User login
It’s late on a Thursday afternoon. Even through the six walls that separate you from the waiting room you can feel the impatient throng of families as you struggle to see the tympanic membrane of a feverish and uncooperative 3-year-old. You already have scraped his auditory canal once with your curette. Your gut tells you that he must have an otitis but deeper in your soul there are other voices reminding you that to make the diagnosis you must visualize his ear drum. Your skill and the technology on hand has failed you.
It’s a Sunday morning, weekend hours, and you are seeing a 12-year-old with a sore throat and fever. Her physical exam suggests that she has strep pharyngitis but the team member in charge of restocking supplies has forgotten to reorder rapid strep kits and you used the last one yesterday afternoon.
Do you ignore your training and treat these sick children with antibiotics?
If you are someone who perceives the world in black and white, your response to these scenarios is simple because you NEVER prescribe antibiotics without seeing a tympanic membrane or confirming your suspicion with a rapid strep test. There are unrealistic solutions that could include requesting an immediate ear/nose/throat consult or sending the patient on an hour-long odyssey to the hospital lab. But for the rest of us who see in shades of gray, we may have to compromise our principles and temporarily become poor antibiotic stewards. The question is, how often do you compromise? Once a week, once a month, twice a year, or twice a day?
A study published in Pediatrics looks at the issue of antibiotic stewardship as it relates to telemedicine (“Antibiotic Prescribing During Pediatrics Direct-to-Consumer Telemedicine Visits,” Pediatrics. 2019 May. doi: 10.1542/peds.2018-2491).
The investigators found that children with acute respiratory infections were more likely to receive antibiotics and less likely to receive guideline concordant management at direct-to-consumer (DTC) telemedicine visits than when they were seen by their primary care physician or at an urgent care center.
In their discussion, the researchers note several possible explanations for the discrepancies they observed. DTC telemedicine visits are limited by the devices used by the families and physicians and generally lack availability of otoscopy and strep testing. The authors also wonder whether “there may be differential expectations for antibiotics among children and parents who use DTC telemedicine versus in person care.” Does this mean that families who utilize DTC telemedicine undervalue in-person care and/or are willing to compromise by accepting what they may suspect is substandard care for the convenience of DTC telemedicine?
Which brings me to my point. A physician who accepts the challenge of seeing pediatric patients with acute respiratory illnesses knowing that he or she will not be able to visualize tympanic membranes or perform strep testing also has accepted the fact that he or she will be compromising the principles of antibiotic stewardship he or she must have – or maybe should have – learned in medical school or residency.
We all occasionally compromise our principles when technology fails us or when the situations are extraordinary. But I am troubled that there some physicians who are willing to practice in an environment in which they are aware that they will be compromising their antibiotic stewardship on a daily or even hourly basis.
Dr. Wilkoff practiced primary care pediatrics in Brunswick, Maine for nearly 40 years. He has authored several books on behavioral pediatrics, including “How to Say No to Your Toddler.” Email him at [email protected].
It’s late on a Thursday afternoon. Even through the six walls that separate you from the waiting room you can feel the impatient throng of families as you struggle to see the tympanic membrane of a feverish and uncooperative 3-year-old. You already have scraped his auditory canal once with your curette. Your gut tells you that he must have an otitis but deeper in your soul there are other voices reminding you that to make the diagnosis you must visualize his ear drum. Your skill and the technology on hand has failed you.
It’s a Sunday morning, weekend hours, and you are seeing a 12-year-old with a sore throat and fever. Her physical exam suggests that she has strep pharyngitis but the team member in charge of restocking supplies has forgotten to reorder rapid strep kits and you used the last one yesterday afternoon.
Do you ignore your training and treat these sick children with antibiotics?
If you are someone who perceives the world in black and white, your response to these scenarios is simple because you NEVER prescribe antibiotics without seeing a tympanic membrane or confirming your suspicion with a rapid strep test. There are unrealistic solutions that could include requesting an immediate ear/nose/throat consult or sending the patient on an hour-long odyssey to the hospital lab. But for the rest of us who see in shades of gray, we may have to compromise our principles and temporarily become poor antibiotic stewards. The question is, how often do you compromise? Once a week, once a month, twice a year, or twice a day?
A study published in Pediatrics looks at the issue of antibiotic stewardship as it relates to telemedicine (“Antibiotic Prescribing During Pediatrics Direct-to-Consumer Telemedicine Visits,” Pediatrics. 2019 May. doi: 10.1542/peds.2018-2491).
The investigators found that children with acute respiratory infections were more likely to receive antibiotics and less likely to receive guideline concordant management at direct-to-consumer (DTC) telemedicine visits than when they were seen by their primary care physician or at an urgent care center.
In their discussion, the researchers note several possible explanations for the discrepancies they observed. DTC telemedicine visits are limited by the devices used by the families and physicians and generally lack availability of otoscopy and strep testing. The authors also wonder whether “there may be differential expectations for antibiotics among children and parents who use DTC telemedicine versus in person care.” Does this mean that families who utilize DTC telemedicine undervalue in-person care and/or are willing to compromise by accepting what they may suspect is substandard care for the convenience of DTC telemedicine?
Which brings me to my point. A physician who accepts the challenge of seeing pediatric patients with acute respiratory illnesses knowing that he or she will not be able to visualize tympanic membranes or perform strep testing also has accepted the fact that he or she will be compromising the principles of antibiotic stewardship he or she must have – or maybe should have – learned in medical school or residency.
We all occasionally compromise our principles when technology fails us or when the situations are extraordinary. But I am troubled that there some physicians who are willing to practice in an environment in which they are aware that they will be compromising their antibiotic stewardship on a daily or even hourly basis.
Dr. Wilkoff practiced primary care pediatrics in Brunswick, Maine for nearly 40 years. He has authored several books on behavioral pediatrics, including “How to Say No to Your Toddler.” Email him at [email protected].
It’s late on a Thursday afternoon. Even through the six walls that separate you from the waiting room you can feel the impatient throng of families as you struggle to see the tympanic membrane of a feverish and uncooperative 3-year-old. You already have scraped his auditory canal once with your curette. Your gut tells you that he must have an otitis but deeper in your soul there are other voices reminding you that to make the diagnosis you must visualize his ear drum. Your skill and the technology on hand has failed you.
It’s a Sunday morning, weekend hours, and you are seeing a 12-year-old with a sore throat and fever. Her physical exam suggests that she has strep pharyngitis but the team member in charge of restocking supplies has forgotten to reorder rapid strep kits and you used the last one yesterday afternoon.
Do you ignore your training and treat these sick children with antibiotics?
If you are someone who perceives the world in black and white, your response to these scenarios is simple because you NEVER prescribe antibiotics without seeing a tympanic membrane or confirming your suspicion with a rapid strep test. There are unrealistic solutions that could include requesting an immediate ear/nose/throat consult or sending the patient on an hour-long odyssey to the hospital lab. But for the rest of us who see in shades of gray, we may have to compromise our principles and temporarily become poor antibiotic stewards. The question is, how often do you compromise? Once a week, once a month, twice a year, or twice a day?
A study published in Pediatrics looks at the issue of antibiotic stewardship as it relates to telemedicine (“Antibiotic Prescribing During Pediatrics Direct-to-Consumer Telemedicine Visits,” Pediatrics. 2019 May. doi: 10.1542/peds.2018-2491).
The investigators found that children with acute respiratory infections were more likely to receive antibiotics and less likely to receive guideline concordant management at direct-to-consumer (DTC) telemedicine visits than when they were seen by their primary care physician or at an urgent care center.
In their discussion, the researchers note several possible explanations for the discrepancies they observed. DTC telemedicine visits are limited by the devices used by the families and physicians and generally lack availability of otoscopy and strep testing. The authors also wonder whether “there may be differential expectations for antibiotics among children and parents who use DTC telemedicine versus in person care.” Does this mean that families who utilize DTC telemedicine undervalue in-person care and/or are willing to compromise by accepting what they may suspect is substandard care for the convenience of DTC telemedicine?
Which brings me to my point. A physician who accepts the challenge of seeing pediatric patients with acute respiratory illnesses knowing that he or she will not be able to visualize tympanic membranes or perform strep testing also has accepted the fact that he or she will be compromising the principles of antibiotic stewardship he or she must have – or maybe should have – learned in medical school or residency.
We all occasionally compromise our principles when technology fails us or when the situations are extraordinary. But I am troubled that there some physicians who are willing to practice in an environment in which they are aware that they will be compromising their antibiotic stewardship on a daily or even hourly basis.
Dr. Wilkoff practiced primary care pediatrics in Brunswick, Maine for nearly 40 years. He has authored several books on behavioral pediatrics, including “How to Say No to Your Toddler.” Email him at [email protected].
