User login
LVADs achieve cardiac palliation in muscular dystrophies
At one time, respiratory failure was the primary cause of death in young men and boys with muscular dystrophies, but since improvements in ventilator support have addressed this problem, cardiac complications such as cardiomyopathy have become the main cause of death in this group, with the highest risk of death in people with Duchenne muscular dystrophy (DMD). Researchers from Rome have reported that the novel use of ventricular assist devices in this population can prolong life.
Gianluigi Perri, MD, PhD, of University Hospital and Bambino Gesù Children Hospital in Rome, and his coauthors, shared their experience treating seven patients with dystrophinopathies and dilated cardiomyopathy (DCM) with left ventricular assist devices (LVADs) from February 2011 to February 2016 (J Thorac Cardiovasc Surg. 2017 March;153:669-74). “Our experience indicates that the use of an LVAD as destination therapy in patients with dystrophinopathies with end-stage DCM is feasible, suggesting that it may be suitable as a palliative therapy for the treatment of these patients with no other therapeutic options,” Dr. Perri and his coauthors said.
Heart transplantation is considered the procedure of choice for children with severe advanced heart failure, but transplantation is contraindicated for children with dystrophinopathies because of the risk of respiratory failure and progression of skeletal myopathy leads to limited functional capacity. Hence, Dr. Perri and his coauthors developed their alternative treatment for end-stage heart failure in these children. They used the Jarvik 2000 LVAD (Jarvik Heart Inc., New York) as destination therapy.
Six of the seven patients they operated on had DMD and one had beta-2 sarcoglycan deficit. Their ages ranged from 14.2 to 23.4 years. Two patients had early complications: retropharyngeal bleeding and cholecystectomy; and abdominal bleeding and splenectomy. Two different patients had late complications: gastrostomy; and osteolysis and infection at the pedestal site. Three patients died after the operation: one of stroke at 15 months; one of severe bleeding about 28 months later; and one of lung infection 45 months afterward. Follow-up for the surviving patients ranged from about 2 months to 40 months. Median hospital stay was 77 days.
Dr. Perri and his coauthors noted that the DMD Care Considerations Working Group expanded acceptable therapies for DMD cardiomyopathy to include novel treatments such as mechanical circulatory support and implantable cardioverter-defibrillators.
“Although the best approach remains unclear, it does seem clear that treatment should be more aggressive,” the researchers said. The limited life expectancy of these patients makes transplantation a complicated choice when a shortage of donors is a concern. “Therefore, the alternative therapeutic option is the use of LVAD,” Dr. Perri and his coauthors said.
These patients need care at centers “with a high level of experience of patients with DMD,” the researchers stated. Common comorbidities such as severe kyphoscoliosis and respiratory muscle weakness in this population increase surgical risks.
Dr. Perri and his coauthors used a surgical technique that involved avoiding the left thoracotomy approach common in adults who undergo VAD implantation, because of respiratory insufficiency in these younger patients. They also used cardiopulmonary bypass in all but one patient who had a minimally invasive off-pump procedure through a left anterior minithoracotomy.
The researchers “strongly suggest” noninvasive ventilation after surgery to assist in pulmonary function often compromised by scoliosis and muscle weakness. “Our experience shows that postoperative care can be extremely challenging and is often burdened by unexpected complications,” they noted.
Kyphoscoliosis poses challenges when placing drains, and complications of these patients should be treated only in a specialized center. “Indeed, one of our patients died in a peripheral hospital because they underwent bronchoscopic examination with an endoscope that caused severe and intractable retropharyngeal bleeding,” they said.
The researchers no relevant financial relationships to disclose.
Almost all young men living with Duchenne muscular dystrophy will develop heart failure, but for many of these patients, continuous-flow left ventricular assist devices can provide “reliable support” for up to a decade, David L. S. Morales, MD, of the Heart Institute at Cincinnati Children’s Hospital Medical Center, said in his invited commentary (J Thorac Cardiovasc Surg. 2017;153:675-6)
“The current series demonstrates, as has been shown at our institute as well as others, that one can provide an effective therapy for certain patients with DMD and heart failure,” Dr. Morales said of the work of Dr. Perri and coauthors. Dr. Morales added that maximizing outcomes in this population hinges on finding the appropriate time point for intervention in the disease process.
While “there is still much to be learned,” Dr. Morales said, Dr. Perri and his coauthors have shown that LVAD therapy is an option in patients with DMD and heart failure who have failed other treatments. “These young men may, therefore, have the option to extend their lives and possibly have the opportunity to benefit from the impressive medical advances being made,” he said. “Perhaps they and their families have been provided hope.”
Dr. Morales disclosed relationships with Berlin Heart, HeartWare and Oregon Total Artificial Heart.
Almost all young men living with Duchenne muscular dystrophy will develop heart failure, but for many of these patients, continuous-flow left ventricular assist devices can provide “reliable support” for up to a decade, David L. S. Morales, MD, of the Heart Institute at Cincinnati Children’s Hospital Medical Center, said in his invited commentary (J Thorac Cardiovasc Surg. 2017;153:675-6)
“The current series demonstrates, as has been shown at our institute as well as others, that one can provide an effective therapy for certain patients with DMD and heart failure,” Dr. Morales said of the work of Dr. Perri and coauthors. Dr. Morales added that maximizing outcomes in this population hinges on finding the appropriate time point for intervention in the disease process.
While “there is still much to be learned,” Dr. Morales said, Dr. Perri and his coauthors have shown that LVAD therapy is an option in patients with DMD and heart failure who have failed other treatments. “These young men may, therefore, have the option to extend their lives and possibly have the opportunity to benefit from the impressive medical advances being made,” he said. “Perhaps they and their families have been provided hope.”
Dr. Morales disclosed relationships with Berlin Heart, HeartWare and Oregon Total Artificial Heart.
Almost all young men living with Duchenne muscular dystrophy will develop heart failure, but for many of these patients, continuous-flow left ventricular assist devices can provide “reliable support” for up to a decade, David L. S. Morales, MD, of the Heart Institute at Cincinnati Children’s Hospital Medical Center, said in his invited commentary (J Thorac Cardiovasc Surg. 2017;153:675-6)
“The current series demonstrates, as has been shown at our institute as well as others, that one can provide an effective therapy for certain patients with DMD and heart failure,” Dr. Morales said of the work of Dr. Perri and coauthors. Dr. Morales added that maximizing outcomes in this population hinges on finding the appropriate time point for intervention in the disease process.
While “there is still much to be learned,” Dr. Morales said, Dr. Perri and his coauthors have shown that LVAD therapy is an option in patients with DMD and heart failure who have failed other treatments. “These young men may, therefore, have the option to extend their lives and possibly have the opportunity to benefit from the impressive medical advances being made,” he said. “Perhaps they and their families have been provided hope.”
Dr. Morales disclosed relationships with Berlin Heart, HeartWare and Oregon Total Artificial Heart.
At one time, respiratory failure was the primary cause of death in young men and boys with muscular dystrophies, but since improvements in ventilator support have addressed this problem, cardiac complications such as cardiomyopathy have become the main cause of death in this group, with the highest risk of death in people with Duchenne muscular dystrophy (DMD). Researchers from Rome have reported that the novel use of ventricular assist devices in this population can prolong life.
Gianluigi Perri, MD, PhD, of University Hospital and Bambino Gesù Children Hospital in Rome, and his coauthors, shared their experience treating seven patients with dystrophinopathies and dilated cardiomyopathy (DCM) with left ventricular assist devices (LVADs) from February 2011 to February 2016 (J Thorac Cardiovasc Surg. 2017 March;153:669-74). “Our experience indicates that the use of an LVAD as destination therapy in patients with dystrophinopathies with end-stage DCM is feasible, suggesting that it may be suitable as a palliative therapy for the treatment of these patients with no other therapeutic options,” Dr. Perri and his coauthors said.
Heart transplantation is considered the procedure of choice for children with severe advanced heart failure, but transplantation is contraindicated for children with dystrophinopathies because of the risk of respiratory failure and progression of skeletal myopathy leads to limited functional capacity. Hence, Dr. Perri and his coauthors developed their alternative treatment for end-stage heart failure in these children. They used the Jarvik 2000 LVAD (Jarvik Heart Inc., New York) as destination therapy.
Six of the seven patients they operated on had DMD and one had beta-2 sarcoglycan deficit. Their ages ranged from 14.2 to 23.4 years. Two patients had early complications: retropharyngeal bleeding and cholecystectomy; and abdominal bleeding and splenectomy. Two different patients had late complications: gastrostomy; and osteolysis and infection at the pedestal site. Three patients died after the operation: one of stroke at 15 months; one of severe bleeding about 28 months later; and one of lung infection 45 months afterward. Follow-up for the surviving patients ranged from about 2 months to 40 months. Median hospital stay was 77 days.
Dr. Perri and his coauthors noted that the DMD Care Considerations Working Group expanded acceptable therapies for DMD cardiomyopathy to include novel treatments such as mechanical circulatory support and implantable cardioverter-defibrillators.
“Although the best approach remains unclear, it does seem clear that treatment should be more aggressive,” the researchers said. The limited life expectancy of these patients makes transplantation a complicated choice when a shortage of donors is a concern. “Therefore, the alternative therapeutic option is the use of LVAD,” Dr. Perri and his coauthors said.
These patients need care at centers “with a high level of experience of patients with DMD,” the researchers stated. Common comorbidities such as severe kyphoscoliosis and respiratory muscle weakness in this population increase surgical risks.
Dr. Perri and his coauthors used a surgical technique that involved avoiding the left thoracotomy approach common in adults who undergo VAD implantation, because of respiratory insufficiency in these younger patients. They also used cardiopulmonary bypass in all but one patient who had a minimally invasive off-pump procedure through a left anterior minithoracotomy.
The researchers “strongly suggest” noninvasive ventilation after surgery to assist in pulmonary function often compromised by scoliosis and muscle weakness. “Our experience shows that postoperative care can be extremely challenging and is often burdened by unexpected complications,” they noted.
Kyphoscoliosis poses challenges when placing drains, and complications of these patients should be treated only in a specialized center. “Indeed, one of our patients died in a peripheral hospital because they underwent bronchoscopic examination with an endoscope that caused severe and intractable retropharyngeal bleeding,” they said.
The researchers no relevant financial relationships to disclose.
At one time, respiratory failure was the primary cause of death in young men and boys with muscular dystrophies, but since improvements in ventilator support have addressed this problem, cardiac complications such as cardiomyopathy have become the main cause of death in this group, with the highest risk of death in people with Duchenne muscular dystrophy (DMD). Researchers from Rome have reported that the novel use of ventricular assist devices in this population can prolong life.
Gianluigi Perri, MD, PhD, of University Hospital and Bambino Gesù Children Hospital in Rome, and his coauthors, shared their experience treating seven patients with dystrophinopathies and dilated cardiomyopathy (DCM) with left ventricular assist devices (LVADs) from February 2011 to February 2016 (J Thorac Cardiovasc Surg. 2017 March;153:669-74). “Our experience indicates that the use of an LVAD as destination therapy in patients with dystrophinopathies with end-stage DCM is feasible, suggesting that it may be suitable as a palliative therapy for the treatment of these patients with no other therapeutic options,” Dr. Perri and his coauthors said.
Heart transplantation is considered the procedure of choice for children with severe advanced heart failure, but transplantation is contraindicated for children with dystrophinopathies because of the risk of respiratory failure and progression of skeletal myopathy leads to limited functional capacity. Hence, Dr. Perri and his coauthors developed their alternative treatment for end-stage heart failure in these children. They used the Jarvik 2000 LVAD (Jarvik Heart Inc., New York) as destination therapy.
Six of the seven patients they operated on had DMD and one had beta-2 sarcoglycan deficit. Their ages ranged from 14.2 to 23.4 years. Two patients had early complications: retropharyngeal bleeding and cholecystectomy; and abdominal bleeding and splenectomy. Two different patients had late complications: gastrostomy; and osteolysis and infection at the pedestal site. Three patients died after the operation: one of stroke at 15 months; one of severe bleeding about 28 months later; and one of lung infection 45 months afterward. Follow-up for the surviving patients ranged from about 2 months to 40 months. Median hospital stay was 77 days.
Dr. Perri and his coauthors noted that the DMD Care Considerations Working Group expanded acceptable therapies for DMD cardiomyopathy to include novel treatments such as mechanical circulatory support and implantable cardioverter-defibrillators.
“Although the best approach remains unclear, it does seem clear that treatment should be more aggressive,” the researchers said. The limited life expectancy of these patients makes transplantation a complicated choice when a shortage of donors is a concern. “Therefore, the alternative therapeutic option is the use of LVAD,” Dr. Perri and his coauthors said.
These patients need care at centers “with a high level of experience of patients with DMD,” the researchers stated. Common comorbidities such as severe kyphoscoliosis and respiratory muscle weakness in this population increase surgical risks.
Dr. Perri and his coauthors used a surgical technique that involved avoiding the left thoracotomy approach common in adults who undergo VAD implantation, because of respiratory insufficiency in these younger patients. They also used cardiopulmonary bypass in all but one patient who had a minimally invasive off-pump procedure through a left anterior minithoracotomy.
The researchers “strongly suggest” noninvasive ventilation after surgery to assist in pulmonary function often compromised by scoliosis and muscle weakness. “Our experience shows that postoperative care can be extremely challenging and is often burdened by unexpected complications,” they noted.
Kyphoscoliosis poses challenges when placing drains, and complications of these patients should be treated only in a specialized center. “Indeed, one of our patients died in a peripheral hospital because they underwent bronchoscopic examination with an endoscope that caused severe and intractable retropharyngeal bleeding,” they said.
The researchers no relevant financial relationships to disclose.
FROM THE JOURNAL OF THORACIC AND CARDIOVASCULAR SURGERY
Key clinical point: A left ventricular assist device can be used as destination therapy in patients with Duchenne muscular dystrophy dystrophinopathies and end-stage dilated cardiomyopathy.
Major finding: Four of seven patients who had LVAD survived long term, and survival for the three who died ranged from 15 to 44 months.
Data source: Single-center, retrospective review of seven patients with DMD who had LVAD for DCM from February 2011 to February 2016.
Disclosure: Dr. Perri and his coauthors reported having no relevant financial disclosures.
Preoperative variables can predict prolonged air leak
Prolonged air leak is a well-known complication after lung cancer surgery that can worsen patient outcomes and drive up costs, and while international authors have developed tools to calculate the risk of PAL, their use has been limited in the United States for various reasons. Researchers at the University of Pittsburgh have reported on a predictive model that uses easy-to-obtain patient factors, such as forced expiratory volume and smoking history, to help surgeons identify patients at greatest risk for complications and implement preventative measures.
Adam Attaar and his coauthors reported that their nomogram had an accuracy rate of 76%, with a 95% confidence interval, for predicting PAL after surgery (J Thorac Cardiovasc Surg. 2017 March;153[3]:690-9). “Using readily available candidate variables, our nomogram predicts increasing risk of prolonged air leak with good discriminatory ability,” noted Mr. Attaar, a student at University of Pittsburgh, and his coauthors.
Previously published reports put the incidence of PAL complications at 6%-18%, they noted. In the University of Pittsburgh series of 2,317 patients who had pulmonary resection for lung cancer or nodules from January 2009 to June 2014, the incidence was 8.6%.
In this series, patients with PAL were more likely to be older, men, and smokers, and to have a lower body mass index, peripheral vascular disease, chronic obstructive pulmonary disease, a history of steroid use, a high Zubrod score and lower forced expiratory volume.“They were less likely to have diabetes or to be hospitalized before surgery,” the researchers said. Surgical factors that characterized patients with PAL were resection for primary lung cancer rather than benign or metastatic tumors; lobectomy/segmentectomy or bilobectomy rather than wedge resection; a right-sided resection; thoracotomy; and a surgeon with higher annual caseloads.
Not all those factors made it into the nomogram, however. The nomogram scores each of these 10 variables to calculate the risk of PAL, in order of their weighting: lower forced expiratory volume, procedure type, BMI, right-sided thoracotomy, preoperative hospitalization, annual surgeon caseload, wedge resection by thoracotomy, reoperation, smoking history, and Zubrod score. A second nomogram drops out surgeon volume to make it more generalizable to other institutions.
In explaining higher surgeon volume as a risk factor for PAL, the researchers said that high-volume surgeons may be operating on patients with variables not accounted for in the Society of Thoracic Surgeons General Thoracic Surgery Database. “These unmeasured variables … could reveal modifiable technical factors to reduce the incidence of PAL and require further study,” the researchers said.
Fast-track discharge has gained acceptance in recent years as a way to spare patients a prolonged hospital stay and cut costs, but in this series the median hospital stay for patients with PAL was 10 days vs. 4 days for non-PAL patients (P less than 0.001).
“An accurate and generalizable PAL risk stratification tool could facilitate surgical decision making and patient-specific care” and aid in the design of trials to evaluate air-leak reduction methods such as sealants, buttressed staple lines, and pneumoperitoneum the researchers wrote.
Going forward, further development of the model would involve a multicenter study and inclusion of risk factors not accounted for in the thoracic surgery database, they noted.
The researchers had no relevant financial relationships to disclose.
The authors of this study “have performed a rigorous set of analyses to create this model,” Chi-Fu Jeffrey Yang, MD, of Duke University, Durham, N.C., noted in his invited commentary (J Thorac Cardiovasc Surg. 2017 March;53[3]:700-1). “The strengths of this study include its sound statistical analysis and study design,” Dr. Yang wrote. He gave the authors credit for using bootstrapping to internally validate the model.
However, Dr. Yang said that the database used by the researchers did not account for “numerous important variables,” including presence of pleural adhesions and emphysema status. The analysis also grouped lobectomy and segmentectomy together, and did not consider intraoperative variables such as sealant use, or postoperative management.
While Dr. Yang commended the study authors for developing a “reliable nomogram,” getting it implemented in the clinic is another hurdle. “It is commonly cited that it takes approximately 17 years for research evidence to translate into daily practice,” he said. To shorten that time line, he suggested the authors take a cue from various tech groups: Develop an app that surgeons can use.
Dr. Yang had no relevant financial relationships to disclose.
The authors of this study “have performed a rigorous set of analyses to create this model,” Chi-Fu Jeffrey Yang, MD, of Duke University, Durham, N.C., noted in his invited commentary (J Thorac Cardiovasc Surg. 2017 March;53[3]:700-1). “The strengths of this study include its sound statistical analysis and study design,” Dr. Yang wrote. He gave the authors credit for using bootstrapping to internally validate the model.
However, Dr. Yang said that the database used by the researchers did not account for “numerous important variables,” including presence of pleural adhesions and emphysema status. The analysis also grouped lobectomy and segmentectomy together, and did not consider intraoperative variables such as sealant use, or postoperative management.
While Dr. Yang commended the study authors for developing a “reliable nomogram,” getting it implemented in the clinic is another hurdle. “It is commonly cited that it takes approximately 17 years for research evidence to translate into daily practice,” he said. To shorten that time line, he suggested the authors take a cue from various tech groups: Develop an app that surgeons can use.
Dr. Yang had no relevant financial relationships to disclose.
The authors of this study “have performed a rigorous set of analyses to create this model,” Chi-Fu Jeffrey Yang, MD, of Duke University, Durham, N.C., noted in his invited commentary (J Thorac Cardiovasc Surg. 2017 March;53[3]:700-1). “The strengths of this study include its sound statistical analysis and study design,” Dr. Yang wrote. He gave the authors credit for using bootstrapping to internally validate the model.
However, Dr. Yang said that the database used by the researchers did not account for “numerous important variables,” including presence of pleural adhesions and emphysema status. The analysis also grouped lobectomy and segmentectomy together, and did not consider intraoperative variables such as sealant use, or postoperative management.
While Dr. Yang commended the study authors for developing a “reliable nomogram,” getting it implemented in the clinic is another hurdle. “It is commonly cited that it takes approximately 17 years for research evidence to translate into daily practice,” he said. To shorten that time line, he suggested the authors take a cue from various tech groups: Develop an app that surgeons can use.
Dr. Yang had no relevant financial relationships to disclose.
Prolonged air leak is a well-known complication after lung cancer surgery that can worsen patient outcomes and drive up costs, and while international authors have developed tools to calculate the risk of PAL, their use has been limited in the United States for various reasons. Researchers at the University of Pittsburgh have reported on a predictive model that uses easy-to-obtain patient factors, such as forced expiratory volume and smoking history, to help surgeons identify patients at greatest risk for complications and implement preventative measures.
Adam Attaar and his coauthors reported that their nomogram had an accuracy rate of 76%, with a 95% confidence interval, for predicting PAL after surgery (J Thorac Cardiovasc Surg. 2017 March;153[3]:690-9). “Using readily available candidate variables, our nomogram predicts increasing risk of prolonged air leak with good discriminatory ability,” noted Mr. Attaar, a student at University of Pittsburgh, and his coauthors.
Previously published reports put the incidence of PAL complications at 6%-18%, they noted. In the University of Pittsburgh series of 2,317 patients who had pulmonary resection for lung cancer or nodules from January 2009 to June 2014, the incidence was 8.6%.
In this series, patients with PAL were more likely to be older, men, and smokers, and to have a lower body mass index, peripheral vascular disease, chronic obstructive pulmonary disease, a history of steroid use, a high Zubrod score and lower forced expiratory volume.“They were less likely to have diabetes or to be hospitalized before surgery,” the researchers said. Surgical factors that characterized patients with PAL were resection for primary lung cancer rather than benign or metastatic tumors; lobectomy/segmentectomy or bilobectomy rather than wedge resection; a right-sided resection; thoracotomy; and a surgeon with higher annual caseloads.
Not all those factors made it into the nomogram, however. The nomogram scores each of these 10 variables to calculate the risk of PAL, in order of their weighting: lower forced expiratory volume, procedure type, BMI, right-sided thoracotomy, preoperative hospitalization, annual surgeon caseload, wedge resection by thoracotomy, reoperation, smoking history, and Zubrod score. A second nomogram drops out surgeon volume to make it more generalizable to other institutions.
In explaining higher surgeon volume as a risk factor for PAL, the researchers said that high-volume surgeons may be operating on patients with variables not accounted for in the Society of Thoracic Surgeons General Thoracic Surgery Database. “These unmeasured variables … could reveal modifiable technical factors to reduce the incidence of PAL and require further study,” the researchers said.
Fast-track discharge has gained acceptance in recent years as a way to spare patients a prolonged hospital stay and cut costs, but in this series the median hospital stay for patients with PAL was 10 days vs. 4 days for non-PAL patients (P less than 0.001).
“An accurate and generalizable PAL risk stratification tool could facilitate surgical decision making and patient-specific care” and aid in the design of trials to evaluate air-leak reduction methods such as sealants, buttressed staple lines, and pneumoperitoneum the researchers wrote.
Going forward, further development of the model would involve a multicenter study and inclusion of risk factors not accounted for in the thoracic surgery database, they noted.
The researchers had no relevant financial relationships to disclose.
Prolonged air leak is a well-known complication after lung cancer surgery that can worsen patient outcomes and drive up costs, and while international authors have developed tools to calculate the risk of PAL, their use has been limited in the United States for various reasons. Researchers at the University of Pittsburgh have reported on a predictive model that uses easy-to-obtain patient factors, such as forced expiratory volume and smoking history, to help surgeons identify patients at greatest risk for complications and implement preventative measures.
Adam Attaar and his coauthors reported that their nomogram had an accuracy rate of 76%, with a 95% confidence interval, for predicting PAL after surgery (J Thorac Cardiovasc Surg. 2017 March;153[3]:690-9). “Using readily available candidate variables, our nomogram predicts increasing risk of prolonged air leak with good discriminatory ability,” noted Mr. Attaar, a student at University of Pittsburgh, and his coauthors.
Previously published reports put the incidence of PAL complications at 6%-18%, they noted. In the University of Pittsburgh series of 2,317 patients who had pulmonary resection for lung cancer or nodules from January 2009 to June 2014, the incidence was 8.6%.
In this series, patients with PAL were more likely to be older, men, and smokers, and to have a lower body mass index, peripheral vascular disease, chronic obstructive pulmonary disease, a history of steroid use, a high Zubrod score and lower forced expiratory volume.“They were less likely to have diabetes or to be hospitalized before surgery,” the researchers said. Surgical factors that characterized patients with PAL were resection for primary lung cancer rather than benign or metastatic tumors; lobectomy/segmentectomy or bilobectomy rather than wedge resection; a right-sided resection; thoracotomy; and a surgeon with higher annual caseloads.
Not all those factors made it into the nomogram, however. The nomogram scores each of these 10 variables to calculate the risk of PAL, in order of their weighting: lower forced expiratory volume, procedure type, BMI, right-sided thoracotomy, preoperative hospitalization, annual surgeon caseload, wedge resection by thoracotomy, reoperation, smoking history, and Zubrod score. A second nomogram drops out surgeon volume to make it more generalizable to other institutions.
In explaining higher surgeon volume as a risk factor for PAL, the researchers said that high-volume surgeons may be operating on patients with variables not accounted for in the Society of Thoracic Surgeons General Thoracic Surgery Database. “These unmeasured variables … could reveal modifiable technical factors to reduce the incidence of PAL and require further study,” the researchers said.
Fast-track discharge has gained acceptance in recent years as a way to spare patients a prolonged hospital stay and cut costs, but in this series the median hospital stay for patients with PAL was 10 days vs. 4 days for non-PAL patients (P less than 0.001).
“An accurate and generalizable PAL risk stratification tool could facilitate surgical decision making and patient-specific care” and aid in the design of trials to evaluate air-leak reduction methods such as sealants, buttressed staple lines, and pneumoperitoneum the researchers wrote.
Going forward, further development of the model would involve a multicenter study and inclusion of risk factors not accounted for in the thoracic surgery database, they noted.
The researchers had no relevant financial relationships to disclose.
FROM THE JOURNAL OF THORACIC AND CARDIOVASCULAR SURGERY
Key clinical point: Preoperative variables can be evaluated to determine patient risk for prolonged air leak (PAL) in lung resection for cancer.
Major finding: A nomogram demonstrated 76% discriminatory accuracy in predicting PAL after lung resection.
Data source: Analysis of 2,522 pulmonary resections performed at eight hospitals within the University of Pittsburgh health system from January 2009 to June 2014.
Disclosures: The researchers had no conflicts of interest to disclose.
STAS predictive for lung SCC recurrence
First described in 2015, tumor spread through air spaces is a recently recognized form of invasion in lung carcinoma, but it has not been well described in lung squamous cell carcinoma. However, a study out of Memorial Sloan-Kettering Cancer Center reports spread through air spaces (STAS) is one of the most significant histologic findings in lung squamous cell carcinoma (SCC).
In multivariable models for any recurrence and lung cancer–specific death, the researchers found that STAS was a significant independent predictor for both outcomes (P = .034 and .016, respectively).
“We found that STAS in lung SCC was associated with p-stage, lymphatic and vascular invasion, necrosis, larger nuclear diameter, increased mitoses and high Ki-67 labeling index,” wrote lead author Shaohua Lu, MD, and coauthors (J Thorac Oncol. 2017 Feb;12[2]:223-34). Their findings are based on an analysis of 445 patients who had resection for stage I-III SCC over a 10-year period ending in 2009.
The Sloan-Kettering Group previously reported that STAS was a predictor of recurrence in stage I lung adenocarcinoma patients who had a limited resection (J Thorac Oncol. 2015;10[5]:806-14), and others reported STAS was a clinically significant finding in the disease. In the latest study, Dr. Lu and colleagues set out to determine if STAS is associated with tumor aggressiveness in lung SCC by using a large cohort of patients who had lung SCC resection. The lung resections they studied are from the aforementioned 2015 study that used immunohistochemistry to confirm squamous differentiation in otherwise poorly differentiated tumors.
Two pathologists reviewed tumor slides and used Ki-67 staining to confirm squamous differentiation. The study population comprised 98% former smokers and the median age was 71.3; 76% (336) were older than 65.
Dr. Lu and colleagues noted how STAS in lung SCC differs from its presentation in lung adenocarcinoma. “In contrast to lung adenocarcinoma, in which STAS can manifest as micropapillary clusters, solid nests or single cells, all STAS lesions in lung SCCs consist of solid tumor cell nests,” they wrote.
They found that STAS was associated with a higher risk of recurrence in SCC patients who had lobectomy, but not sublobar resection, whereas in patients with lung adenocarcinoma STAS was associated with a high risk of recurrence if they had sublobar resection.
The study observed STAS in 132 patients (30%). With a median follow-up of 3.4 years, 61% (273) of all patients died in that time. STAS tumors were more aggressive in nature than were non-STAS tumors. Pathologic features strongly associated with STAS were lymphatic invasion (40% for STAS vs. 19% for non-STAS patients); vascular invasion (36% vs. 22%); larger tumor size (median 4 cm vs. 3 cm); higher Ki-67 labeling index (32% vs. 13%); and higher tumor stage (23% with p-stage I, 35% p-stage II, and 43% p-stage III), all significant differences. Patients with STAS also had a higher 5-year cumulative incidence of any recurrence (39% vs. 26%) and lung cancer-specific death (30% vs. 14%), both significant differences.
STAS has an “insidious pattern of tumor invasion” that can be difficult for pathologists to detect and requires the gathering of specimens that include the adjacent lung parenchyma, Dr. Lu and colleagues said. They also dispelled the myth that STAS is an ex vivo artifact. “STAS is morphologically different from tissue floaters and contaminant or extraneous tissues that can lead to diagnostic errors,” they said.
And while the study showed that STAS is an independent predictor of recurrence and cancer-specific death, it was not predictive of overall survival – perhaps because most of the study population was over age 65 and were more likely to die from other causes rather than lung cancer. “We found a strong correlation between STAS and high-grade morphologic patterns such as nuclear size, nuclear atypia, mitotic count and Ki-67 labeling index, suggesting that STAS is associated with tumor proliferation,” Dr. Lu and coauthors said.
“Because we found STAS to show greater prognostic significance than lymphatic vascular, and visceral pleural invasion, all of which are histologic features recommended to be recorded in pathology reports for lung cancer specimens, in the future, STAS may be appropriate to add to this list,” the researchers noted.
Dr. Lu and coauthors had no financial relationships to disclose.
STAS (spread through air spaces) has emerged as a harbinger of poor clinical behavior in adenocarcinoma of the lung. In this new manuscript, a team from Memorial Sloan-Kettering Cancer Center demonstrates that this phenomenon is evident in squamous cell cancer of the lung as well.
A few important take-home messages are worthy of particular note in this manuscript. The first is that STAS is fairly common, present in one-third of all patients with squamous cell cancer. The second is that STAS is correlated with other known indicators of aggressive behavior such as stage, vascular and lymphatic invasion, and a high Ki-67 labeling index. The third is that STAS is not restricted to one particular histological subtype of squamous cell cancer. The fourth is that STAS is predictive of lung cancer–related recurrence and death, independent of other prognostic factors.
While the study needs to be replicated in other datasets, it demonstrates the power of careful pathologic examination in predicting tumor biology. The age old concept deserves renewed emphasis in the current era of ‘Omics’ of various kinds.
Sai Yendamuri, MD, is professor and chair of the department of thoracic surgery at Roswell Park Cancer Institute in Buffalo, N.Y., and is an associate medical editor for Thoracic Surgery News. He has no relevant disclosures.
STAS (spread through air spaces) has emerged as a harbinger of poor clinical behavior in adenocarcinoma of the lung. In this new manuscript, a team from Memorial Sloan-Kettering Cancer Center demonstrates that this phenomenon is evident in squamous cell cancer of the lung as well.
A few important take-home messages are worthy of particular note in this manuscript. The first is that STAS is fairly common, present in one-third of all patients with squamous cell cancer. The second is that STAS is correlated with other known indicators of aggressive behavior such as stage, vascular and lymphatic invasion, and a high Ki-67 labeling index. The third is that STAS is not restricted to one particular histological subtype of squamous cell cancer. The fourth is that STAS is predictive of lung cancer–related recurrence and death, independent of other prognostic factors.
While the study needs to be replicated in other datasets, it demonstrates the power of careful pathologic examination in predicting tumor biology. The age old concept deserves renewed emphasis in the current era of ‘Omics’ of various kinds.
Sai Yendamuri, MD, is professor and chair of the department of thoracic surgery at Roswell Park Cancer Institute in Buffalo, N.Y., and is an associate medical editor for Thoracic Surgery News. He has no relevant disclosures.
STAS (spread through air spaces) has emerged as a harbinger of poor clinical behavior in adenocarcinoma of the lung. In this new manuscript, a team from Memorial Sloan-Kettering Cancer Center demonstrates that this phenomenon is evident in squamous cell cancer of the lung as well.
A few important take-home messages are worthy of particular note in this manuscript. The first is that STAS is fairly common, present in one-third of all patients with squamous cell cancer. The second is that STAS is correlated with other known indicators of aggressive behavior such as stage, vascular and lymphatic invasion, and a high Ki-67 labeling index. The third is that STAS is not restricted to one particular histological subtype of squamous cell cancer. The fourth is that STAS is predictive of lung cancer–related recurrence and death, independent of other prognostic factors.
While the study needs to be replicated in other datasets, it demonstrates the power of careful pathologic examination in predicting tumor biology. The age old concept deserves renewed emphasis in the current era of ‘Omics’ of various kinds.
Sai Yendamuri, MD, is professor and chair of the department of thoracic surgery at Roswell Park Cancer Institute in Buffalo, N.Y., and is an associate medical editor for Thoracic Surgery News. He has no relevant disclosures.
First described in 2015, tumor spread through air spaces is a recently recognized form of invasion in lung carcinoma, but it has not been well described in lung squamous cell carcinoma. However, a study out of Memorial Sloan-Kettering Cancer Center reports spread through air spaces (STAS) is one of the most significant histologic findings in lung squamous cell carcinoma (SCC).
In multivariable models for any recurrence and lung cancer–specific death, the researchers found that STAS was a significant independent predictor for both outcomes (P = .034 and .016, respectively).
“We found that STAS in lung SCC was associated with p-stage, lymphatic and vascular invasion, necrosis, larger nuclear diameter, increased mitoses and high Ki-67 labeling index,” wrote lead author Shaohua Lu, MD, and coauthors (J Thorac Oncol. 2017 Feb;12[2]:223-34). Their findings are based on an analysis of 445 patients who had resection for stage I-III SCC over a 10-year period ending in 2009.
The Sloan-Kettering Group previously reported that STAS was a predictor of recurrence in stage I lung adenocarcinoma patients who had a limited resection (J Thorac Oncol. 2015;10[5]:806-14), and others reported STAS was a clinically significant finding in the disease. In the latest study, Dr. Lu and colleagues set out to determine if STAS is associated with tumor aggressiveness in lung SCC by using a large cohort of patients who had lung SCC resection. The lung resections they studied are from the aforementioned 2015 study that used immunohistochemistry to confirm squamous differentiation in otherwise poorly differentiated tumors.
Two pathologists reviewed tumor slides and used Ki-67 staining to confirm squamous differentiation. The study population comprised 98% former smokers and the median age was 71.3; 76% (336) were older than 65.
Dr. Lu and colleagues noted how STAS in lung SCC differs from its presentation in lung adenocarcinoma. “In contrast to lung adenocarcinoma, in which STAS can manifest as micropapillary clusters, solid nests or single cells, all STAS lesions in lung SCCs consist of solid tumor cell nests,” they wrote.
They found that STAS was associated with a higher risk of recurrence in SCC patients who had lobectomy, but not sublobar resection, whereas in patients with lung adenocarcinoma STAS was associated with a high risk of recurrence if they had sublobar resection.
The study observed STAS in 132 patients (30%). With a median follow-up of 3.4 years, 61% (273) of all patients died in that time. STAS tumors were more aggressive in nature than were non-STAS tumors. Pathologic features strongly associated with STAS were lymphatic invasion (40% for STAS vs. 19% for non-STAS patients); vascular invasion (36% vs. 22%); larger tumor size (median 4 cm vs. 3 cm); higher Ki-67 labeling index (32% vs. 13%); and higher tumor stage (23% with p-stage I, 35% p-stage II, and 43% p-stage III), all significant differences. Patients with STAS also had a higher 5-year cumulative incidence of any recurrence (39% vs. 26%) and lung cancer-specific death (30% vs. 14%), both significant differences.
STAS has an “insidious pattern of tumor invasion” that can be difficult for pathologists to detect and requires the gathering of specimens that include the adjacent lung parenchyma, Dr. Lu and colleagues said. They also dispelled the myth that STAS is an ex vivo artifact. “STAS is morphologically different from tissue floaters and contaminant or extraneous tissues that can lead to diagnostic errors,” they said.
And while the study showed that STAS is an independent predictor of recurrence and cancer-specific death, it was not predictive of overall survival – perhaps because most of the study population was over age 65 and were more likely to die from other causes rather than lung cancer. “We found a strong correlation between STAS and high-grade morphologic patterns such as nuclear size, nuclear atypia, mitotic count and Ki-67 labeling index, suggesting that STAS is associated with tumor proliferation,” Dr. Lu and coauthors said.
“Because we found STAS to show greater prognostic significance than lymphatic vascular, and visceral pleural invasion, all of which are histologic features recommended to be recorded in pathology reports for lung cancer specimens, in the future, STAS may be appropriate to add to this list,” the researchers noted.
Dr. Lu and coauthors had no financial relationships to disclose.
First described in 2015, tumor spread through air spaces is a recently recognized form of invasion in lung carcinoma, but it has not been well described in lung squamous cell carcinoma. However, a study out of Memorial Sloan-Kettering Cancer Center reports spread through air spaces (STAS) is one of the most significant histologic findings in lung squamous cell carcinoma (SCC).
In multivariable models for any recurrence and lung cancer–specific death, the researchers found that STAS was a significant independent predictor for both outcomes (P = .034 and .016, respectively).
“We found that STAS in lung SCC was associated with p-stage, lymphatic and vascular invasion, necrosis, larger nuclear diameter, increased mitoses and high Ki-67 labeling index,” wrote lead author Shaohua Lu, MD, and coauthors (J Thorac Oncol. 2017 Feb;12[2]:223-34). Their findings are based on an analysis of 445 patients who had resection for stage I-III SCC over a 10-year period ending in 2009.
The Sloan-Kettering Group previously reported that STAS was a predictor of recurrence in stage I lung adenocarcinoma patients who had a limited resection (J Thorac Oncol. 2015;10[5]:806-14), and others reported STAS was a clinically significant finding in the disease. In the latest study, Dr. Lu and colleagues set out to determine if STAS is associated with tumor aggressiveness in lung SCC by using a large cohort of patients who had lung SCC resection. The lung resections they studied are from the aforementioned 2015 study that used immunohistochemistry to confirm squamous differentiation in otherwise poorly differentiated tumors.
Two pathologists reviewed tumor slides and used Ki-67 staining to confirm squamous differentiation. The study population comprised 98% former smokers and the median age was 71.3; 76% (336) were older than 65.
Dr. Lu and colleagues noted how STAS in lung SCC differs from its presentation in lung adenocarcinoma. “In contrast to lung adenocarcinoma, in which STAS can manifest as micropapillary clusters, solid nests or single cells, all STAS lesions in lung SCCs consist of solid tumor cell nests,” they wrote.
They found that STAS was associated with a higher risk of recurrence in SCC patients who had lobectomy, but not sublobar resection, whereas in patients with lung adenocarcinoma STAS was associated with a high risk of recurrence if they had sublobar resection.
The study observed STAS in 132 patients (30%). With a median follow-up of 3.4 years, 61% (273) of all patients died in that time. STAS tumors were more aggressive in nature than were non-STAS tumors. Pathologic features strongly associated with STAS were lymphatic invasion (40% for STAS vs. 19% for non-STAS patients); vascular invasion (36% vs. 22%); larger tumor size (median 4 cm vs. 3 cm); higher Ki-67 labeling index (32% vs. 13%); and higher tumor stage (23% with p-stage I, 35% p-stage II, and 43% p-stage III), all significant differences. Patients with STAS also had a higher 5-year cumulative incidence of any recurrence (39% vs. 26%) and lung cancer-specific death (30% vs. 14%), both significant differences.
STAS has an “insidious pattern of tumor invasion” that can be difficult for pathologists to detect and requires the gathering of specimens that include the adjacent lung parenchyma, Dr. Lu and colleagues said. They also dispelled the myth that STAS is an ex vivo artifact. “STAS is morphologically different from tissue floaters and contaminant or extraneous tissues that can lead to diagnostic errors,” they said.
And while the study showed that STAS is an independent predictor of recurrence and cancer-specific death, it was not predictive of overall survival – perhaps because most of the study population was over age 65 and were more likely to die from other causes rather than lung cancer. “We found a strong correlation between STAS and high-grade morphologic patterns such as nuclear size, nuclear atypia, mitotic count and Ki-67 labeling index, suggesting that STAS is associated with tumor proliferation,” Dr. Lu and coauthors said.
“Because we found STAS to show greater prognostic significance than lymphatic vascular, and visceral pleural invasion, all of which are histologic features recommended to be recorded in pathology reports for lung cancer specimens, in the future, STAS may be appropriate to add to this list,” the researchers noted.
Dr. Lu and coauthors had no financial relationships to disclose.
FROM THE JOURNAL OF THORACIC ONCOLOGY
Key clinical point: Spread through air spaces (STAS) is a prognostic histologic finding in lung squamous cell carcinoma.
Major finding: STAS was observed in 30% of patients and frequency increased with age.
Data source: Retrospective analysis of 445 resections for solitary stage I-III lung squamous cell carcinoma at Memorial Sloan-Kettering Cancer Center between 1999 and 2009.
Disclosure: Dr. Lu and coauthors reported having no relevant financial disclosures.
Can better operations improve CABG in women?
Worse outcomes after cardiovascular arterial bypass grafting (CABG) in women have been attributed to a number of clinical and nonclinical factors: older age, delayed diagnosis and treatment, more comorbidities, smaller body size, underuse of arterial grafts, and referral bias. However, a team of Cleveland Clinic researchers reported that women were less likely than men to have bilateral–internal thoracic artery (ITA) grafting and complete revascularization, both of which are linked to better long-term survival.
“Women had less favorable preoperative characteristics than men but received fewer bilateral-ITA grafts and less all-arterial grafting as part of their revascularization strategy,” Tamer Attia, MD, MSc, and his coauthors said in the study published in the Journal of Thoracic and Cardiovascular Surgery. They also found that women were more likely to die in the hospital after CABG and had lower risk-adjusted long-term survival than men (2017 March;153:571-9).
Survival was lowest in women who were not completely revascularized and had no ITA grafting, while survival was highest in men who were completely revascularized and had bilateral grafting, Dr. Attia and coauthors said.
The researchers’ goal was to use extensive risk adjustment to evaluate how differences in revascularization strategies influenced survival of men and women after CABG. They analyzed 57,943 primary, isolated CABG procedures performed at Cleveland Clinic from 1972 to 2011, including 11,009 procedures in women.
The researchers identified differences between sexes in three key areas: revascularization strategies, in-hospital outcomes, and time-related survival.
With regard to revascularization strategies, while men were significantly more likely to have incomplete revascularization than were women, women received significantly fewer arterial grafts (8.4% vs. 9.3% for men). This included fewer bilateral-ITA grafts and radial artery grafts, less use of total arterial revascularization, and greater use of saphenous vein grafts (SVGs) to the left anterior descending artery. Women were also significantly more likely to receive only SVGs for revascularization (32% vs. 30% for men; P less than .0001). Most operations for both women and men were done with cardiopulmonary bypass, but significantly more women had off-pump procedures (5.4% vs. 2.9%).
In the hospital after operations, women were significantly more prone to postoperative deep sternal–wound infections and septicemias, as well as strokes and renal failure, including dialysis-dependent renal failure. Women also had higher rates of new-onset atrial fibrillation (15% vs. 13% in men), and higher rates of mechanical ventilation for more than 24 hours (13% vs. 9.2%). Women spent more time in the ICU and hospital overall, and their in-hospital death rate was more than double that of men (2.7% vs. 1.1%).
Women also had shorter long-term survival, “and this has persisted since the beginning of CABG at Cleveland Clinic,” Dr. Attia and coauthors said. What’s more, the survival gap between women in the study and women in the general population post CABG was wider than that in men. “After we adjusted for patient and revascularization strategy differences, female sex remained an independent risk factor for death overall and both early and late after CABG.”
Incomplete revascularization had greater consequences for women than for men. At 10 years, 58% of women with incomplete revascularization survived, vs. 70% of men. At 20 years, the rates were 25% for women and 35% for men. “Use of ITA grafts was associated with better survival than use of SVGs alone and was best when bilateral-ITA grafting was performed,” Dr. Attia and coauthors said. However, the study determined that bilateral grafting seems less effective in women long-term. “Hence, a patient’s sex deserves special consideration in operative planning.”
Many questions about CABG in women remain: Identifying which female patients would benefit from more meticulous conduit harvesting, from better coronary artery selection, and from bilateral-ITA grafting and which are less susceptible to sternal would infections could increase appropriate use of bilateral-ITA grafting, the researchers noted. “The difference in effectiveness of bilateral-ITA grafting needs to be considered in women at elevated risk for bilateral-ITA harvesting complications.”
Coauthor Ellen Mayer Sabik, MD, is a principal investigator for Abbott Laboratories and is on the scientific advisory board of Medtronic. Dr. Attia and all other coauthors reported having no relevant financial relationships to disclose.
As with other long-term analyses, the answer in this study “is in the shadows as opposed to the spotlight,” George L. Hicks Jr., MD, said in his invited commentary (J Thorac Cardiovasc Surg. 2017;153[3]:580-1).
Dr. Hicks of the University of Rochester (N.Y.) noted key limitations of the study: use of all-cause mortality, substandard use of bilateral– or single–internal thoracic artery grafting, little data about postdischarge cholesterol levels, diabetes incidence, or blood pressure, among others. However, “the authors raise the banner for the continued need for increased use of arterial revascularization with the eventual hope that the Arterial Revascularization Trial will reinforce the survival benefits manifested by that strategy,” he said.
Dr. Hicks invoked the besseller, “Men Are From Mars and Women From Venus.” “If men are truly from Mars and different from the women of Venus, it behooves all practitioners to aggressively monitor and treat women after menopause for the potential – if not inevitable – onset of cardiovascular problems, hypertension, hyperlipidemia, diabetes, and stroke,” Dr. Hicks said.
Reducing risks and not changing the type of operation will even out the differences in postoperative survival between genders, he indicated. “Furthermore, the extension of similar therapies – for example, [bilateral–internal thoracic artery] or all-arterial grafting and improved long-term risk modification in both men and women – may improve the inequality but not eliminate the differences until we know that both men and women come from the same planet,” he said.
Dr. Hicks reported having no relevant financial relationships to disclose.
As with other long-term analyses, the answer in this study “is in the shadows as opposed to the spotlight,” George L. Hicks Jr., MD, said in his invited commentary (J Thorac Cardiovasc Surg. 2017;153[3]:580-1).
Dr. Hicks of the University of Rochester (N.Y.) noted key limitations of the study: use of all-cause mortality, substandard use of bilateral– or single–internal thoracic artery grafting, little data about postdischarge cholesterol levels, diabetes incidence, or blood pressure, among others. However, “the authors raise the banner for the continued need for increased use of arterial revascularization with the eventual hope that the Arterial Revascularization Trial will reinforce the survival benefits manifested by that strategy,” he said.
Dr. Hicks invoked the besseller, “Men Are From Mars and Women From Venus.” “If men are truly from Mars and different from the women of Venus, it behooves all practitioners to aggressively monitor and treat women after menopause for the potential – if not inevitable – onset of cardiovascular problems, hypertension, hyperlipidemia, diabetes, and stroke,” Dr. Hicks said.
Reducing risks and not changing the type of operation will even out the differences in postoperative survival between genders, he indicated. “Furthermore, the extension of similar therapies – for example, [bilateral–internal thoracic artery] or all-arterial grafting and improved long-term risk modification in both men and women – may improve the inequality but not eliminate the differences until we know that both men and women come from the same planet,” he said.
Dr. Hicks reported having no relevant financial relationships to disclose.
As with other long-term analyses, the answer in this study “is in the shadows as opposed to the spotlight,” George L. Hicks Jr., MD, said in his invited commentary (J Thorac Cardiovasc Surg. 2017;153[3]:580-1).
Dr. Hicks of the University of Rochester (N.Y.) noted key limitations of the study: use of all-cause mortality, substandard use of bilateral– or single–internal thoracic artery grafting, little data about postdischarge cholesterol levels, diabetes incidence, or blood pressure, among others. However, “the authors raise the banner for the continued need for increased use of arterial revascularization with the eventual hope that the Arterial Revascularization Trial will reinforce the survival benefits manifested by that strategy,” he said.
Dr. Hicks invoked the besseller, “Men Are From Mars and Women From Venus.” “If men are truly from Mars and different from the women of Venus, it behooves all practitioners to aggressively monitor and treat women after menopause for the potential – if not inevitable – onset of cardiovascular problems, hypertension, hyperlipidemia, diabetes, and stroke,” Dr. Hicks said.
Reducing risks and not changing the type of operation will even out the differences in postoperative survival between genders, he indicated. “Furthermore, the extension of similar therapies – for example, [bilateral–internal thoracic artery] or all-arterial grafting and improved long-term risk modification in both men and women – may improve the inequality but not eliminate the differences until we know that both men and women come from the same planet,” he said.
Dr. Hicks reported having no relevant financial relationships to disclose.
Worse outcomes after cardiovascular arterial bypass grafting (CABG) in women have been attributed to a number of clinical and nonclinical factors: older age, delayed diagnosis and treatment, more comorbidities, smaller body size, underuse of arterial grafts, and referral bias. However, a team of Cleveland Clinic researchers reported that women were less likely than men to have bilateral–internal thoracic artery (ITA) grafting and complete revascularization, both of which are linked to better long-term survival.
“Women had less favorable preoperative characteristics than men but received fewer bilateral-ITA grafts and less all-arterial grafting as part of their revascularization strategy,” Tamer Attia, MD, MSc, and his coauthors said in the study published in the Journal of Thoracic and Cardiovascular Surgery. They also found that women were more likely to die in the hospital after CABG and had lower risk-adjusted long-term survival than men (2017 March;153:571-9).
Survival was lowest in women who were not completely revascularized and had no ITA grafting, while survival was highest in men who were completely revascularized and had bilateral grafting, Dr. Attia and coauthors said.
The researchers’ goal was to use extensive risk adjustment to evaluate how differences in revascularization strategies influenced survival of men and women after CABG. They analyzed 57,943 primary, isolated CABG procedures performed at Cleveland Clinic from 1972 to 2011, including 11,009 procedures in women.
The researchers identified differences between sexes in three key areas: revascularization strategies, in-hospital outcomes, and time-related survival.
With regard to revascularization strategies, while men were significantly more likely to have incomplete revascularization than were women, women received significantly fewer arterial grafts (8.4% vs. 9.3% for men). This included fewer bilateral-ITA grafts and radial artery grafts, less use of total arterial revascularization, and greater use of saphenous vein grafts (SVGs) to the left anterior descending artery. Women were also significantly more likely to receive only SVGs for revascularization (32% vs. 30% for men; P less than .0001). Most operations for both women and men were done with cardiopulmonary bypass, but significantly more women had off-pump procedures (5.4% vs. 2.9%).
In the hospital after operations, women were significantly more prone to postoperative deep sternal–wound infections and septicemias, as well as strokes and renal failure, including dialysis-dependent renal failure. Women also had higher rates of new-onset atrial fibrillation (15% vs. 13% in men), and higher rates of mechanical ventilation for more than 24 hours (13% vs. 9.2%). Women spent more time in the ICU and hospital overall, and their in-hospital death rate was more than double that of men (2.7% vs. 1.1%).
Women also had shorter long-term survival, “and this has persisted since the beginning of CABG at Cleveland Clinic,” Dr. Attia and coauthors said. What’s more, the survival gap between women in the study and women in the general population post CABG was wider than that in men. “After we adjusted for patient and revascularization strategy differences, female sex remained an independent risk factor for death overall and both early and late after CABG.”
Incomplete revascularization had greater consequences for women than for men. At 10 years, 58% of women with incomplete revascularization survived, vs. 70% of men. At 20 years, the rates were 25% for women and 35% for men. “Use of ITA grafts was associated with better survival than use of SVGs alone and was best when bilateral-ITA grafting was performed,” Dr. Attia and coauthors said. However, the study determined that bilateral grafting seems less effective in women long-term. “Hence, a patient’s sex deserves special consideration in operative planning.”
Many questions about CABG in women remain: Identifying which female patients would benefit from more meticulous conduit harvesting, from better coronary artery selection, and from bilateral-ITA grafting and which are less susceptible to sternal would infections could increase appropriate use of bilateral-ITA grafting, the researchers noted. “The difference in effectiveness of bilateral-ITA grafting needs to be considered in women at elevated risk for bilateral-ITA harvesting complications.”
Coauthor Ellen Mayer Sabik, MD, is a principal investigator for Abbott Laboratories and is on the scientific advisory board of Medtronic. Dr. Attia and all other coauthors reported having no relevant financial relationships to disclose.
Worse outcomes after cardiovascular arterial bypass grafting (CABG) in women have been attributed to a number of clinical and nonclinical factors: older age, delayed diagnosis and treatment, more comorbidities, smaller body size, underuse of arterial grafts, and referral bias. However, a team of Cleveland Clinic researchers reported that women were less likely than men to have bilateral–internal thoracic artery (ITA) grafting and complete revascularization, both of which are linked to better long-term survival.
“Women had less favorable preoperative characteristics than men but received fewer bilateral-ITA grafts and less all-arterial grafting as part of their revascularization strategy,” Tamer Attia, MD, MSc, and his coauthors said in the study published in the Journal of Thoracic and Cardiovascular Surgery. They also found that women were more likely to die in the hospital after CABG and had lower risk-adjusted long-term survival than men (2017 March;153:571-9).
Survival was lowest in women who were not completely revascularized and had no ITA grafting, while survival was highest in men who were completely revascularized and had bilateral grafting, Dr. Attia and coauthors said.
The researchers’ goal was to use extensive risk adjustment to evaluate how differences in revascularization strategies influenced survival of men and women after CABG. They analyzed 57,943 primary, isolated CABG procedures performed at Cleveland Clinic from 1972 to 2011, including 11,009 procedures in women.
The researchers identified differences between sexes in three key areas: revascularization strategies, in-hospital outcomes, and time-related survival.
With regard to revascularization strategies, while men were significantly more likely to have incomplete revascularization than were women, women received significantly fewer arterial grafts (8.4% vs. 9.3% for men). This included fewer bilateral-ITA grafts and radial artery grafts, less use of total arterial revascularization, and greater use of saphenous vein grafts (SVGs) to the left anterior descending artery. Women were also significantly more likely to receive only SVGs for revascularization (32% vs. 30% for men; P less than .0001). Most operations for both women and men were done with cardiopulmonary bypass, but significantly more women had off-pump procedures (5.4% vs. 2.9%).
In the hospital after operations, women were significantly more prone to postoperative deep sternal–wound infections and septicemias, as well as strokes and renal failure, including dialysis-dependent renal failure. Women also had higher rates of new-onset atrial fibrillation (15% vs. 13% in men), and higher rates of mechanical ventilation for more than 24 hours (13% vs. 9.2%). Women spent more time in the ICU and hospital overall, and their in-hospital death rate was more than double that of men (2.7% vs. 1.1%).
Women also had shorter long-term survival, “and this has persisted since the beginning of CABG at Cleveland Clinic,” Dr. Attia and coauthors said. What’s more, the survival gap between women in the study and women in the general population post CABG was wider than that in men. “After we adjusted for patient and revascularization strategy differences, female sex remained an independent risk factor for death overall and both early and late after CABG.”
Incomplete revascularization had greater consequences for women than for men. At 10 years, 58% of women with incomplete revascularization survived, vs. 70% of men. At 20 years, the rates were 25% for women and 35% for men. “Use of ITA grafts was associated with better survival than use of SVGs alone and was best when bilateral-ITA grafting was performed,” Dr. Attia and coauthors said. However, the study determined that bilateral grafting seems less effective in women long-term. “Hence, a patient’s sex deserves special consideration in operative planning.”
Many questions about CABG in women remain: Identifying which female patients would benefit from more meticulous conduit harvesting, from better coronary artery selection, and from bilateral-ITA grafting and which are less susceptible to sternal would infections could increase appropriate use of bilateral-ITA grafting, the researchers noted. “The difference in effectiveness of bilateral-ITA grafting needs to be considered in women at elevated risk for bilateral-ITA harvesting complications.”
Coauthor Ellen Mayer Sabik, MD, is a principal investigator for Abbott Laboratories and is on the scientific advisory board of Medtronic. Dr. Attia and all other coauthors reported having no relevant financial relationships to disclose.
FROM THE JOURNAL OF THORACIC AND CARDIOVASCULAR SURGERY
Key clinical point: Survival rates after CABG are worse for women than for men.
Major finding: In both men and women, complete revascularization and use of bilateral-ITA grafting achieve better long-term survival than incomplete revascularization and single-ITA grafting.
Data source: Analysis of 57,943 adults who had primary isolated CABG from 1972 to 2011 at Cleveland Clinic.
Disclosure: Coauthor Ellen Mayer Sabik, MD, is a principal investigator for Abbott Laboratories and is on the scientific advisory board of Medtronic. Dr. Attia and all other coauthors reported having no relevant financial disclosures.
Aortic repair in Loeys-Dietz syndrome requires close follow-up
The knowledge about Loeys-Dietz syndrome has evolved quickly since Hal Dietz, MD, and Bart Loeys, MD, at Johns Hopkins University, Baltimore, first reported on it in 2005.
Now, another team of Johns Hopkins investigators have reported that an aggressive approach with aortic root replacement coupled with valve-sparing whenever possible produces favorable results, but that clinicians must follow these patients closely with cardiovascular imaging.
“Growing experience with Loeys-Dietz syndrome has confirmed early impressions of its aggressive nature and proclivity toward aortic catastrophe,” Nishant D. Patel, MD, and his coauthors said in the February issue of the Journal of Thoracic and Cardiovascular Surgery (2017;153:406-12). They reported on results of all 79 patients with Loeys-Dietz syndrome (LDS) who had cardiovascular surgery at Johns Hopkins. There were two (3%) deaths during surgery and eight (10%) late deaths. Patients with LDS are at risk for dissection early when the aortic root reaches 4 cm. Despite what they termed “favorable” outcomes of surgery, Dr. Patel and his coauthors acknowledged that reintervention rates for this population are high – 19 patients (24%) had subsequent operations. That suggests cardiac surgeons must closely monitor these patients. “Meticulous follow-up with cardiovascular surveillance imaging remains important for management, particularly as clinical LDS subtypes are characterized and more tailored treatment is developed,” Dr. Patel and his coauthors reported.
They advise echocardiography every 3 to 6 months for the first year after surgery and then every 6 to 12 months afterward. Full-body imaging should occur at least every 2 years. “In particular, patients with type B dissections should be monitored aggressively for aneurysm growth,” Dr. Patel and his coauthors said. They recommend imaging at seven to 14 days after dissection, then repeat imaging at 1, 3, 6, and 12 months, and then yearly thereafter.
They noted that four LDS subtypes have been identified. Although those with LDS1 and 2 subtypes are prone to aortic rupture at an earlier age and at smaller aortic diameters than other connective tissue disorders, the medical and surgical management for all subtypes are similar, Dr. Patel and his coauthors indicated.
“Certain congenital heart defects are more common among patients with LDS, compared with the normal population, including patent ductus arteriosus and mitral valve prolapse/insufficiency,” they said. Genotype is one factor that determines the need for surgery in LDS patients, Dr. Patel and his coauthors said. Others are growth rate, aortic valve function, family history, and severity of noncardiac phenotype.
The 79 patients in the study were divided almost evenly between gender, and the average age at first operation was 24.9 years; 38 were children younger than 18 years and 20 had a previous sternotomy. Aortic root replacement represented the predominant operation in the group, accounting for 65 operations (82.3%), of which 52 (80%) were valve-sparing procedures and the remainder were composite valve-graft procedures. The other procedures the researchers performed were nine aortic arch replacements (11.4%), three open thoracoabdominal repairs (3.8%) and two ascending aorta replacements (2.5%).
“Valve-sparing root replacement has become a safe and reliable option for appropriately selected younger patients with LDS,” Dr. Patel and his coauthors wrote. Five patients needed a second operation on the aortic valve or root; three of them had a Florida sleeve procedure. “Based on these initial outcomes with the Florida sleeve at our institution, we have abandoned this procedure in favor of conventional valve-sparing root replacement,” Dr. Patel and his coauthors stated.
Dr. Patel and his coauthors had no financial relationships to disclose.
A rare disease such as Loeys-Dietz syndrome (LDS) seems more common now in vascular surgery, as we are the specialty making decisions on disorders of the descending thoracic aorta. Understanding not only the clinical presentation with the aortic root involvement but the fact that these patients require close surveillance is the key message.
Often we are consulted regarding or admit a patient with an acute type B dissection who usually has a history of poorly controlled hypertension but, also, has a history of “aneurysms” or a family member who passed away at a young age. These clues should lead us to explore the “molecular diagnosis” as well to see if patients have a connective tissue disorder such as LDS or vascular Ehlers-Danlos syndrome (vEDS). Because many of these syndromes have overlapping symptoms, understanding the type of connective tissue disorder will allow us to appreciate the differences, especially in a syndrome such as LDS, which was first reported in 2005 and is associated with more cardiac and aortic root pathologies than vEDS.
At the University of Washington, my colleague Dr. Sherene Shalhub heads a vascular genetics clinic in which she examines patients with potential connective tissue disorders in an attempt to make the molecular diagnosis and identify surveillance protocols and study the effect of open and endovascular repairs in these patients. Pooling data on these patients from around the country and collaborating within, as well as outside of, our specialty is imperative to increasing our understanding of these disorders. I believe we are seeing a trend in which we crave studies such as Dr. Patel’s to increase our knowledge on these rare (but now more common) entities.
Niten Singh, MD, is the director of the Limb Preservation Service at the Regional Vascular Center at Harborview Medical Center, Seattle, and an Associate Editor of Vascular Specialist.
A rare disease such as Loeys-Dietz syndrome (LDS) seems more common now in vascular surgery, as we are the specialty making decisions on disorders of the descending thoracic aorta. Understanding not only the clinical presentation with the aortic root involvement but the fact that these patients require close surveillance is the key message.
Often we are consulted regarding or admit a patient with an acute type B dissection who usually has a history of poorly controlled hypertension but, also, has a history of “aneurysms” or a family member who passed away at a young age. These clues should lead us to explore the “molecular diagnosis” as well to see if patients have a connective tissue disorder such as LDS or vascular Ehlers-Danlos syndrome (vEDS). Because many of these syndromes have overlapping symptoms, understanding the type of connective tissue disorder will allow us to appreciate the differences, especially in a syndrome such as LDS, which was first reported in 2005 and is associated with more cardiac and aortic root pathologies than vEDS.
At the University of Washington, my colleague Dr. Sherene Shalhub heads a vascular genetics clinic in which she examines patients with potential connective tissue disorders in an attempt to make the molecular diagnosis and identify surveillance protocols and study the effect of open and endovascular repairs in these patients. Pooling data on these patients from around the country and collaborating within, as well as outside of, our specialty is imperative to increasing our understanding of these disorders. I believe we are seeing a trend in which we crave studies such as Dr. Patel’s to increase our knowledge on these rare (but now more common) entities.
Niten Singh, MD, is the director of the Limb Preservation Service at the Regional Vascular Center at Harborview Medical Center, Seattle, and an Associate Editor of Vascular Specialist.
A rare disease such as Loeys-Dietz syndrome (LDS) seems more common now in vascular surgery, as we are the specialty making decisions on disorders of the descending thoracic aorta. Understanding not only the clinical presentation with the aortic root involvement but the fact that these patients require close surveillance is the key message.
Often we are consulted regarding or admit a patient with an acute type B dissection who usually has a history of poorly controlled hypertension but, also, has a history of “aneurysms” or a family member who passed away at a young age. These clues should lead us to explore the “molecular diagnosis” as well to see if patients have a connective tissue disorder such as LDS or vascular Ehlers-Danlos syndrome (vEDS). Because many of these syndromes have overlapping symptoms, understanding the type of connective tissue disorder will allow us to appreciate the differences, especially in a syndrome such as LDS, which was first reported in 2005 and is associated with more cardiac and aortic root pathologies than vEDS.
At the University of Washington, my colleague Dr. Sherene Shalhub heads a vascular genetics clinic in which she examines patients with potential connective tissue disorders in an attempt to make the molecular diagnosis and identify surveillance protocols and study the effect of open and endovascular repairs in these patients. Pooling data on these patients from around the country and collaborating within, as well as outside of, our specialty is imperative to increasing our understanding of these disorders. I believe we are seeing a trend in which we crave studies such as Dr. Patel’s to increase our knowledge on these rare (but now more common) entities.
Niten Singh, MD, is the director of the Limb Preservation Service at the Regional Vascular Center at Harborview Medical Center, Seattle, and an Associate Editor of Vascular Specialist.
The knowledge about Loeys-Dietz syndrome has evolved quickly since Hal Dietz, MD, and Bart Loeys, MD, at Johns Hopkins University, Baltimore, first reported on it in 2005.
Now, another team of Johns Hopkins investigators have reported that an aggressive approach with aortic root replacement coupled with valve-sparing whenever possible produces favorable results, but that clinicians must follow these patients closely with cardiovascular imaging.
“Growing experience with Loeys-Dietz syndrome has confirmed early impressions of its aggressive nature and proclivity toward aortic catastrophe,” Nishant D. Patel, MD, and his coauthors said in the February issue of the Journal of Thoracic and Cardiovascular Surgery (2017;153:406-12). They reported on results of all 79 patients with Loeys-Dietz syndrome (LDS) who had cardiovascular surgery at Johns Hopkins. There were two (3%) deaths during surgery and eight (10%) late deaths. Patients with LDS are at risk for dissection early when the aortic root reaches 4 cm. Despite what they termed “favorable” outcomes of surgery, Dr. Patel and his coauthors acknowledged that reintervention rates for this population are high – 19 patients (24%) had subsequent operations. That suggests cardiac surgeons must closely monitor these patients. “Meticulous follow-up with cardiovascular surveillance imaging remains important for management, particularly as clinical LDS subtypes are characterized and more tailored treatment is developed,” Dr. Patel and his coauthors reported.
They advise echocardiography every 3 to 6 months for the first year after surgery and then every 6 to 12 months afterward. Full-body imaging should occur at least every 2 years. “In particular, patients with type B dissections should be monitored aggressively for aneurysm growth,” Dr. Patel and his coauthors said. They recommend imaging at seven to 14 days after dissection, then repeat imaging at 1, 3, 6, and 12 months, and then yearly thereafter.
They noted that four LDS subtypes have been identified. Although those with LDS1 and 2 subtypes are prone to aortic rupture at an earlier age and at smaller aortic diameters than other connective tissue disorders, the medical and surgical management for all subtypes are similar, Dr. Patel and his coauthors indicated.
“Certain congenital heart defects are more common among patients with LDS, compared with the normal population, including patent ductus arteriosus and mitral valve prolapse/insufficiency,” they said. Genotype is one factor that determines the need for surgery in LDS patients, Dr. Patel and his coauthors said. Others are growth rate, aortic valve function, family history, and severity of noncardiac phenotype.
The 79 patients in the study were divided almost evenly between gender, and the average age at first operation was 24.9 years; 38 were children younger than 18 years and 20 had a previous sternotomy. Aortic root replacement represented the predominant operation in the group, accounting for 65 operations (82.3%), of which 52 (80%) were valve-sparing procedures and the remainder were composite valve-graft procedures. The other procedures the researchers performed were nine aortic arch replacements (11.4%), three open thoracoabdominal repairs (3.8%) and two ascending aorta replacements (2.5%).
“Valve-sparing root replacement has become a safe and reliable option for appropriately selected younger patients with LDS,” Dr. Patel and his coauthors wrote. Five patients needed a second operation on the aortic valve or root; three of them had a Florida sleeve procedure. “Based on these initial outcomes with the Florida sleeve at our institution, we have abandoned this procedure in favor of conventional valve-sparing root replacement,” Dr. Patel and his coauthors stated.
Dr. Patel and his coauthors had no financial relationships to disclose.
The knowledge about Loeys-Dietz syndrome has evolved quickly since Hal Dietz, MD, and Bart Loeys, MD, at Johns Hopkins University, Baltimore, first reported on it in 2005.
Now, another team of Johns Hopkins investigators have reported that an aggressive approach with aortic root replacement coupled with valve-sparing whenever possible produces favorable results, but that clinicians must follow these patients closely with cardiovascular imaging.
“Growing experience with Loeys-Dietz syndrome has confirmed early impressions of its aggressive nature and proclivity toward aortic catastrophe,” Nishant D. Patel, MD, and his coauthors said in the February issue of the Journal of Thoracic and Cardiovascular Surgery (2017;153:406-12). They reported on results of all 79 patients with Loeys-Dietz syndrome (LDS) who had cardiovascular surgery at Johns Hopkins. There were two (3%) deaths during surgery and eight (10%) late deaths. Patients with LDS are at risk for dissection early when the aortic root reaches 4 cm. Despite what they termed “favorable” outcomes of surgery, Dr. Patel and his coauthors acknowledged that reintervention rates for this population are high – 19 patients (24%) had subsequent operations. That suggests cardiac surgeons must closely monitor these patients. “Meticulous follow-up with cardiovascular surveillance imaging remains important for management, particularly as clinical LDS subtypes are characterized and more tailored treatment is developed,” Dr. Patel and his coauthors reported.
They advise echocardiography every 3 to 6 months for the first year after surgery and then every 6 to 12 months afterward. Full-body imaging should occur at least every 2 years. “In particular, patients with type B dissections should be monitored aggressively for aneurysm growth,” Dr. Patel and his coauthors said. They recommend imaging at seven to 14 days after dissection, then repeat imaging at 1, 3, 6, and 12 months, and then yearly thereafter.
They noted that four LDS subtypes have been identified. Although those with LDS1 and 2 subtypes are prone to aortic rupture at an earlier age and at smaller aortic diameters than other connective tissue disorders, the medical and surgical management for all subtypes are similar, Dr. Patel and his coauthors indicated.
“Certain congenital heart defects are more common among patients with LDS, compared with the normal population, including patent ductus arteriosus and mitral valve prolapse/insufficiency,” they said. Genotype is one factor that determines the need for surgery in LDS patients, Dr. Patel and his coauthors said. Others are growth rate, aortic valve function, family history, and severity of noncardiac phenotype.
The 79 patients in the study were divided almost evenly between gender, and the average age at first operation was 24.9 years; 38 were children younger than 18 years and 20 had a previous sternotomy. Aortic root replacement represented the predominant operation in the group, accounting for 65 operations (82.3%), of which 52 (80%) were valve-sparing procedures and the remainder were composite valve-graft procedures. The other procedures the researchers performed were nine aortic arch replacements (11.4%), three open thoracoabdominal repairs (3.8%) and two ascending aorta replacements (2.5%).
“Valve-sparing root replacement has become a safe and reliable option for appropriately selected younger patients with LDS,” Dr. Patel and his coauthors wrote. Five patients needed a second operation on the aortic valve or root; three of them had a Florida sleeve procedure. “Based on these initial outcomes with the Florida sleeve at our institution, we have abandoned this procedure in favor of conventional valve-sparing root replacement,” Dr. Patel and his coauthors stated.
Dr. Patel and his coauthors had no financial relationships to disclose.
Key clinical point: Outcomes for aortic surgery in Loeys-Dietz syndrome are favorable, but reintervention rates are high.
Major finding: Patients require close postoperative follow-up with cardiovascular imaging.
Data source: Retrospective review of 79 patients who had cardiovascular surgery for LDS over 26 years at Johns Hopkins University.
Aortic repair in Loeys-Dietz syndrome requires close follow-up
The knowledge about Loeys-Dietz syndrome has evolved quickly since Hal Dietz, MD, and Bart Loeys, MD, at Johns Hopkins University, Baltimore, first reported on it in 2005. Now, another team of Johns Hopkins investigators have reported that an aggressive approach with aortic root replacement coupled with valve-sparing whenever possible produces favorable results, but that clinicians must follow these patients closely with cardiovascular imaging.
“Growing experience with Loeys-Dietz syndrome has confirmed early impressions of its aggressive nature and proclivity toward aortic catastrophe,” Nishant D. Patel, MD, and his coauthors said in the February issue of the Journal of Thoracic and Cardiovascular Surgery (2017;153:406-12). They reported on results of all 79 patients with Loeys-Dietz syndrome (LDS) who had cardiovascular surgery at Johns Hopkins. There were two (3%) deaths during surgery and eight (10%) late deaths.
Patients with LDS are at risk for dissection early when the aortic root reaches 4 cm. Despite what they termed “favorable” outcomes of surgery, Dr. Patel and his coauthors acknowledged that reintervention rates for this population are high – 19 patients (24%) had subsequent operations. That suggests cardiac surgeons must closely monitor these patients. “Meticulous follow-up with cardiovascular surveillance imaging remains important for management, particularly as clinical LDS subtypes are characterized and more tailored treatment is developed,” Dr. Patel and his coauthors reported.
They advise echocardiography every 3 to 6 months for the first year after surgery and then every 6 to 12 months afterward. Full-body imaging should occur at least every 2 years.
“In particular, patients with type B dissections should be monitored aggressively for aneurysm growth,” Dr. Patel and his coauthors said. They recommend imaging at seven to 14 days after dissection, then repeat imaging at 1, 3, 6, and 12 months, and then yearly thereafter.
They noted that four LDS subtypes have been identified. Although those with LDS1 and 2 subtypes are prone to aortic rupture at an earlier age and at smaller aortic diameters than other connective tissue disorders, the medical and surgical management for all subtypes are similar, Dr. Patel and his coauthors indicated.
“Certain congenital heart defects are more common among patients with LDS, compared with the normal population, including patent ductus arteriosus and mitral valve prolapse/insufficiency,” they said. Genotype is one factor that determines the need for surgery in LDS patients, Dr. Patel and his coauthors said. Others are growth rate, aortic valve function, family history, and severity of noncardiac phenotype.
The 79 patients in the study were divided almost evenly between gender, and the average age at first operation was 24.9 years; 38 were children younger than 18 years and 20 had a previous sternotomy.
Aortic root replacement represented the predominant operation in the group, accounting for 65 operations (82.3%), of which 52 (80%) were valve-sparing procedures and the remainder were composite valve-graft procedures. The other procedures the researchers performed were nine aortic arch replacements (11.4%), three open thoracoabdominal repairs (3.8%) and two ascending aorta replacements (2.5%).
“Valve-sparing root replacement has become a safe and reliable option for appropriately selected younger patients with LDS,” Dr. Patel and his coauthors wrote. Five patients needed a second operation on the aortic valve or root; three of them had a Florida sleeve procedure. “Based on these initial outcomes with the Florida sleeve at our institution, we have abandoned this procedure in favor of conventional valve-sparing root replacement,” Dr. Patel and his coauthors stated.
Dr. Patel and his coauthors had no financial relationships to disclose.
This report by Dr. Patel and his coauthors confirms the need for close surveillance of individuals with Loeys-Dietz syndrome who have had aortic operations, John S. Ikonomidis, MD, PhD, of the Medical University of South Carolina, Charleston, said in his invited commentary (J Thorac Cardiovasc Surg. 2017;153:413-4).
Dr. Ikonomidis noted this study is important because of its population size. “This is probably the largest single-center surgical report of this kind in the world,” he said.
The study highlighted a number of issues germane to LDS patients who have cardiovascular surgery, among them a critical need for genetic testing to help cardiac surgeons determine the disease genotype and what operation to perform, Dr. Ikonomidis said.
But Dr. Ikonomidis also pointed out the variation in aortic root size in the study patients. The smallest root in the series was 2 cm and 21 of 65 patients with a maximum root diameter smaller than 4 cm had root surgery. “This is a testament to the fact that surgical decision making in this population is dependent not just on the known genotype and aortic dimensions, but also on the rate of growth, aortic valve function, severity of noncardiac phenotype, and family history,” Dr. Ikonomidis said.
Dr. Ikonomidis had no financial relationships to disclose.
This report by Dr. Patel and his coauthors confirms the need for close surveillance of individuals with Loeys-Dietz syndrome who have had aortic operations, John S. Ikonomidis, MD, PhD, of the Medical University of South Carolina, Charleston, said in his invited commentary (J Thorac Cardiovasc Surg. 2017;153:413-4).
Dr. Ikonomidis noted this study is important because of its population size. “This is probably the largest single-center surgical report of this kind in the world,” he said.
The study highlighted a number of issues germane to LDS patients who have cardiovascular surgery, among them a critical need for genetic testing to help cardiac surgeons determine the disease genotype and what operation to perform, Dr. Ikonomidis said.
But Dr. Ikonomidis also pointed out the variation in aortic root size in the study patients. The smallest root in the series was 2 cm and 21 of 65 patients with a maximum root diameter smaller than 4 cm had root surgery. “This is a testament to the fact that surgical decision making in this population is dependent not just on the known genotype and aortic dimensions, but also on the rate of growth, aortic valve function, severity of noncardiac phenotype, and family history,” Dr. Ikonomidis said.
Dr. Ikonomidis had no financial relationships to disclose.
This report by Dr. Patel and his coauthors confirms the need for close surveillance of individuals with Loeys-Dietz syndrome who have had aortic operations, John S. Ikonomidis, MD, PhD, of the Medical University of South Carolina, Charleston, said in his invited commentary (J Thorac Cardiovasc Surg. 2017;153:413-4).
Dr. Ikonomidis noted this study is important because of its population size. “This is probably the largest single-center surgical report of this kind in the world,” he said.
The study highlighted a number of issues germane to LDS patients who have cardiovascular surgery, among them a critical need for genetic testing to help cardiac surgeons determine the disease genotype and what operation to perform, Dr. Ikonomidis said.
But Dr. Ikonomidis also pointed out the variation in aortic root size in the study patients. The smallest root in the series was 2 cm and 21 of 65 patients with a maximum root diameter smaller than 4 cm had root surgery. “This is a testament to the fact that surgical decision making in this population is dependent not just on the known genotype and aortic dimensions, but also on the rate of growth, aortic valve function, severity of noncardiac phenotype, and family history,” Dr. Ikonomidis said.
Dr. Ikonomidis had no financial relationships to disclose.
The knowledge about Loeys-Dietz syndrome has evolved quickly since Hal Dietz, MD, and Bart Loeys, MD, at Johns Hopkins University, Baltimore, first reported on it in 2005. Now, another team of Johns Hopkins investigators have reported that an aggressive approach with aortic root replacement coupled with valve-sparing whenever possible produces favorable results, but that clinicians must follow these patients closely with cardiovascular imaging.
“Growing experience with Loeys-Dietz syndrome has confirmed early impressions of its aggressive nature and proclivity toward aortic catastrophe,” Nishant D. Patel, MD, and his coauthors said in the February issue of the Journal of Thoracic and Cardiovascular Surgery (2017;153:406-12). They reported on results of all 79 patients with Loeys-Dietz syndrome (LDS) who had cardiovascular surgery at Johns Hopkins. There were two (3%) deaths during surgery and eight (10%) late deaths.
Patients with LDS are at risk for dissection early when the aortic root reaches 4 cm. Despite what they termed “favorable” outcomes of surgery, Dr. Patel and his coauthors acknowledged that reintervention rates for this population are high – 19 patients (24%) had subsequent operations. That suggests cardiac surgeons must closely monitor these patients. “Meticulous follow-up with cardiovascular surveillance imaging remains important for management, particularly as clinical LDS subtypes are characterized and more tailored treatment is developed,” Dr. Patel and his coauthors reported.
They advise echocardiography every 3 to 6 months for the first year after surgery and then every 6 to 12 months afterward. Full-body imaging should occur at least every 2 years.
“In particular, patients with type B dissections should be monitored aggressively for aneurysm growth,” Dr. Patel and his coauthors said. They recommend imaging at seven to 14 days after dissection, then repeat imaging at 1, 3, 6, and 12 months, and then yearly thereafter.
They noted that four LDS subtypes have been identified. Although those with LDS1 and 2 subtypes are prone to aortic rupture at an earlier age and at smaller aortic diameters than other connective tissue disorders, the medical and surgical management for all subtypes are similar, Dr. Patel and his coauthors indicated.
“Certain congenital heart defects are more common among patients with LDS, compared with the normal population, including patent ductus arteriosus and mitral valve prolapse/insufficiency,” they said. Genotype is one factor that determines the need for surgery in LDS patients, Dr. Patel and his coauthors said. Others are growth rate, aortic valve function, family history, and severity of noncardiac phenotype.
The 79 patients in the study were divided almost evenly between gender, and the average age at first operation was 24.9 years; 38 were children younger than 18 years and 20 had a previous sternotomy.
Aortic root replacement represented the predominant operation in the group, accounting for 65 operations (82.3%), of which 52 (80%) were valve-sparing procedures and the remainder were composite valve-graft procedures. The other procedures the researchers performed were nine aortic arch replacements (11.4%), three open thoracoabdominal repairs (3.8%) and two ascending aorta replacements (2.5%).
“Valve-sparing root replacement has become a safe and reliable option for appropriately selected younger patients with LDS,” Dr. Patel and his coauthors wrote. Five patients needed a second operation on the aortic valve or root; three of them had a Florida sleeve procedure. “Based on these initial outcomes with the Florida sleeve at our institution, we have abandoned this procedure in favor of conventional valve-sparing root replacement,” Dr. Patel and his coauthors stated.
Dr. Patel and his coauthors had no financial relationships to disclose.
The knowledge about Loeys-Dietz syndrome has evolved quickly since Hal Dietz, MD, and Bart Loeys, MD, at Johns Hopkins University, Baltimore, first reported on it in 2005. Now, another team of Johns Hopkins investigators have reported that an aggressive approach with aortic root replacement coupled with valve-sparing whenever possible produces favorable results, but that clinicians must follow these patients closely with cardiovascular imaging.
“Growing experience with Loeys-Dietz syndrome has confirmed early impressions of its aggressive nature and proclivity toward aortic catastrophe,” Nishant D. Patel, MD, and his coauthors said in the February issue of the Journal of Thoracic and Cardiovascular Surgery (2017;153:406-12). They reported on results of all 79 patients with Loeys-Dietz syndrome (LDS) who had cardiovascular surgery at Johns Hopkins. There were two (3%) deaths during surgery and eight (10%) late deaths.
Patients with LDS are at risk for dissection early when the aortic root reaches 4 cm. Despite what they termed “favorable” outcomes of surgery, Dr. Patel and his coauthors acknowledged that reintervention rates for this population are high – 19 patients (24%) had subsequent operations. That suggests cardiac surgeons must closely monitor these patients. “Meticulous follow-up with cardiovascular surveillance imaging remains important for management, particularly as clinical LDS subtypes are characterized and more tailored treatment is developed,” Dr. Patel and his coauthors reported.
They advise echocardiography every 3 to 6 months for the first year after surgery and then every 6 to 12 months afterward. Full-body imaging should occur at least every 2 years.
“In particular, patients with type B dissections should be monitored aggressively for aneurysm growth,” Dr. Patel and his coauthors said. They recommend imaging at seven to 14 days after dissection, then repeat imaging at 1, 3, 6, and 12 months, and then yearly thereafter.
They noted that four LDS subtypes have been identified. Although those with LDS1 and 2 subtypes are prone to aortic rupture at an earlier age and at smaller aortic diameters than other connective tissue disorders, the medical and surgical management for all subtypes are similar, Dr. Patel and his coauthors indicated.
“Certain congenital heart defects are more common among patients with LDS, compared with the normal population, including patent ductus arteriosus and mitral valve prolapse/insufficiency,” they said. Genotype is one factor that determines the need for surgery in LDS patients, Dr. Patel and his coauthors said. Others are growth rate, aortic valve function, family history, and severity of noncardiac phenotype.
The 79 patients in the study were divided almost evenly between gender, and the average age at first operation was 24.9 years; 38 were children younger than 18 years and 20 had a previous sternotomy.
Aortic root replacement represented the predominant operation in the group, accounting for 65 operations (82.3%), of which 52 (80%) were valve-sparing procedures and the remainder were composite valve-graft procedures. The other procedures the researchers performed were nine aortic arch replacements (11.4%), three open thoracoabdominal repairs (3.8%) and two ascending aorta replacements (2.5%).
“Valve-sparing root replacement has become a safe and reliable option for appropriately selected younger patients with LDS,” Dr. Patel and his coauthors wrote. Five patients needed a second operation on the aortic valve or root; three of them had a Florida sleeve procedure. “Based on these initial outcomes with the Florida sleeve at our institution, we have abandoned this procedure in favor of conventional valve-sparing root replacement,” Dr. Patel and his coauthors stated.
Dr. Patel and his coauthors had no financial relationships to disclose.
Key clinical point: Outcomes for aortic surgery in Loeys-Dietz syndrome are favorable, but reintervention rates are high.
Major finding: Patients require close postoperative follow-up with cardiovascular imaging.
Data source: Retrospective review of 79 patients who had cardiovascular surgery for LDS over 26 years at Johns Hopkins University.
Disclosure: Dr. Patel and his coauthors reported having no relevant financial disclosures.
Can a nomogram foretell invasive pulmonary adenocarcinoma?
The diagnosis of solitary peripheral subsolid nodule carries with it an undefined risk of invasive pulmonary carcinoma, but clinicians have not had a tool that can help guide their planning for surgery. However, researchers in China have developed a nomogram that they said may aid clinicians to predict the risk of invasive pulmonary adenocarcinoma in these patients.
“Validation by the use of bootstrap resampling revealed optimal discrimination and calibration, indicating that the nomogram may have clinical utility,” said Chenghua Jin, MD, and Jinlin Cao, MD, of Zhejiang University, Hangzhou, China, and coauthors. They reported their findings in the February issue of the Journal of Thoracic and Cardiovascular Surgery (2017;153:42-9).
The nomogram accounts for the following factors: computed tomography attenuation; nodule size; spiculation; signs of vascular convergence; pleural tags; and solid proportion. “The nomogram showed a robust discrimination with an area under the receiver operating characteristic curve of 0.894,” Dr. Jin and coauthors reported. An area under the curve of 1 is equivalent to 100%, so the area under the curve this study reported shows close to 90% accuracy.
The study involved a retrospective analysis of 273 consecutive patients who had resection of a solitary peripheral subsolid nodule at Zhejiang University School of Medicine from January 2013 to December 2014. Subsolid pulmonary nodules include pure ground-glass nodules and part-solid nodules that feature both solid and ground-glass components. “The optimal management of patients with a subsolid nodule is of growing clinical concern, because the most common diagnosis for resected subsolid nodules is lung adenocarcinoma,” Dr. Jin and colleagues indicated.
Of the study population, 58% were diagnosed with invasive pulmonary adenocarcinoma. Other diagnoses within the group were benign (13%), atypical adenomatous hyperplasia (1%), adenocarcinoma in situ (6.5%) and minimally invasive adenocarcinoma (21%).
Results of the multivariable analyses showed that invasive pulmonary adenocarcinoma correlated with the following characteristics: lesion size; spiculation; vascular convergence; and pleural tag. Factors that were not significant included age, family history of lung cancer, CT attenuation, and solid proportion. However, the researchers did include CT attenuation, along with solid proportion, in the final regression analysis based on their contributions to the statistical analysis.
For the model, CT attenuation of –500 to –200 Hounsfield units carried an odds ratio of 1.690 (P = .228) while CT attenuation greater than –200 HU had an OR of 1.791 (P = .645). Positive spiculation had an OR of 3.312 (no P value given) and negative vascular convergence an OR of 0.300 (no P value given).
While a number of prediction models have been devised and validated to evaluate the likelihood of malignancy in pulmonary nodules, they have not given subsolid nodules “specific or detailed consideration,” Dr. Jin and and coauthors said. “To our knowledge, this study was the first to construct a quantitative nomogram to predict the probability of invasive pulmonary adenocarcinoma in patients with subsolid nodules,” the researchers wrote.
One limitation of the study is its selection bias toward patients with a greater probability of having a malignancy. Also, validation of the nomogram requires external analysis with additional databases from other countries and with more diverse ethnic groups. Another shortcoming is the retrospective nature of the study and a small number of patients who had positron emission tomography. “Further data collection, wider geographic recruitment, and incorporation of positron emission tomography results and some molecular factors could improve this model for future use,” Dr. Jin and coauthors concluded.
Dr. Jin and Dr. Cao had no relevant financial disclosures. The study received funding from the Zhejiang Province Science and Technology Plan.
The nomogram Dr. Jin and coauthors present can be a valuable tool for determining the extent of resection of subsolid pulmonary nodules and to distinguish invasive from preinvasive disease where preoperative needle biopsy and intraopertiave frozen section typically cannot, Bryan Burt, MD, of Baylor College of Medicine, Houston, said in his invited commentary (J Thorac Cardiovasc Surg. 2017;153:460-1).
“However,” Dr. Burt added, “as the accuracy of frozen section for this disease improves, as it has in select centers, the clinical utility of such a nomogram will diminish.”
Dr. Burt further pointed out that several of the variables Dr. Jin and coauthors used in constructing their nomogram “are not universally reported features of cross-sectional chest imaging” in other institutions and countries.
Use of the nomogram relies on experienced chest radiologists to aid in scoring variables and a validation methodology that a retrospective trial cannot meet, Dr. Burt said. “Of note, this nomogram was constructed from a dataset composed of only surgically resected lesions, and it will be imperative to validate these methods among a larger cohort of individuals with subsolid pulmonary nodules treated both surgically and nonsurgically, ideally in a prospective trial,” Dr. Burt concluded.
Dr. Burt had no relevant financial disclosures.
The nomogram Dr. Jin and coauthors present can be a valuable tool for determining the extent of resection of subsolid pulmonary nodules and to distinguish invasive from preinvasive disease where preoperative needle biopsy and intraopertiave frozen section typically cannot, Bryan Burt, MD, of Baylor College of Medicine, Houston, said in his invited commentary (J Thorac Cardiovasc Surg. 2017;153:460-1).
“However,” Dr. Burt added, “as the accuracy of frozen section for this disease improves, as it has in select centers, the clinical utility of such a nomogram will diminish.”
Dr. Burt further pointed out that several of the variables Dr. Jin and coauthors used in constructing their nomogram “are not universally reported features of cross-sectional chest imaging” in other institutions and countries.
Use of the nomogram relies on experienced chest radiologists to aid in scoring variables and a validation methodology that a retrospective trial cannot meet, Dr. Burt said. “Of note, this nomogram was constructed from a dataset composed of only surgically resected lesions, and it will be imperative to validate these methods among a larger cohort of individuals with subsolid pulmonary nodules treated both surgically and nonsurgically, ideally in a prospective trial,” Dr. Burt concluded.
Dr. Burt had no relevant financial disclosures.
The nomogram Dr. Jin and coauthors present can be a valuable tool for determining the extent of resection of subsolid pulmonary nodules and to distinguish invasive from preinvasive disease where preoperative needle biopsy and intraopertiave frozen section typically cannot, Bryan Burt, MD, of Baylor College of Medicine, Houston, said in his invited commentary (J Thorac Cardiovasc Surg. 2017;153:460-1).
“However,” Dr. Burt added, “as the accuracy of frozen section for this disease improves, as it has in select centers, the clinical utility of such a nomogram will diminish.”
Dr. Burt further pointed out that several of the variables Dr. Jin and coauthors used in constructing their nomogram “are not universally reported features of cross-sectional chest imaging” in other institutions and countries.
Use of the nomogram relies on experienced chest radiologists to aid in scoring variables and a validation methodology that a retrospective trial cannot meet, Dr. Burt said. “Of note, this nomogram was constructed from a dataset composed of only surgically resected lesions, and it will be imperative to validate these methods among a larger cohort of individuals with subsolid pulmonary nodules treated both surgically and nonsurgically, ideally in a prospective trial,” Dr. Burt concluded.
Dr. Burt had no relevant financial disclosures.
The diagnosis of solitary peripheral subsolid nodule carries with it an undefined risk of invasive pulmonary carcinoma, but clinicians have not had a tool that can help guide their planning for surgery. However, researchers in China have developed a nomogram that they said may aid clinicians to predict the risk of invasive pulmonary adenocarcinoma in these patients.
“Validation by the use of bootstrap resampling revealed optimal discrimination and calibration, indicating that the nomogram may have clinical utility,” said Chenghua Jin, MD, and Jinlin Cao, MD, of Zhejiang University, Hangzhou, China, and coauthors. They reported their findings in the February issue of the Journal of Thoracic and Cardiovascular Surgery (2017;153:42-9).
The nomogram accounts for the following factors: computed tomography attenuation; nodule size; spiculation; signs of vascular convergence; pleural tags; and solid proportion. “The nomogram showed a robust discrimination with an area under the receiver operating characteristic curve of 0.894,” Dr. Jin and coauthors reported. An area under the curve of 1 is equivalent to 100%, so the area under the curve this study reported shows close to 90% accuracy.
The study involved a retrospective analysis of 273 consecutive patients who had resection of a solitary peripheral subsolid nodule at Zhejiang University School of Medicine from January 2013 to December 2014. Subsolid pulmonary nodules include pure ground-glass nodules and part-solid nodules that feature both solid and ground-glass components. “The optimal management of patients with a subsolid nodule is of growing clinical concern, because the most common diagnosis for resected subsolid nodules is lung adenocarcinoma,” Dr. Jin and colleagues indicated.
Of the study population, 58% were diagnosed with invasive pulmonary adenocarcinoma. Other diagnoses within the group were benign (13%), atypical adenomatous hyperplasia (1%), adenocarcinoma in situ (6.5%) and minimally invasive adenocarcinoma (21%).
Results of the multivariable analyses showed that invasive pulmonary adenocarcinoma correlated with the following characteristics: lesion size; spiculation; vascular convergence; and pleural tag. Factors that were not significant included age, family history of lung cancer, CT attenuation, and solid proportion. However, the researchers did include CT attenuation, along with solid proportion, in the final regression analysis based on their contributions to the statistical analysis.
For the model, CT attenuation of –500 to –200 Hounsfield units carried an odds ratio of 1.690 (P = .228) while CT attenuation greater than –200 HU had an OR of 1.791 (P = .645). Positive spiculation had an OR of 3.312 (no P value given) and negative vascular convergence an OR of 0.300 (no P value given).
While a number of prediction models have been devised and validated to evaluate the likelihood of malignancy in pulmonary nodules, they have not given subsolid nodules “specific or detailed consideration,” Dr. Jin and and coauthors said. “To our knowledge, this study was the first to construct a quantitative nomogram to predict the probability of invasive pulmonary adenocarcinoma in patients with subsolid nodules,” the researchers wrote.
One limitation of the study is its selection bias toward patients with a greater probability of having a malignancy. Also, validation of the nomogram requires external analysis with additional databases from other countries and with more diverse ethnic groups. Another shortcoming is the retrospective nature of the study and a small number of patients who had positron emission tomography. “Further data collection, wider geographic recruitment, and incorporation of positron emission tomography results and some molecular factors could improve this model for future use,” Dr. Jin and coauthors concluded.
Dr. Jin and Dr. Cao had no relevant financial disclosures. The study received funding from the Zhejiang Province Science and Technology Plan.
The diagnosis of solitary peripheral subsolid nodule carries with it an undefined risk of invasive pulmonary carcinoma, but clinicians have not had a tool that can help guide their planning for surgery. However, researchers in China have developed a nomogram that they said may aid clinicians to predict the risk of invasive pulmonary adenocarcinoma in these patients.
“Validation by the use of bootstrap resampling revealed optimal discrimination and calibration, indicating that the nomogram may have clinical utility,” said Chenghua Jin, MD, and Jinlin Cao, MD, of Zhejiang University, Hangzhou, China, and coauthors. They reported their findings in the February issue of the Journal of Thoracic and Cardiovascular Surgery (2017;153:42-9).
The nomogram accounts for the following factors: computed tomography attenuation; nodule size; spiculation; signs of vascular convergence; pleural tags; and solid proportion. “The nomogram showed a robust discrimination with an area under the receiver operating characteristic curve of 0.894,” Dr. Jin and coauthors reported. An area under the curve of 1 is equivalent to 100%, so the area under the curve this study reported shows close to 90% accuracy.
The study involved a retrospective analysis of 273 consecutive patients who had resection of a solitary peripheral subsolid nodule at Zhejiang University School of Medicine from January 2013 to December 2014. Subsolid pulmonary nodules include pure ground-glass nodules and part-solid nodules that feature both solid and ground-glass components. “The optimal management of patients with a subsolid nodule is of growing clinical concern, because the most common diagnosis for resected subsolid nodules is lung adenocarcinoma,” Dr. Jin and colleagues indicated.
Of the study population, 58% were diagnosed with invasive pulmonary adenocarcinoma. Other diagnoses within the group were benign (13%), atypical adenomatous hyperplasia (1%), adenocarcinoma in situ (6.5%) and minimally invasive adenocarcinoma (21%).
Results of the multivariable analyses showed that invasive pulmonary adenocarcinoma correlated with the following characteristics: lesion size; spiculation; vascular convergence; and pleural tag. Factors that were not significant included age, family history of lung cancer, CT attenuation, and solid proportion. However, the researchers did include CT attenuation, along with solid proportion, in the final regression analysis based on their contributions to the statistical analysis.
For the model, CT attenuation of –500 to –200 Hounsfield units carried an odds ratio of 1.690 (P = .228) while CT attenuation greater than –200 HU had an OR of 1.791 (P = .645). Positive spiculation had an OR of 3.312 (no P value given) and negative vascular convergence an OR of 0.300 (no P value given).
While a number of prediction models have been devised and validated to evaluate the likelihood of malignancy in pulmonary nodules, they have not given subsolid nodules “specific or detailed consideration,” Dr. Jin and and coauthors said. “To our knowledge, this study was the first to construct a quantitative nomogram to predict the probability of invasive pulmonary adenocarcinoma in patients with subsolid nodules,” the researchers wrote.
One limitation of the study is its selection bias toward patients with a greater probability of having a malignancy. Also, validation of the nomogram requires external analysis with additional databases from other countries and with more diverse ethnic groups. Another shortcoming is the retrospective nature of the study and a small number of patients who had positron emission tomography. “Further data collection, wider geographic recruitment, and incorporation of positron emission tomography results and some molecular factors could improve this model for future use,” Dr. Jin and coauthors concluded.
Dr. Jin and Dr. Cao had no relevant financial disclosures. The study received funding from the Zhejiang Province Science and Technology Plan.
EXPERT ANALYSIS FROM THE JOURNAL OF THORACIC AND CARDIOVASCULAR SURGERY
Key clinical point: Investigators developed a nomogram that may help predict the risk of invasive pulmonary adenocarcinoma for patients with a solitary peripheral subsolid nodule.
Major finding: This nomogram may help clinicians individualize each patient’s prognosis for invasive pulmonary adenocarcinoma and develop treatment plans accordingly.
Data source: Retrospective analysis of 273 consecutive patients who had surgery to remove a solitary peripheral subsolid nodule at a single center.
Disclosure: The investigators received support from the Zhejiang Province Science and Technology Plan. Dr. Jin and Dr. Cao reported having no relevant financial disclosures.
Will genome editing advance animal-to-human transplantation?
Advances in gene editing are pushing the possibility of raising pigs for organs that may be transplanted into humans with immunosuppression regimens comparable to those now used in human-to-human transplants, coauthors James Butler, MD, and A. Joseph Tector, MD, PhD, stated in an expert opinion in the February issue of the Journal of Thoracic and Cardiovascular Surgery (2017;153:488-92).
Developments in genome editing could bring new approaches to management of cardiopulmonary diseases, Dr. Butler and Dr. Tector noted. “Recently, cardiac-specific and lung-specific applications have been described, which will allow for the rapid creation of new models of heart and lung disease,” they said. Specifically, they noted gene targeting might eventually offer a way to treat challenging genetic problems “like the heterogeneous nature of nonsquamous cell lung cancer.”
Dr. Butler is with the department of surgery at Indiana University, Indianapolis, and Dr. Tector is with the department of surgery at the University of Alabama at Birmingham.
Driving this research are advances in a genome editing approach known as CRISPR, or clustered regularly interspaced short palindromic repeats, along with understanding of the CRISPR-associated Cas9 protein. “CRISPR gene-targeting is easier to use than previous tools because the Cas9 nuclease is not tethered to the gene targeting element; rather, it binds to a polymerase chain reaction primer-like single guide RNA,” Dr. Butler and Dr. Tector said. They called CRISPR technology “one of the greatest medical breakthroughs from prokaryotes since Alexander Fleming noticed a contaminant strain of Penicillium notatum clearing Staphylococcus cultures.”
CRISPR technology has been used in developing multiple gene knockout pigs and neutralizing three separate porcine genes that encode human xenoantigens in a single reaction, leading to efficient methods for creating pigs with multiple genetic modifications.
According to the website of the Broad Institute of MIT and Harvard, Cambridge, Mass., where researchers perfected the system to work in eukaryotes, CRISPR works by using short RNA sequences designed by researchers to guide the system to matching sequences of DNA. When the target DNA is found, Cas9 – one of the enzymes produced by the CRISPR system – binds to the DNA and cuts it, shutting the targeted gene off.
“By facilitating high-throughput model creation, CRISPR has elucidated which modifications are necessary and which are not; despite the ability to alter many loci concurrently, recent evidence has implicated three porcine genes that are responsible for the majority of human-antiporcine humoral immunity,” Dr. Butler and Dr. Tector wrote.
Those genes are the Gal[alpha]1-3 epitope (Gal-alpha), CMAH and B4GaINT2 genes. “Each of these three genes is expressed in pigs but has been evolutionarily silenced in humans,” the coauthors added.
When those three genes are silenced in pigs, “measures of human-antiporcine humoral immunity are reduced to levels comparable with allograft transplantation standards,” they said (Xenotransplantation. 2015 Jan-Feb;22:20-31). “This raises the possibility that porcine-to-human xenotransplantation may be clinically viable with the addition of conventional immunosuppressive regimens.”
While CRISPR genome editing has yet to reach its full potential, researchers and clinicians should pay attention, according to Dr. Butler and Dr. Tector.
More recent modifications of CRISPR technology have shown promise in not just knocking out or turning off specific genes, but rather guiding directed replacement of genes with researcher-designed substitutes. This can enable permanent transformation of functional genes with altered behavior, according to the Broad Institute website.
Dr. Tector disclosed he has received funding from United Therapeutics and founded Xenobridge with patents for xenotransplantation. Dr. Butler has no relevant financial relationships to disclose.
CRISPR and CRISPR-associated proteins have emerged as effective genome editing techniques that may lead to cardiac and lung models and possibly xenotransplantation, Ari A. Mennander, MD, PhD, of the Tampere (Finland) University Heart Hospital, said in his invited commentary (J Thorac Cardiovasc Surg. 2017;153:492).
The concept Dr. Butler and Dr. Tector discuss involves not using antibodies to ameliorate porcine antibodies that cause rejection in humans, but rather reengineering the genetic composition of pigs to eliminate those antibodies. “According to the wildest of dreams, these genes affecting porcine glycan expression may be silenced, and the human–antiporcine humoral immunity is controlled down to the level comparable with human allograft rejection,” Dr. Mennander said.
However, such a breakthrough carries with it consequences, Dr. Mennander said. “Should one worry about the induction of zoonosis, as well as the ethical aspects of transplanting the patient a whole organ of a pig? Would even a successful xenotransplant program seriously compete with artificial hearts or allografts?” Embracing the method too early would open its advocates to ridicule, he said.
“We are to applaud the researchers for ever-lasting and exemplary enthusiasm for a futuristic new surgical solution; the future may lie as much in current clinical solutions as in innovative discoveries based on persistent scientific experiments,” Dr. Mennander said.
Dr. Mennander had no relevant financial relationships to disclose.
CRISPR and CRISPR-associated proteins have emerged as effective genome editing techniques that may lead to cardiac and lung models and possibly xenotransplantation, Ari A. Mennander, MD, PhD, of the Tampere (Finland) University Heart Hospital, said in his invited commentary (J Thorac Cardiovasc Surg. 2017;153:492).
The concept Dr. Butler and Dr. Tector discuss involves not using antibodies to ameliorate porcine antibodies that cause rejection in humans, but rather reengineering the genetic composition of pigs to eliminate those antibodies. “According to the wildest of dreams, these genes affecting porcine glycan expression may be silenced, and the human–antiporcine humoral immunity is controlled down to the level comparable with human allograft rejection,” Dr. Mennander said.
However, such a breakthrough carries with it consequences, Dr. Mennander said. “Should one worry about the induction of zoonosis, as well as the ethical aspects of transplanting the patient a whole organ of a pig? Would even a successful xenotransplant program seriously compete with artificial hearts or allografts?” Embracing the method too early would open its advocates to ridicule, he said.
“We are to applaud the researchers for ever-lasting and exemplary enthusiasm for a futuristic new surgical solution; the future may lie as much in current clinical solutions as in innovative discoveries based on persistent scientific experiments,” Dr. Mennander said.
Dr. Mennander had no relevant financial relationships to disclose.
CRISPR and CRISPR-associated proteins have emerged as effective genome editing techniques that may lead to cardiac and lung models and possibly xenotransplantation, Ari A. Mennander, MD, PhD, of the Tampere (Finland) University Heart Hospital, said in his invited commentary (J Thorac Cardiovasc Surg. 2017;153:492).
The concept Dr. Butler and Dr. Tector discuss involves not using antibodies to ameliorate porcine antibodies that cause rejection in humans, but rather reengineering the genetic composition of pigs to eliminate those antibodies. “According to the wildest of dreams, these genes affecting porcine glycan expression may be silenced, and the human–antiporcine humoral immunity is controlled down to the level comparable with human allograft rejection,” Dr. Mennander said.
However, such a breakthrough carries with it consequences, Dr. Mennander said. “Should one worry about the induction of zoonosis, as well as the ethical aspects of transplanting the patient a whole organ of a pig? Would even a successful xenotransplant program seriously compete with artificial hearts or allografts?” Embracing the method too early would open its advocates to ridicule, he said.
“We are to applaud the researchers for ever-lasting and exemplary enthusiasm for a futuristic new surgical solution; the future may lie as much in current clinical solutions as in innovative discoveries based on persistent scientific experiments,” Dr. Mennander said.
Dr. Mennander had no relevant financial relationships to disclose.
Advances in gene editing are pushing the possibility of raising pigs for organs that may be transplanted into humans with immunosuppression regimens comparable to those now used in human-to-human transplants, coauthors James Butler, MD, and A. Joseph Tector, MD, PhD, stated in an expert opinion in the February issue of the Journal of Thoracic and Cardiovascular Surgery (2017;153:488-92).
Developments in genome editing could bring new approaches to management of cardiopulmonary diseases, Dr. Butler and Dr. Tector noted. “Recently, cardiac-specific and lung-specific applications have been described, which will allow for the rapid creation of new models of heart and lung disease,” they said. Specifically, they noted gene targeting might eventually offer a way to treat challenging genetic problems “like the heterogeneous nature of nonsquamous cell lung cancer.”
Dr. Butler is with the department of surgery at Indiana University, Indianapolis, and Dr. Tector is with the department of surgery at the University of Alabama at Birmingham.
Driving this research are advances in a genome editing approach known as CRISPR, or clustered regularly interspaced short palindromic repeats, along with understanding of the CRISPR-associated Cas9 protein. “CRISPR gene-targeting is easier to use than previous tools because the Cas9 nuclease is not tethered to the gene targeting element; rather, it binds to a polymerase chain reaction primer-like single guide RNA,” Dr. Butler and Dr. Tector said. They called CRISPR technology “one of the greatest medical breakthroughs from prokaryotes since Alexander Fleming noticed a contaminant strain of Penicillium notatum clearing Staphylococcus cultures.”
CRISPR technology has been used in developing multiple gene knockout pigs and neutralizing three separate porcine genes that encode human xenoantigens in a single reaction, leading to efficient methods for creating pigs with multiple genetic modifications.
According to the website of the Broad Institute of MIT and Harvard, Cambridge, Mass., where researchers perfected the system to work in eukaryotes, CRISPR works by using short RNA sequences designed by researchers to guide the system to matching sequences of DNA. When the target DNA is found, Cas9 – one of the enzymes produced by the CRISPR system – binds to the DNA and cuts it, shutting the targeted gene off.
“By facilitating high-throughput model creation, CRISPR has elucidated which modifications are necessary and which are not; despite the ability to alter many loci concurrently, recent evidence has implicated three porcine genes that are responsible for the majority of human-antiporcine humoral immunity,” Dr. Butler and Dr. Tector wrote.
Those genes are the Gal[alpha]1-3 epitope (Gal-alpha), CMAH and B4GaINT2 genes. “Each of these three genes is expressed in pigs but has been evolutionarily silenced in humans,” the coauthors added.
When those three genes are silenced in pigs, “measures of human-antiporcine humoral immunity are reduced to levels comparable with allograft transplantation standards,” they said (Xenotransplantation. 2015 Jan-Feb;22:20-31). “This raises the possibility that porcine-to-human xenotransplantation may be clinically viable with the addition of conventional immunosuppressive regimens.”
While CRISPR genome editing has yet to reach its full potential, researchers and clinicians should pay attention, according to Dr. Butler and Dr. Tector.
More recent modifications of CRISPR technology have shown promise in not just knocking out or turning off specific genes, but rather guiding directed replacement of genes with researcher-designed substitutes. This can enable permanent transformation of functional genes with altered behavior, according to the Broad Institute website.
Dr. Tector disclosed he has received funding from United Therapeutics and founded Xenobridge with patents for xenotransplantation. Dr. Butler has no relevant financial relationships to disclose.
Advances in gene editing are pushing the possibility of raising pigs for organs that may be transplanted into humans with immunosuppression regimens comparable to those now used in human-to-human transplants, coauthors James Butler, MD, and A. Joseph Tector, MD, PhD, stated in an expert opinion in the February issue of the Journal of Thoracic and Cardiovascular Surgery (2017;153:488-92).
Developments in genome editing could bring new approaches to management of cardiopulmonary diseases, Dr. Butler and Dr. Tector noted. “Recently, cardiac-specific and lung-specific applications have been described, which will allow for the rapid creation of new models of heart and lung disease,” they said. Specifically, they noted gene targeting might eventually offer a way to treat challenging genetic problems “like the heterogeneous nature of nonsquamous cell lung cancer.”
Dr. Butler is with the department of surgery at Indiana University, Indianapolis, and Dr. Tector is with the department of surgery at the University of Alabama at Birmingham.
Driving this research are advances in a genome editing approach known as CRISPR, or clustered regularly interspaced short palindromic repeats, along with understanding of the CRISPR-associated Cas9 protein. “CRISPR gene-targeting is easier to use than previous tools because the Cas9 nuclease is not tethered to the gene targeting element; rather, it binds to a polymerase chain reaction primer-like single guide RNA,” Dr. Butler and Dr. Tector said. They called CRISPR technology “one of the greatest medical breakthroughs from prokaryotes since Alexander Fleming noticed a contaminant strain of Penicillium notatum clearing Staphylococcus cultures.”
CRISPR technology has been used in developing multiple gene knockout pigs and neutralizing three separate porcine genes that encode human xenoantigens in a single reaction, leading to efficient methods for creating pigs with multiple genetic modifications.
According to the website of the Broad Institute of MIT and Harvard, Cambridge, Mass., where researchers perfected the system to work in eukaryotes, CRISPR works by using short RNA sequences designed by researchers to guide the system to matching sequences of DNA. When the target DNA is found, Cas9 – one of the enzymes produced by the CRISPR system – binds to the DNA and cuts it, shutting the targeted gene off.
“By facilitating high-throughput model creation, CRISPR has elucidated which modifications are necessary and which are not; despite the ability to alter many loci concurrently, recent evidence has implicated three porcine genes that are responsible for the majority of human-antiporcine humoral immunity,” Dr. Butler and Dr. Tector wrote.
Those genes are the Gal[alpha]1-3 epitope (Gal-alpha), CMAH and B4GaINT2 genes. “Each of these three genes is expressed in pigs but has been evolutionarily silenced in humans,” the coauthors added.
When those three genes are silenced in pigs, “measures of human-antiporcine humoral immunity are reduced to levels comparable with allograft transplantation standards,” they said (Xenotransplantation. 2015 Jan-Feb;22:20-31). “This raises the possibility that porcine-to-human xenotransplantation may be clinically viable with the addition of conventional immunosuppressive regimens.”
While CRISPR genome editing has yet to reach its full potential, researchers and clinicians should pay attention, according to Dr. Butler and Dr. Tector.
More recent modifications of CRISPR technology have shown promise in not just knocking out or turning off specific genes, but rather guiding directed replacement of genes with researcher-designed substitutes. This can enable permanent transformation of functional genes with altered behavior, according to the Broad Institute website.
Dr. Tector disclosed he has received funding from United Therapeutics and founded Xenobridge with patents for xenotransplantation. Dr. Butler has no relevant financial relationships to disclose.
Key clinical point: CRISPR/Cas9 genome editing is advancing the creation of animal models for xenotransplantation into humans.
Major finding: Genome editing tools are moving xenotransplantation models quickly toward potential treatments for cardiopulmonary disease.
Data source: Expert opinion with literature review.
Disclosures: Dr. Tector disclosed he has received funding from United Therapeutics and founded Xenobridge with patents for xenotransplantation. Dr. Butler reported having no relevant financial disclosures.
Pairing vascular reconstruction, pancreatic cancer resection
CHICAGO – More than 53,000 people will develop pancreatic ductal adenocarcinoma in the United States this year, and upwards of 41,000 will die from the disease, many of them with tumors considered unresectable because they involve adjacent vessels. However, researchers at the University of California, Irvine, have found that careful removal of the tumor around involved veins and arteries, even in borderline cases, can improve outcomes for these patients.
Roy M. Fujitani, MD, updated previously published data on a single-center study he coauthored in 2015 of 270 patients who had undergone a Whipple operation, 183 for pancreatic adenocarcinoma (J Vasc Surg. 2015;61:475-80) at a symposium on vascular surgery sponsored by Northwestern University.
“Pancreatic ductal adenocarcinoma continues to have a very poor prognosis and this is likely due to the early metastasis and late symptom presentation of our patients,” said Dr. Fujitani of the University of California, Irvine. “The Whipple operation with concomitant vascular reconstruction for borderline resectable T3 lesions with vascular invasion may allow for increased microscopic margin negative surgical resections, including in those patients receiving neoadjuvant therapy.”
Resection of pancreatic tumors without vascular involvement is fairly straightforward for surgical oncologists to perform, Dr. Fujitani said, but pancreatic tumors enter the borderline resectable category when preoperative CT scan shows portal vein abutment, for which vascular surgery should provide counsel and assist. However, even in some cases when preoperative CT scan shows unresectable, locally advanced pancreatic tumor with celiac artery encasement, neoadjuvant therapy may downstage the disease into the borderline category, he said.
“Patients with borderline resectable or stage II disease are those one should consider for reconstruction,” Dr. Fujitani said. Resectable findings of borderline disease include encasement of the portal vein, superior mesenteric vein and the confluence of the portal venous system (with suitable proximal and distal targets for reconstruction); and less-than-circumferential involvement of the common hepatic artery or right hepatic artery – but without involvement of the superior mesenteric artery or the celiac axis and “certainly not” the aorta. “This would account for about one-fourth of patients in high-volume centers as being able to receive concomitant vascular reconstruction,” Dr. Fujitani said.
If less than 20% of the portal venous system is involved, the tumor can be resected with part of the vessel followed by primary repair. “Our preference is to do a vein patch onto the vein,” he said. “The other option is to use an autologous conduit either from a vein harvested elsewhere or a prosthetic conduit.” His group prefers the former approach because of the risk of infection with prosthetic conduits. Another approach is to use cryopreserved vein allografts.
In the UCI series, 60 patients with borderline lesions underwent vascular reconstruction. “As it turned out, there was no significant difference in survival between the reconstruction group and the nonreconstruction group,” Dr. Fujitani said, “but it’s important to note that these patients who had the reconstruction would never have been operated on if we were not able to do the reconstruction.” Thirty-day mortality was around 5% and 1-year survival around 70% in both groups, he said. However, at about 1.5 years the Kaplan-Meier survival curves between the two groups diverged, which Dr. Fujitani attributed to more advanced disease in the reconstruction group.
“We found lymph node status and tumor margins were most important in determining survival of these patients,” he said. “Gaining an R0 resection is the most important thing that determines favorable survivability.”
Dr. Fujitani also reviewed different techniques for vascular reconstruction, and while differences in complication rates or 1-, 2-, or 3-year survival were not statistically significant, he did note that mean survival with lateral venorrhaphy exceeded that of primary anastomosis and interposition graft – 21 months vs. 13 months vs. 4 months, suggesting the merits of a more aggressive approach to vascular resection and reconstruction.
“Improvement of survival outcomes may be achieved with concomitant advanced vascular reconstruction in carefully selected patients,” Dr. Fujitani said. “There are multiple options for vascular reconstruction for mesenteric portal venous and visceral arterial involvement using standard vascular surgical techniques.” He added that a dedicated team of experienced surgical oncologists and vascular surgeons for these reconstructions “is essential for successful outcomes.”
Dr. Fujitani had no relevant financial relationships to disclose.
CHICAGO – More than 53,000 people will develop pancreatic ductal adenocarcinoma in the United States this year, and upwards of 41,000 will die from the disease, many of them with tumors considered unresectable because they involve adjacent vessels. However, researchers at the University of California, Irvine, have found that careful removal of the tumor around involved veins and arteries, even in borderline cases, can improve outcomes for these patients.
Roy M. Fujitani, MD, updated previously published data on a single-center study he coauthored in 2015 of 270 patients who had undergone a Whipple operation, 183 for pancreatic adenocarcinoma (J Vasc Surg. 2015;61:475-80) at a symposium on vascular surgery sponsored by Northwestern University.
“Pancreatic ductal adenocarcinoma continues to have a very poor prognosis and this is likely due to the early metastasis and late symptom presentation of our patients,” said Dr. Fujitani of the University of California, Irvine. “The Whipple operation with concomitant vascular reconstruction for borderline resectable T3 lesions with vascular invasion may allow for increased microscopic margin negative surgical resections, including in those patients receiving neoadjuvant therapy.”
Resection of pancreatic tumors without vascular involvement is fairly straightforward for surgical oncologists to perform, Dr. Fujitani said, but pancreatic tumors enter the borderline resectable category when preoperative CT scan shows portal vein abutment, for which vascular surgery should provide counsel and assist. However, even in some cases when preoperative CT scan shows unresectable, locally advanced pancreatic tumor with celiac artery encasement, neoadjuvant therapy may downstage the disease into the borderline category, he said.
“Patients with borderline resectable or stage II disease are those one should consider for reconstruction,” Dr. Fujitani said. Resectable findings of borderline disease include encasement of the portal vein, superior mesenteric vein and the confluence of the portal venous system (with suitable proximal and distal targets for reconstruction); and less-than-circumferential involvement of the common hepatic artery or right hepatic artery – but without involvement of the superior mesenteric artery or the celiac axis and “certainly not” the aorta. “This would account for about one-fourth of patients in high-volume centers as being able to receive concomitant vascular reconstruction,” Dr. Fujitani said.
If less than 20% of the portal venous system is involved, the tumor can be resected with part of the vessel followed by primary repair. “Our preference is to do a vein patch onto the vein,” he said. “The other option is to use an autologous conduit either from a vein harvested elsewhere or a prosthetic conduit.” His group prefers the former approach because of the risk of infection with prosthetic conduits. Another approach is to use cryopreserved vein allografts.
In the UCI series, 60 patients with borderline lesions underwent vascular reconstruction. “As it turned out, there was no significant difference in survival between the reconstruction group and the nonreconstruction group,” Dr. Fujitani said, “but it’s important to note that these patients who had the reconstruction would never have been operated on if we were not able to do the reconstruction.” Thirty-day mortality was around 5% and 1-year survival around 70% in both groups, he said. However, at about 1.5 years the Kaplan-Meier survival curves between the two groups diverged, which Dr. Fujitani attributed to more advanced disease in the reconstruction group.
“We found lymph node status and tumor margins were most important in determining survival of these patients,” he said. “Gaining an R0 resection is the most important thing that determines favorable survivability.”
Dr. Fujitani also reviewed different techniques for vascular reconstruction, and while differences in complication rates or 1-, 2-, or 3-year survival were not statistically significant, he did note that mean survival with lateral venorrhaphy exceeded that of primary anastomosis and interposition graft – 21 months vs. 13 months vs. 4 months, suggesting the merits of a more aggressive approach to vascular resection and reconstruction.
“Improvement of survival outcomes may be achieved with concomitant advanced vascular reconstruction in carefully selected patients,” Dr. Fujitani said. “There are multiple options for vascular reconstruction for mesenteric portal venous and visceral arterial involvement using standard vascular surgical techniques.” He added that a dedicated team of experienced surgical oncologists and vascular surgeons for these reconstructions “is essential for successful outcomes.”
Dr. Fujitani had no relevant financial relationships to disclose.
CHICAGO – More than 53,000 people will develop pancreatic ductal adenocarcinoma in the United States this year, and upwards of 41,000 will die from the disease, many of them with tumors considered unresectable because they involve adjacent vessels. However, researchers at the University of California, Irvine, have found that careful removal of the tumor around involved veins and arteries, even in borderline cases, can improve outcomes for these patients.
Roy M. Fujitani, MD, updated previously published data on a single-center study he coauthored in 2015 of 270 patients who had undergone a Whipple operation, 183 for pancreatic adenocarcinoma (J Vasc Surg. 2015;61:475-80) at a symposium on vascular surgery sponsored by Northwestern University.
“Pancreatic ductal adenocarcinoma continues to have a very poor prognosis and this is likely due to the early metastasis and late symptom presentation of our patients,” said Dr. Fujitani of the University of California, Irvine. “The Whipple operation with concomitant vascular reconstruction for borderline resectable T3 lesions with vascular invasion may allow for increased microscopic margin negative surgical resections, including in those patients receiving neoadjuvant therapy.”
Resection of pancreatic tumors without vascular involvement is fairly straightforward for surgical oncologists to perform, Dr. Fujitani said, but pancreatic tumors enter the borderline resectable category when preoperative CT scan shows portal vein abutment, for which vascular surgery should provide counsel and assist. However, even in some cases when preoperative CT scan shows unresectable, locally advanced pancreatic tumor with celiac artery encasement, neoadjuvant therapy may downstage the disease into the borderline category, he said.
“Patients with borderline resectable or stage II disease are those one should consider for reconstruction,” Dr. Fujitani said. Resectable findings of borderline disease include encasement of the portal vein, superior mesenteric vein and the confluence of the portal venous system (with suitable proximal and distal targets for reconstruction); and less-than-circumferential involvement of the common hepatic artery or right hepatic artery – but without involvement of the superior mesenteric artery or the celiac axis and “certainly not” the aorta. “This would account for about one-fourth of patients in high-volume centers as being able to receive concomitant vascular reconstruction,” Dr. Fujitani said.
If less than 20% of the portal venous system is involved, the tumor can be resected with part of the vessel followed by primary repair. “Our preference is to do a vein patch onto the vein,” he said. “The other option is to use an autologous conduit either from a vein harvested elsewhere or a prosthetic conduit.” His group prefers the former approach because of the risk of infection with prosthetic conduits. Another approach is to use cryopreserved vein allografts.
In the UCI series, 60 patients with borderline lesions underwent vascular reconstruction. “As it turned out, there was no significant difference in survival between the reconstruction group and the nonreconstruction group,” Dr. Fujitani said, “but it’s important to note that these patients who had the reconstruction would never have been operated on if we were not able to do the reconstruction.” Thirty-day mortality was around 5% and 1-year survival around 70% in both groups, he said. However, at about 1.5 years the Kaplan-Meier survival curves between the two groups diverged, which Dr. Fujitani attributed to more advanced disease in the reconstruction group.
“We found lymph node status and tumor margins were most important in determining survival of these patients,” he said. “Gaining an R0 resection is the most important thing that determines favorable survivability.”
Dr. Fujitani also reviewed different techniques for vascular reconstruction, and while differences in complication rates or 1-, 2-, or 3-year survival were not statistically significant, he did note that mean survival with lateral venorrhaphy exceeded that of primary anastomosis and interposition graft – 21 months vs. 13 months vs. 4 months, suggesting the merits of a more aggressive approach to vascular resection and reconstruction.
“Improvement of survival outcomes may be achieved with concomitant advanced vascular reconstruction in carefully selected patients,” Dr. Fujitani said. “There are multiple options for vascular reconstruction for mesenteric portal venous and visceral arterial involvement using standard vascular surgical techniques.” He added that a dedicated team of experienced surgical oncologists and vascular surgeons for these reconstructions “is essential for successful outcomes.”
Dr. Fujitani had no relevant financial relationships to disclose.
AT THE NORTHWESTERN VASCULAR SYMPOSIUM
Key clinical point: A more aggressive vascular resection and reconstruction in pancreatic cancer may improve outcomes and palliation in these patients.
Major finding: Mean survival with lateral venorrhaphy exceeded primary anastomosis and interposition graft (21 months vs. 13 months vs. 4 months).
Data source: Updated data of previously published single-center retrospective review of 183 patients who had Whipple procedure for pancreatic adenocarcinoma.
Disclosures: Dr. Fujitani reported having no financial disclosures.
VQI confirms improvements in vascular practice
CHICAGO – Five years after the Society for Vascular Surgery launched the Vascular Quality Initiative, participating centers are more likely to use chlorhexidine and have also cut their surgery times and reduced their transfusion rates, according to results presented at a symposium on vascular surgery sponsored by Northwestern University.
But more drastic have been the improvements once low-performing centers have made in these measures and others, Larry Kraiss, MD, of the University of Utah, Salt Lake City, said in reporting an update on VQI. “If you look at centers that had a big change in not using chlorhexidine to using chlorhexidine, the reduction of surgical site infections [SSI] in that subgroup was actually pretty significant,” said Dr. Kraiss, chair of the governing council of the SVS Patient Safety Organization, which oversees VQI.
VQI identified a similar trend among length of stay after carotid endarterectomy (CEA) and endovascular aneurysm repair (EVAR) at centers that had been performing below the norm. VQI data showed that at 5 years, patients discharged on both statins and aspirin have better long-term survival than do patients discharged on neither, Dr. Kraiss said.
These pivotal improvements came about after the VQI distributed what it calls COPI reports – for Center Opportunity Profile for Improvement – to participating centers. Currently, 379 centers in 46 states and Ontario participate in VQI, feeding data into 12 different vascular procedure registries ranging from peripheral vascular interventions to lower-extremity amputations. As of Nov. 1, 2016, 330,400 procedures had been submitted to VQI.
Dr. Kraiss called the COPI report the “workhorse” of the VQI. “It can give participating centers insight into what they can do to improve outcomes,” he said. It is one of three types of reports VQI provides. The others are benchmarking reports that show the masked ratings for all participating centers but confidentially highlight the rating of the individual center receiving the report; and reports for individual providers.
The most recent readout of the SSI COPI report compared measures in two periods: 2011-2012 and 2013-2014. In those periods, overall use of chlorhexidine rose from 66.6% to 81.2%; transfusion rates of more than 2 units fell from 14.4% to 11.5%; the share of procedures lasting 220 minutes or more fell from 50.2% to 47.7%; and SSI rate overall fell from 3.4% to 3.1%. While the change in SSI was not statistically significant, Dr. Kraiss said the 17 centers that had a large increase in chlorhexidine use did see statistically significant declines in SSI.
VQI also showed a 5-year survival rate of 79% of patients discharged with both statin and aspirin therapy vs. 61% for patients discharged without (J Vasc Surg. 2015;61[4]:1010-9). “This represents an opportunity to inform individual providers about how often they discharge patients on an aspirin and statin,” Dr. Kraiss said. Provider-targeted reports show how individual physicians rate in their region and nationwide.
VQI is more than a registry, Dr. Kraiss said; it’s also organized into 17 regional quality groups that provide surgeons a safe place to discuss VQI data and how to use that to encourage best practices. “There’s no risk of compromising or making the information identifiable,” he said. “It’s a matter of just getting together and trying to share best practices in a relatively informal environment, and hopefully through that drive quality improvement.
Other benefits of participating in VQI are that it can help surgeons comply with requirements for Medicare’s Merit-based Incentive Payment System (MIPS). VQI also offers opportunities to enroll in industry-sponsored clinical trials, which can help defray the cost of VQI participation, he said.
Dr. Kraiss had no relevant financial relationships to disclose.
CHICAGO – Five years after the Society for Vascular Surgery launched the Vascular Quality Initiative, participating centers are more likely to use chlorhexidine and have also cut their surgery times and reduced their transfusion rates, according to results presented at a symposium on vascular surgery sponsored by Northwestern University.
But more drastic have been the improvements once low-performing centers have made in these measures and others, Larry Kraiss, MD, of the University of Utah, Salt Lake City, said in reporting an update on VQI. “If you look at centers that had a big change in not using chlorhexidine to using chlorhexidine, the reduction of surgical site infections [SSI] in that subgroup was actually pretty significant,” said Dr. Kraiss, chair of the governing council of the SVS Patient Safety Organization, which oversees VQI.
VQI identified a similar trend among length of stay after carotid endarterectomy (CEA) and endovascular aneurysm repair (EVAR) at centers that had been performing below the norm. VQI data showed that at 5 years, patients discharged on both statins and aspirin have better long-term survival than do patients discharged on neither, Dr. Kraiss said.
These pivotal improvements came about after the VQI distributed what it calls COPI reports – for Center Opportunity Profile for Improvement – to participating centers. Currently, 379 centers in 46 states and Ontario participate in VQI, feeding data into 12 different vascular procedure registries ranging from peripheral vascular interventions to lower-extremity amputations. As of Nov. 1, 2016, 330,400 procedures had been submitted to VQI.
Dr. Kraiss called the COPI report the “workhorse” of the VQI. “It can give participating centers insight into what they can do to improve outcomes,” he said. It is one of three types of reports VQI provides. The others are benchmarking reports that show the masked ratings for all participating centers but confidentially highlight the rating of the individual center receiving the report; and reports for individual providers.
The most recent readout of the SSI COPI report compared measures in two periods: 2011-2012 and 2013-2014. In those periods, overall use of chlorhexidine rose from 66.6% to 81.2%; transfusion rates of more than 2 units fell from 14.4% to 11.5%; the share of procedures lasting 220 minutes or more fell from 50.2% to 47.7%; and SSI rate overall fell from 3.4% to 3.1%. While the change in SSI was not statistically significant, Dr. Kraiss said the 17 centers that had a large increase in chlorhexidine use did see statistically significant declines in SSI.
VQI also showed a 5-year survival rate of 79% of patients discharged with both statin and aspirin therapy vs. 61% for patients discharged without (J Vasc Surg. 2015;61[4]:1010-9). “This represents an opportunity to inform individual providers about how often they discharge patients on an aspirin and statin,” Dr. Kraiss said. Provider-targeted reports show how individual physicians rate in their region and nationwide.
VQI is more than a registry, Dr. Kraiss said; it’s also organized into 17 regional quality groups that provide surgeons a safe place to discuss VQI data and how to use that to encourage best practices. “There’s no risk of compromising or making the information identifiable,” he said. “It’s a matter of just getting together and trying to share best practices in a relatively informal environment, and hopefully through that drive quality improvement.
Other benefits of participating in VQI are that it can help surgeons comply with requirements for Medicare’s Merit-based Incentive Payment System (MIPS). VQI also offers opportunities to enroll in industry-sponsored clinical trials, which can help defray the cost of VQI participation, he said.
Dr. Kraiss had no relevant financial relationships to disclose.
CHICAGO – Five years after the Society for Vascular Surgery launched the Vascular Quality Initiative, participating centers are more likely to use chlorhexidine and have also cut their surgery times and reduced their transfusion rates, according to results presented at a symposium on vascular surgery sponsored by Northwestern University.
But more drastic have been the improvements once low-performing centers have made in these measures and others, Larry Kraiss, MD, of the University of Utah, Salt Lake City, said in reporting an update on VQI. “If you look at centers that had a big change in not using chlorhexidine to using chlorhexidine, the reduction of surgical site infections [SSI] in that subgroup was actually pretty significant,” said Dr. Kraiss, chair of the governing council of the SVS Patient Safety Organization, which oversees VQI.
VQI identified a similar trend among length of stay after carotid endarterectomy (CEA) and endovascular aneurysm repair (EVAR) at centers that had been performing below the norm. VQI data showed that at 5 years, patients discharged on both statins and aspirin have better long-term survival than do patients discharged on neither, Dr. Kraiss said.
These pivotal improvements came about after the VQI distributed what it calls COPI reports – for Center Opportunity Profile for Improvement – to participating centers. Currently, 379 centers in 46 states and Ontario participate in VQI, feeding data into 12 different vascular procedure registries ranging from peripheral vascular interventions to lower-extremity amputations. As of Nov. 1, 2016, 330,400 procedures had been submitted to VQI.
Dr. Kraiss called the COPI report the “workhorse” of the VQI. “It can give participating centers insight into what they can do to improve outcomes,” he said. It is one of three types of reports VQI provides. The others are benchmarking reports that show the masked ratings for all participating centers but confidentially highlight the rating of the individual center receiving the report; and reports for individual providers.
The most recent readout of the SSI COPI report compared measures in two periods: 2011-2012 and 2013-2014. In those periods, overall use of chlorhexidine rose from 66.6% to 81.2%; transfusion rates of more than 2 units fell from 14.4% to 11.5%; the share of procedures lasting 220 minutes or more fell from 50.2% to 47.7%; and SSI rate overall fell from 3.4% to 3.1%. While the change in SSI was not statistically significant, Dr. Kraiss said the 17 centers that had a large increase in chlorhexidine use did see statistically significant declines in SSI.
VQI also showed a 5-year survival rate of 79% of patients discharged with both statin and aspirin therapy vs. 61% for patients discharged without (J Vasc Surg. 2015;61[4]:1010-9). “This represents an opportunity to inform individual providers about how often they discharge patients on an aspirin and statin,” Dr. Kraiss said. Provider-targeted reports show how individual physicians rate in their region and nationwide.
VQI is more than a registry, Dr. Kraiss said; it’s also organized into 17 regional quality groups that provide surgeons a safe place to discuss VQI data and how to use that to encourage best practices. “There’s no risk of compromising or making the information identifiable,” he said. “It’s a matter of just getting together and trying to share best practices in a relatively informal environment, and hopefully through that drive quality improvement.
Other benefits of participating in VQI are that it can help surgeons comply with requirements for Medicare’s Merit-based Incentive Payment System (MIPS). VQI also offers opportunities to enroll in industry-sponsored clinical trials, which can help defray the cost of VQI participation, he said.
Dr. Kraiss had no relevant financial relationships to disclose.
AT THE NORTHWESTERN VASCULAR SYMPOSIUM
Key clinical point: The Vascular Quality Initiative (VQI) provides comparative outcomes data that centers and surgeons can use to improve quality.
Major finding: Hospital length of stay for carotid endarterectomy averages 1.6 days for VQI centers vs. 2.6 days for nonparticipating centers.
Data source: VQI database.
Disclosures: Dr. Kraiss reported having no financial disclosures.