Study Limited, Not Convincing
Article Type
Changed
Fri, 01/11/2019 - 11:33
Display Headline
JAAD: Adapalene-Benzoyl Peroxide Improves Even Severe Acne

Combination adapalene-benzoyl peroxide for acne vulgaris is more effective than either therapy alone, according to the results of a new analysis.

The therapy reduced total lesion count after 12 weeks, regardless of a patient's initial number of lesions, according to Dr. Steven R. Feldman of the department of dermatology at Wake Forest University, Winston-Salem, N.C., and his colleagues.

    Dr. Steven R. Feldman

The investigators pooled data from three multicenter, randomized clinical trials of similar design, totaling 3,853 patients. The three studies had four treatment groups (combination, adapalene only, benzoyl peroxide [BPO] only, and a gel vehicle).

The study investigators defined three subgroups based on lesion count: lowest 25%, middle 50%, and highest 25%. They found that efficacy of adapalene-benzoyl relative to its gel vehicle increased with number of lesions (J. Amer. Acad. Dermatol. 2011 [doi:10.1016/j.jaad.2010.03.036]).

Also, "adapalene-BPO was significantly more efficacious, compared with the monotherapies and vehicle in percent reduction of inflammatory, noninflammatory, and total lesions," the investigators wrote. "The superior efficacy of adapalene-BPO was also confirmed in all lesion count subgroups."

Total lesion counts in the three subgroups treated with combination therapy were reduced by 19%, 26%, and 29%, respectively.

The patients were aged 12 years or older and had 20-50 inflammatory lesions and 30-100 noninflammatory lesions on their face. Although 495 patients dropped out of the study, they were proportionally distributed among the three subgroups.

As for adverse events, tolerability was similar across all lesion count subgroups, with events being highest at week 1. The most common side effect was dry sin.

Dr. Feldman said in an interview that by subtracting the effect of the gel vehicle, he could more clearly determine the effect of the drug itself, since the study did not incorporate a placebo. However, he added, in clinical practice what is important is the full effect of the drug for the patient, aided by the gel vehicle.

He concluded that because the combination therapy showed similar overall improvement in the low- and high-lesion count groups, topical drugs are a viable first option even for severe acne cases. In addition, studies show that combination therapies simplify treatment for the patient and increase likelihood of adherence.

The study received funding from Galderma. Dr. Feldman disclosed receiving grant funding from Galderma, as well as serving as a speaker, investigator, and consultant for the pharmaceutical company. All of the other investigators for this study also disclosed relationships with Galderma.

Body

    



This study makes no dent

in the practice of deciding on a case-by-case basis whether to begin with

topical or systemic treatments for acne, according to Dr. Neil S. Goldberg. None

of the patients included in the study showed a severe enough level of acne from

the study's description to warrant bypassing the conventional first step of

topical treatment. Therefore, the study authors, in asserting that the study

makes the case for considering topical treatments as a first option even for

patients with severe acne, based their argument on a limited clinical spectrum.

Dr. Goldberg is a member of the editorial advisory

board of Skin & Allergy News and practices dermatology in Bronxville, N.Y.

Author and Disclosure Information

Publications
Topics
Legacy Keywords
adapalene-benzoyl peroxide, acne vulgaris, Dr. Steven R. Feldman, dermatology
Author and Disclosure Information

Author and Disclosure Information

Body

    



This study makes no dent

in the practice of deciding on a case-by-case basis whether to begin with

topical or systemic treatments for acne, according to Dr. Neil S. Goldberg. None

of the patients included in the study showed a severe enough level of acne from

the study's description to warrant bypassing the conventional first step of

topical treatment. Therefore, the study authors, in asserting that the study

makes the case for considering topical treatments as a first option even for

patients with severe acne, based their argument on a limited clinical spectrum.

Dr. Goldberg is a member of the editorial advisory

board of Skin & Allergy News and practices dermatology in Bronxville, N.Y.

Body

    



This study makes no dent

in the practice of deciding on a case-by-case basis whether to begin with

topical or systemic treatments for acne, according to Dr. Neil S. Goldberg. None

of the patients included in the study showed a severe enough level of acne from

the study's description to warrant bypassing the conventional first step of

topical treatment. Therefore, the study authors, in asserting that the study

makes the case for considering topical treatments as a first option even for

patients with severe acne, based their argument on a limited clinical spectrum.

Dr. Goldberg is a member of the editorial advisory

board of Skin & Allergy News and practices dermatology in Bronxville, N.Y.

Title
Study Limited, Not Convincing
Study Limited, Not Convincing

Combination adapalene-benzoyl peroxide for acne vulgaris is more effective than either therapy alone, according to the results of a new analysis.

The therapy reduced total lesion count after 12 weeks, regardless of a patient's initial number of lesions, according to Dr. Steven R. Feldman of the department of dermatology at Wake Forest University, Winston-Salem, N.C., and his colleagues.

    Dr. Steven R. Feldman

The investigators pooled data from three multicenter, randomized clinical trials of similar design, totaling 3,853 patients. The three studies had four treatment groups (combination, adapalene only, benzoyl peroxide [BPO] only, and a gel vehicle).

The study investigators defined three subgroups based on lesion count: lowest 25%, middle 50%, and highest 25%. They found that efficacy of adapalene-benzoyl relative to its gel vehicle increased with number of lesions (J. Amer. Acad. Dermatol. 2011 [doi:10.1016/j.jaad.2010.03.036]).

Also, "adapalene-BPO was significantly more efficacious, compared with the monotherapies and vehicle in percent reduction of inflammatory, noninflammatory, and total lesions," the investigators wrote. "The superior efficacy of adapalene-BPO was also confirmed in all lesion count subgroups."

Total lesion counts in the three subgroups treated with combination therapy were reduced by 19%, 26%, and 29%, respectively.

The patients were aged 12 years or older and had 20-50 inflammatory lesions and 30-100 noninflammatory lesions on their face. Although 495 patients dropped out of the study, they were proportionally distributed among the three subgroups.

As for adverse events, tolerability was similar across all lesion count subgroups, with events being highest at week 1. The most common side effect was dry sin.

Dr. Feldman said in an interview that by subtracting the effect of the gel vehicle, he could more clearly determine the effect of the drug itself, since the study did not incorporate a placebo. However, he added, in clinical practice what is important is the full effect of the drug for the patient, aided by the gel vehicle.

He concluded that because the combination therapy showed similar overall improvement in the low- and high-lesion count groups, topical drugs are a viable first option even for severe acne cases. In addition, studies show that combination therapies simplify treatment for the patient and increase likelihood of adherence.

The study received funding from Galderma. Dr. Feldman disclosed receiving grant funding from Galderma, as well as serving as a speaker, investigator, and consultant for the pharmaceutical company. All of the other investigators for this study also disclosed relationships with Galderma.

Combination adapalene-benzoyl peroxide for acne vulgaris is more effective than either therapy alone, according to the results of a new analysis.

The therapy reduced total lesion count after 12 weeks, regardless of a patient's initial number of lesions, according to Dr. Steven R. Feldman of the department of dermatology at Wake Forest University, Winston-Salem, N.C., and his colleagues.

    Dr. Steven R. Feldman

The investigators pooled data from three multicenter, randomized clinical trials of similar design, totaling 3,853 patients. The three studies had four treatment groups (combination, adapalene only, benzoyl peroxide [BPO] only, and a gel vehicle).

The study investigators defined three subgroups based on lesion count: lowest 25%, middle 50%, and highest 25%. They found that efficacy of adapalene-benzoyl relative to its gel vehicle increased with number of lesions (J. Amer. Acad. Dermatol. 2011 [doi:10.1016/j.jaad.2010.03.036]).

Also, "adapalene-BPO was significantly more efficacious, compared with the monotherapies and vehicle in percent reduction of inflammatory, noninflammatory, and total lesions," the investigators wrote. "The superior efficacy of adapalene-BPO was also confirmed in all lesion count subgroups."

Total lesion counts in the three subgroups treated with combination therapy were reduced by 19%, 26%, and 29%, respectively.

The patients were aged 12 years or older and had 20-50 inflammatory lesions and 30-100 noninflammatory lesions on their face. Although 495 patients dropped out of the study, they were proportionally distributed among the three subgroups.

As for adverse events, tolerability was similar across all lesion count subgroups, with events being highest at week 1. The most common side effect was dry sin.

Dr. Feldman said in an interview that by subtracting the effect of the gel vehicle, he could more clearly determine the effect of the drug itself, since the study did not incorporate a placebo. However, he added, in clinical practice what is important is the full effect of the drug for the patient, aided by the gel vehicle.

He concluded that because the combination therapy showed similar overall improvement in the low- and high-lesion count groups, topical drugs are a viable first option even for severe acne cases. In addition, studies show that combination therapies simplify treatment for the patient and increase likelihood of adherence.

The study received funding from Galderma. Dr. Feldman disclosed receiving grant funding from Galderma, as well as serving as a speaker, investigator, and consultant for the pharmaceutical company. All of the other investigators for this study also disclosed relationships with Galderma.

Publications
Publications
Topics
Article Type
Display Headline
JAAD: Adapalene-Benzoyl Peroxide Improves Even Severe Acne
Display Headline
JAAD: Adapalene-Benzoyl Peroxide Improves Even Severe Acne
Legacy Keywords
adapalene-benzoyl peroxide, acne vulgaris, Dr. Steven R. Feldman, dermatology
Legacy Keywords
adapalene-benzoyl peroxide, acne vulgaris, Dr. Steven R. Feldman, dermatology
Article Source

FROM THE JOURNAL OF THE AMERICAN ACADEMY OF DERMATOLOGY

PURLs Copyright

Inside the Article

Vitals

Major Finding: Total lesion counts with combination

therapy were reduced by 19% for patients with the lowest lesion count, 26% for patients

with a medium lesion count, and 29% for patients with the highest lesion count.

Data Source: Pooled

data from three multicenter, randomized clinical trials of similar design,

totaling 3,853 patients.

Disclosures: The

study received funding from Galderma. Dr. Feldman disclosed receiving grant

funding from Galderma, as well as serving as a speaker, investigator, and

consultant for the pharmaceutical company. All of the other investigators for

this study also disclosed relationships with Galderma.