an app that will allow parents to upload videos that can be analyzed using the model. Physicians can then view the video and determine if there is suspicion of a seizure.

Miron also believes that this approach could find use in other types of seizures and populations, including older children and adults. “We have actually built some models for detection of seizures for videos in adults as well. Looking more towards the future, I’m sure AI will be used to analyze videos of other neurological disorders with motor symptoms [such as] movement disorders and gait,” he said.

 

Encouraging Early Research

Hussain, who is a professor of pediatrics at UCLA Health, lauded the work generally but emphasized that it is still in the early stage. “Their comparison was a relatively easy one. They’re just comparing normal versus infantile spasms, and they’re looking at the seizure versus normal behavior. Usually, the distinction is much harder in that there are kids who are having behaviors that are maybe other types of seizures, which is much harder to distinguish from infantile spasms, in contrast to just normal behaviors. The other mimic of infantile spasms is things like infant heartburn. Those kids will often have some posturing, and they often will be in pain. They might cry. That’s something that infantile spasms will often generate, so that’s why there’s a lot of confusion between those two,” said Hussain.

He noted that there have been efforts to raise awareness of infantile spasms among physicians and the general public, but that hasn’t reduced the increased detection.

 

Another Resource

In fact, parents with suspicions often go to social media sites like YouTube and a Facebook group dedicated to infantile spasms. “You can Google infantile spasms, and you’ll see examples of weird behaviors, and then you’ll look in the comments, and you’ll see this commenter said: ‘These could be infantile spasms. You should go to a children’s hospital. Don’t leave until you get an EEG to make sure that these are not seizures. There’s all kinds of great advice there, and it really shouldn’t be the situation where to get the best care, you need to go on YouTube,’ ” said Hussain.

Miron and Hussain had no relevant financial disclosures.

A version of this article first appeared on Medscape.com.

LOS ANGELES — Artificial intelligence (AI) analysis of caregiver-recorded videos has the potential to diagnose infantile epileptic spasm syndrome, according to a new study.

Infants with the condition can have poor outcomes with even small delays in diagnosis and ensuing treatment, potentially leading to intellectual disability, autism, and worse epilepsy. “It’s super important to start the treatment early, but oftentimes, these symptoms are just misrecognized by primary care or ER physicians. It takes a long time to diagnose,” said Gadi Miron, MD, who presented the study at the American Epilepsy Society (AES) 78th Annual Meeting 2024.

 

What Is This? What Should I Do?

Parents who observe unusual behavior often seek advice from friends and family members and receive false reassurance that such behavior isn’t unusual. Even physicians may contribute if they are unaware of infantile spasms, which is a rare disorder. “And then again, they get false reassurance, and because of that false reassurance, you get a diagnostic delay,” said Shaun Hussain, MD, who was asked to comment on the study.

The timing and frequency of infantile spasms create challenges for diagnosis. They only last about 1 second, and they tend to cluster in the morning. By the time a caregiver brings an infant to a healthcare provider, they may have trouble describing the behavior. “Parents are struggling to describe what they saw, and it often just does not resonate, or doesn’t make the healthcare provider think about infantile spasms,” said Hussain.

The idea to employ AI came from looking at videos of infants on YouTube and the realization that many patients upload them in an effort to seek advice. “So many parents upload these videos and ask in the comments, ‘What is this? What should I do? Can somebody help me?’ said Miron, who is a neurologist and researcher at Charité — Universitätsmedizin Berlin in Germany.

 

AI and Video Can Aid Diagnosis

The researchers built a model that they trained to recognize epileptic spasms using openly available YouTube videos, including 141 infants, 991 recorded seizures, and 597 non-seizure video segments, along with a non-seizure cohort of 127 infants with an accompanying 1385 video segments.

Each video segment was reviewed by two specialists, and they had to agree for it to be counted as an epileptic spasm.

The model detected epileptic seizures with an area under the curve (AUC) of 0.96. It had a sensitivity of 82%, specificity of 90%, and accuracy of 85% when applied to the training set.

The researchers then tested it against three validation sets. In the first, a smartphone-based set retrieved from TikTok of 26 infants with 70 epileptic spasms and 31 non-seizure 5-second video segments, the model had an AUC of 0.98, a sensitivity of 89%, a specificity of 100%, and an accuracy of 92%.

A second smartphone-based set of 67 infants, drawn from YouTube, showed a false detection rate of 0.75% (five detections out of 666 video segments). A third dataset collected from in-hospital EEG monitoring of 21 infants without seizures revealed a false-positive rate of 3.4% (365 of 10,860 video segments).

The group is now developing an app that will allow parents to upload videos that can be analyzed using the model. Physicians can then view the video and determine if there is suspicion of a seizure.

Miron also believes that this approach could find use in other types of seizures and populations, including older children and adults. “We have actually built some models for detection of seizures for videos in adults as well. Looking more towards the future, I’m sure AI will be used to analyze videos of other neurological disorders with motor symptoms [such as] movement disorders and gait,” he said.

 

Encouraging Early Research

Hussain, who is a professor of pediatrics at UCLA Health, lauded the work generally but emphasized that it is still in the early stage. “Their comparison was a relatively easy one. They’re just comparing normal versus infantile spasms, and they’re looking at the seizure versus normal behavior. Usually, the distinction is much harder in that there are kids who are having behaviors that are maybe other types of seizures, which is much harder to distinguish from infantile spasms, in contrast to just normal behaviors. The other mimic of infantile spasms is things like infant heartburn. Those kids will often have some posturing, and they often will be in pain. They might cry. That’s something that infantile spasms will often generate, so that’s why there’s a lot of confusion between those two,” said Hussain.

He noted that there have been efforts to raise awareness of infantile spasms among physicians and the general public, but that hasn’t reduced the increased detection.

 

Another Resource

In fact, parents with suspicions often go to social media sites like YouTube and a Facebook group dedicated to infantile spasms. “You can Google infantile spasms, and you’ll see examples of weird behaviors, and then you’ll look in the comments, and you’ll see this commenter said: ‘These could be infantile spasms. You should go to a children’s hospital. Don’t leave until you get an EEG to make sure that these are not seizures. There’s all kinds of great advice there, and it really shouldn’t be the situation where to get the best care, you need to go on YouTube,’ ” said Hussain.

Miron and Hussain had no relevant financial disclosures.

A version of this article first appeared on Medscape.com.

LOS ANGELES — Artificial intelligence (AI) analysis of caregiver-recorded videos has the potential to diagnose infantile epileptic spasm syndrome, according to a new study.

Infants with the condition can have poor outcomes with even small delays in diagnosis and ensuing treatment, potentially leading to intellectual disability, autism, and worse epilepsy. “It’s super important to start the treatment early, but oftentimes, these symptoms are just misrecognized by primary care or ER physicians. It takes a long time to diagnose,” said Gadi Miron, MD, who presented the study at the American Epilepsy Society (AES) 78th Annual Meeting 2024.

 

What Is This? What Should I Do?

Parents who observe unusual behavior often seek advice from friends and family members and receive false reassurance that such behavior isn’t unusual. Even physicians may contribute if they are unaware of infantile spasms, which is a rare disorder. “And then again, they get false reassurance, and because of that false reassurance, you get a diagnostic delay,” said Shaun Hussain, MD, who was asked to comment on the study.

The timing and frequency of infantile spasms create challenges for diagnosis. They only last about 1 second, and they tend to cluster in the morning. By the time a caregiver brings an infant to a healthcare provider, they may have trouble describing the behavior. “Parents are struggling to describe what they saw, and it often just does not resonate, or doesn’t make the healthcare provider think about infantile spasms,” said Hussain.

The idea to employ AI came from looking at videos of infants on YouTube and the realization that many patients upload them in an effort to seek advice. “So many parents upload these videos and ask in the comments, ‘What is this? What should I do? Can somebody help me?’ said Miron, who is a neurologist and researcher at Charité — Universitätsmedizin Berlin in Germany.

 

AI and Video Can Aid Diagnosis

The researchers built a model that they trained to recognize epileptic spasms using openly available YouTube videos, including 141 infants, 991 recorded seizures, and 597 non-seizure video segments, along with a non-seizure cohort of 127 infants with an accompanying 1385 video segments.

Each video segment was reviewed by two specialists, and they had to agree for it to be counted as an epileptic spasm.

The model detected epileptic seizures with an area under the curve (AUC) of 0.96. It had a sensitivity of 82%, specificity of 90%, and accuracy of 85% when applied to the training set.

The researchers then tested it against three validation sets. In the first, a smartphone-based set retrieved from TikTok of 26 infants with 70 epileptic spasms and 31 non-seizure 5-second video segments, the model had an AUC of 0.98, a sensitivity of 89%, a specificity of 100%, and an accuracy of 92%.

A second smartphone-based set of 67 infants, drawn from YouTube, showed a false detection rate of 0.75% (five detections out of 666 video segments). A third dataset collected from in-hospital EEG monitoring of 21 infants without seizures revealed a false-positive rate of 3.4% (365 of 10,860 video segments).

The group is now developing an app that will allow parents to upload videos that can be analyzed using the model. Physicians can then view the video and determine if there is suspicion of a seizure.

Miron also believes that this approach could find use in other types of seizures and populations, including older children and adults. “We have actually built some models for detection of seizures for videos in adults as well. Looking more towards the future, I’m sure AI will be used to analyze videos of other neurological disorders with motor symptoms [such as] movement disorders and gait,” he said.

 

Encouraging Early Research

Hussain, who is a professor of pediatrics at UCLA Health, lauded the work generally but emphasized that it is still in the early stage. “Their comparison was a relatively easy one. They’re just comparing normal versus infantile spasms, and they’re looking at the seizure versus normal behavior. Usually, the distinction is much harder in that there are kids who are having behaviors that are maybe other types of seizures, which is much harder to distinguish from infantile spasms, in contrast to just normal behaviors. The other mimic of infantile spasms is things like infant heartburn. Those kids will often have some posturing, and they often will be in pain. They might cry. That’s something that infantile spasms will often generate, so that’s why there’s a lot of confusion between those two,” said Hussain.

He noted that there have been efforts to raise awareness of infantile spasms among physicians and the general public, but that hasn’t reduced the increased detection.

 

Another Resource

In fact, parents with suspicions often go to social media sites like YouTube and a Facebook group dedicated to infantile spasms. “You can Google infantile spasms, and you’ll see examples of weird behaviors, and then you’ll look in the comments, and you’ll see this commenter said: ‘These could be infantile spasms. You should go to a children’s hospital. Don’t leave until you get an EEG to make sure that these are not seizures. There’s all kinds of great advice there, and it really shouldn’t be the situation where to get the best care, you need to go on YouTube,’ ” said Hussain.

Miron and Hussain had no relevant financial disclosures.

A version of this article first appeared on Medscape.com.

Interleukin-6 receptor (IL-6r) inhibition is a promising approach for the treatment of calcium pyrophosphate deposition disease (CPPD), although no prospective studies have been conducted to date. Nevertheless, a retrospective analysis of patients treated with the IL-6r inhibitor tocilizumab, presented at American College of Rheumatology (ACR) 2024 Annual Meeting, showed improved CPPD control in more than two thirds of patients who had failed or could not tolerate usual therapies.

Both the monosodium urate (MSU) crystals associated with gout and CPP crystals induce inflammation dependent on IL-1 beta, but IL-1 beta inhibitors have been investigated more as treatments for gout than for CPPD, and they are recommended by both ACR and European Alliance of Associations for Rheumatology (EULAR) guidelines for patients with gout who have flares despite efforts to treat with colchicine, nonsteroidal anti-inflammatory drugs, and corticosteroids. However, IL-1 beta inhibitors are sometimes used off label in CPPD.

There are similarities among the various crystal types that induce arthritis, typically producing similar clinical features of acute arthritis and severe pain and local inflammation and tending to self-resolve within days to weeks. Those shared clinical features suggest common inflammatory mechanisms, likely stemming from the innate immune system, said Augustin Latourte, MD, PhD, of Lariboisière Hospital, Paris, France, during a talk on the topic at the annual research symposium of the Gout Hyperuricemia and Crystal-Associated Disease Network (G-CAN).

CPPD management is generally derived from strategies developed for gout, but there is little evidence supporting IL-1 beta inhibitors outside of case reports, he said. One clinical trial published in 2020 showed efficacy of the IL-1 inhibitor anakinra, but the study was halted due to low patient recruitment, resulting in a small study population. In that study, “anakinra seems to have a faster onset of action than prednisone and could be useful in specific situations regarding acute CPPD arthritis. But it’s not relevant for chronic CPPD arthritis when you have persistent polyarthritis requiring chronic treatment. Anakinra requires daily injections and may not be appropriate in this situation,” he said.

IL-6r inhibition has been studied since IL-6 was first discovered in 1989 as a mediator of inflammatory responses in gout and CPPD, when it was shown that both CPP and MSU crystals can stimulate its production. In monocytes, IL-6 is expressed at higher levels than IL-1 beta in response to both CPP and MSU crystals. IL-6 production in monocytes in response to crystals is dependent on IL-1, and IL-1 inhibition reduces IL-6 production. “So the hypothesis is that IL-1 beta is the first event, and the production of IL-6 and the amplification of crystal inflammation occurs downstream before the self-limitation of the crystal-induced arthritis. IL-6 may be a very important event in the onset of crystal-induced inflammation,” Latourte said.

 

Building on Mechanistic Insights to Test Off-Label Use of Tocilizumab

Inspired by this insight, Latourte’s group tested tocilizumab in a 28-year-old man with a familial ANKH mutation who had not responded to anakinra and other conventional treatments. The patient experienced a reduction in flare intensity in the first month after the initial treatment and no flares after the second tocilizumab infusion. The group went on to test tocilizumab in 10 additional patients with CPPD (median age, 62.5 years), including 6 with idiopathic CPPD, 3 with Gitelman syndrome, and 1 with ANKH mutation. The clinical presentation included four with recurrent acute arthritis and six with chronic polyarthritis, and all had x-ray–proven disease, with a median visual analog scale (VAS) of 60 mm out of 100 mm. Tocilizumab was administered intravenously or subcutaneously. At 3 months, there was a median improvement of 30 mm in the VAS. Treatment efficacy continued for a median follow-up of 5.5 months at the time of publication, and the researchers have noted ongoing efficacy out to 50 months for some patients.

Tocilizumab has gone on to more frequent use in Europe as a second- or third-line therapy for CPPD, which led Latourte and his colleagues to perform the retrospective analysis that they presented at the ACR meeting. It included 55 patients who received tocilizumab for chronic inflammatory CPPD at two university hospitals. Participants had a median age of 72 years, and 67.3% were women. The patient group included 39 with chronic CPPD, 14 with recurrent acute CPPD (who experienced 0-4 attacks per month), and two patients with mixed CPPD. All participants had been treated with colchicine, and 20 had been treated also with prednisone and 24 with anakinra. Patients had stopped anakinra because it was either ineffective (n = 13) or poorly tolerated (n = 11).

Tocilizumab was administered intravenously in 46 patients and subcutaneously in nine patients for a median duration of 16.5 months (range, 0.8-76.4 months). The median VAS for pain (0- to 100-mm scale) dropped from 60 mm at baseline to 40 mm at 3 months and 30 mm at 6 months. There were 21 adverse events, including 8 cytopenias, 6 transaminase elevations, 4 infections (two severe), and 3 injection-site reactions. After a median of 7.8 months, 26 patients discontinued tocilizumab because of lack of efficacy in 15 patients and intolerance in 11. Among those who continued on tocilizumab, the median length of treatment was 26.0 months (range, 3-76.5 months).

 

Comments on the Study

The study population had some unusual characteristics, according to G-CAN President Robert Terkeltaub, MD, who was asked to comment on the study. “Almost half the patients had received anakinra and then, basically, they failed. In about half of the people who got anakinra, it didn’t work, and in the other half, it wasn’t well tolerated. It’s just rather odd. I find anakinra reasonably well tolerated by people, but we’re dealing with an older population of patients, and the subcutaneous administration of anakinra sometimes can give you injection site reactions, but people started off with a pain level that was close to what we register as severe pain, and the pain level decreased,” he said.

Treatment decisions can be difficult in patients with chronic or acute recurrent CPPD, said Terkeltaub, professor of medicine at the University of California, San Diego. “What’s the lesser evil? Putting people on chronic prednisone is really hard on patients or using a biologic that’s more of an immunologic scalpel here, and more selective, and trying to get people through a long course of therapy. If you have chronic arthritis, it took a while for it to get chronic, and it generally doesn’t go away overnight.”

Terkeltaub also pointed out the gastrointestinal side effects of IL-6r inhibitors, which can include diverticulitis, but there are also concerns over infections and lipid and liver abnormalities. Subcutaneously injected tocilizumab also has a longer half-life than something like anakinra.

Beyond the retrospective nature of the study and the limits it imposes on conclusions that can be drawn, Terkeltaub noted a lack of data on the number of “inflamed joints [in each patient] and what the functioning of the patients was.”

Still, the findings are encouraging. “What I can glean from this study is that the first biologic drug might be an IL-6 inhibitor, but you really need prospective, controlled, blinded clinical trials to know, and it’s hard. It’s just hard to do those trials” because patients tend to be of advanced age, Terkeltaub said.

Latourte said a randomized controlled trial of tocilizumab vs placebo, called TociCCAre, is planned to begin in France in 2025.

Latourte has financial relationships with Fresenius Kabi, Roche Chugai, AbbVie, Arsylab, Celltrion, Janssen, Nordic, Pfizer, UCB, Amgen, Biogen, Galapagos, and Eli Lilly. Terkeltaub had no relevant financial disclosures.

A version of this article appeared on Medscape.com.

Interleukin-6 receptor (IL-6r) inhibition is a promising approach for the treatment of calcium pyrophosphate deposition disease (CPPD), although no prospective studies have been conducted to date. Nevertheless, a retrospective analysis of patients treated with the IL-6r inhibitor tocilizumab, presented at American College of Rheumatology (ACR) 2024 Annual Meeting, showed improved CPPD control in more than two thirds of patients who had failed or could not tolerate usual therapies.

Both the monosodium urate (MSU) crystals associated with gout and CPP crystals induce inflammation dependent on IL-1 beta, but IL-1 beta inhibitors have been investigated more as treatments for gout than for CPPD, and they are recommended by both ACR and European Alliance of Associations for Rheumatology (EULAR) guidelines for patients with gout who have flares despite efforts to treat with colchicine, nonsteroidal anti-inflammatory drugs, and corticosteroids. However, IL-1 beta inhibitors are sometimes used off label in CPPD.

There are similarities among the various crystal types that induce arthritis, typically producing similar clinical features of acute arthritis and severe pain and local inflammation and tending to self-resolve within days to weeks. Those shared clinical features suggest common inflammatory mechanisms, likely stemming from the innate immune system, said Augustin Latourte, MD, PhD, of Lariboisière Hospital, Paris, France, during a talk on the topic at the annual research symposium of the Gout Hyperuricemia and Crystal-Associated Disease Network (G-CAN).

CPPD management is generally derived from strategies developed for gout, but there is little evidence supporting IL-1 beta inhibitors outside of case reports, he said. One clinical trial published in 2020 showed efficacy of the IL-1 inhibitor anakinra, but the study was halted due to low patient recruitment, resulting in a small study population. In that study, “anakinra seems to have a faster onset of action than prednisone and could be useful in specific situations regarding acute CPPD arthritis. But it’s not relevant for chronic CPPD arthritis when you have persistent polyarthritis requiring chronic treatment. Anakinra requires daily injections and may not be appropriate in this situation,” he said.

IL-6r inhibition has been studied since IL-6 was first discovered in 1989 as a mediator of inflammatory responses in gout and CPPD, when it was shown that both CPP and MSU crystals can stimulate its production. In monocytes, IL-6 is expressed at higher levels than IL-1 beta in response to both CPP and MSU crystals. IL-6 production in monocytes in response to crystals is dependent on IL-1, and IL-1 inhibition reduces IL-6 production. “So the hypothesis is that IL-1 beta is the first event, and the production of IL-6 and the amplification of crystal inflammation occurs downstream before the self-limitation of the crystal-induced arthritis. IL-6 may be a very important event in the onset of crystal-induced inflammation,” Latourte said.

 

Building on Mechanistic Insights to Test Off-Label Use of Tocilizumab

Inspired by this insight, Latourte’s group tested tocilizumab in a 28-year-old man with a familial ANKH mutation who had not responded to anakinra and other conventional treatments. The patient experienced a reduction in flare intensity in the first month after the initial treatment and no flares after the second tocilizumab infusion. The group went on to test tocilizumab in 10 additional patients with CPPD (median age, 62.5 years), including 6 with idiopathic CPPD, 3 with Gitelman syndrome, and 1 with ANKH mutation. The clinical presentation included four with recurrent acute arthritis and six with chronic polyarthritis, and all had x-ray–proven disease, with a median visual analog scale (VAS) of 60 mm out of 100 mm. Tocilizumab was administered intravenously or subcutaneously. At 3 months, there was a median improvement of 30 mm in the VAS. Treatment efficacy continued for a median follow-up of 5.5 months at the time of publication, and the researchers have noted ongoing efficacy out to 50 months for some patients.

Tocilizumab has gone on to more frequent use in Europe as a second- or third-line therapy for CPPD, which led Latourte and his colleagues to perform the retrospective analysis that they presented at the ACR meeting. It included 55 patients who received tocilizumab for chronic inflammatory CPPD at two university hospitals. Participants had a median age of 72 years, and 67.3% were women. The patient group included 39 with chronic CPPD, 14 with recurrent acute CPPD (who experienced 0-4 attacks per month), and two patients with mixed CPPD. All participants had been treated with colchicine, and 20 had been treated also with prednisone and 24 with anakinra. Patients had stopped anakinra because it was either ineffective (n = 13) or poorly tolerated (n = 11).

Tocilizumab was administered intravenously in 46 patients and subcutaneously in nine patients for a median duration of 16.5 months (range, 0.8-76.4 months). The median VAS for pain (0- to 100-mm scale) dropped from 60 mm at baseline to 40 mm at 3 months and 30 mm at 6 months. There were 21 adverse events, including 8 cytopenias, 6 transaminase elevations, 4 infections (two severe), and 3 injection-site reactions. After a median of 7.8 months, 26 patients discontinued tocilizumab because of lack of efficacy in 15 patients and intolerance in 11. Among those who continued on tocilizumab, the median length of treatment was 26.0 months (range, 3-76.5 months).

 

Comments on the Study

The study population had some unusual characteristics, according to G-CAN President Robert Terkeltaub, MD, who was asked to comment on the study. “Almost half the patients had received anakinra and then, basically, they failed. In about half of the people who got anakinra, it didn’t work, and in the other half, it wasn’t well tolerated. It’s just rather odd. I find anakinra reasonably well tolerated by people, but we’re dealing with an older population of patients, and the subcutaneous administration of anakinra sometimes can give you injection site reactions, but people started off with a pain level that was close to what we register as severe pain, and the pain level decreased,” he said.

Treatment decisions can be difficult in patients with chronic or acute recurrent CPPD, said Terkeltaub, professor of medicine at the University of California, San Diego. “What’s the lesser evil? Putting people on chronic prednisone is really hard on patients or using a biologic that’s more of an immunologic scalpel here, and more selective, and trying to get people through a long course of therapy. If you have chronic arthritis, it took a while for it to get chronic, and it generally doesn’t go away overnight.”

Terkeltaub also pointed out the gastrointestinal side effects of IL-6r inhibitors, which can include diverticulitis, but there are also concerns over infections and lipid and liver abnormalities. Subcutaneously injected tocilizumab also has a longer half-life than something like anakinra.

Beyond the retrospective nature of the study and the limits it imposes on conclusions that can be drawn, Terkeltaub noted a lack of data on the number of “inflamed joints [in each patient] and what the functioning of the patients was.”

Still, the findings are encouraging. “What I can glean from this study is that the first biologic drug might be an IL-6 inhibitor, but you really need prospective, controlled, blinded clinical trials to know, and it’s hard. It’s just hard to do those trials” because patients tend to be of advanced age, Terkeltaub said.

Latourte said a randomized controlled trial of tocilizumab vs placebo, called TociCCAre, is planned to begin in France in 2025.

Latourte has financial relationships with Fresenius Kabi, Roche Chugai, AbbVie, Arsylab, Celltrion, Janssen, Nordic, Pfizer, UCB, Amgen, Biogen, Galapagos, and Eli Lilly. Terkeltaub had no relevant financial disclosures.

A version of this article appeared on Medscape.com.

Interleukin-6 receptor (IL-6r) inhibition is a promising approach for the treatment of calcium pyrophosphate deposition disease (CPPD), although no prospective studies have been conducted to date. Nevertheless, a retrospective analysis of patients treated with the IL-6r inhibitor tocilizumab, presented at American College of Rheumatology (ACR) 2024 Annual Meeting, showed improved CPPD control in more than two thirds of patients who had failed or could not tolerate usual therapies.

Both the monosodium urate (MSU) crystals associated with gout and CPP crystals induce inflammation dependent on IL-1 beta, but IL-1 beta inhibitors have been investigated more as treatments for gout than for CPPD, and they are recommended by both ACR and European Alliance of Associations for Rheumatology (EULAR) guidelines for patients with gout who have flares despite efforts to treat with colchicine, nonsteroidal anti-inflammatory drugs, and corticosteroids. However, IL-1 beta inhibitors are sometimes used off label in CPPD.

There are similarities among the various crystal types that induce arthritis, typically producing similar clinical features of acute arthritis and severe pain and local inflammation and tending to self-resolve within days to weeks. Those shared clinical features suggest common inflammatory mechanisms, likely stemming from the innate immune system, said Augustin Latourte, MD, PhD, of Lariboisière Hospital, Paris, France, during a talk on the topic at the annual research symposium of the Gout Hyperuricemia and Crystal-Associated Disease Network (G-CAN).

CPPD management is generally derived from strategies developed for gout, but there is little evidence supporting IL-1 beta inhibitors outside of case reports, he said. One clinical trial published in 2020 showed efficacy of the IL-1 inhibitor anakinra, but the study was halted due to low patient recruitment, resulting in a small study population. In that study, “anakinra seems to have a faster onset of action than prednisone and could be useful in specific situations regarding acute CPPD arthritis. But it’s not relevant for chronic CPPD arthritis when you have persistent polyarthritis requiring chronic treatment. Anakinra requires daily injections and may not be appropriate in this situation,” he said.

IL-6r inhibition has been studied since IL-6 was first discovered in 1989 as a mediator of inflammatory responses in gout and CPPD, when it was shown that both CPP and MSU crystals can stimulate its production. In monocytes, IL-6 is expressed at higher levels than IL-1 beta in response to both CPP and MSU crystals. IL-6 production in monocytes in response to crystals is dependent on IL-1, and IL-1 inhibition reduces IL-6 production. “So the hypothesis is that IL-1 beta is the first event, and the production of IL-6 and the amplification of crystal inflammation occurs downstream before the self-limitation of the crystal-induced arthritis. IL-6 may be a very important event in the onset of crystal-induced inflammation,” Latourte said.

 

Building on Mechanistic Insights to Test Off-Label Use of Tocilizumab

Inspired by this insight, Latourte’s group tested tocilizumab in a 28-year-old man with a familial ANKH mutation who had not responded to anakinra and other conventional treatments. The patient experienced a reduction in flare intensity in the first month after the initial treatment and no flares after the second tocilizumab infusion. The group went on to test tocilizumab in 10 additional patients with CPPD (median age, 62.5 years), including 6 with idiopathic CPPD, 3 with Gitelman syndrome, and 1 with ANKH mutation. The clinical presentation included four with recurrent acute arthritis and six with chronic polyarthritis, and all had x-ray–proven disease, with a median visual analog scale (VAS) of 60 mm out of 100 mm. Tocilizumab was administered intravenously or subcutaneously. At 3 months, there was a median improvement of 30 mm in the VAS. Treatment efficacy continued for a median follow-up of 5.5 months at the time of publication, and the researchers have noted ongoing efficacy out to 50 months for some patients.

Tocilizumab has gone on to more frequent use in Europe as a second- or third-line therapy for CPPD, which led Latourte and his colleagues to perform the retrospective analysis that they presented at the ACR meeting. It included 55 patients who received tocilizumab for chronic inflammatory CPPD at two university hospitals. Participants had a median age of 72 years, and 67.3% were women. The patient group included 39 with chronic CPPD, 14 with recurrent acute CPPD (who experienced 0-4 attacks per month), and two patients with mixed CPPD. All participants had been treated with colchicine, and 20 had been treated also with prednisone and 24 with anakinra. Patients had stopped anakinra because it was either ineffective (n = 13) or poorly tolerated (n = 11).

Tocilizumab was administered intravenously in 46 patients and subcutaneously in nine patients for a median duration of 16.5 months (range, 0.8-76.4 months). The median VAS for pain (0- to 100-mm scale) dropped from 60 mm at baseline to 40 mm at 3 months and 30 mm at 6 months. There were 21 adverse events, including 8 cytopenias, 6 transaminase elevations, 4 infections (two severe), and 3 injection-site reactions. After a median of 7.8 months, 26 patients discontinued tocilizumab because of lack of efficacy in 15 patients and intolerance in 11. Among those who continued on tocilizumab, the median length of treatment was 26.0 months (range, 3-76.5 months).

 

Comments on the Study

The study population had some unusual characteristics, according to G-CAN President Robert Terkeltaub, MD, who was asked to comment on the study. “Almost half the patients had received anakinra and then, basically, they failed. In about half of the people who got anakinra, it didn’t work, and in the other half, it wasn’t well tolerated. It’s just rather odd. I find anakinra reasonably well tolerated by people, but we’re dealing with an older population of patients, and the subcutaneous administration of anakinra sometimes can give you injection site reactions, but people started off with a pain level that was close to what we register as severe pain, and the pain level decreased,” he said.

Treatment decisions can be difficult in patients with chronic or acute recurrent CPPD, said Terkeltaub, professor of medicine at the University of California, San Diego. “What’s the lesser evil? Putting people on chronic prednisone is really hard on patients or using a biologic that’s more of an immunologic scalpel here, and more selective, and trying to get people through a long course of therapy. If you have chronic arthritis, it took a while for it to get chronic, and it generally doesn’t go away overnight.”

Terkeltaub also pointed out the gastrointestinal side effects of IL-6r inhibitors, which can include diverticulitis, but there are also concerns over infections and lipid and liver abnormalities. Subcutaneously injected tocilizumab also has a longer half-life than something like anakinra.

Beyond the retrospective nature of the study and the limits it imposes on conclusions that can be drawn, Terkeltaub noted a lack of data on the number of “inflamed joints [in each patient] and what the functioning of the patients was.”

Still, the findings are encouraging. “What I can glean from this study is that the first biologic drug might be an IL-6 inhibitor, but you really need prospective, controlled, blinded clinical trials to know, and it’s hard. It’s just hard to do those trials” because patients tend to be of advanced age, Terkeltaub said.

Latourte said a randomized controlled trial of tocilizumab vs placebo, called TociCCAre, is planned to begin in France in 2025.

Latourte has financial relationships with Fresenius Kabi, Roche Chugai, AbbVie, Arsylab, Celltrion, Janssen, Nordic, Pfizer, UCB, Amgen, Biogen, Galapagos, and Eli Lilly. Terkeltaub had no relevant financial disclosures.

A version of this article appeared on Medscape.com.

For gout, xanthine oxidase (XO) inhibitors are the choice for first-line urate-lowering therapy (ULT) according to the 2020 American College of Rheumatology Guideline for the Management of Gout, which endorsed allopurinol, but should that be the approach for all patients, or should first-line therapy be tailored to the mechanism of each patient’s hyperuricemia? Two gout experts, Lisa Stamp, MBChB, PhD, a rheumatologist and professor of medicine at the University of Otago in Christchurch, New Zealand, and Fernando Pérez-Ruiz, MD, PhD, consultant in the Rheumatology Division of Cruces University Hospital, Barakaldo, head of the Investigation Group for Arthritis at Biocruces Health Research Institute, Barakaldo, and associate professor in the Department of Medicine at the Faculty of Medicine and Nursing at the University of the Basque Country in Leioa, Spain, debated this question recently at the annual research symposium of the Gout, Hyperuricemia and Crystal-Associated Disease Network.

Before the debate began, audience members voted on the question and 56% favored using XO inhibitors as a first-line therapy for all rather than tailoring first-line therapy to disease mechanism.

Up first, Stamp argued that XO inhibitors should be first-line therapy for all patients with gout. She said that XO inhibitors have been demonstrated to work regardless of the cause of hyperuricemia and degree of kidney function, and they are cheap, readily available, and easy to administer. She showed results from a study published by her debate opponent, Pérez-Ruiz, which demonstrated efficacy of XO inhibitors in both under-excreters and over-excreters of uric acid. That study compared the efficacy of the XO inhibitor allopurinol to the uricosuric agent benzbromarone and found the latter to be more effective, but Stamp argued that the allopurinol dose used in the study — 300 mg/d — “may not be enough for many patients who have gout. Dose-restricting allopurinol is one way to demonstrate that an alternative agent is superior,” she said.

A more recent study showed low-dose benzbromarone was better than low-dose febuxostat, another XO inhibitor. “I think we do need to have clinical trials that reflect real-world practice. I accept that this may have reflected [accepted practice where the studies] were undertaken, but these [XO inhibitor] doses don’t represent what many of us would do in other parts of the world,” Stamp said.

One concern is the utility of a ULT in patients with impaired renal function. Stamp cited her own post hoc analysis of a randomized, controlled trial showing that allopurinol is effective irrespective of renal function, as long as the dose is escalated to achieve target urate level, and a meta-analysis of observational studies suggesting that febuxostat is effective irrespective of renal function.

On the other hand, she showed data from a 1994 study of benzbromarone in renal transplant recipients, which showed that the drug’s effect on decreasing plasma uric acid dropped off significantly with lower creatinine clearance. “It does work, but the efficacy really drops off as renal function decreases. Benzbromarone is probably the most effective uricosuric in patients with renal impairment, but this agent is not readily available,” Stamp said.

The uricosuric agent probenecid, which is generally available across the world, led to only about 30% success in achieving target levels of uric acid among patients with an estimated glomerular filtration rate < 50 mL/min/1.73 m². “I think we can all agree that getting 30% of our patients to target uric acid is not an acceptable outcome,” she said.

Stamp emphasized the importance of drug availability and noted that allopurinol is also the only medication for gout that is on the World Health Organization list of essential medications. “I think we should be recommending medications that are readily available, irrespective of where you live,” she said, noting that this is true of allopurinol, febuxostat, and probenecid.

Stamp also addressed the mechanism of action of ULTs. “Does the cause of hyperuricemia affect treatment response? I don’t think it does. Most people respond to allopurinol whether they’re a normal excreter or an under-excreter. Everyone who is lacking uricase will respond to allopurinol. Not everyone will respond to a uricosuric [agent], particularly in the setting of comorbidities such as renal impairment, which many of our patients with gout have,” she said.

 

Counterargument: Combine Therapies With Different Mechanisms of Action

In his counterargument, Pérez-Ruiz contended that gout is not in fact a metabolic disease and suggested that combining therapies with different mechanisms of action could be the best approach for difficult-to-treat gout. “The problem we face in clinical practice is how to treat difficult-to-treat patients,” he said. He referenced his own PhD thesis, which showed both high urinary uric acid output and underexcretion among patients with gout.

Pérez-Ruiz agreed that XO inhibitors should be used as first-line therapy but noted that the effect of allopurinol tapers off at higher doses. “If you use very high doses of allopurinol, you cannot expect to get much more effect,” he said. This is also true of febuxostat, he said.

He showed another study that illustrated difficulties in achieving target serum urate level with intensive therapy. “Even using a high dose of allopurinol, if you would like to get lower than 3 mg/dL for intensive therapy, close to 50% of patients will fail,” he said.

Pérez-Ruiz described a strategy of combining XO inhibitors with a uricosuric therapy, creating what he called a “uricase-like effect” on serum uric acid levels. Ruiz-Perez uses high-dose febuxostat in patients with chronic kidney disease who cannot be given uricosuric agents. “You can go to very low [serum urate levels] by raising up the doses,” he said.

He does not believe that allopurinol is the best agent for combination therapy in the treatment of tophaceous deposits. Instead, he favors combinations with febuxostat. He presented his own experience with 12 patients with very severe tophaceous gout who he treated with a combination of febuxostat and benzbromarone, which reduced serum urate to just over 2 mg/dL. “So this is a pegloticase-like effect [that is] very useful for tophaceous gout,” he said.

In her response, Stamp noted that most of the studies presented by Pérez-Ruiz showed XO inhibitors as first-line therapies, with other medications added on. “I think I heard Fernando agree with me. In just about all of those slides, he showed that a xanthine oxidase inhibitor was the first-line therapy, and subsequently a uricosuric was added,” she said.

Still, Stamp took issue with the idea that serum urate needs to get as low as Pérez-Ruiz advocated for. “What’s the risk associated with getting a serum urate to that level? I’m not sure that a sustained serum urate of around 1 [mg/dL] is necessarily good in the long term,” she said.

Stamp also pointed out the potential risks of polypharmacy, along with adherence issues. “If we can give our patients one therapy, one drug that’s going to get them to a target that we know is going to have beneficial long-term effects, that’s going to help improve our adherence. Maybe we are coming to a new era of [treatment, with] remission induction driving the serum urate very low, and then a maintenance therapy where we can back off. But irrespective, if you use that strategy, Fernando nicely showed that every time you’re going to start with a xanthine oxidase inhibitor,” she said.

After the debate, audience members voted again, and this time the result was 66% in favor of XO inhibitors as a first-line treatment.

Pérez-Ruiz is an adviser for Arthrosi, LG, Novartis, Protalix, and SOBI. He is a speaker for Menarini Central America and the Spanish Foundation for Rheumatology and has received funding from Cruces Rheumatology Association. Stamp did not disclose any financial relationships.

A version of this article first appeared on Medscape.com.

For gout, xanthine oxidase (XO) inhibitors are the choice for first-line urate-lowering therapy (ULT) according to the 2020 American College of Rheumatology Guideline for the Management of Gout, which endorsed allopurinol, but should that be the approach for all patients, or should first-line therapy be tailored to the mechanism of each patient’s hyperuricemia? Two gout experts, Lisa Stamp, MBChB, PhD, a rheumatologist and professor of medicine at the University of Otago in Christchurch, New Zealand, and Fernando Pérez-Ruiz, MD, PhD, consultant in the Rheumatology Division of Cruces University Hospital, Barakaldo, head of the Investigation Group for Arthritis at Biocruces Health Research Institute, Barakaldo, and associate professor in the Department of Medicine at the Faculty of Medicine and Nursing at the University of the Basque Country in Leioa, Spain, debated this question recently at the annual research symposium of the Gout, Hyperuricemia and Crystal-Associated Disease Network.

Before the debate began, audience members voted on the question and 56% favored using XO inhibitors as a first-line therapy for all rather than tailoring first-line therapy to disease mechanism.

Up first, Stamp argued that XO inhibitors should be first-line therapy for all patients with gout. She said that XO inhibitors have been demonstrated to work regardless of the cause of hyperuricemia and degree of kidney function, and they are cheap, readily available, and easy to administer. She showed results from a study published by her debate opponent, Pérez-Ruiz, which demonstrated efficacy of XO inhibitors in both under-excreters and over-excreters of uric acid. That study compared the efficacy of the XO inhibitor allopurinol to the uricosuric agent benzbromarone and found the latter to be more effective, but Stamp argued that the allopurinol dose used in the study — 300 mg/d — “may not be enough for many patients who have gout. Dose-restricting allopurinol is one way to demonstrate that an alternative agent is superior,” she said.

A more recent study showed low-dose benzbromarone was better than low-dose febuxostat, another XO inhibitor. “I think we do need to have clinical trials that reflect real-world practice. I accept that this may have reflected [accepted practice where the studies] were undertaken, but these [XO inhibitor] doses don’t represent what many of us would do in other parts of the world,” Stamp said.

One concern is the utility of a ULT in patients with impaired renal function. Stamp cited her own post hoc analysis of a randomized, controlled trial showing that allopurinol is effective irrespective of renal function, as long as the dose is escalated to achieve target urate level, and a meta-analysis of observational studies suggesting that febuxostat is effective irrespective of renal function.

On the other hand, she showed data from a 1994 study of benzbromarone in renal transplant recipients, which showed that the drug’s effect on decreasing plasma uric acid dropped off significantly with lower creatinine clearance. “It does work, but the efficacy really drops off as renal function decreases. Benzbromarone is probably the most effective uricosuric in patients with renal impairment, but this agent is not readily available,” Stamp said.

The uricosuric agent probenecid, which is generally available across the world, led to only about 30% success in achieving target levels of uric acid among patients with an estimated glomerular filtration rate < 50 mL/min/1.73 m². “I think we can all agree that getting 30% of our patients to target uric acid is not an acceptable outcome,” she said.

Stamp emphasized the importance of drug availability and noted that allopurinol is also the only medication for gout that is on the World Health Organization list of essential medications. “I think we should be recommending medications that are readily available, irrespective of where you live,” she said, noting that this is true of allopurinol, febuxostat, and probenecid.

Stamp also addressed the mechanism of action of ULTs. “Does the cause of hyperuricemia affect treatment response? I don’t think it does. Most people respond to allopurinol whether they’re a normal excreter or an under-excreter. Everyone who is lacking uricase will respond to allopurinol. Not everyone will respond to a uricosuric [agent], particularly in the setting of comorbidities such as renal impairment, which many of our patients with gout have,” she said.

 

Counterargument: Combine Therapies With Different Mechanisms of Action

In his counterargument, Pérez-Ruiz contended that gout is not in fact a metabolic disease and suggested that combining therapies with different mechanisms of action could be the best approach for difficult-to-treat gout. “The problem we face in clinical practice is how to treat difficult-to-treat patients,” he said. He referenced his own PhD thesis, which showed both high urinary uric acid output and underexcretion among patients with gout.

Pérez-Ruiz agreed that XO inhibitors should be used as first-line therapy but noted that the effect of allopurinol tapers off at higher doses. “If you use very high doses of allopurinol, you cannot expect to get much more effect,” he said. This is also true of febuxostat, he said.

He showed another study that illustrated difficulties in achieving target serum urate level with intensive therapy. “Even using a high dose of allopurinol, if you would like to get lower than 3 mg/dL for intensive therapy, close to 50% of patients will fail,” he said.

Pérez-Ruiz described a strategy of combining XO inhibitors with a uricosuric therapy, creating what he called a “uricase-like effect” on serum uric acid levels. Ruiz-Perez uses high-dose febuxostat in patients with chronic kidney disease who cannot be given uricosuric agents. “You can go to very low [serum urate levels] by raising up the doses,” he said.

He does not believe that allopurinol is the best agent for combination therapy in the treatment of tophaceous deposits. Instead, he favors combinations with febuxostat. He presented his own experience with 12 patients with very severe tophaceous gout who he treated with a combination of febuxostat and benzbromarone, which reduced serum urate to just over 2 mg/dL. “So this is a pegloticase-like effect [that is] very useful for tophaceous gout,” he said.

In her response, Stamp noted that most of the studies presented by Pérez-Ruiz showed XO inhibitors as first-line therapies, with other medications added on. “I think I heard Fernando agree with me. In just about all of those slides, he showed that a xanthine oxidase inhibitor was the first-line therapy, and subsequently a uricosuric was added,” she said.

Still, Stamp took issue with the idea that serum urate needs to get as low as Pérez-Ruiz advocated for. “What’s the risk associated with getting a serum urate to that level? I’m not sure that a sustained serum urate of around 1 [mg/dL] is necessarily good in the long term,” she said.

Stamp also pointed out the potential risks of polypharmacy, along with adherence issues. “If we can give our patients one therapy, one drug that’s going to get them to a target that we know is going to have beneficial long-term effects, that’s going to help improve our adherence. Maybe we are coming to a new era of [treatment, with] remission induction driving the serum urate very low, and then a maintenance therapy where we can back off. But irrespective, if you use that strategy, Fernando nicely showed that every time you’re going to start with a xanthine oxidase inhibitor,” she said.

After the debate, audience members voted again, and this time the result was 66% in favor of XO inhibitors as a first-line treatment.

Pérez-Ruiz is an adviser for Arthrosi, LG, Novartis, Protalix, and SOBI. He is a speaker for Menarini Central America and the Spanish Foundation for Rheumatology and has received funding from Cruces Rheumatology Association. Stamp did not disclose any financial relationships.

A version of this article first appeared on Medscape.com.

For gout, xanthine oxidase (XO) inhibitors are the choice for first-line urate-lowering therapy (ULT) according to the 2020 American College of Rheumatology Guideline for the Management of Gout, which endorsed allopurinol, but should that be the approach for all patients, or should first-line therapy be tailored to the mechanism of each patient’s hyperuricemia? Two gout experts, Lisa Stamp, MBChB, PhD, a rheumatologist and professor of medicine at the University of Otago in Christchurch, New Zealand, and Fernando Pérez-Ruiz, MD, PhD, consultant in the Rheumatology Division of Cruces University Hospital, Barakaldo, head of the Investigation Group for Arthritis at Biocruces Health Research Institute, Barakaldo, and associate professor in the Department of Medicine at the Faculty of Medicine and Nursing at the University of the Basque Country in Leioa, Spain, debated this question recently at the annual research symposium of the Gout, Hyperuricemia and Crystal-Associated Disease Network.

Before the debate began, audience members voted on the question and 56% favored using XO inhibitors as a first-line therapy for all rather than tailoring first-line therapy to disease mechanism.

Up first, Stamp argued that XO inhibitors should be first-line therapy for all patients with gout. She said that XO inhibitors have been demonstrated to work regardless of the cause of hyperuricemia and degree of kidney function, and they are cheap, readily available, and easy to administer. She showed results from a study published by her debate opponent, Pérez-Ruiz, which demonstrated efficacy of XO inhibitors in both under-excreters and over-excreters of uric acid. That study compared the efficacy of the XO inhibitor allopurinol to the uricosuric agent benzbromarone and found the latter to be more effective, but Stamp argued that the allopurinol dose used in the study — 300 mg/d — “may not be enough for many patients who have gout. Dose-restricting allopurinol is one way to demonstrate that an alternative agent is superior,” she said.

A more recent study showed low-dose benzbromarone was better than low-dose febuxostat, another XO inhibitor. “I think we do need to have clinical trials that reflect real-world practice. I accept that this may have reflected [accepted practice where the studies] were undertaken, but these [XO inhibitor] doses don’t represent what many of us would do in other parts of the world,” Stamp said.

One concern is the utility of a ULT in patients with impaired renal function. Stamp cited her own post hoc analysis of a randomized, controlled trial showing that allopurinol is effective irrespective of renal function, as long as the dose is escalated to achieve target urate level, and a meta-analysis of observational studies suggesting that febuxostat is effective irrespective of renal function.

On the other hand, she showed data from a 1994 study of benzbromarone in renal transplant recipients, which showed that the drug’s effect on decreasing plasma uric acid dropped off significantly with lower creatinine clearance. “It does work, but the efficacy really drops off as renal function decreases. Benzbromarone is probably the most effective uricosuric in patients with renal impairment, but this agent is not readily available,” Stamp said.

The uricosuric agent probenecid, which is generally available across the world, led to only about 30% success in achieving target levels of uric acid among patients with an estimated glomerular filtration rate < 50 mL/min/1.73 m². “I think we can all agree that getting 30% of our patients to target uric acid is not an acceptable outcome,” she said.

Stamp emphasized the importance of drug availability and noted that allopurinol is also the only medication for gout that is on the World Health Organization list of essential medications. “I think we should be recommending medications that are readily available, irrespective of where you live,” she said, noting that this is true of allopurinol, febuxostat, and probenecid.

Stamp also addressed the mechanism of action of ULTs. “Does the cause of hyperuricemia affect treatment response? I don’t think it does. Most people respond to allopurinol whether they’re a normal excreter or an under-excreter. Everyone who is lacking uricase will respond to allopurinol. Not everyone will respond to a uricosuric [agent], particularly in the setting of comorbidities such as renal impairment, which many of our patients with gout have,” she said.

 

Counterargument: Combine Therapies With Different Mechanisms of Action

In his counterargument, Pérez-Ruiz contended that gout is not in fact a metabolic disease and suggested that combining therapies with different mechanisms of action could be the best approach for difficult-to-treat gout. “The problem we face in clinical practice is how to treat difficult-to-treat patients,” he said. He referenced his own PhD thesis, which showed both high urinary uric acid output and underexcretion among patients with gout.

Pérez-Ruiz agreed that XO inhibitors should be used as first-line therapy but noted that the effect of allopurinol tapers off at higher doses. “If you use very high doses of allopurinol, you cannot expect to get much more effect,” he said. This is also true of febuxostat, he said.

He showed another study that illustrated difficulties in achieving target serum urate level with intensive therapy. “Even using a high dose of allopurinol, if you would like to get lower than 3 mg/dL for intensive therapy, close to 50% of patients will fail,” he said.

Pérez-Ruiz described a strategy of combining XO inhibitors with a uricosuric therapy, creating what he called a “uricase-like effect” on serum uric acid levels. Ruiz-Perez uses high-dose febuxostat in patients with chronic kidney disease who cannot be given uricosuric agents. “You can go to very low [serum urate levels] by raising up the doses,” he said.

He does not believe that allopurinol is the best agent for combination therapy in the treatment of tophaceous deposits. Instead, he favors combinations with febuxostat. He presented his own experience with 12 patients with very severe tophaceous gout who he treated with a combination of febuxostat and benzbromarone, which reduced serum urate to just over 2 mg/dL. “So this is a pegloticase-like effect [that is] very useful for tophaceous gout,” he said.

In her response, Stamp noted that most of the studies presented by Pérez-Ruiz showed XO inhibitors as first-line therapies, with other medications added on. “I think I heard Fernando agree with me. In just about all of those slides, he showed that a xanthine oxidase inhibitor was the first-line therapy, and subsequently a uricosuric was added,” she said.

Still, Stamp took issue with the idea that serum urate needs to get as low as Pérez-Ruiz advocated for. “What’s the risk associated with getting a serum urate to that level? I’m not sure that a sustained serum urate of around 1 [mg/dL] is necessarily good in the long term,” she said.

Stamp also pointed out the potential risks of polypharmacy, along with adherence issues. “If we can give our patients one therapy, one drug that’s going to get them to a target that we know is going to have beneficial long-term effects, that’s going to help improve our adherence. Maybe we are coming to a new era of [treatment, with] remission induction driving the serum urate very low, and then a maintenance therapy where we can back off. But irrespective, if you use that strategy, Fernando nicely showed that every time you’re going to start with a xanthine oxidase inhibitor,” she said.

After the debate, audience members voted again, and this time the result was 66% in favor of XO inhibitors as a first-line treatment.

Pérez-Ruiz is an adviser for Arthrosi, LG, Novartis, Protalix, and SOBI. He is a speaker for Menarini Central America and the Spanish Foundation for Rheumatology and has received funding from Cruces Rheumatology Association. Stamp did not disclose any financial relationships.

A version of this article first appeared on Medscape.com.

LOS ANGELES — Individuals with both uncontrolled epilepsy and sleep apnea are at significantly higher risk for mortality than those with epilepsy alone, according to a new analysis of over 2 million patient-years drawn from the Komodo Health Claims Database.

“A 10-year-old with uncontrolled epilepsy and central sleep apnea is about 200 times more likely to die than a general population 10-year-old. That’s comparable to a 10-year-old with {epilepsy and} congestive heart failure. Noncentral sleep apnea is comparable to being paralyzed. It’s a huge risk factor,” said poster presenter Dan Lloyd, advanced analytics lead at UCB, which sponsored the research.

The ordering of sleep apnea tests for patients with epilepsy is widely variable, according to Stefanie Dedeurwaerdere, PhD, who is the innovation and value creation lead at UCB. “Some doctors do that as a general practice, and some don’t. There’s no coherency in the way these studies are requested for epilepsy patients. We want to create some awareness around this topic,” she said, and added that treatment of sleep apnea may improve epileptic seizures.

The findings were presented at the American Epilepsy Society (AES) 78th Annual Meeting 2024.

The study included mortality rates between January 2018 and December 2022, with a total of 2,355,410 patient-years and 968,993 patients, with an age distribution of 19.1% age 1 to less than 18 years, 23.7% age 18-35 years, and 57.2% age 36 years or older. Sleep apnea prevalences were 0.7% for central sleep apnea (CSA), 14.0% for obstructive sleep apnea (OSA), and 85.3% with no sleep apnea.

Among those aged 1-18 years, the standardized mortality ratio (SMR) for those with uncontrolled epilepsy was 27.7. For those with comorbid OSA, the SMR was 74.2, and for comorbid CSA, the SMR was 135.9. The association was less pronounced in older groups, dipping to 7.0, 11.3, and 19.5 in those aged 18-35 years, and 3.3, 3.1, and 2.8 among those aged 36 years or older.

Among the 1-18 age group, SMRs for other comorbidities included 132.3 for heart failure, 74.9 for hemiplegia/paraplegia, 55.3 for cerebrovascular disease, and 44.6 for chronic pulmonary disease.

Asked for comment, Gordon Buchanan, MD, PhD, welcomed the new work. “The results did not surprise me. I study sleep, epilepsy, and [sudden unexplained death in epilepsy (SUDEP)] in particular ... and every time I speak on these topics, someone asks me about risk of SUDEP in patients with sleep apnea. It’s great to finally have some data,” said Buchanan, a professor of neurology at the University of Iowa, Iowa City.

The authors found that patients undergoing continuous positive airway pressure (CPAP)/bi-level positive airway pressure therapy had a higher mortality risk than those not undergoing CPAP therapy but cautioned that uncontrolled confounders may be contributing to the effect.

Buchanan wondered if treatment with CPAP would be associated with a decreased mortality risk. “I think that would be interesting, but I know that, especially in children, it can be difficult to get them to remain compliant with CPAP. I think that would be interesting to know, if pushing harder to get the kids to comply with CPAP would reduce mortality,” he said.

The specific finding of heightened mortality associated with CSA is interesting, according to Buchanan. “We think of seizures propagating through the brain, maybe through direct synaptic connections or through spreading depolarization. So I think it would make sense that it would hit central regions that would then lead to sleep apnea.” 

The relationship between OSA and epilepsy is likely complex. Epilepsy medications and special diets may influence body composition, which could in turn affect the risk for OSA, as could medications associated with psychiatric comorbidities, according to Buchanan.

The study is retrospective and based on claims data. It does not prove causation, and claims data do not fully capture mortality, which may lead to conservative SMR estimates. The researchers did not control for socioeconomic status, treatment status, and other comorbidities or conditions.

Lloyd and Dedeurwaerdere are employees of UCB, which sponsored the study. Buchanan had no relevant financial disclosures.

A version of this article appeared on Medscape.com.

LOS ANGELES — Individuals with both uncontrolled epilepsy and sleep apnea are at significantly higher risk for mortality than those with epilepsy alone, according to a new analysis of over 2 million patient-years drawn from the Komodo Health Claims Database.

“A 10-year-old with uncontrolled epilepsy and central sleep apnea is about 200 times more likely to die than a general population 10-year-old. That’s comparable to a 10-year-old with {epilepsy and} congestive heart failure. Noncentral sleep apnea is comparable to being paralyzed. It’s a huge risk factor,” said poster presenter Dan Lloyd, advanced analytics lead at UCB, which sponsored the research.

The ordering of sleep apnea tests for patients with epilepsy is widely variable, according to Stefanie Dedeurwaerdere, PhD, who is the innovation and value creation lead at UCB. “Some doctors do that as a general practice, and some don’t. There’s no coherency in the way these studies are requested for epilepsy patients. We want to create some awareness around this topic,” she said, and added that treatment of sleep apnea may improve epileptic seizures.

The findings were presented at the American Epilepsy Society (AES) 78th Annual Meeting 2024.

The study included mortality rates between January 2018 and December 2022, with a total of 2,355,410 patient-years and 968,993 patients, with an age distribution of 19.1% age 1 to less than 18 years, 23.7% age 18-35 years, and 57.2% age 36 years or older. Sleep apnea prevalences were 0.7% for central sleep apnea (CSA), 14.0% for obstructive sleep apnea (OSA), and 85.3% with no sleep apnea.

Among those aged 1-18 years, the standardized mortality ratio (SMR) for those with uncontrolled epilepsy was 27.7. For those with comorbid OSA, the SMR was 74.2, and for comorbid CSA, the SMR was 135.9. The association was less pronounced in older groups, dipping to 7.0, 11.3, and 19.5 in those aged 18-35 years, and 3.3, 3.1, and 2.8 among those aged 36 years or older.

Among the 1-18 age group, SMRs for other comorbidities included 132.3 for heart failure, 74.9 for hemiplegia/paraplegia, 55.3 for cerebrovascular disease, and 44.6 for chronic pulmonary disease.

Asked for comment, Gordon Buchanan, MD, PhD, welcomed the new work. “The results did not surprise me. I study sleep, epilepsy, and [sudden unexplained death in epilepsy (SUDEP)] in particular ... and every time I speak on these topics, someone asks me about risk of SUDEP in patients with sleep apnea. It’s great to finally have some data,” said Buchanan, a professor of neurology at the University of Iowa, Iowa City.

The authors found that patients undergoing continuous positive airway pressure (CPAP)/bi-level positive airway pressure therapy had a higher mortality risk than those not undergoing CPAP therapy but cautioned that uncontrolled confounders may be contributing to the effect.

Buchanan wondered if treatment with CPAP would be associated with a decreased mortality risk. “I think that would be interesting, but I know that, especially in children, it can be difficult to get them to remain compliant with CPAP. I think that would be interesting to know, if pushing harder to get the kids to comply with CPAP would reduce mortality,” he said.

The specific finding of heightened mortality associated with CSA is interesting, according to Buchanan. “We think of seizures propagating through the brain, maybe through direct synaptic connections or through spreading depolarization. So I think it would make sense that it would hit central regions that would then lead to sleep apnea.” 

The relationship between OSA and epilepsy is likely complex. Epilepsy medications and special diets may influence body composition, which could in turn affect the risk for OSA, as could medications associated with psychiatric comorbidities, according to Buchanan.

The study is retrospective and based on claims data. It does not prove causation, and claims data do not fully capture mortality, which may lead to conservative SMR estimates. The researchers did not control for socioeconomic status, treatment status, and other comorbidities or conditions.

Lloyd and Dedeurwaerdere are employees of UCB, which sponsored the study. Buchanan had no relevant financial disclosures.

A version of this article appeared on Medscape.com.

LOS ANGELES — Individuals with both uncontrolled epilepsy and sleep apnea are at significantly higher risk for mortality than those with epilepsy alone, according to a new analysis of over 2 million patient-years drawn from the Komodo Health Claims Database.

“A 10-year-old with uncontrolled epilepsy and central sleep apnea is about 200 times more likely to die than a general population 10-year-old. That’s comparable to a 10-year-old with {epilepsy and} congestive heart failure. Noncentral sleep apnea is comparable to being paralyzed. It’s a huge risk factor,” said poster presenter Dan Lloyd, advanced analytics lead at UCB, which sponsored the research.

The ordering of sleep apnea tests for patients with epilepsy is widely variable, according to Stefanie Dedeurwaerdere, PhD, who is the innovation and value creation lead at UCB. “Some doctors do that as a general practice, and some don’t. There’s no coherency in the way these studies are requested for epilepsy patients. We want to create some awareness around this topic,” she said, and added that treatment of sleep apnea may improve epileptic seizures.

The findings were presented at the American Epilepsy Society (AES) 78th Annual Meeting 2024.

The study included mortality rates between January 2018 and December 2022, with a total of 2,355,410 patient-years and 968,993 patients, with an age distribution of 19.1% age 1 to less than 18 years, 23.7% age 18-35 years, and 57.2% age 36 years or older. Sleep apnea prevalences were 0.7% for central sleep apnea (CSA), 14.0% for obstructive sleep apnea (OSA), and 85.3% with no sleep apnea.

Among those aged 1-18 years, the standardized mortality ratio (SMR) for those with uncontrolled epilepsy was 27.7. For those with comorbid OSA, the SMR was 74.2, and for comorbid CSA, the SMR was 135.9. The association was less pronounced in older groups, dipping to 7.0, 11.3, and 19.5 in those aged 18-35 years, and 3.3, 3.1, and 2.8 among those aged 36 years or older.

Among the 1-18 age group, SMRs for other comorbidities included 132.3 for heart failure, 74.9 for hemiplegia/paraplegia, 55.3 for cerebrovascular disease, and 44.6 for chronic pulmonary disease.

Asked for comment, Gordon Buchanan, MD, PhD, welcomed the new work. “The results did not surprise me. I study sleep, epilepsy, and [sudden unexplained death in epilepsy (SUDEP)] in particular ... and every time I speak on these topics, someone asks me about risk of SUDEP in patients with sleep apnea. It’s great to finally have some data,” said Buchanan, a professor of neurology at the University of Iowa, Iowa City.

The authors found that patients undergoing continuous positive airway pressure (CPAP)/bi-level positive airway pressure therapy had a higher mortality risk than those not undergoing CPAP therapy but cautioned that uncontrolled confounders may be contributing to the effect.

Buchanan wondered if treatment with CPAP would be associated with a decreased mortality risk. “I think that would be interesting, but I know that, especially in children, it can be difficult to get them to remain compliant with CPAP. I think that would be interesting to know, if pushing harder to get the kids to comply with CPAP would reduce mortality,” he said.

The specific finding of heightened mortality associated with CSA is interesting, according to Buchanan. “We think of seizures propagating through the brain, maybe through direct synaptic connections or through spreading depolarization. So I think it would make sense that it would hit central regions that would then lead to sleep apnea.” 

The relationship between OSA and epilepsy is likely complex. Epilepsy medications and special diets may influence body composition, which could in turn affect the risk for OSA, as could medications associated with psychiatric comorbidities, according to Buchanan.

The study is retrospective and based on claims data. It does not prove causation, and claims data do not fully capture mortality, which may lead to conservative SMR estimates. The researchers did not control for socioeconomic status, treatment status, and other comorbidities or conditions.

Lloyd and Dedeurwaerdere are employees of UCB, which sponsored the study. Buchanan had no relevant financial disclosures.

A version of this article appeared on Medscape.com.

A Mediterranean-inspired plant-based diet improved self-reported measures of gout as well as uric acid levels, a pilot study has found. 

There hasn’t been a lot of research on diet in gout, according to Anna Kretova, RD, who presented the study at the annual research symposium of the Gout Hyperuricemia and Crystal-Associated Disease Network. She noted that a 2019 systematic review of low-calorie diets, low-purine diets, and Mediterranean diets found that uric acid levels below 0.6 mmol/L were achieved only in those on the Mediterranean diet (Nutrients. 2019 Dec 4;11[12]:2955). A 2020 study compared a low-fat, high-carbohydrate, plant-based diet vs an animal-based, ketogenic diet in healthy individuals. After 2 weeks, uric acid levels increased in those on the animal-based, low-carb diet and decreased in those on the plant-based diet. 

Some foods are considered to be proinflammatory and generally come from animal origins, including saturated fats and animal protein in addition to ultraprocessed foods. Foods that have anti-inflammatory properties are mostly plant based and unprocessed and often rich in fiber. “From recent interventional studies, we also know that the whole-foods plant-based diet has shown to be effective as treatments of the main comorbidities of gout, such as obesity, cardiovascular disease, or [osteoarthritis],” said Kretova, who is a registered dietitian and a researcher at the Reade Rehabilitation and Rheumatology Center, Amsterdam, the Netherlands. 

Those findings led the researchers to develop a whole-foods, plant-based diet and test its effect on serum uric acid in patients with gout, as well as gout disease activity and cardiovascular disease risk. Participants could not eat meat, fish, eggs, or dairy. 

The trial included 33 individuals with gout who were randomized to a 16-week intervention with five consultations with a registered dietitian (n = 18) or a wait-list control group (n = 15) who received standard care. The mean age overall was 52 years, and 91% were men. The mean body mass index (BMI) was 32.6 kg/m2, and the median uric acid level was 0.50 mmol/L (8.4 mg/dL).

Among gout-related outcomes, the researchers noted improvements in gout severity as measured by visual analog scale (VAS; between group difference, –2.0; P =.01), pain as measured by VAS (between group difference, –2.0; P =.04), and uric acid levels after adjustment for age, sex, and BMI (between group difference, –0.05 mmol/L, P =.004). There were also improvements in the intervention group in weight loss (between group difference, –5.3 kg; P <.0001), BMI (between group difference, –1.7; P < .0001), waist circumference (between group difference, –3.9 cm; P = .004), and low-density lipoprotein (LDL) cholesterol (between group difference, –0.5; P = .007).

At 16 weeks, “we concluded that a Mediterranean-inspired whole-foods, plant-based diet significantly lowers serum uric acid in patients with gout and abdominal obesity, and additionally, the diet reduces gout-related pain and disease activity, promotes substantial weight loss, decreases weight circumference, and improves LDL cholesterol levels, and thus decreases [cardiovascular disease] risk in these patients,” Kretova said. 

She added that some might question whether a uric acid reduction of –0.05 mmol/L is clinically relevant. “We would argue it is because of the strong decrease in disease activity and pain in the intervention group,” Kretova said. 

The study is limited by its small size, the fact that it was not blinded, and the 4-month duration, which might be too short to capture potential indirect effects of diet on hyperuricemia and chronic inflammation, Kretova said. The group is planning to follow participants out to 12 months in an extension study.

During the Q&A session after the presentation, an audience member asked if the participants were vegetarians before they entered the study, and whether the dietary change could be sustained. “It’s a very good proof-of-concept study, but whether an intervention based entirely on plant-based therapy will be something that patients will be able to adhere to long term [is uncertain],” Kretova said.

She was optimistic, even though the participants generally enjoyed food and ate a lot of red meat. “I think there will be a gradation of people who can sustain and who cannot sustain [the diet]. From what we saw, people actually found it easier to follow than they expected, and a lot of participants changed their diet permanently for the better. Not everyone became [entirely] plant-based, but they became much more plant-based than they expected from themselves. So, it is definitely feasible,” she said.

Kretova reported no relevant financial relationships.

A version of this article appeared on Medscape.com.

A Mediterranean-inspired plant-based diet improved self-reported measures of gout as well as uric acid levels, a pilot study has found. 

There hasn’t been a lot of research on diet in gout, according to Anna Kretova, RD, who presented the study at the annual research symposium of the Gout Hyperuricemia and Crystal-Associated Disease Network. She noted that a 2019 systematic review of low-calorie diets, low-purine diets, and Mediterranean diets found that uric acid levels below 0.6 mmol/L were achieved only in those on the Mediterranean diet (Nutrients. 2019 Dec 4;11[12]:2955). A 2020 study compared a low-fat, high-carbohydrate, plant-based diet vs an animal-based, ketogenic diet in healthy individuals. After 2 weeks, uric acid levels increased in those on the animal-based, low-carb diet and decreased in those on the plant-based diet. 

Some foods are considered to be proinflammatory and generally come from animal origins, including saturated fats and animal protein in addition to ultraprocessed foods. Foods that have anti-inflammatory properties are mostly plant based and unprocessed and often rich in fiber. “From recent interventional studies, we also know that the whole-foods plant-based diet has shown to be effective as treatments of the main comorbidities of gout, such as obesity, cardiovascular disease, or [osteoarthritis],” said Kretova, who is a registered dietitian and a researcher at the Reade Rehabilitation and Rheumatology Center, Amsterdam, the Netherlands. 

Those findings led the researchers to develop a whole-foods, plant-based diet and test its effect on serum uric acid in patients with gout, as well as gout disease activity and cardiovascular disease risk. Participants could not eat meat, fish, eggs, or dairy. 

The trial included 33 individuals with gout who were randomized to a 16-week intervention with five consultations with a registered dietitian (n = 18) or a wait-list control group (n = 15) who received standard care. The mean age overall was 52 years, and 91% were men. The mean body mass index (BMI) was 32.6 kg/m2, and the median uric acid level was 0.50 mmol/L (8.4 mg/dL).

Among gout-related outcomes, the researchers noted improvements in gout severity as measured by visual analog scale (VAS; between group difference, –2.0; P =.01), pain as measured by VAS (between group difference, –2.0; P =.04), and uric acid levels after adjustment for age, sex, and BMI (between group difference, –0.05 mmol/L, P =.004). There were also improvements in the intervention group in weight loss (between group difference, –5.3 kg; P <.0001), BMI (between group difference, –1.7; P < .0001), waist circumference (between group difference, –3.9 cm; P = .004), and low-density lipoprotein (LDL) cholesterol (between group difference, –0.5; P = .007).

At 16 weeks, “we concluded that a Mediterranean-inspired whole-foods, plant-based diet significantly lowers serum uric acid in patients with gout and abdominal obesity, and additionally, the diet reduces gout-related pain and disease activity, promotes substantial weight loss, decreases weight circumference, and improves LDL cholesterol levels, and thus decreases [cardiovascular disease] risk in these patients,” Kretova said. 

She added that some might question whether a uric acid reduction of –0.05 mmol/L is clinically relevant. “We would argue it is because of the strong decrease in disease activity and pain in the intervention group,” Kretova said. 

The study is limited by its small size, the fact that it was not blinded, and the 4-month duration, which might be too short to capture potential indirect effects of diet on hyperuricemia and chronic inflammation, Kretova said. The group is planning to follow participants out to 12 months in an extension study.

During the Q&A session after the presentation, an audience member asked if the participants were vegetarians before they entered the study, and whether the dietary change could be sustained. “It’s a very good proof-of-concept study, but whether an intervention based entirely on plant-based therapy will be something that patients will be able to adhere to long term [is uncertain],” Kretova said.

She was optimistic, even though the participants generally enjoyed food and ate a lot of red meat. “I think there will be a gradation of people who can sustain and who cannot sustain [the diet]. From what we saw, people actually found it easier to follow than they expected, and a lot of participants changed their diet permanently for the better. Not everyone became [entirely] plant-based, but they became much more plant-based than they expected from themselves. So, it is definitely feasible,” she said.

Kretova reported no relevant financial relationships.

A version of this article appeared on Medscape.com.

A Mediterranean-inspired plant-based diet improved self-reported measures of gout as well as uric acid levels, a pilot study has found. 

There hasn’t been a lot of research on diet in gout, according to Anna Kretova, RD, who presented the study at the annual research symposium of the Gout Hyperuricemia and Crystal-Associated Disease Network. She noted that a 2019 systematic review of low-calorie diets, low-purine diets, and Mediterranean diets found that uric acid levels below 0.6 mmol/L were achieved only in those on the Mediterranean diet (Nutrients. 2019 Dec 4;11[12]:2955). A 2020 study compared a low-fat, high-carbohydrate, plant-based diet vs an animal-based, ketogenic diet in healthy individuals. After 2 weeks, uric acid levels increased in those on the animal-based, low-carb diet and decreased in those on the plant-based diet. 

Some foods are considered to be proinflammatory and generally come from animal origins, including saturated fats and animal protein in addition to ultraprocessed foods. Foods that have anti-inflammatory properties are mostly plant based and unprocessed and often rich in fiber. “From recent interventional studies, we also know that the whole-foods plant-based diet has shown to be effective as treatments of the main comorbidities of gout, such as obesity, cardiovascular disease, or [osteoarthritis],” said Kretova, who is a registered dietitian and a researcher at the Reade Rehabilitation and Rheumatology Center, Amsterdam, the Netherlands. 

Those findings led the researchers to develop a whole-foods, plant-based diet and test its effect on serum uric acid in patients with gout, as well as gout disease activity and cardiovascular disease risk. Participants could not eat meat, fish, eggs, or dairy. 

The trial included 33 individuals with gout who were randomized to a 16-week intervention with five consultations with a registered dietitian (n = 18) or a wait-list control group (n = 15) who received standard care. The mean age overall was 52 years, and 91% were men. The mean body mass index (BMI) was 32.6 kg/m2, and the median uric acid level was 0.50 mmol/L (8.4 mg/dL).

Among gout-related outcomes, the researchers noted improvements in gout severity as measured by visual analog scale (VAS; between group difference, –2.0; P =.01), pain as measured by VAS (between group difference, –2.0; P =.04), and uric acid levels after adjustment for age, sex, and BMI (between group difference, –0.05 mmol/L, P =.004). There were also improvements in the intervention group in weight loss (between group difference, –5.3 kg; P <.0001), BMI (between group difference, –1.7; P < .0001), waist circumference (between group difference, –3.9 cm; P = .004), and low-density lipoprotein (LDL) cholesterol (between group difference, –0.5; P = .007).

At 16 weeks, “we concluded that a Mediterranean-inspired whole-foods, plant-based diet significantly lowers serum uric acid in patients with gout and abdominal obesity, and additionally, the diet reduces gout-related pain and disease activity, promotes substantial weight loss, decreases weight circumference, and improves LDL cholesterol levels, and thus decreases [cardiovascular disease] risk in these patients,” Kretova said. 

She added that some might question whether a uric acid reduction of –0.05 mmol/L is clinically relevant. “We would argue it is because of the strong decrease in disease activity and pain in the intervention group,” Kretova said. 

The study is limited by its small size, the fact that it was not blinded, and the 4-month duration, which might be too short to capture potential indirect effects of diet on hyperuricemia and chronic inflammation, Kretova said. The group is planning to follow participants out to 12 months in an extension study.

During the Q&A session after the presentation, an audience member asked if the participants were vegetarians before they entered the study, and whether the dietary change could be sustained. “It’s a very good proof-of-concept study, but whether an intervention based entirely on plant-based therapy will be something that patients will be able to adhere to long term [is uncertain],” Kretova said.

She was optimistic, even though the participants generally enjoyed food and ate a lot of red meat. “I think there will be a gradation of people who can sustain and who cannot sustain [the diet]. From what we saw, people actually found it easier to follow than they expected, and a lot of participants changed their diet permanently for the better. Not everyone became [entirely] plant-based, but they became much more plant-based than they expected from themselves. So, it is definitely feasible,” she said.

Kretova reported no relevant financial relationships.

A version of this article appeared on Medscape.com.

In a nearly unanimous vote at the annual research symposium of the Gout Hyperuricemia and Crystal-Associated Disease Network (G-CAN), members approved a revision to gout remission criteria first established in 2016. The new version simplifies the definition in response to patient comments that the earlier version was redundant in some areas. 

The previous version was developed following deliberations by 49 clinicians and researchers with experience in gout. They settled on a definition of gout remission that included five criteria:

• Serum urate levels lower than 0.36 mmol/L measured at least twice over 12 months, with no intervening values of 0.36 mmol/L or higher
• No gout flares over 12 months
• No tophi
• Pain score due to gout < 2 at least twice over 12 months on a 10-point Likert scale or 10-cm visual analog scale, with no intervening values ≥ 2
• Patient global assessment of gout disease activity < 2 on a 10-point Likert scale or 10-cm visual analog scale, with no intervening values of ≥ 2.

Some participants reported that patients sometimes misattributed pain from other sources while using patient-reported outcomes (PROs). The argument for keeping PROs was that they are validated measures and endorsed by Outcome Measures in Rheumatology. Nevertheless, there was no direct patient involvement in the development of the 2016 criteria.

Researchers later interviewed 20 individuals with well-controlled gout to get their feedback on the 2016 criteria. Those individuals endorsed the existing criteria and did not suggest any new ones, but they suggested that the pain due to gout and the absence of gout flares were redundant measures. One said: “If you have no flare-ups, you’ve got no pain; it sort of answers itself.”

“That was a bit challenging for us because it wasn’t quite what we expected, but I think it did make us look again at the definition and think about whether we could simplify the definition further,” Nicola Dalbeth, MBChB, said during a presentation at G-CAN. Dalbeth is an academic rheumatologist at the University of Auckland, in New Zealand, who was also the lead author of the original criteria.

 

Simplified Version Created With Only Three Criteria

In response to these points, researchers produced a revised version with only three criteria, including the serum urate, absence of gout flares, and absence of subcutaneous tophi at the time of assessment.

To determine if the simplified criteria performed well, they compared the original and revised remission criteria in the context of the CARES trial, the Nottingham nurse-led trial, and randomized controlled trials in patients with gout that were conducted in New Zealand (here and here).

Dansoa Tabi-Amponsah, a PhD candidate at the University of Auckland, presented results of a study comparing the two versions in the Nottingham trial, which included 517 participants who received nurse-led or usual general practitioner care. The nurse-led care included education, regular follow-up and serum urate testing, individualized advice on gout flare management, and escalation of urate-lowering therapy with a treat-to-target strategy.

Both definitions demonstrated a link between the nurse-led strategy and increased rates of remission at year 1 and year 2, although the simplified definition found that more patients were in remission (17.6% vs 9.9% at year 1 and 42.7% vs 28.4% at year 2, both P < .001). “This is something we’ve seen across all of our analyses,” said Tabi-Amponsah. 

Both criteria also found significant differences in remission rates between the nurse-led group in year 2 vs year 1 but not in the usual care group.

Participants who achieved remission had better gout impact scale scores in areas like worrying that a gout attack will occur, fears of worsening gout, and concerns about the impact of gout on future activities. “This is important because during that qualitative study, a key aspect of being in remission was no longer being worried about their gout, no longer feeling anxious about having constant gout flares, and having control over their gout. So, it’s important to note that despite the absence of PROs in that simplified definition, it’s still able to align with the patients’ perspectives of their disease state,” said Tabi-Amponsah.

During the Q&A period after her talk, an audience member asked whether the higher rate of remission found by the simplified criteria is actually a good thing. “If I compare that to rheumatoid arthritis, when you use DAS28 you have a lot more remission, but still progression. So, are we missing some people? Are we including people in remission that still have disease?” she asked. 

Tabi-Amponsah responded that the pain and patient global assessment domains seem to be quite difficult to achieve. In a separate analysis, the researchers examined tender and swollen joint counts and found that those achieving remission no longer had tender or swollen joints. “So, we don’t think the simplified definition is heavily misclassifying anyone as being in remission,” she said. 

During the Q&A following Dalbeth’s talk, an audience member asked about patients with what he described as “mountains of tophi,” despite responding well to uricase therapy. “They may take months or even a year to really resolve that burden. They may be doing very well, yet they’re not going to be in remission because they’ve still got visible tophi. So, are we underselling them, and do we need a different definition for them doing well that this doesn’t capture?” he asked.

Dalbeth suggested that patients with large amounts of tophi aren’t really in remission. “I think we do need to be thinking about the disease, not just in terms of just crystals or just inflammation, but actually trying to integrate both of those, and I think this is where these composite measures might work quite well. I think we need to be aiming for holistic disease control, which is essentially what this is,” she said. 

Tabi-Amponsah and Dalbeth did not disclose any financial relationships. 

 

A version of this article appeared on Medscape.com.

In a nearly unanimous vote at the annual research symposium of the Gout Hyperuricemia and Crystal-Associated Disease Network (G-CAN), members approved a revision to gout remission criteria first established in 2016. The new version simplifies the definition in response to patient comments that the earlier version was redundant in some areas. 

The previous version was developed following deliberations by 49 clinicians and researchers with experience in gout. They settled on a definition of gout remission that included five criteria:

• Serum urate levels lower than 0.36 mmol/L measured at least twice over 12 months, with no intervening values of 0.36 mmol/L or higher
• No gout flares over 12 months
• No tophi
• Pain score due to gout < 2 at least twice over 12 months on a 10-point Likert scale or 10-cm visual analog scale, with no intervening values ≥ 2
• Patient global assessment of gout disease activity < 2 on a 10-point Likert scale or 10-cm visual analog scale, with no intervening values of ≥ 2.

Some participants reported that patients sometimes misattributed pain from other sources while using patient-reported outcomes (PROs). The argument for keeping PROs was that they are validated measures and endorsed by Outcome Measures in Rheumatology. Nevertheless, there was no direct patient involvement in the development of the 2016 criteria.

Researchers later interviewed 20 individuals with well-controlled gout to get their feedback on the 2016 criteria. Those individuals endorsed the existing criteria and did not suggest any new ones, but they suggested that the pain due to gout and the absence of gout flares were redundant measures. One said: “If you have no flare-ups, you’ve got no pain; it sort of answers itself.”

“That was a bit challenging for us because it wasn’t quite what we expected, but I think it did make us look again at the definition and think about whether we could simplify the definition further,” Nicola Dalbeth, MBChB, said during a presentation at G-CAN. Dalbeth is an academic rheumatologist at the University of Auckland, in New Zealand, who was also the lead author of the original criteria.

 

Simplified Version Created With Only Three Criteria

In response to these points, researchers produced a revised version with only three criteria, including the serum urate, absence of gout flares, and absence of subcutaneous tophi at the time of assessment.

To determine if the simplified criteria performed well, they compared the original and revised remission criteria in the context of the CARES trial, the Nottingham nurse-led trial, and randomized controlled trials in patients with gout that were conducted in New Zealand (here and here).

Dansoa Tabi-Amponsah, a PhD candidate at the University of Auckland, presented results of a study comparing the two versions in the Nottingham trial, which included 517 participants who received nurse-led or usual general practitioner care. The nurse-led care included education, regular follow-up and serum urate testing, individualized advice on gout flare management, and escalation of urate-lowering therapy with a treat-to-target strategy.

Both definitions demonstrated a link between the nurse-led strategy and increased rates of remission at year 1 and year 2, although the simplified definition found that more patients were in remission (17.6% vs 9.9% at year 1 and 42.7% vs 28.4% at year 2, both P < .001). “This is something we’ve seen across all of our analyses,” said Tabi-Amponsah. 

Both criteria also found significant differences in remission rates between the nurse-led group in year 2 vs year 1 but not in the usual care group.

Participants who achieved remission had better gout impact scale scores in areas like worrying that a gout attack will occur, fears of worsening gout, and concerns about the impact of gout on future activities. “This is important because during that qualitative study, a key aspect of being in remission was no longer being worried about their gout, no longer feeling anxious about having constant gout flares, and having control over their gout. So, it’s important to note that despite the absence of PROs in that simplified definition, it’s still able to align with the patients’ perspectives of their disease state,” said Tabi-Amponsah.

During the Q&A period after her talk, an audience member asked whether the higher rate of remission found by the simplified criteria is actually a good thing. “If I compare that to rheumatoid arthritis, when you use DAS28 you have a lot more remission, but still progression. So, are we missing some people? Are we including people in remission that still have disease?” she asked. 

Tabi-Amponsah responded that the pain and patient global assessment domains seem to be quite difficult to achieve. In a separate analysis, the researchers examined tender and swollen joint counts and found that those achieving remission no longer had tender or swollen joints. “So, we don’t think the simplified definition is heavily misclassifying anyone as being in remission,” she said. 

During the Q&A following Dalbeth’s talk, an audience member asked about patients with what he described as “mountains of tophi,” despite responding well to uricase therapy. “They may take months or even a year to really resolve that burden. They may be doing very well, yet they’re not going to be in remission because they’ve still got visible tophi. So, are we underselling them, and do we need a different definition for them doing well that this doesn’t capture?” he asked.

Dalbeth suggested that patients with large amounts of tophi aren’t really in remission. “I think we do need to be thinking about the disease, not just in terms of just crystals or just inflammation, but actually trying to integrate both of those, and I think this is where these composite measures might work quite well. I think we need to be aiming for holistic disease control, which is essentially what this is,” she said. 

Tabi-Amponsah and Dalbeth did not disclose any financial relationships. 

 

A version of this article appeared on Medscape.com.

In a nearly unanimous vote at the annual research symposium of the Gout Hyperuricemia and Crystal-Associated Disease Network (G-CAN), members approved a revision to gout remission criteria first established in 2016. The new version simplifies the definition in response to patient comments that the earlier version was redundant in some areas. 

The previous version was developed following deliberations by 49 clinicians and researchers with experience in gout. They settled on a definition of gout remission that included five criteria:

• Serum urate levels lower than 0.36 mmol/L measured at least twice over 12 months, with no intervening values of 0.36 mmol/L or higher
• No gout flares over 12 months
• No tophi
• Pain score due to gout < 2 at least twice over 12 months on a 10-point Likert scale or 10-cm visual analog scale, with no intervening values ≥ 2
• Patient global assessment of gout disease activity < 2 on a 10-point Likert scale or 10-cm visual analog scale, with no intervening values of ≥ 2.

Some participants reported that patients sometimes misattributed pain from other sources while using patient-reported outcomes (PROs). The argument for keeping PROs was that they are validated measures and endorsed by Outcome Measures in Rheumatology. Nevertheless, there was no direct patient involvement in the development of the 2016 criteria.

Researchers later interviewed 20 individuals with well-controlled gout to get their feedback on the 2016 criteria. Those individuals endorsed the existing criteria and did not suggest any new ones, but they suggested that the pain due to gout and the absence of gout flares were redundant measures. One said: “If you have no flare-ups, you’ve got no pain; it sort of answers itself.”

“That was a bit challenging for us because it wasn’t quite what we expected, but I think it did make us look again at the definition and think about whether we could simplify the definition further,” Nicola Dalbeth, MBChB, said during a presentation at G-CAN. Dalbeth is an academic rheumatologist at the University of Auckland, in New Zealand, who was also the lead author of the original criteria.

 

Simplified Version Created With Only Three Criteria

In response to these points, researchers produced a revised version with only three criteria, including the serum urate, absence of gout flares, and absence of subcutaneous tophi at the time of assessment.

To determine if the simplified criteria performed well, they compared the original and revised remission criteria in the context of the CARES trial, the Nottingham nurse-led trial, and randomized controlled trials in patients with gout that were conducted in New Zealand (here and here).

Dansoa Tabi-Amponsah, a PhD candidate at the University of Auckland, presented results of a study comparing the two versions in the Nottingham trial, which included 517 participants who received nurse-led or usual general practitioner care. The nurse-led care included education, regular follow-up and serum urate testing, individualized advice on gout flare management, and escalation of urate-lowering therapy with a treat-to-target strategy.

Both definitions demonstrated a link between the nurse-led strategy and increased rates of remission at year 1 and year 2, although the simplified definition found that more patients were in remission (17.6% vs 9.9% at year 1 and 42.7% vs 28.4% at year 2, both P < .001). “This is something we’ve seen across all of our analyses,” said Tabi-Amponsah. 

Both criteria also found significant differences in remission rates between the nurse-led group in year 2 vs year 1 but not in the usual care group.

Participants who achieved remission had better gout impact scale scores in areas like worrying that a gout attack will occur, fears of worsening gout, and concerns about the impact of gout on future activities. “This is important because during that qualitative study, a key aspect of being in remission was no longer being worried about their gout, no longer feeling anxious about having constant gout flares, and having control over their gout. So, it’s important to note that despite the absence of PROs in that simplified definition, it’s still able to align with the patients’ perspectives of their disease state,” said Tabi-Amponsah.

During the Q&A period after her talk, an audience member asked whether the higher rate of remission found by the simplified criteria is actually a good thing. “If I compare that to rheumatoid arthritis, when you use DAS28 you have a lot more remission, but still progression. So, are we missing some people? Are we including people in remission that still have disease?” she asked. 

Tabi-Amponsah responded that the pain and patient global assessment domains seem to be quite difficult to achieve. In a separate analysis, the researchers examined tender and swollen joint counts and found that those achieving remission no longer had tender or swollen joints. “So, we don’t think the simplified definition is heavily misclassifying anyone as being in remission,” she said. 

During the Q&A following Dalbeth’s talk, an audience member asked about patients with what he described as “mountains of tophi,” despite responding well to uricase therapy. “They may take months or even a year to really resolve that burden. They may be doing very well, yet they’re not going to be in remission because they’ve still got visible tophi. So, are we underselling them, and do we need a different definition for them doing well that this doesn’t capture?” he asked.

Dalbeth suggested that patients with large amounts of tophi aren’t really in remission. “I think we do need to be thinking about the disease, not just in terms of just crystals or just inflammation, but actually trying to integrate both of those, and I think this is where these composite measures might work quite well. I think we need to be aiming for holistic disease control, which is essentially what this is,” she said. 

Tabi-Amponsah and Dalbeth did not disclose any financial relationships. 

 

A version of this article appeared on Medscape.com.

Efforts to combat hyperuricemia may find help from gut microbes, according to Dylan Dodd, MD, PhD, who spoke at the annual research symposium of the Gout, Hyperuricemia, and Crystal-Associated Disease Network.

Dodd is an assistant professor of pathology and microbiology and immunology at Stanford University, Palo Alto, California, where he studies novel metabolic pathways in microbes. “The idea is that we can leverage these novel pathways that microbes have as therapeutics to promote human health, and in particular for this meeting today, we’re focused on hyperuricemia and how microbes that break down purines may actually have a role as urate-lowering therapies,” Dodd said during his presentation.

Specifically, he highlighted the fact that some microbes found in the gut break down purines as a food source, producing both energy and molecular building blocks for their own use. Dietary purines, left intact, can otherwise be absorbed and metabolized by the body to produce urate.

Nucleic acids like DNA and RNA in the diet are first broken down by enzymes produced in the pancreas, resulting in purine nucleosides, which in turn are believed to be the source of purines absorbed in the small intestine and eventually into circulation, according to Dodd. “I really view urate in the intestine as being in equilibrium between being secreted into the lumen but also being reabsorbed, and specifically, as it pertains to microbes in the gut. If the microbes degrade the urate, then it will limit its reabsorption, and that could increase net excretion,” Dodd said.

There is evidence that some strains of Lactobacillus species, which are the most important group in the human gut, can metabolize purine nucleosides, he said. In recent years, researchers have screened for Lactobacillus species capable of metabolizing purine nucleosides. The research shows some strain-to-strain variation, but most are proprietary, making it impossible to conduct follow-up research. A small number of human trials have suggested efficacy, but they have generally been conducted in few patients with mixed results. “Overall, I think it’s promising that these lactobacilli probiotics could potentially be used as urate-lowering therapies,” Dodd said.

Aside from direct metabolism of purines, Dodd’s group has identified an additional pathway that some microbes can use to break down urate into short-chain fatty acids. His group cultured various purine nucleosides with various bacterial strains, including two Lactobacillus strains, under anaerobic conditions. The Lactobacillus strains did not degrade urate, but some bacterial species did. The group also found that Lactobacillus could convert nucleosides, including those derived from purines, into the smaller nucleobase compounds, but they did not consume the resultant purines. Some other types of bacteria consumed all purines “voraciously,” according to Dodd, and his team is working to identify the bacterial genetic pathways that drive the metabolic pathways. 

Such studies may open up various therapeutic pathways, he said. One is to employ Lactobacillus probiotics to convert purine nucleosides to their nucleobases, which could reduce absorption in the small intestine. Other bacteria could potentially be used to convert urate produced by paracellular reabsorption to short-chain fatty acids, which have potential benefits through their anti-inflammatory properties. Finally, probiotics could be engineered to degrade urate produced in the intestine. 

Dodd noted that probiotics would have the advantage of high patient acceptance and are generally regarded as safe. Some existing products might have purine-degrading capabilities but haven’t been tested, he said. However, there is strain-to-strain variation and the probiotic formulas would likely need to be optimized to reduce nucleobases. On the other hand, bacteria that degrade urate are likely safe since they have been found in the guts of healthy individuals. However, there are still potential safety concerns, and it is unknown if they could withstand the harsh conditions of the upper gastrointestinal tract or if they would remain active even in the presence of oxygen found in the small intestine, he said. 

During the Q&A period after his talk, Dodd was asked whether fructose consumption could suppress the function of anaerobic bacteria that naturally degrade purine. “When people talk about fructose-induced hyperuricemia, they talk about the ATP degradation in fructose metabolism in the liver or small intestine, [but] they never talk about this potential pathway in the gut,” the questioner said.

Dodd responded that his group found that some carbohydrates suppress urate degradation in some bacterial strains. “It’s certainly a possible mechanism that increased fructose intake could suppress microbial urate degradation in the gut, and that could contribute to hyperuricemia, but obviously more studies need to be done,” he said.

Another audience member wondered if antibiotic use could be tied to gout risk and whether serum urate levels might rise after antibiotic use. “Do you have any data on serum urate before and after antibiotic use, where you might expect to see changes which might support your hypothesis?” she asked. Dodd said that the group had done a retrospective analysis of data from Stanford’s medical records and did not find a change in serum urate after antibiotic exposure. However, a controlled feeding study of healthy individuals who later received antibiotics showed a large increase in urate levels, but the study did not include plasma samples. “It’s a really good question, and we hope to be able to follow that up,” he said.

Dodd disclosed no relevant financial relationships.

 

A version of this article appeared on Medscape.com.

Efforts to combat hyperuricemia may find help from gut microbes, according to Dylan Dodd, MD, PhD, who spoke at the annual research symposium of the Gout, Hyperuricemia, and Crystal-Associated Disease Network.

Dodd is an assistant professor of pathology and microbiology and immunology at Stanford University, Palo Alto, California, where he studies novel metabolic pathways in microbes. “The idea is that we can leverage these novel pathways that microbes have as therapeutics to promote human health, and in particular for this meeting today, we’re focused on hyperuricemia and how microbes that break down purines may actually have a role as urate-lowering therapies,” Dodd said during his presentation.

Specifically, he highlighted the fact that some microbes found in the gut break down purines as a food source, producing both energy and molecular building blocks for their own use. Dietary purines, left intact, can otherwise be absorbed and metabolized by the body to produce urate.

Nucleic acids like DNA and RNA in the diet are first broken down by enzymes produced in the pancreas, resulting in purine nucleosides, which in turn are believed to be the source of purines absorbed in the small intestine and eventually into circulation, according to Dodd. “I really view urate in the intestine as being in equilibrium between being secreted into the lumen but also being reabsorbed, and specifically, as it pertains to microbes in the gut. If the microbes degrade the urate, then it will limit its reabsorption, and that could increase net excretion,” Dodd said.

There is evidence that some strains of Lactobacillus species, which are the most important group in the human gut, can metabolize purine nucleosides, he said. In recent years, researchers have screened for Lactobacillus species capable of metabolizing purine nucleosides. The research shows some strain-to-strain variation, but most are proprietary, making it impossible to conduct follow-up research. A small number of human trials have suggested efficacy, but they have generally been conducted in few patients with mixed results. “Overall, I think it’s promising that these lactobacilli probiotics could potentially be used as urate-lowering therapies,” Dodd said.

Aside from direct metabolism of purines, Dodd’s group has identified an additional pathway that some microbes can use to break down urate into short-chain fatty acids. His group cultured various purine nucleosides with various bacterial strains, including two Lactobacillus strains, under anaerobic conditions. The Lactobacillus strains did not degrade urate, but some bacterial species did. The group also found that Lactobacillus could convert nucleosides, including those derived from purines, into the smaller nucleobase compounds, but they did not consume the resultant purines. Some other types of bacteria consumed all purines “voraciously,” according to Dodd, and his team is working to identify the bacterial genetic pathways that drive the metabolic pathways. 

Such studies may open up various therapeutic pathways, he said. One is to employ Lactobacillus probiotics to convert purine nucleosides to their nucleobases, which could reduce absorption in the small intestine. Other bacteria could potentially be used to convert urate produced by paracellular reabsorption to short-chain fatty acids, which have potential benefits through their anti-inflammatory properties. Finally, probiotics could be engineered to degrade urate produced in the intestine. 

Dodd noted that probiotics would have the advantage of high patient acceptance and are generally regarded as safe. Some existing products might have purine-degrading capabilities but haven’t been tested, he said. However, there is strain-to-strain variation and the probiotic formulas would likely need to be optimized to reduce nucleobases. On the other hand, bacteria that degrade urate are likely safe since they have been found in the guts of healthy individuals. However, there are still potential safety concerns, and it is unknown if they could withstand the harsh conditions of the upper gastrointestinal tract or if they would remain active even in the presence of oxygen found in the small intestine, he said. 

During the Q&A period after his talk, Dodd was asked whether fructose consumption could suppress the function of anaerobic bacteria that naturally degrade purine. “When people talk about fructose-induced hyperuricemia, they talk about the ATP degradation in fructose metabolism in the liver or small intestine, [but] they never talk about this potential pathway in the gut,” the questioner said.

Dodd responded that his group found that some carbohydrates suppress urate degradation in some bacterial strains. “It’s certainly a possible mechanism that increased fructose intake could suppress microbial urate degradation in the gut, and that could contribute to hyperuricemia, but obviously more studies need to be done,” he said.

Another audience member wondered if antibiotic use could be tied to gout risk and whether serum urate levels might rise after antibiotic use. “Do you have any data on serum urate before and after antibiotic use, where you might expect to see changes which might support your hypothesis?” she asked. Dodd said that the group had done a retrospective analysis of data from Stanford’s medical records and did not find a change in serum urate after antibiotic exposure. However, a controlled feeding study of healthy individuals who later received antibiotics showed a large increase in urate levels, but the study did not include plasma samples. “It’s a really good question, and we hope to be able to follow that up,” he said.

Dodd disclosed no relevant financial relationships.

 

A version of this article appeared on Medscape.com.

Efforts to combat hyperuricemia may find help from gut microbes, according to Dylan Dodd, MD, PhD, who spoke at the annual research symposium of the Gout, Hyperuricemia, and Crystal-Associated Disease Network.

Dodd is an assistant professor of pathology and microbiology and immunology at Stanford University, Palo Alto, California, where he studies novel metabolic pathways in microbes. “The idea is that we can leverage these novel pathways that microbes have as therapeutics to promote human health, and in particular for this meeting today, we’re focused on hyperuricemia and how microbes that break down purines may actually have a role as urate-lowering therapies,” Dodd said during his presentation.

Specifically, he highlighted the fact that some microbes found in the gut break down purines as a food source, producing both energy and molecular building blocks for their own use. Dietary purines, left intact, can otherwise be absorbed and metabolized by the body to produce urate.

Nucleic acids like DNA and RNA in the diet are first broken down by enzymes produced in the pancreas, resulting in purine nucleosides, which in turn are believed to be the source of purines absorbed in the small intestine and eventually into circulation, according to Dodd. “I really view urate in the intestine as being in equilibrium between being secreted into the lumen but also being reabsorbed, and specifically, as it pertains to microbes in the gut. If the microbes degrade the urate, then it will limit its reabsorption, and that could increase net excretion,” Dodd said.

There is evidence that some strains of Lactobacillus species, which are the most important group in the human gut, can metabolize purine nucleosides, he said. In recent years, researchers have screened for Lactobacillus species capable of metabolizing purine nucleosides. The research shows some strain-to-strain variation, but most are proprietary, making it impossible to conduct follow-up research. A small number of human trials have suggested efficacy, but they have generally been conducted in few patients with mixed results. “Overall, I think it’s promising that these lactobacilli probiotics could potentially be used as urate-lowering therapies,” Dodd said.

Aside from direct metabolism of purines, Dodd’s group has identified an additional pathway that some microbes can use to break down urate into short-chain fatty acids. His group cultured various purine nucleosides with various bacterial strains, including two Lactobacillus strains, under anaerobic conditions. The Lactobacillus strains did not degrade urate, but some bacterial species did. The group also found that Lactobacillus could convert nucleosides, including those derived from purines, into the smaller nucleobase compounds, but they did not consume the resultant purines. Some other types of bacteria consumed all purines “voraciously,” according to Dodd, and his team is working to identify the bacterial genetic pathways that drive the metabolic pathways. 

Such studies may open up various therapeutic pathways, he said. One is to employ Lactobacillus probiotics to convert purine nucleosides to their nucleobases, which could reduce absorption in the small intestine. Other bacteria could potentially be used to convert urate produced by paracellular reabsorption to short-chain fatty acids, which have potential benefits through their anti-inflammatory properties. Finally, probiotics could be engineered to degrade urate produced in the intestine. 

Dodd noted that probiotics would have the advantage of high patient acceptance and are generally regarded as safe. Some existing products might have purine-degrading capabilities but haven’t been tested, he said. However, there is strain-to-strain variation and the probiotic formulas would likely need to be optimized to reduce nucleobases. On the other hand, bacteria that degrade urate are likely safe since they have been found in the guts of healthy individuals. However, there are still potential safety concerns, and it is unknown if they could withstand the harsh conditions of the upper gastrointestinal tract or if they would remain active even in the presence of oxygen found in the small intestine, he said. 

During the Q&A period after his talk, Dodd was asked whether fructose consumption could suppress the function of anaerobic bacteria that naturally degrade purine. “When people talk about fructose-induced hyperuricemia, they talk about the ATP degradation in fructose metabolism in the liver or small intestine, [but] they never talk about this potential pathway in the gut,” the questioner said.

Dodd responded that his group found that some carbohydrates suppress urate degradation in some bacterial strains. “It’s certainly a possible mechanism that increased fructose intake could suppress microbial urate degradation in the gut, and that could contribute to hyperuricemia, but obviously more studies need to be done,” he said.

Another audience member wondered if antibiotic use could be tied to gout risk and whether serum urate levels might rise after antibiotic use. “Do you have any data on serum urate before and after antibiotic use, where you might expect to see changes which might support your hypothesis?” she asked. Dodd said that the group had done a retrospective analysis of data from Stanford’s medical records and did not find a change in serum urate after antibiotic exposure. However, a controlled feeding study of healthy individuals who later received antibiotics showed a large increase in urate levels, but the study did not include plasma samples. “It’s a really good question, and we hope to be able to follow that up,” he said.

Dodd disclosed no relevant financial relationships.

 

A version of this article appeared on Medscape.com.