User login
LOS ANGELES—Most older adults recover well from traumatic brain injury (TBI), according to research presented at the 70th Annual Meeting of the American Academy of Neurology. Compared with younger patients, older adults endorse less independence after injury, but are less likely to report TBI-related neurobehavioral symptoms. A greater burden of preinjury disability among the elderly may explain these apparently conflicting results, according to the researchers.
Geriatric TBI is “a silent and growing epidemic,” said Raquel Gardner, MD, Assistant Professor of Neurology at the University of California, San Francisco. Older adults have the highest incidence of TBI-related emergency department visits, hospitalizations, and deaths, according to 2013 data from the CDC. Most research has indicated that this population has worse outcomes of TBI than younger populations do. Few studies, however, have examined age-related differences in neurobehavioral outcomes of TBI.
Injury Was More Severe Among Older Patients
To address this gap in the literature, Dr. Gardner and colleagues examined data from the TRACK-TBI pilot study. Eligible patients presented to participating trauma centers within 24 hours of sustaining a TBI that was severe enough to warrant head CT. The TRACK-TBI study excluded participants with a diagnosis of dementia or any pre-existing condition that would impair their ability to complete outcome assessments. Patients’ neurobehavioral outcomes were evaluated prospectively with measures such as the Glasgow Outcome Scale Extended (GOSE), Craig Handicap Assessment and Reporting Technique-Short Form (CHART-SF), Brief Symptom Inventory (BSI-18), Rivermead Post-Concussion Questionnaire (RPQ), Posttraumatic Stress Disorder Checklist-Civilian (PCL-C), and the Satisfaction With Life Scale (SWLS). 
Dr. Gardner and colleagues categorized 586 patients as young (ie, younger than 40), middle-aged (ie, ages 40 to 59), or older (ie, age 60 or older). They compared baseline features and six-month neurobehavioral outcomes between the three groups using χ2, analysis of variance, and regression modeling.
Patients’ age ranged from 16 to 94. At baseline, the prevalence of female sex and white race increased with increasing age. Older adults were less likely to report a prior history of TBI than the other two age groups. TBI resulted from a fall for most older patients. At presentation, Glasgow Coma Scale scores did not differ significantly between the three patient groups, and older adults were less likely to report having experienced loss of consciousness or posttraumatic amnesia than the other groups.
Injury was more severe among older patients, however, as assessed by the Acute Injury Scale, the Injury Severity Scale, and CT pathology, compared with younger participants. Older patients also were more likely to be admitted to the intensive care unit.
Measures May Not Be Age-Appropriate
At six months, 415 of the participants completed the GOSE. The mortality rate was approximately 18% among older patients, compared with 7% among middle-aged patients and less than 1% among young patients. Among older patients who survived to six months, most achieved a good recovery, which was defined as a GOSE score of 7 to 8. After the researchers adjusted the data for baseline demographic differences, the rate of good recovery was not significantly different between the three age groups.
Older patients reported significantly less anxiety than other patients, as measured by the BSI-18. Older patients tended to report fewer symptoms overall on the BSI-18 and the RPQ, compared with the other groups. In addition, older patients reported fewer symptoms of PTSD and less dissatisfaction with life, compared with the other groups.
CHART-SF scores, however, were worse overall among older patients, said Dr. Gardner. Although they indicated better economic outcomes among older patients, compared with the other age groups, they also indicated less independence among older patients. Cognition and mobility in particular were worse among older patients than among the other groups.
Older patients were more likely to complete the GOSE than younger patients, but less likely to complete other assessments. The differences in response rates could create a misleadingly positive impression of six-month outcomes among older patients, said Dr. Gardner.
One interpretation of the results is that measures that are not age-appropriate are causing older patients to underreport TBI symptoms, she added. Survival bias also may partly explain the positive six-month outcomes. “We need studies that are truly representative of the entire geriatric TBI population and systematically measure, rather than exclude for, this huge heterogeneity in preinjury disability,” said Dr. Gardner. Investigators should take steps “to optimize enrollment, optimize retention, and optimize outcome completion in a frail and burdened population. We need to ultimately develop consensus NINDS geriatric TBI common data elements…. Only then can we unravel predictors of meaningful recovery in this vulnerable population, develop age-appropriate treatment guidelines, and improve outcomes.”
—Erik Greb
Suggested Reading
Yue JK, Winkler EA, Sharma S, et al. Temporal profile of care following mild traumatic brain injury: predictors of hospital admission, follow-up referral and six-month outcome. Brain Inj. 2017;31(13-14):1820-1829.
LOS ANGELES—Most older adults recover well from traumatic brain injury (TBI), according to research presented at the 70th Annual Meeting of the American Academy of Neurology. Compared with younger patients, older adults endorse less independence after injury, but are less likely to report TBI-related neurobehavioral symptoms. A greater burden of preinjury disability among the elderly may explain these apparently conflicting results, according to the researchers.
Geriatric TBI is “a silent and growing epidemic,” said Raquel Gardner, MD, Assistant Professor of Neurology at the University of California, San Francisco. Older adults have the highest incidence of TBI-related emergency department visits, hospitalizations, and deaths, according to 2013 data from the CDC. Most research has indicated that this population has worse outcomes of TBI than younger populations do. Few studies, however, have examined age-related differences in neurobehavioral outcomes of TBI.
Injury Was More Severe Among Older Patients
To address this gap in the literature, Dr. Gardner and colleagues examined data from the TRACK-TBI pilot study. Eligible patients presented to participating trauma centers within 24 hours of sustaining a TBI that was severe enough to warrant head CT. The TRACK-TBI study excluded participants with a diagnosis of dementia or any pre-existing condition that would impair their ability to complete outcome assessments. Patients’ neurobehavioral outcomes were evaluated prospectively with measures such as the Glasgow Outcome Scale Extended (GOSE), Craig Handicap Assessment and Reporting Technique-Short Form (CHART-SF), Brief Symptom Inventory (BSI-18), Rivermead Post-Concussion Questionnaire (RPQ), Posttraumatic Stress Disorder Checklist-Civilian (PCL-C), and the Satisfaction With Life Scale (SWLS).
Dr. Gardner and colleagues categorized 586 patients as young (ie, younger than 40), middle-aged (ie, ages 40 to 59), or older (ie, age 60 or older). They compared baseline features and six-month neurobehavioral outcomes between the three groups using χ2, analysis of variance, and regression modeling.
Patients’ age ranged from 16 to 94. At baseline, the prevalence of female sex and white race increased with increasing age. Older adults were less likely to report a prior history of TBI than the other two age groups. TBI resulted from a fall for most older patients. At presentation, Glasgow Coma Scale scores did not differ significantly between the three patient groups, and older adults were less likely to report having experienced loss of consciousness or posttraumatic amnesia than the other groups.
Injury was more severe among older patients, however, as assessed by the Acute Injury Scale, the Injury Severity Scale, and CT pathology, compared with younger participants. Older patients also were more likely to be admitted to the intensive care unit.
Measures May Not Be Age-Appropriate
At six months, 415 of the participants completed the GOSE. The mortality rate was approximately 18% among older patients, compared with 7% among middle-aged patients and less than 1% among young patients. Among older patients who survived to six months, most achieved a good recovery, which was defined as a GOSE score of 7 to 8. After the researchers adjusted the data for baseline demographic differences, the rate of good recovery was not significantly different between the three age groups.
Older patients reported significantly less anxiety than other patients, as measured by the BSI-18. Older patients tended to report fewer symptoms overall on the BSI-18 and the RPQ, compared with the other groups. In addition, older patients reported fewer symptoms of PTSD and less dissatisfaction with life, compared with the other groups.
CHART-SF scores, however, were worse overall among older patients, said Dr. Gardner. Although they indicated better economic outcomes among older patients, compared with the other age groups, they also indicated less independence among older patients. Cognition and mobility in particular were worse among older patients than among the other groups.
Older patients were more likely to complete the GOSE than younger patients, but less likely to complete other assessments. The differences in response rates could create a misleadingly positive impression of six-month outcomes among older patients, said Dr. Gardner.
One interpretation of the results is that measures that are not age-appropriate are causing older patients to underreport TBI symptoms, she added. Survival bias also may partly explain the positive six-month outcomes. “We need studies that are truly representative of the entire geriatric TBI population and systematically measure, rather than exclude for, this huge heterogeneity in preinjury disability,” said Dr. Gardner. Investigators should take steps “to optimize enrollment, optimize retention, and optimize outcome completion in a frail and burdened population. We need to ultimately develop consensus NINDS geriatric TBI common data elements…. Only then can we unravel predictors of meaningful recovery in this vulnerable population, develop age-appropriate treatment guidelines, and improve outcomes.”
—Erik Greb
Suggested Reading
Yue JK, Winkler EA, Sharma S, et al. Temporal profile of care following mild traumatic brain injury: predictors of hospital admission, follow-up referral and six-month outcome. Brain Inj. 2017;31(13-14):1820-1829.
LOS ANGELES—Most older adults recover well from traumatic brain injury (TBI), according to research presented at the 70th Annual Meeting of the American Academy of Neurology. Compared with younger patients, older adults endorse less independence after injury, but are less likely to report TBI-related neurobehavioral symptoms. A greater burden of preinjury disability among the elderly may explain these apparently conflicting results, according to the researchers.
Geriatric TBI is “a silent and growing epidemic,” said Raquel Gardner, MD, Assistant Professor of Neurology at the University of California, San Francisco. Older adults have the highest incidence of TBI-related emergency department visits, hospitalizations, and deaths, according to 2013 data from the CDC. Most research has indicated that this population has worse outcomes of TBI than younger populations do. Few studies, however, have examined age-related differences in neurobehavioral outcomes of TBI.
Injury Was More Severe Among Older Patients
To address this gap in the literature, Dr. Gardner and colleagues examined data from the TRACK-TBI pilot study. Eligible patients presented to participating trauma centers within 24 hours of sustaining a TBI that was severe enough to warrant head CT. The TRACK-TBI study excluded participants with a diagnosis of dementia or any pre-existing condition that would impair their ability to complete outcome assessments. Patients’ neurobehavioral outcomes were evaluated prospectively with measures such as the Glasgow Outcome Scale Extended (GOSE), Craig Handicap Assessment and Reporting Technique-Short Form (CHART-SF), Brief Symptom Inventory (BSI-18), Rivermead Post-Concussion Questionnaire (RPQ), Posttraumatic Stress Disorder Checklist-Civilian (PCL-C), and the Satisfaction With Life Scale (SWLS).
Dr. Gardner and colleagues categorized 586 patients as young (ie, younger than 40), middle-aged (ie, ages 40 to 59), or older (ie, age 60 or older). They compared baseline features and six-month neurobehavioral outcomes between the three groups using χ2, analysis of variance, and regression modeling.
Patients’ age ranged from 16 to 94. At baseline, the prevalence of female sex and white race increased with increasing age. Older adults were less likely to report a prior history of TBI than the other two age groups. TBI resulted from a fall for most older patients. At presentation, Glasgow Coma Scale scores did not differ significantly between the three patient groups, and older adults were less likely to report having experienced loss of consciousness or posttraumatic amnesia than the other groups.
Injury was more severe among older patients, however, as assessed by the Acute Injury Scale, the Injury Severity Scale, and CT pathology, compared with younger participants. Older patients also were more likely to be admitted to the intensive care unit.
Measures May Not Be Age-Appropriate
At six months, 415 of the participants completed the GOSE. The mortality rate was approximately 18% among older patients, compared with 7% among middle-aged patients and less than 1% among young patients. Among older patients who survived to six months, most achieved a good recovery, which was defined as a GOSE score of 7 to 8. After the researchers adjusted the data for baseline demographic differences, the rate of good recovery was not significantly different between the three age groups.
Older patients reported significantly less anxiety than other patients, as measured by the BSI-18. Older patients tended to report fewer symptoms overall on the BSI-18 and the RPQ, compared with the other groups. In addition, older patients reported fewer symptoms of PTSD and less dissatisfaction with life, compared with the other groups.
CHART-SF scores, however, were worse overall among older patients, said Dr. Gardner. Although they indicated better economic outcomes among older patients, compared with the other age groups, they also indicated less independence among older patients. Cognition and mobility in particular were worse among older patients than among the other groups.
Older patients were more likely to complete the GOSE than younger patients, but less likely to complete other assessments. The differences in response rates could create a misleadingly positive impression of six-month outcomes among older patients, said Dr. Gardner.
One interpretation of the results is that measures that are not age-appropriate are causing older patients to underreport TBI symptoms, she added. Survival bias also may partly explain the positive six-month outcomes. “We need studies that are truly representative of the entire geriatric TBI population and systematically measure, rather than exclude for, this huge heterogeneity in preinjury disability,” said Dr. Gardner. Investigators should take steps “to optimize enrollment, optimize retention, and optimize outcome completion in a frail and burdened population. We need to ultimately develop consensus NINDS geriatric TBI common data elements…. Only then can we unravel predictors of meaningful recovery in this vulnerable population, develop age-appropriate treatment guidelines, and improve outcomes.”
—Erik Greb
Suggested Reading
Yue JK, Winkler EA, Sharma S, et al. Temporal profile of care following mild traumatic brain injury: predictors of hospital admission, follow-up referral and six-month outcome. Brain Inj. 2017;31(13-14):1820-1829.