User login
CHICAGO – Treatment of calcified femoropopliteal lesions with orbital atherectomy led to similar 12-month patency as balloon angioplasty but with a reduced need for stenting, in a randomized, controlled study with 50 patients.
Orbital atherectomy changed vessel compliance, which allowed lower pressure balloon dilatation and hence less vessel disruption, which appeared to produce a low rate of restenosis with minimal stent use. "Lower dissection rates and reduced use of bail-out stents preserves treatment options in the future," said Dr. Raymond Dattilo in a poster at the Annual Scientific Session of the American College of Cardiology. Minimizing stent use in distal, superficial femoral and popliteal arteries also reduces the risk of stent fracture, said Dr. Dattilo, a cardiologist and director of endovascular medicine at St. Francis Health Center in Topeka, Kan.
He ran the COMPLIANCE 360° study to determine whether orbital atherectomy of calcified femoropopliteal lesions using the Diamondback Orbital Atherectomy System reduced the need for stenting without diminishing 12-month vessel patency when compared with percutaneous balloon angioplasty and selected stent use. The study enrolled 50 patients with 65 femoropopliteal lesions. Randomization resulted in two treatment arms with similar patients and types of lesions (based on degree of calcification and plaque morphology). The only statistically-significant difference between the two treatment arms was the percent of patients with diabetes, which affected 18 (72%) patients randomized to orbital atherectomy and 10 (40%) patients treated with balloon angioplasty and bail-out stenting.
Maximum balloon pressure used during angioplasty was 4 atmospheres in the 25 patients treated with orbital atherectomy, and 9 atmospheres in the 25 patients who did not undergo atherectomy. Two patients treated with atherectomy, (8%) required a bail-out stent, compared with 21 (84%) in the angioplasty group, a statistically significant difference.
At 6 months after treatment, 16 of 22 patients (73%) in the atherectomy group with 6-month follow-up had avoided stent placement, were free from target lesion revascularization, and had no restenosis as assessed by duplex ultrasound. Among 24 patients in the balloon angioplasty group assessed after 6 months, two patients (8%) met these same efficacy criteria.
After 12 months, five patients in the atherectomy group of 20 with 12-month follow-up had restenosis or repeat target lesion revascularization, compared with five of 21 patients with angioplasty. The 12-month results showed that the two strategies resulted in similar rates of long-term vessel patency, but the atherectomy patients avoided stent placement.
The COMPLIANCE 360° study was sponsored by Cardiovascular Systems. Dr. Dattilo said he has received financial support from Cardiovascular Systems.☐
This study randomized symptomatic patients (65 lesions) with calcified femoropopliteal stenoses to either angioplasty alone or orbital atherectomy (OA) followed by low pressure angioplasty. Residual stenoses greater than 30% were stented. The endpoints were "freedom from target lesion revascularization.."
Unfortunately, the severity of symptoms and TASC classification of the lesions are not given. The definition/ severity of calcification is also not described.
Not surprisingy, only 8.3% of lesions treated with angioplasty alone did not require immediate stenting or stent placement for restenosis. 72.7% of patients in the OA group did not require stent placement at the time of the procedure or during the first 6 months followup.
Many surgeons use stent placement in the majority of SFA and popliteal lesions and almost all would use stent placement in the setting of significant lesion calcification. Orbital atherectomy is certainly another possible way of dealing with these difficult lesions, but primary stenting would appear to be a more practical and cost-effective approach. The results of this study are unlikely to influence contemporary vascular practice.
Professor Robert A Fitridge is at the University of Adelaide Discipline of Surgery, The Queen Elizabeth Hospital, Woodville, South Australia, Australia. He is an associate medical editor of Vascular Specialist.
This study randomized symptomatic patients (65 lesions) with calcified femoropopliteal stenoses to either angioplasty alone or orbital atherectomy (OA) followed by low pressure angioplasty. Residual stenoses greater than 30% were stented. The endpoints were "freedom from target lesion revascularization.."
Unfortunately, the severity of symptoms and TASC classification of the lesions are not given. The definition/ severity of calcification is also not described.
Not surprisingy, only 8.3% of lesions treated with angioplasty alone did not require immediate stenting or stent placement for restenosis. 72.7% of patients in the OA group did not require stent placement at the time of the procedure or during the first 6 months followup.
Many surgeons use stent placement in the majority of SFA and popliteal lesions and almost all would use stent placement in the setting of significant lesion calcification. Orbital atherectomy is certainly another possible way of dealing with these difficult lesions, but primary stenting would appear to be a more practical and cost-effective approach. The results of this study are unlikely to influence contemporary vascular practice.
Professor Robert A Fitridge is at the University of Adelaide Discipline of Surgery, The Queen Elizabeth Hospital, Woodville, South Australia, Australia. He is an associate medical editor of Vascular Specialist.
This study randomized symptomatic patients (65 lesions) with calcified femoropopliteal stenoses to either angioplasty alone or orbital atherectomy (OA) followed by low pressure angioplasty. Residual stenoses greater than 30% were stented. The endpoints were "freedom from target lesion revascularization.."
Unfortunately, the severity of symptoms and TASC classification of the lesions are not given. The definition/ severity of calcification is also not described.
Not surprisingy, only 8.3% of lesions treated with angioplasty alone did not require immediate stenting or stent placement for restenosis. 72.7% of patients in the OA group did not require stent placement at the time of the procedure or during the first 6 months followup.
Many surgeons use stent placement in the majority of SFA and popliteal lesions and almost all would use stent placement in the setting of significant lesion calcification. Orbital atherectomy is certainly another possible way of dealing with these difficult lesions, but primary stenting would appear to be a more practical and cost-effective approach. The results of this study are unlikely to influence contemporary vascular practice.
Professor Robert A Fitridge is at the University of Adelaide Discipline of Surgery, The Queen Elizabeth Hospital, Woodville, South Australia, Australia. He is an associate medical editor of Vascular Specialist.
CHICAGO – Treatment of calcified femoropopliteal lesions with orbital atherectomy led to similar 12-month patency as balloon angioplasty but with a reduced need for stenting, in a randomized, controlled study with 50 patients.
Orbital atherectomy changed vessel compliance, which allowed lower pressure balloon dilatation and hence less vessel disruption, which appeared to produce a low rate of restenosis with minimal stent use. "Lower dissection rates and reduced use of bail-out stents preserves treatment options in the future," said Dr. Raymond Dattilo in a poster at the Annual Scientific Session of the American College of Cardiology. Minimizing stent use in distal, superficial femoral and popliteal arteries also reduces the risk of stent fracture, said Dr. Dattilo, a cardiologist and director of endovascular medicine at St. Francis Health Center in Topeka, Kan.
He ran the COMPLIANCE 360° study to determine whether orbital atherectomy of calcified femoropopliteal lesions using the Diamondback Orbital Atherectomy System reduced the need for stenting without diminishing 12-month vessel patency when compared with percutaneous balloon angioplasty and selected stent use. The study enrolled 50 patients with 65 femoropopliteal lesions. Randomization resulted in two treatment arms with similar patients and types of lesions (based on degree of calcification and plaque morphology). The only statistically-significant difference between the two treatment arms was the percent of patients with diabetes, which affected 18 (72%) patients randomized to orbital atherectomy and 10 (40%) patients treated with balloon angioplasty and bail-out stenting.
Maximum balloon pressure used during angioplasty was 4 atmospheres in the 25 patients treated with orbital atherectomy, and 9 atmospheres in the 25 patients who did not undergo atherectomy. Two patients treated with atherectomy, (8%) required a bail-out stent, compared with 21 (84%) in the angioplasty group, a statistically significant difference.
At 6 months after treatment, 16 of 22 patients (73%) in the atherectomy group with 6-month follow-up had avoided stent placement, were free from target lesion revascularization, and had no restenosis as assessed by duplex ultrasound. Among 24 patients in the balloon angioplasty group assessed after 6 months, two patients (8%) met these same efficacy criteria.
After 12 months, five patients in the atherectomy group of 20 with 12-month follow-up had restenosis or repeat target lesion revascularization, compared with five of 21 patients with angioplasty. The 12-month results showed that the two strategies resulted in similar rates of long-term vessel patency, but the atherectomy patients avoided stent placement.
The COMPLIANCE 360° study was sponsored by Cardiovascular Systems. Dr. Dattilo said he has received financial support from Cardiovascular Systems.☐
CHICAGO – Treatment of calcified femoropopliteal lesions with orbital atherectomy led to similar 12-month patency as balloon angioplasty but with a reduced need for stenting, in a randomized, controlled study with 50 patients.
Orbital atherectomy changed vessel compliance, which allowed lower pressure balloon dilatation and hence less vessel disruption, which appeared to produce a low rate of restenosis with minimal stent use. "Lower dissection rates and reduced use of bail-out stents preserves treatment options in the future," said Dr. Raymond Dattilo in a poster at the Annual Scientific Session of the American College of Cardiology. Minimizing stent use in distal, superficial femoral and popliteal arteries also reduces the risk of stent fracture, said Dr. Dattilo, a cardiologist and director of endovascular medicine at St. Francis Health Center in Topeka, Kan.
He ran the COMPLIANCE 360° study to determine whether orbital atherectomy of calcified femoropopliteal lesions using the Diamondback Orbital Atherectomy System reduced the need for stenting without diminishing 12-month vessel patency when compared with percutaneous balloon angioplasty and selected stent use. The study enrolled 50 patients with 65 femoropopliteal lesions. Randomization resulted in two treatment arms with similar patients and types of lesions (based on degree of calcification and plaque morphology). The only statistically-significant difference between the two treatment arms was the percent of patients with diabetes, which affected 18 (72%) patients randomized to orbital atherectomy and 10 (40%) patients treated with balloon angioplasty and bail-out stenting.
Maximum balloon pressure used during angioplasty was 4 atmospheres in the 25 patients treated with orbital atherectomy, and 9 atmospheres in the 25 patients who did not undergo atherectomy. Two patients treated with atherectomy, (8%) required a bail-out stent, compared with 21 (84%) in the angioplasty group, a statistically significant difference.
At 6 months after treatment, 16 of 22 patients (73%) in the atherectomy group with 6-month follow-up had avoided stent placement, were free from target lesion revascularization, and had no restenosis as assessed by duplex ultrasound. Among 24 patients in the balloon angioplasty group assessed after 6 months, two patients (8%) met these same efficacy criteria.
After 12 months, five patients in the atherectomy group of 20 with 12-month follow-up had restenosis or repeat target lesion revascularization, compared with five of 21 patients with angioplasty. The 12-month results showed that the two strategies resulted in similar rates of long-term vessel patency, but the atherectomy patients avoided stent placement.
The COMPLIANCE 360° study was sponsored by Cardiovascular Systems. Dr. Dattilo said he has received financial support from Cardiovascular Systems.☐
Major Finding: Orbital atherectomy produced femoropopliteal patency similar to angioplasty, with 8% of patients needing stents compared with 84% in the control arm.
Data Source: Data came from COMPLIANCE 360°, a multicenter, randomized study of 50 patients with calcified femoropopliteal lesions.
Disclosures: The COMPLIANCE 360° study was sponsored by Cardiovascular Systems. Dr. Dattilo said that he has been a consultant to, a speaker for, and has received research grants from Cardiovascular Systems.